THE ASSOCIATED
PE1SS
DISPATCHES
LAST EDITION
'4:00 P.M.
Weather forecast:
Threatening:.
VOL,
xv.
ASIIEVILLE, N. C..THURSDAY AFTERNOON, SEPTEMBER 15, 1910.
3c PER COPY.
Two Principals in Murder Trial
Which Interests the Entire World
WILL BE TREATED JUST ALIKE
v ' ' 1 ' i i'i '
piiffesiiEHiir
I OIK Tl
T
REJECT TERMS
Mr. Taft Will Hereafter Recog
nize no Difference Between
Them in Matter of Fed
eral Patronage.
THIS IS NO CONCESSION
TO INSURGENTS, IT IS SAID
While Certain Ones Were Hostile to
Party Legislation, the President
Thought It Proper to Dis
cipline Them.
BIIVKKLY, MANN., Kept. 15.
President Taft here
after will recognize no differ
once between the so-called
"progressives" and "regu
lars"' of the republican party,
lmt in the matter of federal
support all party leaders will
he treated as republicans.
The president's views to this
effect are given in a letter from
Secretary Norton to a republi
can leader in Iowa, whose name
is not disclosed.
Secretary Norton says that
while iuiKrtant republican
republican legislation pending
in congress was opposed by cer
tain republican leaders, I 'resi
dent Taft felt 'ft his duty to
withhold patronage from those
hostile to efforts to fulfill the
party's pledges.
Not a "Consession to Insur-
Hiscussing Mr. Taft's views
as disclosed in his secretary's
letter, persons conversant with
national policies said they
should not be taken as a con
cession to "insurgency." Ac
cording to the party leaders,
Iowa is not "violently insurg
ent," the republican platform
having approved the presi
dent's effort to secure desired
information for tariff revision
through a Joard of experts.
The president is said to have
withdrawn federal patronage
temporarily from Senators Li
Follette of Wisconsin, I'.ris
tow of Kansas, l)olliver and
Cummins of Iowa and Repre
sentative Hubbard of Iowa.
WILSON'S LBDING
AGISTM FIELD
Platform Prepared Commends Legisla
ture to Submit the Initiative
and Referendum.
Trenton, X. J. Sept 15. W
Wilson, president of Princeton, ap
pears to l,c in the loud lor (he demo
cratic nomination ror governor of
Now Jersey.
The situation is practically a rase ,,1
Dr. Wilson on I ho one side and all
tli! other candidates on tl (lo r.
Colli sides insist they will lr al io lo
muster u two-thirds vote of tin- con
vention. Kcturns nr.. coming in slowly
from the primaries and tin- rc
Milts ran only lie approximated.
Thi' polls did nut close until :i
o'rlock. The republican vote on lnit
cd States senator will probably result
in former I inventor Stokes leading,
w ith Former (lovernor .Murphv sia ond
and Congressman Fowler third, Mr.
Murphy will reeeive a very heavy
vole In Fssox eounty where lie will
prol.alily got 20.0110 against 5.000 for
(!ovi rnnr Stokes, hut (ioveinor Stoke;.'
ote is heavy in southern New Jersey,
where with the exception of Atlantic
City, he seems to have things pretty
01 m il his own way.
f I ($$rxi i -
Ot-CRlPPENiWO ETHEL LE NEVE. IN THE DOW
JlKEtT DOCfVi
IN5P6CIOR DEW e5COK.TNc5 DK-CKIfPEN
ASHORE AT LIVERPOOL
CLABAUGH LOSES CISE
DEIS! GROCERS ASS N.
General Charge in Favor of Defendants
in $150,000 Damage Case,
" " by Judge Grubb.
IS ARRESTED FOR THEFT
OF IMMENSE AMOUNT
George W. Fitzgerald Nabbed as the Man Who Took $173,000 from Chicago Sub-Treasury
Three Years Ago, and Is Held in $50,000 Bail, Which He Gives Story of Subter
fuge to Throw Fitzgerald Off His Guard Indictment Was Found
February 17, 1910.
l-iirminghn in. Sept. IV Judge
tjrnl-b in Federal court today gave
(a general charge for the dclcnil.iuts
'in in., ti'.niiiiii i.iiit of Micl.ni ! i'I.i-
haugh against III" Southern Wholesale
lirocers ussotiation officers and . a
nuinher of its tnemhers.
The plaintiff aliened that the de-
'f. ndants lureeii mm oui ot nusiness
iheeausc he dill hot lieloUK to the as
'soiiation. Altoinevs for the plainliff
will appeal
The government has a suit aRainst
th" assoi ialion, clinrciiiMT violation of
the Sherman anti-trust law.
TO STRAIGHTEN THINGS
lust as Soon as the Singer Is Well
Enough, It Is Said, She Will
Sail for America.
Ml OFFICE OSEIESS
T,
Municipal Authorities Agreed With Him
An Act Unique in the Political
History of New York.
15. ltohet t
office holder ill
simicct ins iti joo.
Vi w York. Sept. 15. Madame Una
t'avnllerl, Iho bride of Itohi rt Wln
Ooop Chanler, Is cnmiiiK to thin cntin
ti. It U Mihl todny on Rood author
ity, to attempt to stralRhten out the
report of their marital differenced mild
to he due t differences over the mar
riage Ktttlenicnt.
Week after next Cavallerl Ih expeet
d to have recovered ufftctently from
n rectnt operation for appenilleitlH to
emtio.
LGBIMER AFFAIR ECHOES
Interest Centers Chiefly in the Noml'
nation ol Candidates for the
State Legislature.
New York. Sept.
Winter, a municipal
the liroitx. has r
There was no need, he thought, for
the office.
The act Is unlouc in tin- political 1iis-
...., ..r th.. ellv His r.'siunatlon has
hecn accepted anil the office will he
abandoned.
Edwards vs. Caleb Powers, in Eleventh
Congress District-Leaders Busy
Trying to Prevent Trouble.
lmlon. K.V.. Sept. 1C Nineteen
mountain cotmlie, roniprlaitiK the
rileventh dltrict, are excited today
.....r th reniil.licun primary In which
it f T,-.iuiinlM. Incuiiihent. ond Caleb
I'owera. former secretary of state, are
.hi, ni.t.onlnir candidates lor connr
There have been bitter pemonnlitles
In the campaign and the leaders of
both sides are busy trying to prevent
trouble.
TIIK WEATIIEU.
Rprlngncld, Sept 15. In the Illinois
congressional districts outside Cook
county, excepting the Eleventh and
Thirteenth, Interest In today's pri
maries la chiefly In the nomination of
candidates for the state legislature.
Echoes ot the deadlock sesdlon,
which resulted In the Hectton of Lorl
mer to the United (States senate are
heard In practically every district
where a representative or senator who
voted for Lorlmcr la seeking renoml-hatlon.
v.., A.l.nvllle and vicinity: Threat
u.nihnr tonight and Friday
t-iiiiin "
without much change in iei..pv.
IUI ,1,,
For North Carolina: i-nruy
-i.i. -u..u,er neur the coast tonight
or Friday; cooler In extreme east and
south portions tonight.
Population of Cleveland ami Jollei
Washington, Bept 15. The popula
.f j'levelund Is 660.664, an In
its iar. or 46.1 per cent,
m.. Tit..i ills.. Is 34. C70, an In
crease of 18.1 per cent
ALL KHIT5
Adolpt Rothbarth, Who Swindled
Banks of Nearly $150,000,
Sends Word from Cell He
Wants no Lawyer.
"I BEGAN TO GET LOANS,
SO EASY I KEPT ON;" SAYS
By Juggling Loans Rothbarth Was Able
to Keep as Much as $300,000
in Air at Once, It Is
Said.
Nc
spirit
can r
linn
York. Sept. 1".. I'.rokeu in
Adidph Kothl.arth, the Ameri
prcsentatie of the hop dealing
if liolhharlh & Co., of Frank-
Capt. Hooper, Republican Nomi
nee for Gov., Endorsed Tenn.
"Regulars" Harmony Re
solution Referred.
PARDON OF DUNCAN COOPER
IS REPEATEDLY DENOUNCED
Hooper Makes Speech and Scathingly
Arraigns Patterson No Other
Office Except Governor
Involved.
tort. London and St. PctersliurK, who
lias confessed to swindliiiK hanks of
nearlj f I r, o ,11 mi, sent word from his
cell ill Toiiih.s prison today that he
"didn't want
"All I want
Itothharth. II
the larceny of
a lawyer."
is a ittiek trial," said
has pleaded guilty to
$111.(1(111 from the Mer-
CIII(';m. Sept. I -MH'orl;: ti.
si i lire reduction ill the hail of
C,euri;e V. KitGerald, irf sh d
sterday eliai'Ked Willi
000 froin the Mih-lica: i
K. crc made in the
Mistrict court today hd'i
l. alum $ I
y three i
1'nilcd St.
e Jlldwe I.
11-
"iO.IIO I
a cell.
is. who hx' ,1 it last nii;lit at
it .Ki rail spent the inv',hl it
.Indue l,andis heard hoth sides and
fused to riiluce hail, l'ond has heen
furnished.
KitGerald was arrested on a heiicli
wurranl. Iri:ed on an indict nient rc-
nrneil secretly Py a federal plilinl
ury r eiirtia ry I i, IJMi, I lie existi nci
I' the i ml 1 I 11 1 III was : -llppl-eyed.
I'll it i- ilas alter the indict ineiit wa--
eci'''l!' returned it was auaoiinecd
hit lie' statute of limitations upcrat
d to stop possihh- criiniual aetioc in
the ease. Viiiuiiliiil.il with this ruse.
secret sen ice men w ere irelalleil lo
wateli Kil.Kerald constanlh , and make
rigid invi stiiration of tin- former
a
liuaiicial i l t
'ries niaile hv
d in the orih
rests
Hi.-.
I' I M'
rcslllli
arrest.
Marshal Klierslcia. .In
agents of the department
and Hepiilv I'tlited Slate
W aller ainwl iht and .1
tier arrested Kitzurrald at
opera t i e
,t.i;er i Id's
I' at
peeiai
of jllsliei
Marshal
T. HucU
his insor-
a net
just
as
lirst
I lo
He
III-
keriiKe otliees in UiSalle sli t
as the former - uh-lreaKUl' telh r
lenou; ,.- Ik. no. Kitzerald was
liken to 1'nited Stat.;; Marshal
s otliee where he was searched,
was tl.t n handcuffed ; ml placed
ill I Cell.
'I'lic iiidii t mciit against Kit.u- raid
as re.ol in t i.url speedier- .ur e.cuit
ee chat res i.i elllh' a. iient and
the imiiili harv;t-s larctn. I'nder
lh'-:e chiri;es a liiaximiim sn
t. ia e el -.i n e.ii s in a federal pri-iHl
and a he ilal to the sum enihe..le.l
is tile pea I) V Oil COllVict ilUl.
Knileil Slal.s liiutrlet Atlenu lal-
win W Sine
pronipted his
arrest, hut d,
ejelit e iile.-et
SUeh ptoe. dill'
Tie sal, -In
Kehrna r- I !i,
all In JI.IH"!
el-.l nlll,
SHAFRQTH WINNER
IT
B CLOSE M A H G 1 1 j
Indications Are That He Will Be Named
by Democrats ot New Jersey
lor Governor.
eoti-Jof-
penver, Sept. If.. Ity a narrow
margin Shafroth was nominated lor
governor Ly the democrati. ;tate
vt ntion last night over I r. I:. I..
rsoii. Trailing in expected today on
Humiliations still pending.
The platform to he voted on today
commends the legislature snluiiitting
the people a constitutional amend
ment for the initiative nun n icreii-
dnm. Senator (iuggenlieim is de
nounced, also the l'ayne-Alilneh tariff
law, lis revision upwards in the inter-
Ht of the trusts. The conservation
if nalural resources of the utute and
nation is eomiiieniled.
T
WILL PROBABLY MEET
State Chairman Will Remain in Syra
cuse to Hear What the Colonel
Says of His Machine.
IS
Some of the Court Ladies Say They Will
Remain in Retirement Until
Canclcjas Quits.
sept. la. The return of
Vice, the Papal nuncio
signal for act i d v in lie
i of a clerical campaign
niti r 'analejas
paratioti is hcing made fur
Math Id.
Monsigiair
here, is III
orga ni.a ti-.
against I'i'1
I Ifcat .l
Ilia II i I est :' I ions of protest
Snine i.i the court ladies s
slay in retirement while l'r
alejas remains in power.
refuses to say what
order for Kil.gerald's
lar -s that he felt sulll
was in hand to warrant
asnry i..ss occurred on
l!U'T. The m.tie- was
and :! lo.iiiiu hills. Ked -throughout
the coiie.trv
wcj-e Pi-ought into the hunt fur the
missing money.
The $1 7::.i)'tf ilisapp. ared from
Kit.g. r thi s cage in the snh-tri asur .
When ipHsti. uieil reginling the dis
appearance of the money Kitzgeraltl
said that h had gun. .nil in luncheon
and that wlo n he returned the money
W.IS g.it'e He was closely i I lest in ll"tl
at the tune and was shaihiwed for
Ti i tl 1 1 hs.
A year . iter the i..hher OCIIIIed
Kilgciald w is at li st, ti I i.v a prival"
detective agency acting .'"or William
Hnldeiivvaek, the suit-treasurer. The
charge was not pressed, however.
LEAK IN OIL PIPES
CAUSE OF Mm
Investigating Board Makes Report on
North Dakota Accident
Crew Exonerated.
(untile .National hank and was held
for trial in an eitial amount of hail.
He had heen under surveillance 4S
hours and his arrest came after a long
conference hclvveeu the district attor
ney's office and a coterie of hankers
with whom he has had dealings.
"Your honor," said the assistant
district attorney in charge of the ease,
"although the specilic sum named in
this complaint is only $10,000, the ac
tual amount this hank alone has lost
will come to more than $100.00(1, hut
I only ask this small hail hecause the
prisoner has admitted that he did
wrong and promises to afford the
prosecution every aid in his power."
The money wenl into speculation,
according to ltothharth's own admis
sion. "I was siuce.0(l in the panic of
KotT," he said, "and hegan to get
loins from tin- hanks. It was so easy
that I Kept on."
F. S. Seln nek, president of the Lib
erty National hank, gave our a state
ment of tic hank's dealings with
I'.othhnrth. "W'e have not thought it
necessary to prosecute." he said, "in
view of the action taken hy the Mer
i i ti t ili- National hank, hut neverthe
less we arc out $7fi.00O. tif course we
shall lake action to get hack as much
d it as we can from the lirtn."
Three other hanks are said to he
Involved, hut their names have not
v. ( come out. It is said that hy jug
gling loans among them, liothharth
was aide to keep as much as $.100,000
in the air al once.
Belated Returns Show That Guernsey
Is Elected, and Hinds Has Also
Probably Won.
W.I lllllglell.
...InPalion and
ing apparatus
Sept. i:
1 sign ot
.01 the
til
l. t.
i Ih
l.er
BRADLEY GONE TO ETAH
AFTER CK RECORDS
News Brought to Copenhagen by a
Captain Who Thinks Dr. Cook
Is With Bradley.
-I 'an h in
e il hrush-
Iree.lnaught.
ponsihlc for
e,-l)ip on the
.. men were
d according
luv i stigating
New York, Sept. 15. Theodore
UooHCvelt and Timothy I Woodruff.
chalrmun of tho republican state com
mittee, will probably meet In Syracuse
Saturday when Col. r.ooseveit speiiks
at the state fair.
Mr.WoodrufflcHVes tonight for Syra
cuse to attend a dinner given in his
honor by the state fair (itTleials, and
will stay until Sunday, to hear what
tho colonel has to say.
Janim K. Kccne Much Ilelter.
1exinKton, Ky.. Sept, lB.Jamsa It.
Keens Is reported as being so much
better that his physician, Dr. John
Scott. belloWD he will be able to leave
the hospital In about ten days and go
m rutletnn Farm, wtiere he will be
the guest of the family of his brother
in-law, Major FoKhslI Pangerneld.
Copenhagen, Sept. l.'t. A govern
ment steamer lias arrived with the
news that John . Ilrailley, the liuiin-
cinl hacker of lr. Frederick A. Cooks
north pole expedition, Is on the way
to Htnh to secure the records and In
struments lr. Cook said he left there.
The captain of tho steanu r thinks
Cook Is with Hradley.
Body Found in Hudson lilentllled.
Wnslilnnton, Sept. 15. The attor
ney general's office, Identities the dead
man found recently in the Hudson
river by the flntfer print system. He
proved to lie a corporal who disap
peared from Fort Blocum. Clues ob
tained thereby will aid In search for
the murderer.
North 1 1, ikota, w . re n
the : id. iit mi that ball
Villi, iust nit. w hereby tin
kill' d Mllll eleven illjlll't
to the report of the
I. n in!
The hoard took much testimony, the
most Important omieg from Lieu
tenant Command- r Hi ti (i. Murlin. In
charge of tin- ship's machinery. He
told in a graphic way how he bad
poison. ilu . tarii .1 two of the oil burn
ers and was at work turning- on the
third v In n there was :i Hash which
se I to run along the pipes and
around to the separating lank. lie
ordered "abandon tire room" instantly,
hul ho tierce was the lire that although
every one rushed for Hie door In the
bulkhead, the three men perished.
nrohahlv Ic-ini: cut oft in Hie bunkers
hy th" Ha me and iiovlous gases.
Touching the faulty deh:n of tin
system, the board found that then
was a leak in the oil pipes which per
mitted the escaping oi! to drop upon
tin- siiner heater causing it lo Hash
and lire tin oil In the settling In at
The board Puds that no blame for the
lire or the damage therefrom attache
to anyone senilis; on the North la
kota. F.vcry possible precaution was
taken when the test ifiu begun and
everything possible was done after the
xnloKlon to limit the dumage. So fur
as the board could ascertain all of tha
(.therm and men acted with the utmost
promptness and efficiency. The dum
age to the structural fittings was not
extensive and could be repaired In ten
duvs hv the ship's own force. No
further proceedings ore recommended
Oldest Cnl lege
(irailimle In the l ulled
Ktates.
Newark. Sept. 15. William nankin
of Summit. N. J., the oldest college
graduate In the t'nlted Stater. Is cele
brating his hundredth birthday anni
versary today. He graduated from
Williams 19 years ilgo. He Is In ex
cellent health.
Miss Taft
Niil lo ltcturii
MawT.
to Itryn-
Phlladelphla. Sept. 15. It is an
nounced at I!ryn-Mawr college that
Miss Helen Taft will not return this
year, hut will assist her mother at
the White House In the many social
duties devolving en the "nrst lady In
I he land." Miss Taft Is said to have
been eager to resume her studies.
Portland. Me., Sept. K.. Two re
uhlican ami two democratic repre
sentatives will constitute the next
Maine delegation in the national
house, liouht as to the make up ot
the delegation was cleared up when
late. I returns from remote tow lis ol
the fourth district showed ine re- c-
ion of Frank F. Cuerusey (republi
can ) of Dover by a small plurality.
Mr (iueinsev s election was conceded
hv bis democratic opponent, i.eorge
M. Hanson of Calais
The election of Asher ( . llinfls, re
uhliean, ill the lirst district is shewn
on the nice oi ine uiionnn.i
turns, but there may he a recount.
In the second and third districts the
lemocratic candidates, Daniel J. Hi'-
(iillicoddy and Samuel W. Gould, won
cislvely.
Attorney Charles V. Johnson, a
prominent democrat ol waterviite, is
be ti candidate for the United Mates
senate at the iing session ot ine
legislature. That body will he demo
cratic, by a vote of 111 to "9 hi joint
session, thereby ensuring the election
f a senator of that political faith to
succeed I'.Ugene nine.
THE "AWLANE TEA"
THE VERYLATEST THING
Due de Rohan Is Going to Give One in
Paris Invitations Received
in This Country.
Now York. Sept. 15. Several New
York society people are Invited to a
novel social function, an "aeroplane
tea" to he given soon In Paris by the
Due de Itohan, a leader of the French
aristocracy. M. Hussen In a Bleriot
machine will make a flight with each
guest.
Kermlt Itoosevelt, who recently re
turned from Turkey, Is a guest of the
de Itohans,
Nashville, Tenn., Sept. 15. The In
dependent democrats of Tennessee
yesterday endorsed the candidacy of
Captain Hen W. Hooper, republican
nominee for governor, and further
cut loose from the regular wing by
referring the hitter's harmony resolu
tion to tin new independent state ex
ecutive committee without discussion.
Thus was organized a formidable
looking triumvirate to the campaign
(insisting of republicans, independent
democrats and state wide uruhobition-
ists. The independents and prohi
bitionists are so closely allied as to
largely overlap in their membership.
Tint possible break in the solid
South, outlined in the convention ex
tends only to one office, the govern
orship. There is a "gentlemen's
agreement' between the independents
and the republicans that neither party
will invade the other's safe legislative
territory, and this the independents
say assures a democratic legislature.
The last republican governor in Ten
nessee was Alvin Hawkins in 1881-82.
11 is a curious fact that his cletcion'
was due to a democratic split led
by Judge S. F. Wilson, who was elect
ed to tlie court of civil appeals as an
independent in the judiciary election
last August which was the forerunner
of .yesterday's convention.
'Che convention was run off without
a ripple of opposition to the program
of the leaders, whose only worry was
to keep the enthusiastic delegates
from prematurely suspending the
rules and nominating Hooper by ac
cla niation.
This was attempted, but ruled out
of order by the permanent chairman.
It. K. L. Mounteastle, national com
mitteeman for Tennessee. There was
a long wait for committee reports,
and then platform resolutions were
adopted and nominations made in
rapid sin ssion by unanimous rising
votes.
The resolution on harmony reads
as follows:
"We recommend that the resolution
sent to this convention by the Patter
son convention be referred to the
state committee elected by tills con
vention for proper answer In accord
ance with the action and nominations
of this convention."
The Cooper Pardon leiiouncc(l.
The pardon of Senator Carmaek's
slayer was denounced repeatedly by
the speakers, and each denunciation
was received with shouts of approval.
Temporary Chairman O. T. FiUhugh
of .Memphis brought the audience to
its f.-ct when be said of tho Carmack-
Cooper case.
"When the highest court, despite his
(Patterson's) efforts to coerce it, had
banded down a decree which branded
his closest friend and chief apolitical
adviser as a murderer, he spat upon
and trampled under foot this judg
ment which was in accord with the
law and justice and which met with
the approval of the civilized world."
( apt. IIimiimt'.s Address.
The convention ended with Captain
Hoopers address. The republican
candidate was frequently Interrupted
by . heeling and applause. He said
In part:
We have recently seen the repub
in party of Tennessee rise above
part'san considerations ana tnrusi
side the tempting possibility of elect
ing ten republican Judges of the
state.
"Many thousands' of republicans
oted for a free and untrammeled
Judiciary without price or promise,
and we are not Insisting today that
anybody owes us anything for that
performance cf duty."
Speaking of the convention of the
republicans and independents, Captain
Hooper said:
While this sequence of events Is
unprecedented In Tennesseo politics, it
mtains no deep and hidden meaning.
It would ba extremely absurd for the
ton es of temperance, law and order,
to be devlded In thla contest . along
national party lines. ,
We have witnessed In this state
for the last four years what was per
haps never seen In a southern state
before, the assembling of the vicious
and criminal elements of all races un
der tho banner of an unscrupulous
organization, an Intensified . imitation
of the Tammany democracy of New
York and the republican ring of Phil
adelphia. We have seen the laws of
this state trampled under foot, and
have then heard the chief executive
of the state publicly proclaim from
one end of the land to the other that
these laws could not be enforced. We
have seen the pardoning power of the
governor converted Into a political as
set and used for tha financial enrich
ment of his henchmen and the polit
ical aggrandisement of himself. - -
"Do you ask who Is the leader r,f
this democrat! j revolution? in , an
swer that It Is none of the other in
dependent leaders w'lom I see before
me here today. Edward W. Car
maek'a body Ilea mouldering in the
Continued on page two.