r
No" SV
ALEIGII. (N. C.) FRIDAY, AUOL'ST
-
Vol xvn
THE STAR.
f jH Mr&-Caro!ik'a 'state Gazette,
DELL 4 .LAy HENCE.'
fubtf!trto; thrv1ltrt rriiiMnu-V .
Mr will ba Mt riihiut i (tail 2l 50 H pad
I a J ", Ihil paper (liicoaliiNied, kt (
' the arwoa)if ihf ff tfori,aalrMll arrearaaaa
r pU. AdreHnriaenit, etacetttitf 11.
tcca lio-, Insetted three Imri lor dollar.
All lellar (a the ciiitun matt bcad ajf .
m-' " ci nil.
V(X1 T"! -
appointed if a b tb.
l -a
iT. P- and ti wl.ith it lui fJ-I rifv
, r' ixriit are vrrr J.f. f ',,;. .1. " T'
a.Ja7
ifffm ht Ifaiional Litclligtnctr.
to rATmc HEXCr.. '
Ilaring now estaWiahad, I m venture to
I j a
tu e, i; fcut zj- .. Br
PmK
y:. br ib. 2L7 w ""T whether
PWr, let cl.ian. .'"! " '."Iuw"" Per wr.U not ts K
owe liMtaner. and lh,t rrmrir . ? rD ,r wo f debate U
. ' oosimfncemtol f od Over , hicfc U U nrki ("1 .u'
HCD
peech of o of ttrihuK b
. i - . .. ' .. i . -wum vii DacK tne it cniiAB I vim !hl. : "
7 wjupa inc poasiDjwy or reMOrubla con- ot Ifte LonJi to tha one . JL.I .V j H . w"llrw aoMor.
oe Sonne, io control the rtm . the , w,ti0,lj t,. ' K J7
freedom, of debate, is he hher i.Minn.4 k- Ln. r.:f.A . K 1 """J T"
tha Coorttieo. or Juatlfied by the ZCL btuJlS. I.
krtw-wn . t.. 'l.v- . cnauiunea the fact. I IM 71h nils ofthn i. . " , " "
"-I vj wjuna con-
reattain tha Vice Prei-
tha power, bj Ctniting
lh Senatef And. se.
.fit . -
nll.t. il 111.. 7T. . : 1 "P- " """ wt now auHice. !Whe.
mi.i;n,,i J 'ri ' . i-"re - -'-iBcm arc inoae of the 8n
j-ou Dive i noi arerruied . tl
lilinn. t-nn I (WO QIIMtinna , . ..
pI. f.KtiU.-j .L.rri.k. rlu "w, nether
ruieaaaunaaeortho Senate utheaoure
of tha wwr f ther Vice President,' all
- lirther inqoirjr; it fairly cloaed. JTut, aa ma.
'7' "ry "in you in the conclu-
phjih-mi'kt irrac
Uh eoitemot ro,i :ih heforee nerweretmaureT.f the power.
r -. w uvilin It W DH IIIWM naMad lk . 1 !. Ilha ak.K.K:kI .a a - - w
per to aaeertain whether.U hM been e ,W Ul v, 11. ZZ L-w.hh,-,t ner H Pinat tha practice of the Howef
. . .. . i t nm usual meamn iiiummonL mi in r. r .i... .i
trained conception of the origin of the pow.
w rrwurni rrr anir aarr a-r I .maH --i
0.fr aau . f 3 r " I ? MWIITIIIVUS .Will '
F"FMn rainy acnved. In
v '"su'5 "i aucif eaaet, is
. mo ainrmativa., I mil nn
Msual tneanin t I Commnni. and in f.nnr ..
i...: t' 7 -ui ina Mouse
inmg; and- thit it it nhW It may hot be imoronei. to ni:,- .
!. . .-.-a . . ' I ,v- bmi UUi H
ion, wmch, in miatake not, haa, in no amall
irp-ee, eaiUnbuted to the error which exists
me decision of the Vice President,
are- Aiflr who ara fur
your absurd and danperous positions, a
The author!! the .Z . If. :ln!L,',,n Vice President
wch. caset. it I its nauaj m..hirt3 " T 5 ! r "Vtr who I
the
"mu nteanintfw ..r think. n-nti'irCr'
jouen. or an, of your aawiatei, to point tfctf iEXSte ! the
u .in .mc , or tue usage of tie Senate: bv hoaaeaaM J - Y " "" - ncy conceae to the Senate the
whicB , the power.fca. been conferred "Son? feTtotu infefS riff M of determining their rnlea, and that tWs
mtch4s or can be designated, -If a' 2 Vce KsidenV li rbelonff. ,JW to he fiRlU comprehend, that of deterniininp what
question bsaakeda.tnthnJ ..k. c "'Li.' rf'Kle- - trance deduction w 0- what is not disnidrl, k.
.. " : . i '.r i inmne ex omcio tfutvtM
Cfil at, the -hfaj
a., k. .
. .44 at. mil fr;j
TenhxbW and priolK: Macon hw.kj be r
Of IDS I rtmnniiu -i
J a . a a iti
b:; iT.-rv'i rf -
m. iiTZrj .'mr'- U1 tr flection of
U a ! rZ"de"' P" ,r"u of '' Senate,
lal BfetD Vl t Ik AMr...l .
tack on the Vice Present
It would hira k,,n :,,,., . , .. ;
and we accordin-'v h - r . J '
cbarres abni Mr. r ,'hrv,,,,'.
lowe&t and most meivcnw hiwlu ..- ..
rj " 7 "''0Ut. :',C,e Pccification,
it M otterljr unnmsibla to m , ...'
LTk ,k- fjr,TMr. "' jro for nothing
ai'Bi the Wise and ,iri... :
ot the part of those
uons Mviny only thit.
hr n,.ite- Ilim t!..-
evillrp : an fhtin... . i . '..V
iiu icai fniiinii nf 1
1 1 i o tnu
l. (k- I n ri in
rk."Ara"iM h i't.r'.lyhon-
"u w air. t::a;t )t) the mi,
political enmiu, h'$ p
VNarakB ai 1 V .. .
a.uiKi3 ir-e fmm r I r,,.,
. . . . - - uv trie
hT.e , ,J.', r'J lent sKaB
;r.k J. "" ,fr ""! "-'Wile
' e at!o, it i , j.
ir the
rate.
atei
l aaay call
c
c
in
e.rn
has
e mriiibrr ha r, I k . ! r . -
poten, the frr.f. ... .
me,!,., ,!vfc , Ulil
at!et,t I' . 1, k. n. , -
The fhiir. n",J f iv . k..c!.
o.. l l -rat, ..vd anxio,,, .
L " power. ndi enet
wie ronv,, !.,,,., U rih. - .
be nf f? b','n,ff'cl-'y to thawenv-;
!l bo.lv. ami not to the Ch;r. - Tha
P0'1, of the Prea-in-. m .i?"!
"f Points is an appellate power win and,
''-cqurntlr, the duties of the Thai, mm! "
ce when a Betiator is called to order bw
,f',t t V. . it .
to i i w no o KHina anpreperea
lo l scharsre its only functions in such a ease
Jliat of deeidinp; on the point of order
lnntted. What tha n;n; r .ki t
'd.r.a; officer u In relation to the freedom of
debate, n this boly. it will bo lime to !.
mien a nitrstion m ha mUi,i..
present Station, foa murA n.-, t .
we nnW a wkcA in f,,n,r of th, i, "
n3t ftkfrttdan tf, '.. n'r Th,t i.
been indefatigable in the,!:, 1, ,r , ',' but, gtiob s it It it n.-m s.i.. .. .'
yi that Tie has been courtron. 'm f. '.,-." M may adj. frarlea! m,;nf.;"A.i 'n...
t . t . ' '""n" " "I nnw.
n3 ,momen V 1,e b"t Com his
committed .i" 7., '""vcr,
wnv wiu;itifiii:iriii i : 1. 1
out all. He did not StOrt Mr l.'.int .t1. r-
the head and front nfiiio iv,....r' . '. I nower ahnnld ha s- . . '
no is Mr. R.indo n Uf in I,- .i,;..7 of the bod. Th vsa tu.:.i.. ...a i
atnjter in our lifitional n.,.i.' prided himself fill ISaC AHnttAa aa. 'at. A.
more than a qmrter of a century he has be,,, ?Mte;but Itwas impoble that he ahidd
rr ra ma, ii.a . n
r ..., vllu ,ulc, , in senate, on
point so nnnortant. n in ik. n..:.
onjpiui power, and that it can eteci,a
control till calle.1 on bv the Senate irself, t
was ri-ht in Itself, he said, in atrir-i enfnm:,.
I to the - principles which had jruided the
in uio ote fust taken that so bitrh a
Z " V 'V's. awi.rtur.1 the whole 1,1,1 ln" connection wa created bV
& ''.Y' incd unchanged j1"9 JP"n of the Cnnatitution.' In dii
HiRhlv Ulcnted .eloquent, sevcre.andecccn. c ,rtrii,'r h'. ?aiT in thi it would be
llic: always wanderii,( f, T, . I unoardnnahta in hia. a u n... . .
HBI. 1.1 , . I . . ' . . ' .'
wuuiu uc ine renir. i nn imti ..k'-.i.t.t i j . ....... ,W.W ,.. ag
immediately quoted, and iT that-were sun- -dS w-7 t it has Mrs of the S
posed:to beXdoubtful. J-Mi'S. ..d J?.!!.0.1 mds.ionsthah the rule, nile extend.
House, would ha hM nnrZZZLZWZ. ! ln:Se"e," -there is
.nmerable instance, of & HSS
w mo power
R I klr TrS f Kaa hk.Ha- a. ' '
No such answer can h . Y,1 WL?', "V V
Whan ua la tk , a .i" .V . . " " W.WIDmolB!
" e wuie lUITCr UI WW?a I inana.4..au T ' , .
StrikinB- o flerence' bn h, .1.: ' . I.'.. ' 7ou ve Te"ooked the ma
dl' Wi8 I'"" wor!,,y f BacoJ"" P'cd ithe Chair, not by the-voice of
, not discredit aSheri.l:L oc!. out oy that or the People: and
dan,evcry Speaker had freely indulged him thrt the"H md not this bodi'. he was ulti.
lfl II ft nonu a I -.(.(,., a. . .
nn."i ! , . "ner, ana that without re. V-T ""Ponsmie. standing In the rehtion
...VJ censure; ana none more freely .u,u no had laid It down as
lUl,C t!resP"t Sec- f State. while he pre. wwiabh rule, to assume no power in tlx,
;. Ir. V , lB . ?us. ol 'epfeentatives. He c"cKw aoubUulj end to confine himself
the nowera
tendered
acknowledfrtnenU,
jerd had been paid to his feelings in the
"7 WW nta oeen done to the
id HVLltU. t in B L Itnw alwa iL': a I lis M IllaW nil Kim aa, a
;dnln w...l... .1.. ' j ,k . . 'b uiautni,DVI . ( . .trewe r
.a.;.. ra;: "lc. J'.ecu- ?".cnina. renowned Commonwealth of pieany aeiepate . In conclusion he
:"T "7" na takes his seat in the Scnafi. An 10 ln senta "is Sincere
tocssesofthe freedom of de. immed ate nivra . ;. w,..i. . . t1" Itliaf n .u. T
. I I- -. - : rt . .. . I i0 in,, vi r- .-trBI Itcl tha v. I ' awiiiuillir II1B n
Km". I iiiic. ' j ne imnmit art im ..... .. r.. dm. r. . . - o . 1
h.A.. .ik Tm...J....u !. I"" . I mm, who had bean
u.,, . . MMwciaiK, k, is, mnr, where there is S so long perm tted. by so manv e..v ,
e phdu-aue, rulethe Senate, the Vice' President has, exercise 'hi. ntal freedoT of
Jtllt let aiieh I SI officio, the niivif.nrn,1.i:na il.. .i. Ih
- - " I .. ' ivtuirtiiuif IUC U1V uivulu I I U rrinrpriWaaa h a aa
stab-1 ceening-s of the Sedate bv it. without anv
debate.'
industry ,d' fidelit W! i Twk i' L"" :
- 'I'VVM ,V
a'lltaf rflPBN Il !as aK.l..
e. I Adminititrriii r. .k 7. V' I dnt!.. Tia-t- '.V-f. . -a . .,
dow. press authoriiv in the rule f a ih.l aflaei ah on thh ,."-.."? "T.?"" .i.. ai...k.a ' . " " "y inw
a . s - . , v tiim wva-. jsii s vau ui na r. .ifn unnn is am sar as va ij ai i.r . nisi iiaii a araatat tiiaaa at a .
of tha Snaata. 'FX V"1 V"" ?." possessea it jbf OmimW rWas a" mquirv. Is there. ,,r 1. f bar. n.ToaS . .i" , UV"f r."J the Whole jr; .rT """"ff .H nI,relumed
Hifla.n whirl, t,.a .---.:;"r""ri""i W-iftif as wellhaM! shown, which his been full .;d.d .ad i -.. ih.n h.a kl" u.ai ne would"
ac Srtd tV tl" 2:1. JBwjf Rcpren. .aaotoriVdetemined inhT for wbaV wodd "iJK a" !2!
the rules of ihe two Houses In tcwrd to the tha ;VkT PreaiHanrr.. ' f ' 'T'1 Pl T'" ?OT5" pet.,, srments on this and usurpation, than helbSti
ny. MbfcirjiL VrB CinriU. Vltla. 1 lit iinh M.k.. iLv - I a . a mivi ivt h u- uiivi nuu U nav naan IahI.J .t
j"Lv" " rrV" ,?a,Sy itrong in the one ?own, and the question is at an end. - There nerfr denied, .h. "..."'."".P-
...neoinen v;,f, . ,..iJfW,, is none, . s - 1 rmittad h. .5 ;.kV" "r naa "
,,:"r,0:, ?Wave it understood,'th.t the ; 'As connected with tht. part of the .ubfect. ST Ions: . 31??.'!'
io not think it neceKary-.toneet thfttidji- would T,.Te bee uVe'l, ZlZdZ $113
culoua charge of ineonsfriencv which vou done to the Sen.ioa . 'd'n(1 V.,e lnJu,t.,cc
make aMinst the Vice President in the ere,: th- State th, 7 ,n,V ""d to
f hia oower. and whiehn.i anda.va 4..:..iad ; .i . '.V'"! wou.kl Wv been
the nepresenlaiives exnrajtclvltla.
pled the power to the Speaker, those of the
Senate, by atronf implication, withhold it
from the Vice President, -little room can be
ich loruouoi. ,Jomp!tre, in this view, Uie
J9ih nile of the House, and the- 7th of the
Senate? 0-he : former jays, If any membet,(riv
v 01 i-Hiiiament nave been adoRted by the
Senate. ., No Such. thnff, I challenge yon ;to
e ai'iKic mie or net Of the -Senate ihaf
NoTS..Th lumbers of tr.i. Z -'
tw will be found In thav.i;n..i i-.2i :
the lit of May, and the rth of June, 1829,? ,
? FKCULCIRCULAR; ,j
m.:rjuiy nth, 1$;-
tHE MILITIA.
by sneakiDe, or otiose., tn in the most 7.7, W Sin , AmoW ' tn vii?;.?
r : i , . . . . o. t ... .. cucrvun yas cnea ineaa miaa aa Ha i aunaorr nv ratapanaa r.. , i :y. 7.ia : iicbc f . . - o i ; i afkuaiiiia
! -e... . v "ri r - -j ?- uu laisc cons'rauuns. we are sat afi.d l. j . . vhirh tha au. .... .f 2L-, ... .
.:.k ih tn- "ai :t . ''-iua no weiznt -"- wi irutj, vi .nil renhlA or
ho know the United, Stes hai adopted oson. '
aaMadl.iln,,aai:an.kl. aL
.uivaui iiic tiuiiHr.ine npitAiiahii 'M.ii.i: ... ' . -. - - I : "
Li . . r'Z'."""' "V I "'P ParOI me rulfsnnd iieairaanf ha (L...I.' I acCOUntA f hla annd..aa I- a,.
.m-mourniay, cautoorcler: in Whfch-rstte tka I Uh: fc. . 1". .vr - . vrarukiur.
tj:..; a T r r.-- i , - . .u iud vasc-ui. ntr. I Wl(n lB wice fresidanl. u...i.i
...k-'- lli.a -.: . '. mci lunnuinir.Tor moment that Mr TaHarann' I lnCKerson. ' It uiffli.U.ML.1 rw , k..l Lt '"wwuoi
. iuc. so cauea w oraet, snail immediately had cited them -.ah Urti - ll"-! "': 1 ,aiw .k" IkLI V "V "H man is i
i oown, urtless permitted to explain and the nuestion w
MnnCA-aiMfill a aa. aa. Aa Jar .A . S . I- ' la I I
?"r appeaiea-to, acculf m the tlo rules
3a P Wvidealtha
-..v y.mtvn ur tuo iiniir snail ne mihmif Ll l milo. f u
t a a . a. T VJ I IVI V ki
.. r"--- witiium if4C Ol the HOnsP arwl mnof..r Tk.i su. t. a- . . -
if Iha a. ? . . - a . .
case require k, ne snail 6e liable to the
censure of the - House.", ?The-jHihj of the
bcnate.nnllie oiintraTv iwnvLln. iri
ber shall be called to order for words spokfen
ftc cxcentionnbla M-m.,U iVinll . :.4.Jj:..-,
wicen ao n in wrrtinp. that the Pmulant
mar be bt:ttcf fenahled to ?nd
"... it.x: u?c corresponding ruleg of
two Houses, jand
rVftlMaVa.,. 41. '
...,.!, u.at Biuuiarppwers are intended "Jo
" Conferred by them.
Alcc.!:e?ldent? 'Or wilj It be insisted on that
of
ptct:
F-'on,
M d.itercrice m.the phrajelogy is accidental,
lien it is known that tliev hma nri.. 'k...
rawed oit.thc -reports 'of committees: who
wmld nnCiatiito
. v. J . " - Ul a,iiT
-v iiouses-c-i coffesponaing wbjcclsf Un
inch cireifmstances, it is impossible lha'
' 7V was unintentional. 'This
Xil!0n!,Jn,ctK'U9 l'-enfftheiied,
Ea.d',!;'-to ? Afferent !t",on.
'0,lse- Tlie Sneaker 1 rhiuan k .ki
,. rv-a.,niircB, nn. is consefinehUy di
haeS?0!u,''b.,e lo tl(e !Wr;nd hia deci.
Sa ii ' r .."" oe appealed from to
s- M:Tb Vice ;re.i(lent. oD the con!
:?.7t ' PraI m Ihe chair b the Conaiin..
rleclaiaiv s re!PPns'ble to the ,30itttiel4ihd l.ia
iinlWr ft, .5 "nout' PP - "?c" ve took
ion i ,? lhe ' eson ot etial a taria
esnalti... 'n,H? conferring power on their
ble f,'. cT"P,mcerK- " remark
.i 'r that the same difTerene ;.,
h betw,e? lhe .PW9id''"? officers of
ie te,k!:frwIl?ch th-y respectively preZ
in . i r "",,," .nepeaiter is chosen
he c,,n, ' ' nncr responsible oh-
-hw W " f. House of Lords, the
nwc,llorKraSiae. e, ofTicio, iu like manner
"le.lCe Preaidan, . k. c . - 3
liVa j -. ic tjtuaic, anu is
owit i.? ?npr' '""possible to the body.
H.lT temaf IF ab,e 'l"11 be Speaker
fcctlv r.f t,."wrn,que.Kn, .while it is
oei J 'fer.t:u,n. W Lwd . Chanceiror
t- ?us' Bkeflfctr dissimilar
'tft ted"- ,..'lve'rt trac. made apuny
J"t.nction between the mode
nceHci,CC I'?' ndtbe Lord
.i..wel or re-tiDDoinfnV ' hd k. .1. -
' "fnH l-ttcr ha; net' Uio
a . a " -
hi , ' .71 , . ?
ai. . f a.i -.1- T a . I ' W VVI1 alUia.U ITaWfl. Ka, I tTl AI. tSJI l ara a -v I I " a a
process ot reason f uu v,"n '"r Voe rresttient io not be-l mieht. is
long to lum as presiding officer of the. Senate, can Peop
i
, , ai ocniue nas not nuopted I ,H1 Ucy are not cbnterred on him by I .piracy
(lie rules of Parliament is : certain, and I con.j the Mies or. usages of the Senate, ortljpie of fault is,
'ess I am not a little tcuriojn to aa tha m L Parliament, f miiv ,A.w affix. h.t : I . in
most certain, tt is for7hrn,-a5 1 Z I W this o-
B fhf.f ha heiaa ak... -1 a .... 1 taUhl!. VaUill NAat!.a aL t 1 aa
that he has chosen the side of libert, .w'ch Will realize the hone of ui all
than Of nouar ..d ..,k . . -yiin raMa.a a .1 . .
. wiiubq n fdi" ivibicuvQ tu uui rri'xc arm itt im
nwTi" Tmf con;'sin verentit regard for the al defence. v T V
nlng to ex- freedom of debate, shall succeed. v ' ft. . . . Si. .4.W$Z
spirit that ; v ;;, , , ' iTmoir i r ?7 re8olon r ConpreW, at '
ubnefunc , "s- I" Me8sion,.Iarn enjoined; to cau
h-aah . . . ' VIII . aa ..v " .-'I'" "1 flii.
cf. of reason
mm, rr in. um... - ....... ... ... i nii.n... ..... i .
. ... v,,c vjciiii.r, ipujsth aaopon, ' is try; re I wy ucserves praise, tor acclinl
not a -trikin : analoirv between 'this nnd ihai ercise iu He lm antad in ih .n
question: whether th conrmori taw :ia utnt i I ought to actuate -lever virtnnua nnhtia
part of the laws of the Union r : Wa; llioiiarv: not tO1 aaaiuma donhlflll nmi'ana ii
lllll..l.l.....l....'j.Jl.J I. .1 .'. . ' I. ,,:.! ..J . . f m .
judicial attihoritv notTObei
me, the areiiments. vhidi w
hh; to the one, would be eqrta
wire Hicsuon, inar jne rules
Parliament ma bV referrad t,
the rules of either House nf tlnnm.
m iad" ZP a1'.0" nln,a? b reiM,iI' thr? re BtiU ever-1 of your remark, tliat
mitteu. . Arguments may be drawn from anv I quire notice. Von hawt !. v
source cnlculated to illuirata: hn h f. I th ttMUA a.lti. t.... " 7 ,vu
aWMaa. t ".." "A --3 , ..; " - ' "'"J"" '".
w
adoptioo by Congres
.The Wisdom of m Ana,,. '1. w '.w- ' .
to attri. ., K6 one, more than mvs-if a.id. h-xr 7 urM' . 8 olneot or f ie beat
;ked and Preside 51 ''J' that ft ahall be
would indl-a ki " t r vuaiuerau
Ir.na. a l . . a a ... -i ar n ..av Mlcian
mi MMn. v i - . , .. . . I ""6 vc-Tiuions oeiure nim.J-.'
......vw, ,.uu na not oniy anacRed I , a ant .. u j.u.a . .
I aa ucuaia on in. am.. ..... .
idad h.d .vt...!. "-.VJ. JV,L
"cod? a Kind.ng force on the Senate, The corrupt are lhe most disposed
without ever havme been recoimiid aa italhura chmmt;n ...d ...
M.i. ui-n 1 , . . s . " , j.iui uynviia.eu and
riiles,if,ThiMs sub.iect of deep and grave onjustitiable attack on Mr. Cs moUves snt
I?ffivithv ' " ,t.,s.1,0t ne?Msary v my "le in fyQr of your heart as your ar,!
purpose,.! feline entering on it. It is suffi. mcnts do of your head. . . Fortunately for hl
resident, can be mora deeply imoresied Mr 'TUX. J' "SUallbeu.
th the great truth, that the preseWoTof niforra- fmP0rtance;of tlw fast is
fcient.at ntahf d- "Jk.. " " I s.. u".: ' I . """-"' iot the
-,.., . ,, . , jcucreon i . rcumciu, nu general oharacter for
i .i i i a 1 1 ic II L rcrCTTPU
w Dy vou as mose or the Senate. "On the con
tue and patriotism shield him from the imp,,. the nation
tationofsuch gross abuse of power, from immortal.
system of
pics, that no cower oue-ht m h dti...j
vhiah a.n K-V..:.l.. ""Z T-a' . "
rights . depends, mainlv. an iia-a ...i..
That nation deserved to conquer tha world!
uihirh aallad i.a aa... . . . .T?
-- ... ... aim anmiiu! ,m an ail
. ,! " .. ."' "l
deserre tliat its libartv hn k.
which lays the foundation of its
-...sAi. . ... ..a,.., xf iiirmni wivh vi buii rDsa 1
.1 ...vi ni. vauivn.HI I, LCU U I B rllifl fit I UlJll lfTlTlllrB Tnifltfaal Max rva af..h..l. av a I . aa ' -.iwM la, IU
th British House of Commons, without stall Ha could not decide' dirfbrcntly '7 om r.h. -?al Rt brinci
lincrlham In ha nkl l.. !.. I I .1', .'!., .. . I .ui
Hetorcit
thai body, which are wholly diasim'.lat. r, I known to Bfi ... ,1 111 " W.T" wn op?J . nd that none ought evtrto be
k ..... ii.. orL.. i. . :. F " " i , . r " ."'"- """ punnciv iiciec.tea out to resnoiuiihl -m...
. " " DCI Ulc yu cite Mr. or private y, that the maxim which ha h-id". I ha k.a m. ,
leffbrsoo's opinion., in which he'says. The in the hi,rhVst eeZ VZl llkV0!' i.fe."! ola of
Senate haye accoingly. formed some rule.
for its government." (they hare been - m.'.rh of c-ovammant. ; ,,.. a " . T Ftxem "tm wu. " ? ?,a not SlVe. my ntjre assent
enlarged s loce.) " but these coin onlv to . troTled bvt he bod o MefcT. u 25" . W?. rules In
r -i a ' . . i a . v s, icn-iLiari. uuFxuun nave ruF Ln wamt,r.t j w ...
and t int. n -.thn., ...k -a...:u:i:. .. ? . . .. . . " --ucu. s mist.
few'eWa. the!,..-. a-faa-V: .k.. Jlr ir . .i .i. . v":' !? exerciseo, question Have 04
oftheJ-residenY
questions of onler nrisinir under their runt TiT- Z?'' . ' J . "".,ul " vccopy this Chair.
. . . ... " ...... i . . ,,v .luiit in uivinir IIW ID P11 UT, III IUIW.M ....
rules, or wnere t (ere i imn i tuu ,i 1 h an a...,. . .l: r...J:.- . " . i :" l o- -- i
uiaii.njn .tii me rresiui
extensive field of decision! Jf v
in, quoting the above oassatre was
mat, wnere tne senate baa adopt
of its own. the rules of Parliament
ot ine senate, completely fads. . Not the m.ght have taken a different yiew of the siib.
V6 . r "K . " ,m ,ucn n -Uec "Ut, as he had decided in conformity
deft,' Mf. JcflersOTk .On the C6ntrarv snva I to nrinrinlpa Inn r,T.d ;,. ht. j f
ih.t ; .t -a .,.:. - f :: : . rr; "r." ",mu www is
r,r iir I v . , ,J! , 'sc eVon J-'newing maugnant jn the extreme, to attri:
....... imuiii,. ia uiuiuit, auu Slicil 11
aj aiuuiiion, i none.
TV. lw.in, 'T,m.mim,.is im. pursues a Oiiterent Urection-nr t .i ' J
snt a very matenw. it is, and long has been, hi., and powers, but to discharge, with irldustrV
mir nhiart Icould not full in hni-in. ra infl.. ... .ot " uuusiry.
- -.1 - -.- ia b"-a,... cncrin ine l ntieiuy, anu nrmness, the duties which mav
to show decision, which you have o seriously assault, be imnoaed ' on ma 1'hua i: . .
lf,?dh;i yourM witness, with pleasure, the re. on rfal
i ------- - a. a w aovaa a is uiiaai r. laai is a s i ii axt nnwaF - is - r a.aH a.a.
scarcelr inferior to the firal. for who
,ai wen appreciate tm itlconveniencea
resulting from different avstema i k.
ante Arraj? lhe MiliUa differinjr amotiz
themlelvea, aa also with thereeular Ar-
taj wun which they mar be wiled to
act; and ret it l. I believe,' too true
that but I.ttle; uniformity prevail; if',
practicable, thi defect must be rcinov"
has bute his decision t moaves of personal en.
This opinion of Mr. Jefierson'a la nmk,. I
bly founded on the latter part of Uie 6th rule, or not. and every otieation nf order .hail h
V luch Strongly, SimnortsiL The ruin la .a daridad hw tha l.;U.i ...l...... j.i.-x- i....
f,.n tvi" .k. .1.-.. . . .a.7 . -r w,.",y".u!u-";oui
v"v"a...u ..it hcii a mciiiucr aiiau lb raupn i it t iera i,a a 4inniir .n h
to order, he slall sit down until the President iot the sense of live Senate." J
he may est
hmnarW av.: I
by the Senate, as they will be then placed,
where alone they can be with perfect safety
From the direction which the debate hi
some degree, took, as well as from what has
been said without these walla, it becomes,
on tin occasion, proper that I should state
for. the information of this body, the cowl
atruction that lhe chair has put on theCtli
and 7th rules of lhe Senate. Th. ... :...
following words: -
-hcrf a member shall be caTW to order 1
lam dulir aehsible how itifita..! u t. '
to establish a uniform n .
itlercnce of condition, physical and '
moral, in the different States, and th, ' .
11. I for that
.....v.. v. i.u.c uiej nave ueeo accu.
tomed to, prate feriola obstaclea to
a homogeneous itaum throughout all 5
the States, yet I would fainTjope not
uwormountabtcX ;; r ' , i 1 ,
All our national '; institutions and
much of ot-i-r legislation,' are founded
" that mutual apirit of deference and
forbearance whidh have w signally dig..
ungnished the Pml of fha, ' .
and herefore one tty jndulgetbe hope ,
that, io an object ofsuch vital impcrtance
as a well reflated Militia, minor iih. .
jccliona will be sacrificed to tits attaltr- ' T
Va
mcui oj so great a good, v