Who Were the Greatest Americans?
By ELMO SCOTT WATSON
F SOMEONE asked you to name the 40 greatest
Americans of the past, who would they be?
Furthermore, if you were requested to select
from these 40 the five who were so outstanding
among the others that there could be no question as
to their right to be called "great," with all that that
word implies, which five would you name?
There's not much doubt about your choice for the No. 1
American. Nearly a century and a half ago, Henry Lee of
Virginia, in delivering his famous funeral oration in congress,
called George Washington "First in War, first in Peace and
First in the Hearts of His Countrymen" and successive genera
tions of Americans have indorsed that characterization by ele
vating him to the highest place in their galaxy of the great.
Nor is there much doubt as '
to whom you would name as
No. 2 American. Although
separated, as to time, by
nearly three-quarters of a
century the names of George
Washington and Abraham
Lincoln are inseparably
linked together in the vener
GEORGE WASHINGTON
ation of their countrymen
and if Washington is No. 1
American then Lincoln is in
evitably No. 2.
As for No. 3, twg names
are pretty certain to come to
your mind and you'll find it
difficult to choose between
them for this honor. But it's
not likely that anyone will
seriously dispute your choice
if you give that place to
either Benjamin Franklin or
Thomas Jefferson and assign
No. 4 place to the other.
No. 5? Ah, here's where you're
going to have difficulty in decid
ing and even after you do, how
many people do you think you
can find who will agree with you?
If, from the other 36 possibilities
you should decide to name the
man who guided this nation
through the greatest war in his
tory, your choice will have the
support of a man who is regarded
as something of an authority on
American greatness.
He is Dr. Dumas Malone, di
rector of the Harvard University
Press, and among the reasons
for calling him an authority are
these facts:
Back in 1922, at the suggestion
of Dr. Frederick Jackson Turner,
one of the leading historians of
the country, the newly-organized
American Council of Learned So
cieties, composed of members
from various colleges and uni
sities, decided to sponsor the
compilation and publication of a
number of volumes of American
biography which would be the
"last word" hi this field. To ac
complish this meant at least 10
WOODBOW WILSON
year* work by hundreds of writ
era who were recognized as au
1 thorities in all fields of Ameri
can history.
More than that, it meant the
expenditure of more than half a
million dollars and the council,
while "long" in vision and am
bition, was unfortunately "short"
is funds. In fact, when it first
took up the project it didn't even
have the )300 necessary for trav
eling expenses for members at
tending committee meetings. But
tt t ound an "angel" in Adolph S.
Ochs, the late publisher of the
New York Times. It required
only one short letter and one in
terview to persuade him to fi
nance the undertaking and under
the direction of Dr. Allen John
son of Yale university the work
was started.
A Monumental Work.
One of the editors who joined
Dr. Johnson's staff in 1929 was
Dr. Malone, a native of Missis
sippi and at that time a profes
sor of history at the University
of Virginia. When Dr. Johnson
died two years later Dr. Malone
was chosen as his successor and
under his direction the Diction
ary of American Biography was
completed last year when the
twentieth volume was issued.
Characterized by competent crit
ics as "the greatest work of his
torical scholarship yet produced
in this country," the Dictionary
contains the biographies of 13,633
Americans who, in the opinion
of Dr. Dumas and the 2,000 bi
ographers who aided him in the
work, were important enough in
the history of our country to en
title them to a place in this per
manent record.
Since Dr. Dumas Malone has
spent seven years of his life in
compiling such a record and in
that time has had an opportunity
to ponder much on the question
of "What is greatness?" it would
seem that he can be safely re
garded as an authority on the
greatest Americans. So one of
the first things he did after com
pleting his editorship of the Dic
tionary of American Biography
was to draw up a list of the 40
greatest Americans.
Then he wrote an article about
it which was printed in the April
issue of Harper's Magazine ?
and immediately a great num
ber of Americans who have their
J
ABRAHAM LINCOLN
own ideas a& to who were the
greatest of their fellow-country
men rose up to say their sayt
"Look! There's not a woman
on the list!" exclaimed some of
them ? and you can guess which
of the sexes did that exclaim
ing I
"Why should there be 18 states
men and soldiers, nine literary
men, three painters and sculp
tors and only one business man?
Doesn't he realize that this
wouldn't be the country it is, if
it weren't for the business menT"
asked some.
"Where are the inventors in
his list? What about Thomas Edi
son?" asked others.
"There certainly ought to be
more than one clergyman and
one educator, among the 40," de
clared still others.
"Aren't scientists who And out
ways to save life just as impor
tant as soldiers who destroy life?
Look there ? three generals and
only one scientist!"
Qoestion of Ranking.
Nor have the disagreements
with Dr. Malone's list been con
fined to the scarcity of repre
sentatives in the various profes
sions. There have also been de
murrers against the order of
rank within the group of states
men, soldiers and jurists. Why
did he rank Ulysses S. Grant
ahead of Robert E. Lee, Jeffer
son Davis ahead of Theodore
Roosevelt, Stephen A. Douglas
ahead of Daniel Webster and
Henry Clay, they ask. They also
question his judgment in includ
ing William Jennings Bryan in
a list that included only a third
of our Presidents. They wonder
why John Quincy Adams rates a
/
I
THE "BIG FIVE"
GEORGE WASHINGTON THOMAS JEFFERSON
ABRAHAM LINCOLN BENJAMIN FRANKLIN
WOODROW WILSON
Statesmen, Soldiers
and Jurists
<la Order *1 Tkilr Rsnk)
James Madison
John Marshall
Alexander Hamilton
Ulysses S. Grant
Robert E. Lee
Andrew Jackson
John C. Calhoun
John Adams
John Quincy Adams
Jefferson Davis
Theodore Roosevelt
Stephen A. Douglas
Daniel Webster
Henry Clay
Grover Cleveland
William Jennings Bryan
Gen. Winfield Scott
Joseph Story
Business
Andrew Carnegie
Literary Men
(In Order of Tbvlr Rank)
Ralph Waldo Emerson
Nathaniel Hawthorne
Samuel L. Clemens (Hark Twain)
Walt Whitman
Edgar Allen Poe
Henry David Tboreaa
Henry James
James Fenimore Cooper
Horace Greeley
Arts
James Abbott Mac Neil Whistler
Augustus Saint-Gaudens
John La Farge
Clergy
Jonathan Edwards
Philosophy
William James
Science
Louis Agassi*
Education
Charles W. Eliot
place in the list but James Mon
roe doesn't and they wonder why
Gen. Winfield Scott is there and
"Stonewall" Jackson isn't.
Dr. Malone is not surprised
that his selection has caused con
troversy, for he expected it when
he wrote his article. He is quot
ed as saying that his list might
easily be revised by substitutions
and changing the order in which
he has placed the 40. But there
is one part of his list which he
says he- "would defend with his
life." They are the first five
names ? Washington, Lincoln,
Jefferson, Franklin and Wilson.
There has been no disagree
ment as to Washington and Lin
coln, and only a little as to the
relative positions of those two
versatile Americans ? Jefferson
and Franklin. But there has been
strong objection to selecting
Woodrow Wilson as the only
American since Lincoln to stand
among the five greatest. Many
have declared that, that position
belongs to Theodore Roosevelt ?
who is tenth on Dr. Malone's list.
In answer to the admirers of the
Strenuous American, the Har
vard professor says:
Roosevelt Vi. Wilson.
"Roosevelt thought of himself
as a man of action and of Wilson
as a man of words. But the rec
ord shows that Wilson was the
man of action and Roosevelt the
man of words. T. R. talked a
great deal, but he couldn't put
things through. Wilson's first two
years are comparable to George
Washington's administration. At
no time after the beginning of
the republic did any administra
tion ever get things done as Wil
son did. He assumed a new role
in the Presidency, comparable to
that of prime minister, leader of
his party.
"As a war President, Wilson
was a better administrator than
Lincoln. The World war was bet
ter conducted than any other we
ever fought. When the Republi
cans went back in 1920, there was
practically, nothing they could
stir up out of the conduct of the
war. But the most important
thing about Wilson was that he
was the first American in history
who was the most important man
in the world. That just never
happened before."
Just as Dr. Malone expected
his selection of Wilson to cause
dispute, so did he expect to draw
fire by the absence of women in
his list. "But it is actually no
reflection on them at all," he
says. "Until recently there has
been no chance for women to
achieve prominence in America.
Until the Civil war, their only
chance for distinction was as a
hostess, like Dolly Madison, or
as writers. There weren't many
writers. Harriet Beecher Stowe
is the best known but she falls
short of the nine men on my list
of writers. Frances Perkins was
the first woman in public life and
she is still alive."
It will be noted that no living
American is included in the list,
since Dr. Malone applied the
same limitation to this list as
was applied to the Dictionary of
American Biography. (Inciden
tally that's the reason for the
use of the word "were" in the
title of this article.)
A Forgotten Hero.
Dr. Malone is not surprised
that there is disagreement over
his inclusion of Gen. W infield
Scott as one of the three great
soldiers which America has pro
duced. But he defends his choice
of "Old Fuss and Feathers" by
declaring that Scott "taught Lee
his generalship and he embodies
the military genius of America
from the War of 1813 to the Civil
war." He says, however, that
anyone "who wishes to do so
may substitute for his name that
of David G. Farragut, the great
est American naval hero." In
fact, throughout his article in
Harper's the Harvard professor,
who refuses to be dogmatic in
his selections except in the case
of the first five, offers the reader
suggestions for other substitu
tions.
His article starts off With the
suggestion that "for the diver
sion of her guests after dinner,
when conversation lags and the
BENJAMIN FRANKLIN
radio program is umpromising, a
perplexed hostess might have re
course to the following game . . .
let each member of the party
write on a slip of paper the
names of the five greatest Amer
icans in history. It will be well
to vote only for 'persons who are
safely dead, though enlivening
jokes about contemporaries need
not be discouraged."
His article ends with this
statement: "It is interesting to
speculate about an additional list
of immortals which might be
drawn up a generation hence. But
I do not propose any such specu
lation to hostesses and their din
ner guests. In fact, I do not
even propose to them the mak
ing of lists of forty names. Five,
or perhaps ten will be enough to
THOMAS JEFFERSON
provoke lively disagreement ? aa
lively, almost, as will be stirred >
up by my tentative and highly
unofficial roster."
His prophecy as to that "lively
disagreement" has come true.
Perhaps YOU are one of those
who would disagree, not only
with his first five, but many oth
ers in his list of 40. That being
the case, why don't YOU draw
up your own list? You'll find it
Just as stimulating ? and perhaps
even more educational than work
ing crossword puzzles!
? Wetteiu Newspaper Ob tea.
"IMPROVED
UNIFORM INTERNATIONAL
SUNDAY I
chool Lesson
By REV. HAROLD L. LUNDQU1ST.
Dean of the Moody Bible Institute
of Chicago.
C Western Newspaper Union.
Lesson for May 16
THE FORBEARANCE OF ISAAC
LESSON TEXT ? Genesis 26: 12-25.
GOLDEN TEXT? Blessed are the peace
makers: tor they shall be called the chil
dren of God. Matthew 5:9.
PRIMARY TOPIC? A Man Who Wouldn't
Quarrel.
JUNIOR TOPIC? Was Isaac a Hero?
INTERMEDIATE AND SENIOR TOPIC?
How to Prevent Quarrels.
YOUNG PEOPLE AND ADULT TOPIC?
Promoting Peace.
In a world largely dominated by
the philosophy that might is right,
and in which men are urged to as
sert themselves and demand their
rights, exacting them even by law
less and violent methods, it is in
creasingly difficult to proclaim the
truth that meekness is not weakness
and that the Christian virtues of pa
tience and long-suffering are not
simply outmoded theories which do
not fit our modern world.
The story of Isaac, the second of
the patriarchs, is instructive from
beginning to end. The five chap
ters preceding our lesson merit
careful reading. Isaac had come
through many blessed experiences
and had also sadly tasted the de
feat of unbelief and sin before we
reach the time of our lesson. Fear
ing a famine, and evidently not be
ing certain that God would care for
him, he had gone down from the
promised land, and was dwelling
in the land of the Philistines. But
God had not forsaken him, and even
there he blessed him.
I. Peace, Prosperity, and Envy
(w. 12-17).
Isaac was at peace although he
was in the enemy's territory. God
had given him great prosperity with
the result that the Philistines hated
him. Times have changed, but men
are the same. Many are they who
will not have the Lord Jesus Christ
to rule over them, but who cast en
vious glances toward those who be
cause they have honored God have
been honored by him with peace of
heart and have been prospered in
whatever they do. (Read Psalm 1.)
Note that Isaac's testimony is
strengthened by his willingness to
yield even what was his right,
rather than cause contention. Un
doubtedly there are times when one
must defend his name and his pos
sessions, but all too often those who
"stand up for their rights" have
wrecked homes, churches, and na
tions, and have gained nothing but
an empty victory.
n. Peace in the World Is Tempo
rary (w. 18-21).
Isaac moved on and digged more
wells, and for a time he was again
at peace, but not for long. He was
still in the land of the Philistines.
We are in the world. We long for
peace, we would throw all our influ
ence on the side of peace. But let
us not be misled, for as long as sin
is in the world there will be strife
and war.
many nooie t^nnsuan men anu
women have permitted their God
given hatred of war and killing to
mislead them into support of un
scriptural and impossible peace pro
grams, often to the loss of their in
terest in the preaching of the gospel
and the winning of souls to Christ.
But is there then never to be
"peace on earth"?
m. Perfect Peace in the Pres
ence of God (w. 22-25).
When Isaac came up into Canaan
the land which God had promised
him, he found permanent peace and
renewed fellowship with God. Even
so, the Christian man and woman
who will step out of a spirituality
destroying fellowship with the world
and will come wholly over into the
spiritual Canaan will find true peace
and intimate communion with God.
A broader application of the same
truth brings before us the teaching
of Scripture that when the One who
has a right to reign, the Lord Jesus
Christ, returns to take his throne,
then and not before, will peace
cover the earth. In the meantime
those who bear the beautiful name
Christian, who are true followers of
the Prince of Peace, will give them
selves to such patient, loving, and
longsuffering testimony to Him that
their personal influence will be to
ward peace in the home, in the
church, in the community, in the
earth.
Always remember that God's
Word, the Bible, is our guide. Let
us read it diligently, intelligently,
prayerfully. To help the reader to
do this, the writer of these notes
will be glad to supply without cost
or obligation a Bible-reading calen
dar with a workable plan for read
ing the blessed Book through in a
year. If possible enclose a stamped
and self-addressed envelope with
your request.
Faults Showing Dp
The good often sigh more over
little faults than the wicked over
great. Hence an old proverb, that
the stain appears greater according
to the brilliancy of what it touches.
? Palmieri.
Sin tl Nat Doing
Doing nothing at all is often the
worst kind of wrong doing. Simply
failing to do what we ought to do
may be more inexcusable than any
mistake in our best methods of do
UNCOMMON
AMERICANS
? ? ?
By Elmo c *??? m
Scott Watson "'JST'
Father of the Dime Novel
A FEW years before the open
ing of the Civil war a printer
in Buffalo, N. Y., began issuing a
magazine called the Youth's Casket
and a little later another, called
the Home Monthly. Neither was
much of a success. More success
ful was his brother who ran a
newsstand and began selling songs
on single pages in much the same
fashion as the ballad-hawkers of an
earlier day. Then the printer broth
er published a number of thes * songs
in a pamphlet called "The Dime
Song Book" and it sold so well that
they decided to move to New York
city and publish other books for ten
cents.
Thus it was that a great Ameri
can institution was born, for these
brothers were Erastus F. and Ir
win P. Beadle and they were the
"Fathers of the Dime Novel." They
took into partnership another na
tive of Buffalo, Robert Adams, and
for the next three decades there
came from the presses of Beadle
and Company and Beadle and Ad
ams a perfect flood of little books
(the Pocket Library, the Half-Dime
Library and the Dime Library) to
thrill the souls of American boys
and to fill the hearts of American
parents with fear that their sons
were being corrupted beyond all
hope by these "yellow-backs."
How groundless that fear was is
shown by the fact that some of the
most distinguished Americans of to
day grew up on a reading diet of
Beadle's dime novels. Exciting and
thrilling those stories may have
been (opening, as so many of them
did. With "Bang! Bang! Bang:!
Three shots rang out and another
redskin bit the dust") but they were
also highly moral. For the Villain
was always foiled, Virtue always
triumphed and it is doubtful if a
single boy ever was ruined by read
ing one of them.
Irwin Beadle retired from the
firm in 1862, Robert Adams died in
1866, and his two younger broth
ers, William and David, succeeded
him. With them as partners Eras
tus Beadle carried the dime novel
to the heights of its success. He
continued in the business until .889.
Then he retired with a fortune built
up by the dimes and nickels of
Young America. He died in 1894 ?
too early to realize that certain of
the little "yellow backs" which he
sold for a dime would later sell for
hundreds of dollars because they
are "Americana" and "collectors'
items"!
She Wanted to Be President
SHE wanted to be President of
the United States but if ever
there was a forlorn hope it was
that ambition of Victoria Clafin
Woodhull.
She started under the handicap of
being bom in Ohio to a family that
was not only poor but disreputable.
And neither she nor her sister,
Tennessee Clafin (or "Tennie C."
as she wrote it) ever tried to re
trieve the family reputation. In
stead, both of them added several
shocking items to Puritanical Amer
ica's low estimate of the Clafins.
For one thing they went in for spir
itualism and, what was worse, they
became free love advocates.
Victoria first married Dr. Can
ning Woodhull but soon discarded
him for Col. James H. Blood, a
handsome and distinguished Civil
war veteran and a kindred spirit,
whom she later married. Tennes
see went to New York and won the
admiration of Commodore Vander
bilt who set her and her sister up
as brokers. Having thus entered
the business world, the sisters set
out to prove that women were just
as capable as men in other lines
of activity.
They began publishing Woodhull
and Clafin's Weekly and with it
Victoria started her own "boom"
for President. She ran for that
high office on a platform of wom
en's rights? and kept right on run
ning for many years. SRe went to
Washington and appeared before
the judiciary committee of the
house of representatives to demand
the right to vote. Of course, she
failed to win that right just as she
failed to get anyone to take her
Presidential candidacy seriously.
So she finall) gt>ve up the at
tempt, discarded Colonel Blood and
went to England where she acquired
another husband, as did her sister.
Then both of them disowned free
love, won their way into English
society and for many years pub
lished a magazine devoted to ad
vanced views on many subjects.
Eventually Victoria settled down
into a placid existence as the Lady
Bountiful of a small town in Wor
cestershire and became known as
"a social reformer who suffered for
views now generally accepted."
When she died in 1927 at the age of
ninety, the vicar who preached her
funeral sermon told his hearers,
"We have been privileged to have
had one of the world's greatest per
sonalities among us"l
Ask Me Another
0 - 4 General Quiz
C Bell Syndicate. ? WNU Scnricc.
1. Ho\ many languages and
systems of writing are there?
2. What state has contributed
the most Supreme court justices?
3. In what year was a perform
ance of "Aida" given at the foot
of the Pyramids in Egypt?
4. Who guards the White House?
5. Who wrote the "Comedie Hu
maine"?
6. What was a bireme?
7. Of what musical instrument
was the clavichord a forerunner?
8. Who were the Jacobites?
9. Of what country was Cather
ine de Medici queen?
10. In what country is Mecca?
11. In what war was James Clin
ton a noted American general?
12. How many sovereigns have
been crowned in Westminster Ab
bey?
Answers
1. Dr. Frank H. Vizetelly says
thjt there are six thousand seven
hundred and sixty named tongues
and systems of writing in the
world.
2. New York has contributed the
most United States Supreme court
justices, 10.
3. In 1912 an impressive open
air production of the opera was
given there.
4. The White House has its own
police force of 48 men. This in
cludes a captain, a lieutenant,
three sergeants and 43 policemen.
There are also 10 Secret Service
men.
5. This is the title of an uncom
pleted series of nearly a hundred
novels by Balzac, designed to give
a panoramic picture of the man
ners and morals of the time. He
began the work in 1829, adopting
the general title in 1842.
6. An ancient galley having two
banks of oars.
7. The piano.
8. Adherents of James n or hit
line.
9. France;
10. Arabia.
11. The Revolution.
12. Thirty-seven sovereigns have
been crowned in the abbey, and
25 queens consort ? all of the kings
and queens since William the Con
queror. Eighteen sovereigns and
14 queens are buried there.
Little Red Schoolhouses
There are 138,542 little red
schoolhouses dotting the nation's
countryside. One - room affairs,
they represent -57 per cent of all
American school buildings and for
the most part teach good old
fashioned American education
with the three R's as the basis. ?
Literary Digest.
Guaranteed to kill
ANTS
Ants art hard to kill, but Perermsn'r Ant
Food is made especially co get them and gat
them f*st. Destroy* ted ants, black ants,
others ? kills young and eggs, too. Sprinkle
along windows, doors, any place where ants
come and go. Safe. Dfleaire 24 hours a day.
2)/, 35/ and 60/ at your druggist's.
PETERMANS
ANT FOOD
That's Respect
A man can differ from us in his
opinions as much as he pleapes if
he thinks a lot of us.
CONSTIPATED
AFter Her
First Baby
Finds Relief
Safe, All.
fogetableWay
Sh? had jghnan np hope
relS'JSr ihf lMTOtd
of faaoai all.
. _ . N* Tablets
fwftagy??of chro^
?new color and MM!
wjetthUtantiTt cently uimSSZ tteeM
oowe i.pveecom
They Are Bare
Only the sparkling speeches
should be long ? about one in 10,000.
Sentinels
of Health
Don't Neglect Them I
doipwd tha kldnaya to do ?
mamloiu iob. TWi tuk i, tb toap U?
flowing Mood atraam (ra? o( an una of
toilj fmporttlaa. Tha act ot llvti if? Itfa
Natura Intended, than la retention a<
nau that nay cauaa body? Ida dta
uaaa. Ona may niffar naccfnr backache.
l>aadajba, attacla of ditzioeaa.
*rtU?f up nlffata. awattlnc. poAnaee
worToetf tirad, ? arrow, i|
^7^Mr?!r\s57S
^?forty mot of pebU. appraY* Af.
Doahs Pills