V THE GAZETTE-NEWS Has The Associated Press Service. . It it In ETer Re8 ComP11 Member Audi Bureau Circulation. WEATHER FORECAST. FAIR TONIGHT. VOLUME XX. NO. 241 ASHEVILLE, N. C WEDNESDAY AFTERNOON, NOVEMBER 24, 1915. PRICE 2 CENTS n Trains 5 CM. (Incite trill- toitoti wwre INVADERS' ADVANCE IN SERB! A IS NOT SO RAPID Contradictory Claims of , Vic tory Leave Real Situation in Doubt Hard Fight ing Continues. ENTENTE POWERS MORE HOPEFUL OF GREECE Berlin Has Revived Report That Russia Contemplates Great Campaign In Bal kans, Through Roumania. London, Nov. 24. Contradic tor)' claims leave the present situation in doubt, but evident ly the advance of the Austro German forces and their Bul garian allies is not so rapid as earlier reports indicated. Ap parently heavy fightingis under way in the section where the Teutonic forces are attempting to form a junction with the Bulgarians. ' The fate of Monastir is still in the balance. Reports eman ating from Athens are to the effect that the Bulgarians, hav ing regard for Greek suscepti bilities, are k waiting for the Germans to come up and oc cupy the city.:,..., . In the' entente capitals jp Kflwed confidence is , professed that Greece is now. moving to T'r.i'd a complete agreement v.ith the wishes of the allies. iVrlin has revived the report ciiti uiu i.vukiuiis uuiimmputit; 0 great campaign in the Bal- 1 iins for which a large army lias gathered at Odessa. The reports . do not indicate that the Berlin government is at nil sure that , Roumania will refuse passage for the Russian troops through her territory. Petrograd report slight ad vances along the Styr river with sharp checks for the Ger mans and Austrians on the northern and southern portions of the eastern fronts. Vienna says, however, that .nothing worthy of mention has occur red on that line. Nevertheless, there is apprehension in Berlin and Vienna over the result of the expected Russian offensive in the extreme southeast. The Italians are looking for the immediate fall of Gorizia, which according to latest re ports is dominated by artillery on both sides and from "no man's land." , "- Notable progress by the Bulgarians In the region southwest of Prlstina lth the capture of 1,000 Serbians, 44 cannon, and 21 machine uns( was announced at the German army head quarters today. Teutonlo troope have mho taken 1,600 additional Serbian prisoners, and have captured six rannon. CBS 'AT ECVERL1ENT Washington. Nov. 14 The watch of the guards at all principal govern nient buildings tn the capital was re - doubled today, on order. Guards sta tioned in strategic positions com manding all entrances to the build ings which house the state, war and navy departments are under orders to question, and. If necessary, to . rch any persons of whom they htve doubt. Hundreds of tourist pa through the buildings dally. Blnce he bomb explosion which wrecked room In the enpltol last summer, nil bomb plots have kept gnvirn hnt detectives busy, there baa been "ore than ueual activity among rds here but now the wateh I to even more strlnt Onerds employe by rwey eetn nl ar eontlni!ly on duff In Iinnls l.4lng tn brMts or.f the "'omfl ry prlrl y the gte- f te the wm, President's Message Deals With Defense Revenue Washington, Nov. 24. President WilBon has laid before the cabinet a practically complete draft of the message he will read before congress December 7. He has decided to touch on the question of raising revenue for nation al defense, but probably only In very Droaa .terms. Some of the cabinet members wanted him to devote the entire address to the question of na tional defense, but as read at the Cab inet meeting, today, it deals with other legislative matters. The president favors outing appro priations, as much as possible for pub lic buildings and rivers and harbors improvements. .Washington, Nov. 28. Chairman U. S. May Act An Austrian's Frotcst Washington, Nov. 24. Officials of the state department and the depart ment of Justice today were consider ing the protest of Baron Erich Zwel denik, charge of the Austro-Hungar-lan embassy, that the statement. Is sued in the name of the department of Justice apparently tended to con- am .Via f AnotHan nnnanlni nffl-!frhA V .1 V.AC lCL. I. U ww..u . .- former Austrian consul. initiative and V without instructions The protest was lodged with the 'from the Vienna government. . state department. The statement was! Offtcta's consider the complaint made by A. Bruce BlelasUi. chief of more or icps luFtified and that un'ess the bureau of Investigation of th de-, there is a disclaimer of authority for partment of Justice after a confer--Mho statement the -Atmtrlan foreign . iv. Tr- rnrlenr in New York office micht make lnautriea. 'Wo His Co-Operation Against Outlaw Bands on the Border. Laredo, Tex., Nov. 24. Governor Ffirirnaon. of Texas, and General Ven. ustlano Carranza, head of the de facto von Bernstorff. the German ambassa government of Mexico, - yesterday ' dor, have failed thus far to bring the pledged the ' co-operation ' of their United States and Germany near an forces In maintaining order along the early settlement of the issues grow-Texas-Mexlcan border and evolved Ing out of the sinking of the Luslta plans to rid the lower Rio Grande nia, with a loss of more than 100 valley of outlaw bands. American lives. It was said today by The two executives met in the ad- persons ln a position to know that ministration building at Nuevo Lre- the points of view of the two govern do, Mexico, opposite this city, at the menus still were widely different, suggestion of General Carranza, and j fn German circles the belief - was were ln conference for more than two 'expressed that a satisfactory agree hours, following which the governor ment could not be reached without and his staff were guests at an elabor-i ate banquet Discuss Raids. Bandits raids was the principal sub- Ject discussed The Mexican "'u - made by Mexican officer to appre-1 iienu ny cuipnv won iMittnv iun . m, V'l 1 Oil HID ...ui. b.ub A A A A .LI.IJ -1 I Vu t.l.l.M aiwmpi to snm -i "J reiuge.on me u. same with respect to any lawless 1 band on the Mexican aide seeking , asylum In Texas was agreed to by Governor Ferguson. . When Governor Ferguson returned to the United Btates. he expressed pleasure at having met the first chief. Carranza was characterised by the governor as "a man of solemn mien. Arm conviction, not prone to -hasty judgment, but rather deliberate, ot great determination and a man who will undoubtedly make a wise ruler over the destinies of Mexico." finpertor Court. The case of Mrs. Belle Rogers and W. F. Roger against the Southern Railway company, In which they seek to recover the sum of $40,000 for the death of Furmen Rogers, an employe of the company at the time ef his death, will probably be concluded this afternoon. The evidence In the case was probably be concluded this after noon. The evidence In the case was finished yesterday afternoon and the arguments by the attorneys before the Jury were made when court recessed for noon. Pythlans to Continue) Aid. At a largely attended and enthusi astic meeting last night, Plngah lodge. Knights of Pythias, voted to continue their appropriation for the Good ftara- aritan mission during the approaching year. The work of the mission is eonild sldered to be one of the most Import ant phi enthropla sotl.Ule parried on In Ashevllat and the support It Is re celvlng le a greet encouregmst to the management. Chamberlain, of the Senate committee on Military Affairs, announced today, that he planned to introduce a bill for national military service, mode ed af ter the Swiss system. He stated that plans to bring the matter up for the serious consideration of congress, and begin 'a plan for military education. Senator Chamberlain, and Chairman Hay of the House Military committee, May or tne House Military committee, officers of the General Staff, and Sec- jV retary Garrison were to have a confers , ence, this week, on the Army Appp priatlon Bill., -. Republican leader Mann tod' cepted President Wilsons lnvit ,0 . A confer on national defense legiV ion, ?isv ,ior Oil . Senator Gallinger, the Republican senate leader has already accepted. Favorably i I ! General Rodriguez, who escaped and wns to Ihe effect that he. had from Cananea and misled the Carran obtalned much valuable Information S8ah'ef- ,a ported on h's way to re. concerning the activity of Consul inforce-the .Nogalee trarripon with an General Von Nuber of Austria and armv ot between 2,000 and 7.000 men. his associates, l.eftrence to the con-' Colonel Cardenas, with 1,200 Car sul general was what the charge ob- fanza cava ry wa ,ast reported as jected to. heading for the Ponora r'ver valley in It is understood that the statement the be!lof that a few hundreds of Rod- was issued without the knowledge of flttnrnpv p-onArn' TVin nrntffRt vpnja - ! r: ' I' ' ' ' ST LL U f ETTLEr U. S. and German Government, Unafcle to Agree Over Case Optimistic. ' Washington, Nov, 24. Conferences between Secre Unslng and Count arbitration. Officials of the state de partment were more optimistic, how ever, the opinion seeming to prevail Hint UlkAIIKALClJ' VJDI 1 1 1 U 1 1 ,T nwuiu lu""'4n,)uu , , lnto the American way of viewing the,wr,uen , the sU,e pWfn conwrn The United States' point of view Is hliuumii iu uoiuiion k'"" iiu Af l (7. ,un, vbavou, ...tvw ... ..', ( , A .. A J I Ik. I1.I . a. ...u-t ..... m. .nn .n.mn.., i.m.,h t bpe opp0,ln the or,erly 1 Mas of American cltisens lost In the J,i, .w. - disaster. The United States Is averse to taking the question to The Hague. T OF GUILTY IS GIVEN IfUiP USES Tennessee Co. and Shipping1 Clerk Convicted in Federal Court at Chattanooga. Chattanooga, Nov. 14. The Jury In the cases of the United Plates vs. T. C. Miller, manager; U C. Myllug. superintendent; Frank Fox, shipping clerk; and A. G. Smith, travelling salesmen, of the Tonneasee Coffin and Casket company, which have been pending In Federal court during the past week, returned a verdict yester day, finding The Tennessee Co Mil and Casket, company, and Fox guilty of shipping liquor Into adjoining tales, without proper!;.- I landing the packages on the outside, verdicts of not guyty were returned In the cases of P.etterton. Myllus and Smith. Government Indictments were based on the al egatlons, that the company, through, lie omc.aia, naa maae it av custom to enclose bottlee ot whiskey In coffins and caskets, which they sent to customers. tletterton, who Is police commis sioner at Chattanooga, denied knowl edge of the fac's, and declared he hsd leued ordere to have It etopped. The Jury accepted h's view of the, eons were drowned. tKla, by the esse. Pentenre, on the company, and 'washing aay or a t-riU: tst Hie Fox, waa passed until tiaturUay, Salto lUver, near Uvcontw, luly, GEL OHGi'5 US CHANGED Failure of Commanders Makes It Necessary to Make New Moves in Effort to Crush Villa '3 Revolution. RODRIGUEZ ESCAPED ANMISLEtf OBREGON ,v ' , AvV eadcr Imported to Be On -C -- ,ay to Reinforce Garrison n.t. Tfrvo-n.lps flnlTeo Alo IM.V M HUM Ooias to Noalcs. Douglas. Ariz.,. Nov. 24. Aval'able Carranza reports onrlv tdav. Indicate that fa'lurps of his ( ommniTlprs com bined with erronnons infdrninHon. has i resulted In the comoMe change of an of General O'rpirrm i r.wh th.i Villa forces n Rono-a. and end revo- lutfonary strife. In Mexico. raBn. i soumvvara from Can- ana. as a lure, was tne mam Villa K.., General Calles at Mobena I" appar- ently in Ignorance of the movement r General Rodtlguez. and has said ti1" "J? wiu be ,n Nogales In five days, "en- "'eBuez reported to Obrenon that ne !f,??rt?d a onr from the attack on v" a forces . bight miles north of puards pt the Carranza ' and Villa forces are reported to have been flKht In? for two days at Lehota whieh was said to. havebeen, .occupied for 'the second ttrne hy . Carranza troops,; late last n'ght. ' -General OcORta leader of the Villa forces out of Santa Cruz was reported to be retiring In the direction of No gales. General Obregon Is preparing to summon two more divisions of rein forcements to Sanora in addition to the 4,000 troops who are expected to reach him at Pedros Nogras. . UFir.yEB3-tFP.iE- rai ra. 'rap Union, However, Is In Favor of "Orderly, and Natural Growth of Navy." Raleigh, N'uv. 24 Prof. W. C. Crosby, educational secretary of the North Carolina Farmers' union, said great deal has been ing the action of the union in resolv ing agalnxt the large naval program 0j jn8 aUminls! ration he wishes to I remind those siieaklng critically of tn. unlon B HCtion. that the farmers The union, he says, merely object ed to any Increase In appropriation for defense and said nothing against the present work done by the adminis tration. Mr. Crosby does not under stand thnt there Is any sentiment against what Is now being done. He thinks that there Is a great deal In the view of John Pprunt HUI that the fnrmere ere so much Inter ested In the passage- of a rural cred its bill and measures thnt vitally af fect them as a dass aa to make them little Jenlous of the attention thnt may be paid to other things which miist some before the next congrexs The farmers spoke only for those who were present, bnt they have had a great opporttin"y to come into eon tact with the thinking of the peop'e back home. Ami the sentiment wee pretty general that the men at home wish to keen the price of Pence as low as poss'ble even If the great fleet must preserve It. U. S. C2UISER SAN DIEGO SENT TO TOP01ABA11PO Washington, Nov, 14. Admiral ..' . '' ( wins ow, commanding V r O SSI! lO AO- fleet, has l'C"i ordered to plal ampo. xlco today with - his 'fianshlp the vruiser Bun Diego, which wl carry HI additional marines J r,ajy ,0 snu tna protect Americans and other foreigners. cheat lo:3 or life HI BSIDGIS DISASTER 1 Rome, Nov, IJ. One hundred per UW1W CO GETS CDIICTS Corporation Will Work 300 Men, at $1.50 and $1.75 Per Day on Development Project. FEDERAL COURT OPENED WITH 82 INDICTMENTS Baptist Mission Board Has k fl1 1a KTaayaIvt Villi WUaU&VUCU XI CO! 11 X Uil A.4. e..v 'Scrintions fHy W. T. Host) RaleiRh, Nov. 24. The- state Is ready to deliver to the Aluminum. tympany or America tne nrst gquaa or convicts to.be put upon tne ' srrent rle.vp nnmpnt snhmA near nlfl W hitney, now Eadin. Some of these men are among the lot which Senator Hugh Chatham vol untarily returned to the state several weeks ago. That Winston-Salem gen tleman csi me down here and said that while his railroad would like to have the men indefinitely, he realized that he -had a disproportionate number of see somebody elae get the benefit of their work. These have not been re turnd but will be a lowed to come hero when th6call Is made. With them it is quite probable that Badln will get 300. Superintendent Mann cannot begin will, the 300, of course, but will send about 100 in the first batch. These will draw $1.50 and 11.75 daily, the old contract under which they worked. When Senator Chatham returns his workers another 100 will be added. The E kin and Alleghany camp will retain a number of workers and will lie kcpl at normal camp during the winter. The resumption of work at Pndin is said to be contemplated upon scale large enough to complete the work ln another year. Two More Candidates. New Hanover and Brunswick coun ty lawyers are pressing the names of Representative W. P. Stacy of New Hanover, and B. H. Cranmer of South, port to succeed Juf'se George Roun tree who has resigned to return to the practice of law. Mr. Stacy is a member of the fam ily of three Blaoy boys, all of whom won the Mangum medal at the Uni versity and took such hlch rank at colk'fre. He was one of the eaders in the 1915 general assembly and is considered a young lellow with such uncommonly good sense and Judg ment as to make him worthy of the big office. His Brunswick neighbors present Mr. Cranmer Just as heartily. Other names have been thrown out to Governor Craig but none pressed with quite the enthusiasm that these two lawyers have behind them. - Judge H. O. Connor , yesterday morning opened Federal court for a term of two weeks for the trial of criminal cases. Eighty-two indict ments have been made. This Is a vast reduction from the last court and the retailer Is hard nressed for manufacturing ground. The court has no big cases at this sit ting, but whlakoy Indictments will, make lit) the bulk of them. The last six months has been a period of offi cial preaching ln which sheriffs and state olilcere have joined wun ino Federal department In running down blockadcrs. The result Is tnat many such cases have been tried In the slate and county courts. Judge Connor yesterday put three foreigners through naturalization pa pers and although all three represent ed different nationalities they are al lies in the continental war. Peter Ijiinlinos. a Greek, renounced his ob lfcat.on to King Constantino I Salisbury, Nov. IS. The North Car whose country seems now on the point 'olliia Stale tiunday School convention of Joining the allies. Jacob Piechatka, a Hum. an. not only went bark on the czar but aked to change his name, Nobody objected. Judge Connor sign- ed him up with the United States and rollment was around luo, which In allowed him to call himself Jacob dicules that there will be an attend- Aaronson. - Ktood Examination. Pleclintka-AHroiiBon could speak but Indifferent English though a bright young lellow. Judge Connor asked him to niui.e a dieunictlon be - tween the two governments under whlih he i.iui lived. "Le one 1 Icef un- der las Czar," he said, "1 leef under pres-ee-dont," he said to Judge Con- nor. Ihe judge smiled encouraging- ly and told him to pioceed. Aarou.on hoved along nicety. Atier prompting I torn Juuge Connor as to tne source of governmental autnor.ty, he said: Ue Car. he ae monarch, ne de law. In United olaies Coiisieas pass law." judiie Connor ' tften let lum swear ' 'ort th old 'l"'ln,t a.'" W n'u' I . , I- nk..A,.l.l. ma, n.a v m ,-... vw .... u an uninUeu luuy to the lie wuuniry. aoioiisou uulaieu his uu- r of t j,euker, an address by A. ..eiisi In pobgamy. y. McAlleter of tlrecnuboro. A. II. fluoil Is an Englishman who At the afternoon seMion the usual works at tne fcxperlmeiil eiauou. Hs formalities of greeting and respon.os hu no dniuuity in meeting tne tent, mnae. up the program, but the words A'l new sulijouts are intelnguiit nat- or w,Koine were warm and the re urally. the utie Oreea bw.ug qu.u,uonse by Dr. C. P. Mil-aurhiln of Limul and the Ru4in at.pu.nnny s Cuncuid. wee In tra-ious Ung isue. gouJ cltinn. Mi. Russiili m a m.i.iiie- The main aJdres ns Wilunm tuird man. a. iirown of Chic to. brld eevrtttary M'uiu t r. u. .vimuoii ano AisHiStant Dwtrlcl Attorney Uiean ar , tCuuUnutd on page I' CHARGES WAS DIRECTOR OF CONSPIRACY M. P. CONFERENCE MEETS IIT WISSTONJEXT YEAR Assignments Read Just Before Adjournment Rev. C. W. Bates Returned Here. r.n.hn. XT TV., nln.. uein session or me iMortn vjaroima lan churcn- ln session here since last o'clock. Throughout the day com- - ".v " ' """' .':,,,,,, ro tha Mrt' n, the stationing committee. However, this matter was delayed from time to time because of the difficulty of sup plying a. I the fields. The next conference meets In Winston-Salem on Wednesday before the fourth Sunday ln November. Rev. N. G. Bethea was elected to preach the conference sermon and Rev. J. D. Williams was elected to preach the ordination sermon. The appointments of ministers fol Cresell j. H. Abernathy; Anderson', A. D. Bhelton: Ashboro, C. L. Whit- aker; Asliboro, C. I Whitaker; Ashe ville, C. W. Bates; Buncombe, T. B. Martin; Bmlington, J. E. Pritchard; Char otte, unsupplied; Cleveland, W, C. Lassiter; Concord, W. R. Lowder- milk; Davidson, 3. U. Hulln; Denton Ueo. L. Reynolds; Fairview, , J. H. Bowman; i'allston, J. H. Moton; Flat Rook, C. A, Cecil; Forsyth, A. O. Llnd. ley; Gaston, W. H. Neese; Graham, O, B. Williams; Granville, D. R. Wil liams; Greensboro, R. M. Andrews; Viroenvil.e Morgan; Guilford, 8. M. Neeiiham; Halilax, R.' A. Swearln- gen; Haw River, W. F. Ashburn; Hen derson, S. F. Taylor; High Point, A. G. Dixon; Denanon, R. C. Stubbins Ienoir. H. D. Gannon: Lincoln. D. M Doy; Littleton, W? E. Swain; Mebane, W. F. Kennett; Mecklenburg, J. H. Stowe; Midland, J. F. Alexander; Mocksvllle, T, A. Williams; Mt. Ver non, J. A. Burgess; Mt. Pdeasant, R. S. Troxler; Oak Ridgo, I W. Ger rlnger; Orange, C. H. Whitaker; Or ange, C. H. Whitaker; Pageland, J. Q. Quick; Pensaco a. Homer Casio; Pied mont, J. W. Self; Pinnacle and Mt Zion, Kd. Suits; Randleman, J. B. O'triant; Randolph, W. M. White; Richland, Joel B. Trogdon; Roanoke, C. J. Edwards; Reiiisvllle, E. G. Low dermilk; Rockingham, W. B. Curratt; baxapahaw, H. 8. B. Thompson; Shel. by. J. D. Morris; Slier City, T. Hi. Davis; Spring Church, R. L. Hethcock; St. Paul, G. F. Mllliway; Stan ey, W. D. Reed; Tabernacle, T, M. Johnson; Ihomasville, B. O. Prltchett; Uwhar rle, IS. A. Biaswell; Vance, A. L. Hun ter; Welch Memorial, unsupplied; West Forsyth, T. F. McCulloch; Why Not, unsupplied; Winston, J. D. Wil liams; Yadkin College, H. L. Powell; Yorboro, W. A. Lamar. TATE SUNDAY SCHOOL Coi;.v T Prvtortanino- Mr.ro mooavomiuj "aav. & .v.v Than 100 Delegates Ses- sions of Great Interest. opened Us annual sesHlon in this city lloniity alternoou with an enrollment that was pleasing to the officials of the asaoulaUon In two ways. The en jance large enough to make the mis Isiuns Interesting and hclplul, and on 'the other hand, that the aim of the officials to keep the attendance from being burdensome to the local enter tamers was euccesslul. Headed by a bend and with flags end banners unfurled, the paewde of Sunday school children ranging from Infants In aiini? to grtvy-haired men (lli women marchud through the principal streets of the city, winding up at the community building, where (ne (PMona 0( the cenvontlon are b nt hold. . 0f the state officials are pree- (nt and no serious changes ln the n.ujir n th. ,1 -oili-ni nrnirrsm are anticipated. One m on the program, a ... .VL - - nuwevir, raa to oe unuimu un c- count of the eerloua Illness ol the fath of the ntrrnnllonsl K'inila.v B hool as - enrUtlnn. Mr. Urown's subject as "The BunJuV School Asuooiallon." BOY-ED U. S. Prosecutor Accuses Get man Naval Attache of Direct ing Expenditure of $750, 000 to Aid Raiders, ASSERTS MONEY WAS SPENT BY MILLIONS Officials of Hamburg-American Line, Now on Trial, Named Chief Actors in Alleged Country-Wide Plots. Not York, Nov. 24. The govern- ment brought forward today mora witnesses to prove the Earl Buenx managing director of the Hamburg- American Steamship line and his three' associates had conspired to ' defraud, the United States when they sent neu tral fleet of steamers out of American ports to supply German warships op erating in the Atlantic and Pacifla early ln the war. While counsel for the defense have conceded that $2,000,000 of German money was expended substantially tn . the manner alleged, evidence thus far has only dealt with $750,000 which was said to have been expended under the direction of Captain Karl Boy-ed, German naval attache. Of this ' amount, according to the chief wit nesses for the government $500,000 . was sent to San Francisco to fiance supply ships which were to leave the Pacific coast porta The charge of conspiracy Is so broad that It takes in about every act that might be proved to have been committed ln this country by the de fendants during the first two months of the war in , furthering German naval warfare. - : The prosecution expects before the trial Is over there will have been wrlt- ten int the records of the case a I larRe Part Of the history of the raiding Qf German commerce destroyers dur ing the early part of the war. The government has 60 witnesses of more still to be heard. Members of the crews of many of the supply ships will teil of being rescued by B..tish warships which sunk or cap tured their ships, or of getting safely back after their ships had completed their mission. New York, Nov. 24. Captain N. Boy-ed, German naval attache at Washington, was the directing head under which was spent $750,000 ln chartering and supplying neutral steamers with coal and provisions for the German warships ln the Atlantlo and Paclflo ln August, 1914, the gov ernment charged and asserted that It Is prepared to prove the charge, in beginning the trial on the charge ot conspiracy of Dr. Karl Bueni, manag ing director of the Hamburg-American line, and three subordinates. Roger B. Wood, assistant United States district attorney ln charge of the prosecution asserted that the en tire sum of money had been expend ed under the personal direction of Captain Boy-ed and that from $500, 000 to $800,000 had been spent at San Francisco for the German war sli'p lietpzlg and perhaps the Dres den. This, the government charges, was part of a conspiracy which ex tended from New York to Philadel phia to New Orleans and San Fran cisco ln which German money was spent by millions and in which the defendants were the leading charac ters. In the performance of thla alleged conspiracy. Prosecutor Wood said that the defendants "rode rough shod over the laws and treaties of the United States as contemptlously aa If they had been mere scraps of pa per." William Rand of counsel for the defense admitted that the defendants had chartered and supplied twelve ships which left American port for the relief of German warships. In do. Ing so, he said, they had acted oa orders received by cable from tf home offices of the line In Germaw. "Dr. Ruent undertook to comply with the Instructions,," said Mr, Rand, "end with this end In view Is sued orders to George Hotter and Aiolph llachmeister (co-defendants) who obeyed . them. ,The Hamburg American line owned or chartered a number of steamers, bought coal and provlrlons and supplies Which were olsded on the steamers and caused or attempted to cause the steamers to sail from the porLvof Newport New iew Tors. Philadelphia. Pensscols and New Or cans with this object In I "The sum . view. a ao expended from time in time wet ware atipolled bv th Hnm - .'office of the comnanv In Hamntm by means of credit with New York lenks end bankers for the Hemburg Amerlcnn line." Among the wltnexses who testified to Car-taln rny-ed'e connection with he all?od conspiracy wna Gustavo W. Ku!pp''mpff. a Qrmen Importer srd exporter lth oflces here. Kirenka-i-T-fe rtrv on the w'n-. Mnrd vm the! be hsii hern nmnn..r 1 jby telephone $ the T'snh i can r ". .... I (Continued on I V