g&e franklin
and
Uty? Highland JKarmtian
WEIMAR JONES
Editorial Page Editor
\
THURSDAY. DECEMBER 10, 1959
But Didn't Lose
It mast have come as a blow to the folks at
Iotla when their community was not among the
top winners in the Western North Carolina Rural
Community Development Contest. And they are
not alone in their disappointment; all the rest of us
in Macon County are disappointed, too.
The record of Iotla's accomplishments was so
impressive ? there were so many projects, they were
such good projects, and the list was so varied ? our
own conviction, prior to Saturday's awards lunch
eon in Asheville, was that Iotla must be one of the
winners, even if not the first prize. When it wasn't,
we were human enough to have a. first reaction of
"How could any community have done better?"
Well, some other communities ? five of them, in
fact? obviously did do better. And all of us, great
as our disappointment may be, can well take pride
that we live in an area where so much .progress
has been made ; where there are at least five com
munities that did a better job even than Iotla.
It is worth remembering, too, that, while Iotla
did not win, it certainly did not lose. Because, as
a result of the unselfish efforts of so many, Iotla
is a better community in which to live. Too, the
folks there have the satisfaction that comes of
achievement; through their own efforts, they made
a better place to live.
Another Side
In the civil rights controversy, are all the valid
arguments on one side? Are the oppenents of pro
posed civil rights legislation opponents only be
cause they are fanatical Southerners who hate the
Negro? Are they animated solely by prejudice?
There is considerable evidence that many Amer
icans believe that.
Yet Senator Sam J. Ervin, Jr., in his talk here
last Thursday night, gave logical reasons why he
has fought and is fighting proposed legislation
aimed at giving the Negro more civil rights. And
one of the things that made what he said so ef
fective was the way he said it. It was said calmly,
without emotion ; it was the closely reasoned argu
ment of a man who thinks things through. That,
indeed, undoubtedly is why Senator Ervin, though
he goes counter to much public sentiment in the
United States, has won widespread respect.
Among reasotis the Senator cited were these:
(a) Such legislation is not needed. There already
is abundant law on the statute books to give every
citi7.en his civil rights.
(b) The legislation that has been proposed, and
is being proposed, is wrong in principle, because it
attempts "to take one group of people and make
them special, favorites of the law". That, he pointed
out, is not "equal protection of the law". This is
one of several ways he said legislation that has
been proposed would make the Negro a special
favorite : Counsel for the plaintiff in a civil rights
case would be paid from tax money; the plaintiff
would be represented by the attorney genetal's of
fice. But the defendant in the case would have to
hire his own lawyer.
The question, it seems to us, is not whether
every citizen is entitled to his civil rights ? he is.
Nor is it whether the Negro has often been de
nied his ? he has. '
The point is two wrongs do not make a right ;
that the way you do something often is as impor
tant as what you do; that it isn't wise to throw
overboard time-tested principles in order to gain
an immediate good end.
When we relinquish the principles of law on
LACK OF BALANCE
Poisons Created In Name Of' Progress Closing In On Us
SOUTH KEN PINES PILOT
The poisons and the destruction
we are creating in the name of
progress continue to close in on
Us Now it's cranberries.
Possibly, with enough nuclear
bomb fall-out racing around the
globe, high in the atmosphere,
to rot our bones and addle our
minds and cause the birth of de
fective babies, it seems unimport
ant that a cancer-produclnc sub
stance gets sprayed on fruit for
human consumption/
But it's not one peril or an
other. To us, it appears all part
of a lack of balance in the human
mind. We harness the atom, but
we experiment with it until we
endanger our health and even
existence. We produce wonder
drUKS but use them so lavishly
that they lose their effectiveness
Wc spray the forests for bugs and
kill fish and animals. We demand
bigger and better cranberries and
bathe them in poison to gain that
end. We want two cars ,in each
garage and then sicken from the
exhaust fumes they throw out.
The problem is too big, too di
verse for any hope of regulation
short of the national government.
Congress should therefore under
take a study of all these new and
only partially understood threats
to human health and welfare and
bring legislation in those fields
up to date, if found necessary.
It is a terrible thing for free
Americans to feel like guinea pigs
when they breathe or eat or have
children who will face a future
full of potential horrors.
This nation has made marvel
ous progress in the fields of hu
man health and welfare, but it
seems time to take stock of our
failings as well as our achieve
ments.
"lae La*t Leaf?
which our justice and freedom are based, we are
endangering justice and freedom for the Negro
himself, because we are endangering it for every- ~ ^
body.
A man should never be ashamed to admit he has been In,
the wrong, which Is but saying In other words that he Is wiser
today than he was yesterday.? Pope.
LETTERS
Another Recalls Reunion
Dear Weimar:
Your November 19 Issue reported the reunion of Confeder
ate veterans In 1889. I well recall that gathering. The veterans
were not so old then. Neither was I.
William P. Slier, chairman of the planning committee, was
my uncle. He had enlisted at the age of 15, one of the young
est to wear the Gray In Macon. His father, Julius T. Slier,
was already In the Army, as were all of the county's able
bodied men. Grandfather Julius (who built "Dixie Hall", and
gave half of the land for the present courthouse and Its sur
rounding square) told Willie he was too young to serve In 1861.
Willie promptly ran away to Ashevllle, and was soon with
the Army of Northern Virginia. I have a letter from him to
his mother about this time. Evidently some member of Willie's
regiment, home on furlough, had reported that the youthful
warrior was acquiring bad habits. Willie assures his mother
that he never, never swore, said his prayers nightly, and
changed his socks frequently.
That 1889 reunion was no one-day affair. Travel was too
difficult on the rutted dirt roads for quick visits. Veterans
pitched tents at the old Camp Meeting Ground, where the
State Prison Camp is now. The present generation may find
It hard to believe, but the Meeting Ground was once a scene
of sylvan beauty. Ferns grew abundantly around a clear, cold
spring. Tall trees gave shade and a thick, leafy carpet. For
all types of gatherings? including religious revivals ? it was an
Ideal site.
By glowing campfires the former soldiers sang, "Tenting
Tonight," and recounted tales of battles long ago. One of
them told me of the death of another uncle, Charles O. Rob
inson, leading a charge at Chancellorsville. Franklin's Confed
erate veteran post was named for him.
Franklin people provided bounteous feasts for the get-to
gether. Confederate soldiers who survived to threescore and
ten were iron men. They starved for four years, and were then
overstuffed with good things by admiring fellow citizens for
the rest of their lives.
In memory, I can see those mounted troopers and quick
stepping Infantry on parade. Drive out past their vanished
encampment some night. Perhaps ? if the wind is right ? you
may hear a faint echo of their spine-tingling Rebel Yell.
All of that merry, gallant company have passed over the
river. There they would ask nothing better than again to fol
low Jeb Stuart, Old Jack, and Marse Robert.
MARY ROBINSON DANIELS
(Mrs. Charles C. Daniels)
New York.
Plan To Restore Vance Birthplace
Editor, The Press:
Through the long history of North Carolina, from 1585 to
the present, this state has had 92 governors, Including a
number of outstanding men and ? in the early days of the
Lords Proprietors ? a few scoundrels.
In this large group, one man stands apart from the rest ?
Zebulon Baird Vance, born In 1830 in Reems Creek valley,
Buncombe County.
Regarded by many authorities as the greatest North Caro
linian who ever lived, Vance served this state during its most
trying times ? the War Between the States and the equally
difficult Reconstruction period. He served two terms as a
U. S. representative, three terms as governor, and four as a
U. S. senator. In 1861 and 1862 he was a colonel in command
of the 26th North Carolina regiment of the Confederate Army.
Holding all these offices, however, did not make Vance a
great man. His greatness came from his honesty and integrtiy,
devotion to duty, keen intelligence and sharp wit, skill as a
public speaker, and an overwhelming love for his native state.
These qualities and many others left the stamp of greatness
on the "mountain giant". As Alfred Moore Waddell said of ,
Vance: "No one in the whole history of the State was ever
so dear to the hearts of the people. He believed In the people
and in their capacity for self-government, and they believed
in him as the truest and best representative and exponent of
their ideas and aspirations."
Vance has been dead for 66 years now and most people to
day ? even in his native county ? remember very little about
his life except the offices he once held.
To honor this Tar Heel immortal, the State Department of
Archives and History plans to restore the birthplace of Vance
on the Reems Creek Road, some 12' miles northeast of Ashe
ville. A date for the start of restoration work has not yet
been set, but probably will come during the first half of 1960.
(Although Vance was born in Buncombe County, this project
is in no sense merely a local one. The restoration will be
financed by state funds and private gifts from throughout
North Carolina, as well as by allocations, from the City of
Asheville and Buncombe County.)
To do an authentic restoration, we need more information
on the old Vance house and on Vance himself, his ancestors
and his descendants. (Col. David Vance, grandfather of Zeb
Vance, built the first Vance house ? a two-story log structure ?
about 1795. That dwelling stood for a century until it was
torn down and replaced with a frame house which was in ex
istence until only recently.)
We also need a quantity of old red hand-made bricks to re
build the chimney and a number of pine logs of various sizes,
including about 20 at least 28 feet in length.
Our budget is limited, so we hope to have some material
contributed to the project.
We will sincerely appreciate any Information on the Vance
house, the Vance family, and also the contribution of hand
made bricks and pine logs.
BOB CONWAY,
Historic Site Specialist
Asheville.
DO YOU REMEMBER?
Looking Backward Through the Files of The Frew
65 YEARS AGO THIS WEEK
(1894)
Court Clerk Lee Crawford "rolls on rubber" (rubber tires on
his bicycle, presumably) between his office and home, and
makes good time.
Base-ball and bird shooting occupied the attention of some
of our sports Thanksgiving day.
Fresh leirons, oranges, bananas, currants, raisins, citron,
figs, stick and fine candies, mixed nuts, chewing gum, &c., Sic.,
at the Drug Store. ? Adv.
One of our statistically Inclined citizens reported that there
are 150 head of horses, 150 head of cattle, and 80 head of hogs
inside of Franklin's corporate limits.
35 YEARS AGO
(1924)
Senator Henry G. Robertson and Representative A. W. Horn
returned home from Asheville last week, where they attended
a meeting of the senators and representatives from the 25
counties of Western North Carolina.
At a meeting of the directors of the Lake Emory Company
last week, Mr. Alex Moore was elected president. Mr. E. S.
Hunnlcutt continues as secretary. Directors are O. A. Jones,
W. B. McOulre, W. L. Higdon, Frank Williams, and John S.
Trotter.
, IS YEARS AGO
(1*44)
We are buying Ivy and Laurel Buries and paying highest
prices at mill in Franklin or by roadside. Highlands Brier,
Inc., Franklin, N. C. ? Adv.
Following a week of bad weather, with high winds, rain,
snow flurries, ice, and near-zero temperatures. Highlands was
visited Monday by a six-inch snow, suspending school and
blocking bus travel.
, 5 YEARS AGO
(1954)
Barbecued boar was the menu when the Macon Ctounty
'Coon Hunters Association met Saturday night at the Nor
mandie restaurant.
Strictly Personal By WKIMAR JONES
Casting an Interesting sidelight
on the Community Development
awards luncheon In Ashevllle last
Saturday were the names of some
of the participating communities.
Looking over the list of names,
I wondered again what I've often
wondered before: Is there any
area, anywhere, that has more
unusual, picturesque place names
than Western North Carolina?
Some of the names on this list
provoked my curiosity: How did
those communities ever get those
names? Some stirred my Imagina
tion: What do they mean? Some
created pictures for me: Who
could see or hear the name with
out seeing the community in his
mind's eye?
I wondered, too, how much some {
of the names may have affected
the people who live there.
Here are some of the ones that
Interested me: .
Ptsgah Forest.- Was it dense
forest when it was settled and
named? Or did it later take Its
name from the National Forest
of that name? I
Hawk. There was a time in
Western North Carolina when the
hawk was the deadly enemy of a
farmer's poultry. Did that com
munity suffer more than most
from the depredations of the
hawk? Or did someone kill a hawk
there under such unusual cir
cumstances as to give the place
Its name?
Sunny-view. Is there more sun
shine there than elsewhere in the <
mountains? Surely the view some- ,
times must be clouded, even ,
covered by fog. Did some pioneer,
after days and nights in cloud
and fog, suddenly see and wel- .
come the sun as he came upon j
the view there? (
Rocky Pass. What pass in the
mountains of Western North
Carolina isn't rocky? Is this one
really so rocky as to make it out- '
standing In. that respect, In this
region of rock?
Double Island To me. there's
always a fascination about the
word "Island", Maybe It's because,
In our relatively narrow Western
North Carolina rivers, there are
so few islands of any consequence.
Maybe It's because there's some
thing exalting about standing on
a bit of land that has water all
around It. In any case, "Double
bland" has a double fascination
for me. Someday I'm going to
see that double island.
Savannah. All of us here know
the location of the creek that
gives the community its name.
It's Just across the crest of the
Cowee; you pass along that creek
as you drive to Sylva. But how
did It ever get that name? Did
some homesick Georgian, in the
old days, give it the nam* of his
native city?
Sleepy Valley. Boy, how quickly
a chamber of commerce would
move to change that name! Yet
It doesn't seem to have affected
the people who live in It: they
were wide enough awake to be
In thU year's community contest.
Iotla. All of us know the nam*
of this beautiful Macon County
valley Is Cherokee. But who knows
how It happens that. If the correct
pronunciation Is "I-o-la", the "t"
ever got In the word? Or. if the
"t" originally was pronounced,
how did it happen we later
dropped it in pronouncing the
word, but failed to drop it in
spelling it?
Palnttown. That's a name to
make you wonder. It's over at the
Cherokee Reservation, of course,
and so it's reasonable to assume
it once may have been the place
where the Indians painted them
selves. But did the Cherokees use
paint? Originally, they didn't wear
feathers, you know; even though
some of them do it today, for
the benefit of the tourists.
Some of the answers to these
questions I no doubt could find,
if I'd do a little looking. But I
wont. Because, to me, the specula
tion about these names is far
more interesting than the facts
would likely be.
LONG MAY IT REMAIN !
The Footlog Across The Creek
WINSTON-SALEM JOURNAL
Mrs. Lillian Cover, Cherokee
County's representative in the
General Assembly, has asked the
State Highway Commission to put
"at least a log" across a creek
near Andrews. Twelve children
now have to wade the creek every
day on their way to and from a
school bus stop, she said.
This request will arouse interest
and curiosity among the state's
older citizens and set some of
them to wondering Just how many
pedestrian footlogs still span small
streams in rural North Carolina.
There may be quite a few old
Footlogs across rural creeks in the
state. But one rarely sees the logs
nowadays, either in driving
through the countryside or in
walking through rustic areas.
Most of them apparently have
gone the way of the little one
teacher schoolhouse, the old cover
ed well, and grandma's milkhouse
down by the spring.
The footlog provided a cheap,
quickly constructed means of
spanning a creek for the benefit
of pedestrians. Usually the log
was the itrimmed trunk of a
large, tough oak, or hickory tree.
It was firmly staked or nailed in
place on each side of the stream.
To prevent walkers from slipping
when the Iot was wet, losing
their foothold ~od plunging Into
the stream, "hand poles" were
usually extended across the stream
about waist-high above the log.
One could hold to the pole as he
went along or grab it if- he started
to slip.
These old footlogs gave growing
boys a chance to show off. Some
of them liked to reveal their
prowess by walking the entire
length of the log without once
touching the convenient "hand
pole". This was indeed quite a
feat if the log happened to be
limber and wiggly. Sometimes
over-confident youngsters made a
misstep and landed up to his
knees in the middle of the creek.
Nowadays when the art of walk
ing seems almost lost and nearly
everyone hops in a car, even to
go just a few hundred yards, pert
haps there is much less need for
the old country creek footlog. But
these crude pedestrian bridges
have a noble tradition of public
usefulness.
Thus old timers to whom the
word footlog brings back nostalgic
memories find something pleasant
in the news that in Cherokee, at
least, the value of these old walk
ways Is still appreciated. Long
may the footlog remain a feature
of the Carolina rustic scene!
SUMMER SCHOOL
BECOMES POPULAR
?
There's a surprising trend in
California education: Summer
school is attracting more high
school students each year. The
State Department of Education
reports one out of every four pub
lic high school students was en
rolled in class during the 1959
summer.
School districts which take the
time to prepare attractive sum
mer class course offerings and
which budget the necessary fdnds
to carry on such worthwhile en
deavors are to be commended. ?
San Bernardino (Calif.) Sun.
THEY VARY
Your Own Bed Is Best
?
W. E. HORNER In Sanford Herald
There's just nothing like sleep
ing in one's own bed.
No matter how many inner
spring or rubberfoam mattresses
there are in hotel and motel
rooms, and regardless of how
thick and smooth, they're never
quite the equal of the bed in
which you normally get your rest.
For 15 nights recently I slept
in a variety of beds in a succes
sion of countries and cities. Two
whole nights and the better part
of another were spent in seats
on trans-Atlantic planes; these
are fairly restful and with backs
reclined and a small pillow edged
behind your head, always pro
vided you either have the gift of
complete relaxation or are weary
enough, you can get at least fitful
sleep. Isn't as restful as sretch
ing out full length but better than,
nothing.
Hotel beds in the cities I slept:
London, Amsterdam, Stuttgart,
Munich, Zurich and Paris, were
comfortable. Most of the time
these boasted feather filled coun
terpanes, several inches thick and
as large as the bed, to keep off
the cold. Most places the single
rooms had two beds, and as noted
in other writings, the chamber
maids always carefully prepared
the second bed for occupancy.
The mattresses were good; usual
ly double innersprlng and the
beds were long enough for a fel
low to stretch out full length.
Enormous pillows were provided
and at Munich there was an extra
gimmick under the mattress: a
wedge shaped affair about 30
inches wide, tapering from zero
inches to eight, which elevated
the head of the bed like a hos
pital bed raised up. These were,
mercifully, detachable; if you took
It out the first night, as I did,
it wasn't replaced. k.
Still, none quite came up to
the bed I sleep in about 340 nights
a year.
RIGHTS VS. RITES
FOR MOTORISTS
Some motorists and pedestrians
are stubborn enough to insist on
their "rights" even if it means
their last rites. ? Traffic Safety
News.
What Do Kids Think About
NEW YORK HERALD TRIBUNE ,
II
' According to a survey just pub
lished by the Office of Education
In Washington, children nowadays
have more fears, anxieties and
worries than children of former
years. Well, the same can prob
ably be said for most adults, even
without a survey. What everybody
is so worried about, we don't
know. But we are Intrigued by
the confidence with which thl^
survey reports on what children
think about. r
Prom time to time we ourselves
have asked the nearest child what
was on his (or her) mind, but
the Information we have elicited
Invariably deal* with such things
as the imminence of Christmas
(it's nearer than most parents
think) or the various reasons for
postponing bedtime an hour on
any given night (the variety is
astounding ) .
If the Office of Education has
additional Information, we shall be
happy to consider it. For our
selves. we would gladly add the
way of a child's mind to those
three other eternal enigmas, the
way of an eagle In the air, the^
way of a serpent on a rock, the
way of a man with a maid.