THE AJ-ZCCIAT-D DI3PATC2E3 LAST EDITION. 4:00 P. U. : Weather rorec&st: Cloudy, Wanner. v VOL. XIV. NO. 223. ASHE VILLE, JT. O-i TUESDAY AFTERNOON, OCTOBER 26, 1909. 3c PER COPY lie An M'JFSTILM IS JT'-IICE Mr. Collins Says That Mr. Bunt ing Was Shot First;' Jones and Gowan Say Collins Was Shot First. MRS. R. M. CADWALLADER, JR., WHO WAS MISS E. M. ROEBUNG ASSISTANT HOTEL STEWARD IS GIVEN MEDAL OF HONOR PRIHGE ITO IS DURFI TODHTH . 4 NEGROES ARE PUT THROUGH SEVERE CROSS EXAMINATION They Did not Weaken, However, With Respect to Any Important Fea- turei of Their Teiti , mony. . Burley Gowan, the colored porter, and Clem Jones, the colored dish washer at the Gladstone hotel at Black Mountain at the time of the fatal shooting of John Hill Buntlng'on the night of August 6, were the star wit nesses for the state this morning In the trial before Judge' Adams In Su perior court of P, C. Watklns, charged "with murder In the second degree for the shooting and killing of Mr. Bunt ing, The two witnesses gave detailed and lengthy statements of the inci dents leading up to the appearance at the hotel , of Mr. Watklns, and told what transpired after the officer ar rived. Incidentally, and notwithstanding Mr. Collins' testimony yesterday, to the effect that Mr. Bunting was shot first, and crumpled up on the floor. and that he (Collins) was shot sec ond, that the officer placed his pistol against Collins' chest, the two negroes testified that Mr. Collins was shot first; Gowan testifying that Mr. Col lins was shot and that witness was shut out of the room; that he didn't see Mr. Bunting shot. Jones Confirms Gowan, . ; Jones also testified that Mr. Collins os shot first, and Mr. Bunting second; ihat when Mr, Collin was ahot he V 'wis standing in front of Mr.- Watklns with his right hand raised, but not in a menacing manner; that Mr. Wat klns' pistol was within perhaps 18 ' Inches of Mr. Collins' body. Jones further testified that the first shot was fired, and the light went out. at one and the same time. Jones and Bur ley were put through a severe cross examination by Mr. Craig, but not once in the essential details of their testimony was their evidence shat tered, Mr. Thompson is Called. : When court opened for the morn ing session H. H. Thompson was call ed to the witness stand. Mr. Thomp son testified that he lives In Hlllsboro; that he has known Mr. Collins for 30 years, and that Mr. Collins' general character is good. , Testimony of Gowan, Burley Gowan was called. He is 'a negro of the ginger-cake type, with aparently ordinary intelligence. He testified that he was porter at the ho tel at the time of the shooting: that he had been to church; - returned about 1 o'clock; went to his .room 20 steps from the hotel; heard no noise; was fixing to go to bed when Mr. Manly, the proprietor of the house came and called for Clem Jones. Wit ness said Clem had not come and Mr. Munly asked witness , to go and get Mr. Watklns, the town constable, wit ness met Clem and they went together to Mr. Watklns' home, some little dis tance away, knocked on Mr. Watklns' floor three or four times before the knock -was answered. .' Went to the Door. Mr. Watklns went to the door and naked what was wanted. Witness said that Mr. Manly had sent for him to go to the hotel and quiet men making a disturbance. Mr. Watklns aressea and starting with Clem and witness to the hotel, asked if Mr. Manly waniea him to demand the peace or lock them un. They saw Mr. Manly when they first reached hotel, Mr. Manly told Mr. Watklns to go and demand the peace; witness heard no noises; before reaching ; the hotel. Mrs. Woodruff noked her head out of e window and hollered to. Mr. Watklns asking him to hurry, up saying they are out in the hall now." The otfloer, witness and Clem Jones went uDstalrs and to room 17; wnen they got into the hall didn't hear nnvthlna-: Mrs. I.lnvllle was In the nail; only person in the hall when of ficer went up. Offioer and witness went to room No. 1: Mr. Watklns knocked; they said "Who's that? Mr. Watklns aald. "a policeman The door was opened and they said "come In." Witness saw pistol after officer struck match; match went out and officer told Clem to light the lomD. , Clem lighted the lamp and of fleer asked the two men, 'what all this fuss about." One of them replied that there wasn't any fuss: that "we ". we lust talking to ourselves." Men were stttln nn In bed: officer told them to get back In bed: talked loud to the men: Collins tried to get Bunting down; Collins standing up had his hand raised; not In a menac ng attitude: lust talking to Wat kins; the gun fired. and light went out; men wasn't doing anything old not see either men put their nana n officer; Collins was shot first; oftl fer's weanon was foet or foot and I naif away from Collins' body; Collins fell back: door shut an! witness, who had been stnmling In doorway, m on :iki,?. . v. i:.--m didn't see . ... .ungsny: "Oh. There was a brilliant wedding at Trenton, N. J., when Miss Emily M. Roebling, eldest daughter of Charles G. Iloebling, president of the John A. Roebling Sons company, wns married to Richard MeCall Cadwala der of Philadelphia. The ceremony was performed by the Rev. Hamilton Schuyler, In Trinity Protestant Epis copal church, and was followed by a reception and breakfast nt the home J God, he's shot me right through the stomach." , Court Asks Question. At this point Judge Adams Inter rupted to auk: "Who did ho say wns shot first?" Mr. Craig He said that Collins was shot first. Mr. Settle Yes, sir; that Is what we understood him to say. Witness continuing, and In reply to question, said i that nt the time of the shooting neither of the men were doing anything, that they did not pUace their hands on the officer; that the men were In their night-clothes; If either of them had anything In the,lr hands witness dldn t see It; wltpess was right herv w ..,' The CroRS-Examlnnfion. On cross-examination by Mr. Craig the witness at first denied that he had made a statement before the coroner: he seemed a bit confused and evident ly did not know Just what was, being sked him. -In an Instant, however, he said that he did testify before the coroner. Burley said he told the cor oner and the reporter who talked to him at the hotel that Collins was shot first. Once, while Mr. Craig was fir ing questions at the witness, and In- Istlng that the answer at the coro ner's inquest did not tally, Burley blurted out: "I Jest told do coroner as nigh as I could direct myself; I was pretty badly skeered." Witness denied that In returning to the hotel with the officer that the officer and Clem and witness struck a trot; that they ran toward the hotel. Witness said they Just walked: that they walked pretty fast. Witness de nied that he had told Mrs. Crawford that Watklns had shot two men; that they Jumped on htm and tried to take his pistol, and that Mr. Watklns had to shoot. i Only Got a Nickel. Witness told of the visit of the newspaper reporter to the hotel; said that he had been given no money sav a nickel that a man gave him; that the nickel was given after he had tour about the matter; it was a tip. Wit ness said he did not remember now manv time M. Watklns told men to stand back and not come on him; wit ness could not say whether or not officer was against the wall. On re direct examination the witness sold that he did not hear cither Mr. Hunt ing or Mr. Collins call Mr. wotKins anything any bad nam?, in con cluding his testimony the witness Gowan solemnly declared: 'No one ever paid me a cent to make a state ment; and that's the God's truth. If ever I told the truth In my life." Court Han tor Order. Clem Jones was called to the stand. Clem Is a tall, sllmly-hUlll negro; black as the ace of spades; thlck-lip- i,rt and a aenulne eastern. Carolina "nigger." Several times during his testimony he created loud laughter In the court room, and twice juuge Adams was forced to rap sharply for order, and to warn spectators and court attendants tnat oeuer oruer must be kept; that In short the laugh ter must be "cut out." Or.ce Clem, when asked about being arrested at Mt. Olive, and running rrom a man, hart the court house crowd laugh ing. He aald that he waa Just arrested for nothing; that the man "wasn't no officer;" that he was told to "run. nigger:" thut someone else says: "run nigger" and, Clem said: "This nlgg?r Jest run." ' . Clem told about being at church on the night of the killing and returning to the hotel. He also told about go ing for th officer and reaching room No. 19, Where the shooting occurred. Witness said that the officer knocked; that he was asked ''who Is that? and A French Aviator Breaks the World's Speed Record - . rw (A Leon I travelled a mile and 860 yards In one .2 rSKm monoplane here today, m ' I.. itii.rint monoii nvyjbrolie the world a apecd re.ord. He) of the brklo's father. In West State, street. . The church and the house were thronged with guests from that -and other cities, niuny from Philadelphia and New York coming In their uuto moblli'B. The bride's gifts represent a fortune, among them being a check from her father for an amount which has been variously reported ns high as $250,000. Mr, Watklns replied: "I nin a police man:" that Mr. Watklns pushed open the door end someone Inside said-. "That's all right; let them come In; wo take care of all pollcemena." Wit ness said that the man was speaking In an ordlt.nry tone of voice; thnt he. was not speaking as though mad." Witness paid that Mr. Watklns struck a match. The officer told the men to "get back oft of me; don't I come on." He said thnt, thls.stntement j f.n made several times by the officer; thftt the officer kept going backward and telling the men "not to come on me:" officer went back to the bureau; his elbow hit the, lamp; it wnt out and $he pistol flred (almost instantly; Colllti fcl across file bed. The officer tol?l Witness to Often tiie door. The officer kept saying "get bnck oft of me;" then Mr. Hunting wns shot. Mr; Hurting fell In the floor and cried: "Oh, Lord, he has shot ' m In the stomach." Witness sa(d Mr. Collins had his hand raised, one hnml holding Bunting When the first shot was tired. Witness told of the visit of the news paper man; he told the newspaper man about the cost. Witness said that no one ever offered hiin money. He told the newspaper man (Mem called htm a printer about the kill ing because the man said he was not a lawyer. , 1 Cross- Examination. On cross-examination Mr. Craig wanted to know of witness what Mr. Manly salil the men were doing that he wanted the town constable. Clem wild that Mr. Munly told him they were using "broken" language. The witness repeated this word several times; he was very positive that Mr. Manly said they were using "broken" language and not vulgar language. Clem denied thut he hud stated at the coroner's Inquest that "they" showed the door open; lie sal that he swore that "he" referring to Mr. Watklns t shoved the door open. Clem main tained that Mr. Watklns put the light out by merely tipping the chimney with his elbow when the officer back ed to the bureau; that Mr. Collins was "one foot and five inches" from the bed. He was positive under Mr. Craig's cross-exiimluatlon that Mr, Collins was not a foot and "six" inch es from th bed although the negro once asked how much a foot waa. Clem denied that he told Clerk Hum mel that both men were on Watklns and that he had to shoot them. He denied that he told Mr. Manly that, and defied that had made that state men to other people. Clom admitted that he had drunk whiskey on the Sunday that the Inquest was held. He snld he ordered a gallon on Friday by mall and that he got It on Hatur day; that he ordered It from Virginia. Clem denied that he had told a man while In Jail that he was afraid of being Indicted for perjury. He aald that he stayed In Jnll for ten days; that lie wanted' to get out: that "Mr. Eugene. Way come down there to see Mr. Black and I asked him to get me out. ' I 'feed' him B." ' -Mr. Bales' Testimony. W. F. Bales,, a reporter for the Citizen, waa called and testified that he went td Black Mountain on the Sunday after the killing. He went to room 17; Clem Jones and Burley Gowan came Ifr! he sent for them; they told him of the killing; the story appearing In the next day's Cltisen was the result of that visit to Black Mountain. He said that he had paid the men nothing to give the story; that he tipped one of them Ave cents and that wus all. He offered no In ducements to either Clem Jones or Burley Gowan to make the statement that the reporter printed. Mr. Bales was pat through a right , (Continued on page 4.) was at a rate of nearly M mile, an hour. All Inmates of Nusery of Pres byterian Orphanage at Lynch k burg Their Rescue from tha House Impossible. HEROIC WORK WAS DONE BY MRS. PRIESTLY, 1 HE COOK . ) : One Little Girl Returned, (or Her Sister. and Perished No Men About Place Older Boys Help- ' t ed Rescue Work. Lynchburg, Va.. Oct. 26. Five children, all Inmates of the nursery, were incinerated In a tire which to lully destroyed 'Hhelton coltago, the home of girls at the Virginia Synod Presbyterian ' Orphans home, early this morning. The dead: UUHY MOOREI'IKLD of Lynch-, burg. . . ' LUCILE MOOREl'IELD of Lynch burg. MAMIE REYNOLDS of Bath coun ty, Virginia. MARIE HICKMAN of Campbell cotinly, . MARY POOLE of DcDowell county, W. Vn. 1 The children Were all in the second floor of a Wing of the building and they were caught by the fire in a manner that made their rescuo Im possible. - Hun Back, to Die With Sister. Ruby MoorefleUl, however, Was tak en out of the building, but when she ascertained, that her younger sister was still inside she ran back Into the burning house and lost her life. The fire was discovered by Mrs. Priest, the cook, who wns aroused by the roar of the Hemes. When she saw that It was Impossible to get the children out by the stairway she rush ed to the third atory ond brought is children downstairs to the second floor, loading them to a veranda top where they wefeSnken flown a Indder, several of them dropping Into the outstretched arms of older boys In the Institution. , Kseiies Miraculous. Mrs. Priest, after saving the child ren, had to jump for her life, sustain ing a dislocated shoulder, a scalp wound and an Injury to her back. She will recover. . All of the escapes were marlculous. Superintendent Flem ing was awny at the time of the fire and there were no men about the house. The women could not save those who perished, for they barely succeeded In wiving J 4 of the other girls. MASONS OF PROMINENCE TO General Grand Council and Chapter Will Meet in Savannah Big Preparations. ' Savannah, Oct. St. Five hundred prominent Musona of the United States and American possessions will come to Savannah for the tenth trl centenlaL assembly of the General Grand Council, Royal and Select Ma sons of the I'nited States and the thirty-fourth tri-contennlal convoca tion of the General Grand Chapter, Uoyal Arch Musona of the United States, November fl to 12 Inclusive. Governor Brown if Georgia will ex tend nn official welcome on behalf of tho state, while the city, besides being represented by Its mayor, "George W. Tied man, will, through elaborate de corations upon the principal business streets and upon many private homes, attest Its welocme. After the business aesslon of No vember 12 the visitors-will be enter tained at night with a banquet on Tybee Island. At this nve prominent Masons will be heard; The General Grand Chapter will be represented by either General Grand Scribe Witt or General Grand It. A. Captain Kuhun. Other speakers will be' Rev. M. Ashby Jones of Columbus, Ga., Rev. Richard Wilkinson of Augusta. Rev. Dr. C. If. Strong of Savannah and P. A. Stovall, editor of the Savannah Press. As souvenir at the banquet each guest will be presented a gold and enameled scarf pin, showing the seal of Savan nah. CONTKNTION OP If. K. THAW ovEn-m xr:n bt appeals court Trlbnnal Decides Tluit Thaw's Com mitment to Watteawan Asylum Was Not IllcaL Albany. N. Y., Oct H. The con tentlon of Harry K. Thaw, slayer of Stanford White, that ha was Illegally committed to Mattertwan state hospl tal for the criminal Insane la over ruled by the New York Court of Ap peals. . To Attend Justice Pcvkluun's Funeral Washington, Oct. 28 Chief Justice Fuller and all the associate Justices of the Supreme court left for Albany today to attend the funeral of the late Jumico Peckham. II m r 1 (TiT) ' II y wn hi mi .ii.nn. j: .. .Of j .Jf jtfe K' f A . ... " y,. mi " ' w y. .t i p t , , T CIVIL VIE VT MEDAL AND CROSJ Of MERIT New York. Oct. 26. In recognition of tile aid be has given to Immigrants from his native country, Louis llml wig Horvnth, an assistant steward at the Hotel Astor, has received the cross of merit from Emperor l'rnucls Jos eph. The distinction paid to llorvutli came ns a great surprise to him nnd to his friends, the notification being tmule officially through Consul General Man ajlovitaky of Atistra-llungnry. Friends of the honored mun storm- THE GARS LEAVE FOR GETTYSBURG Forty-Seven Automobiles Are Now Mak ing the Trip from New York to Atlanta. Philadelphia, Pa., Oct. 2fi. Tli forty-seven automobiles in the good roads tour from New York to Atluntu, under the auspices of the New York Herald and Atlanta Journal, left here today for Gettysburg, I'u., where the chi'' will remain over night. The day's run will bo by way of York. Of forty-seven curs In the tour, nine are being used by officials in charge of the run and the other 3S ure contest ant", for tour prlrc. Thirty-alx of these contestants left here today with clean scores. MILLS WILL NOT CLOSE It THE UNION SECT! v Report Denied All Nine Mentioned in Report Except One Will Run on Full Time. Union, S. C, Oct. 2d, With their products sold ahead for several months, It was denied today that nine cotton mills of this county would close down on account of present high prices of cotton. All the plants, with the exception of Lockhart mills which are noted for a certain class of work only, will con tinue to run on full time, probably until the first of next year. National W, CI. T. V. KlecU Officers. Omaha, Neb., Oct. 16. The con vention of the National Women's Christian Temperance I'nlom elects officers as follows: Mrs. Lillian M. Stevens of Maine, president; Mrs. Francis P. Pnrks of Illinois, corresponding secretary: Mrs. Elizabeth Preston Anderson of North Dakota, recording secretary; Mrs. Sarah lloge of Virginia, assist ant recording secretary, and Mrs. KUnabeth P. Hutchinson of Illinois, treasurer. Alliens College oXt Closed!. Athens, Ala., Oct IS. Athens col legs for young women has not been closed, at reported last night, on ac count of mysterious sickness. Vanguard of Already in New Orleans, Oct. 18.--A!ready the vanguard of thousands who are oomlng to welcome President Taft and to attend tho Iike-lo-the-gulf, LOU I S WOTt VAT H ed him with congratulations, and plans are nlrcady under way by those prominent in several AiiHtro-ilunga-linn societies in tills city to give a re ception to llorvuth, probably selecting the Hotel Astor as the scene for the festivities. llorvutli already possesses a medal from official circles of his country. In 1 !(!! he was presented with a merit medal in appreciation of his work among his countrymen In this city. PRESIDENT TAFT IS BEING SHOWN v - - - His Flagship Landed Him at Cape Girardeau Bright and Early This Morning. ("ape Girardeau, Mo., Oct. 26. Twenty minutes before sunrise Presi dent Tuft stopped from his flugshlp. the Oh under, as it docked here. This cltv, the tirst stop on the trip flom Kt. Louis by boat to New Or leans, greeted the president with pro longed cheers. Thousands of country people arrived during the night by rail and iigm. licni-licd Cairo at Noon. Culro, Ills., Oct. 2. President Taft anil party arrived here at noon. FOUND WITH THROAT CUT IN HER ROOM AT HOTEL IjiUt Die Va Mrs. Ik-iiiicliniii of ohIoh Discovery Mailt by Her Private Physician. Jacksonville, Oct. 26. Wit h her thront cut, Mrs. Muhcl A. Iteuiicham of Huston wus found dying In her room In the Arngon hotel this morn ing, by her private physician. Dr. Itanker of New York, who occupied a room across the hull. She died shortly afterwards. Suicide, attributed to despondency and the fear of an operation, Is the decision ns to her death. TIDAL WAVE IN MEXICO; LOSS ESTIMATED $5,000,000 The Iionm of I, ire Is ol Known, Hut It Is llcllcvcd Thnt Many Perished. - Mexico City, Oct. 26.- The town of Sunta Rosa, Mtxlcn, In the state of Tubs co, was Inundated by , a tital wave last night. The loss of life Is not known, but It believed to be large. The properly loss Is estimated at $5, 000,001. THE WF.ATHKK. Forecast until ft p. m. Wednesday for Ashevllle and vicinity: Partly cloudy weather tonight and Wednes day, slightly warmer tonight. The Dataware Ms ken ll.HH. Newport News, Va., Oct. J6. The battleship Delaware attains a speed of tl.98 knots, the greatest ever made by a first class battleship. Thousands New Orleans deep-waterway convention, beginning here Saturday, Is arriving. That the gathering will be one of the largest in th history of the south Is fully Indicated. Japan's Foremost Statesman Was Shot Today by a Korean, Who Was Actuated by Revenge. SEVERAL OTHERS WERE SHOT AT THE SAME TIME The Tragedy Occured in the Railroad Station at Harbin, as Prince Ito Was Leaving :.- . Car. Harbin, .Oct. SO. Prince Hirobuml Ito, former Japanese president gener al of Korea, and probably Japan's foremost statesman, waa assassinated here this (Tuesday) afternoon by a Korean who had followed him hore for the express purpose of killing him. The motive of the assassin' was revenge. Tho ussassln was arrested. Shot at the Station. Almost Immediately on his arrival here, and Just us Prince Ito left the railroad car at the station, tho attack wns mudo upon him. Tho venerable statesman, accompanied by the Hus sion minister of finance, waa starting to inspect tho guard of honor, drawn up along tho platform, when the pistol shot wns heard. Several more shots were fired In quick succession, the bullets striking the prince In the back. . Prince Ito fell mortally wounded. Three of the prince's companions also were wounded, bullets striking Japan ese Consul-Oenernl Kawakan, General . Manager Taunaka of the South Man c,hurlan railway, and Prince Ito's pri vate secretary. ' j, . Cotuiul-Ueneral Kawakan la badly, but not family. Injured,' It la believed. -The assassin was promptly seized, On being questioned he said he waa a Korean. , Ho Como to Slay. , "I came to Harbin for the sole pur pose of assassinating Prince Ito, to avenge my country," the alayer told his captors. He also aald he had a personal account to settle with the great Japanese statesman, who during his stay in Korea, had ordered the execution of several persona olosely connected with the assassin. An Organized Plot. ' That the assassination waa the out come of a well organised plot, is In dented. Hud the shooting occurred a moment earlier, then lives of a num ber of foreign consuls would have been In danger. Not on Official nusliiciw. Washington, Oct. Sfl.It was In sisted nt the Japanese Kmbaany here thut Ito wns not In Manchuria on official business. ft SUIT AGAINST A Cincinnati Company Has Entered Suit In the Federal Court, Asking $196,000 Damages. Cincinnati. Oct. 18. The E. C. F.nhelby Tobacco company, located In Cincinnati, has entered suit In the Federal court against the Burley To bucco society, and oaka for $196,000 damages. Hush of '49 Gumnu'iitoratcd. Stockton, Cal., Oct 16. A carnival to commemorate the sixtieth anniver sary of the rush of the gold-seekers through Htockton In 1149 waa opened In this city today. The program of festivities, which will laat several days, provides for numerous Interesting fea tures. Including an exact reproduction of un of the early mining camps. . Name Onlerctl Stricken Off. New York. Oct 96. Justice Gerard, In deciding the ballot dispute In New York city campaign, order the name of Judge' Gaynor and the nominees for comptroller and president of the tioard of aldermen atrlcken from the column under the Independence league column. Mrs. John Dearer. News has been received here; of th denth at her home at Plsgah Forest, In Transylvania county, of Mr. John leaver, which occurred Bunday morn ing, Mrs. Deaver waa the wife of John Deaver, merchant of that sec tion, who Is well known In Ashevllle. , A Large Funeral. New York. Oct. J6. A multitude of mourners .forming the largwt fnr -.l procession ever sewn In UrooH- n, f lowd the body of t' e V I M(-l"arrn from bin .' I l . BURLEY SOCIETY