Mass Appeal Booth Theater NYC Director: Geraldine Fitzgerald So, what's so interesting about a play that spoofs Catholicism? Well, if the star is Milo O'Shea and the director is Geraldine Fitzgerald the answer is plenty. Mass AppeaJ has only two per formers. . . . O'Shea as a successful Catholic priest and Michael O'Keefe as a young, idealistic priesthood 'aspi rant. Although a "script for two" seems little to create a Broadway play on, writer Bill Evans has developed a wit ty, attention-holding story that is both funny and poignant. Basically, the story begins with Fa ther Tim Farley (Milo O'Shea) taking in young Mark Dolson (Michael O'Keefe as sort of a protege of the priesthood. Father Farley, long jaded by the materialistic trappings that come with having a large, well-to-do congregation, drives a Mercedes and intermittently drinks burgundy in his study. On the other hand, Mark Dolson is seriously committed and competely non-materialistic. The two opposing personalities and perspectives are the focus of the play's conflict. The skill in reaching this con flict's resolution is largely due to Ger aldine Fitzgerald's direction. As in Long Day's Journey Into Night which she directed at the Public Theater (see National Scene June 1981) Ms. Fitzger ald demonstrates an ability to get the audience involved with and even care about what happens to the characters. And when Father Farley's arrogant fa cade is stripped away he conveys a human vulnerability that is readily un derstood by all. Milo O'Shea' perform ance is among the most gripping of any leading role this season. Mass Appeal is a play with meaning that transcends religious preference. It makes a valid statement about contem porary attitudes and with its creative presentation Mass Appeal is a testa ment to the saying "less is more". Camejot Winter Garden NYC Director: Frank Dunlop Camelot, which was first staged by Moss Hart and subsequently was done on film is back on Broadway starring Richard Harris as King Arthur. This production is just as lavish and fanci ful as in the past. With the Desmond Heeley set and costume design the proper mood is created. Naturally, all of those same delightful songs are done as great effort is put forth to recapture this play's magic. However, to recapture anything can be an extremely elusive pursuit and there are components of this produc tion that did not completely come together. Unfortunately, an outstand ing play is missing an outstanding cast, Richard Harris has flashing moments of brilliance which he may have re tained from his Golden Globe winning performance in the film. But he dis plays (as do most of the cast) periods of low energy which debilitates Camel ot's overall impact. With so much to work with, one wonders why the cast does not gener ate more enthusiasm. But this emotion seems to rise and subside creating a vague unevenness. Richard Muenz (Sir Lancelot) and Barrie Ingham (King Pellinore) give the most consistant per formances. But if one does not expect great acting and can appreciate Ca meJot's technical skill and its music you may find this play entertaining. West Side Waltz Barrymore Theater NYC Director: Noel Willman Katherine Hepburn waltzes back to Broadway in this production as anoth er entry in this season's "year of the star" sweepstakes. However, in her role as a 70-ish, retired concert pianist Ms. Hepburn fares better than most. I must confess that with Ms. Hepburn it has always been difficult for me to determine when she was acting from when she is playing herself. Quite frankly, I still don't know. The Hep burn mistique is just as undefinable for me as it has always been. But whatever she is doing in West Side Waltz Kate Hepburn is thoroughly enjoyable. Throughout the play she is witty, iras cible, sensitive and independent wrap ping these emotions in a regal charm that has become her trademark. Dorothy Loudon, who co-stars, is equally effective as Ms. Hepburn's loyal companion. Ms. Loudon paints a crystal clear protrait of how insecurity and loneliness can have a drastic im pact on us all. She brings such reality to her role that Loudon is certain to receive a Tony nomination. The three remaining performers Re gina Baff, David Margulies and Don Howard all turn in good performances. In fact, the high calibre acting in West Side Waltz is its strongest suit. The plot of West Side Waltz is inter esting but far from powerful. The play seems more a vehicle for the talents of its players. Howevgr, in this rare case the actor's performances shine far above the " script and it works. """V"" if L:k;. ... i. ... , MiJo O'Shea and Michael O'Keefe in "Mass Appeal" 15