THE AWHEEL VIOLE TIM
ASSOCIATED PRESS
SERVICE.
jfEMBKR OF AUDIT BC
RKAU OP CIRCCIiATIOX
TEE WEATHER
WARMER; RAIN" OR SNOW
SUCCESSOR TO THE ASHEVILLE GAZETTE-NEWS.
VOLUME XXL NO. 12.
ASHEVILLE, N. MONDAY AFTERNOON, FEBRUARY 28, 1918.
PRICE 2 CENTS n Tnla 8
GREAT VERDUN BATTLE
HAS REACHED TURNING
POINT. PARIS ASSERTS
MTTIEE
St
E
French Claim That German
Advance Has Been Checked
and Counter Movements
Have Begun.
GERMAN STATEMENT
- CONTRARY, HOWEVER
Berlin Declares Army of the
Crown Prince Continues to
Advance Joffre's Forces
Are Heavily Reinforced.
The great battle of Verdun,
now enterting its second week,
continues with unabated fury,
with the Germany army driv
ing hard at the French de
fenses along the ' lengtlwi&g
line which now runa far be
yond the salient in which lies
the French Fortress
Paris asserts that with the
pouring in of heavy reinforce.
ments for " General Joffre's
army, the German advance has
been cheeked, but Berlin re
ports that the Germans are
continuing their forward ad
vance on the stronghold.
Along the Meuse to the
north of Verdun the Germans
have been unable to make as
rapid progress-as they did a
first, although the battle con
tinues with intensity. On the
Wievre front, where French
forces first fell back, they now
appear to be offering effective
resistance. The pressure here
is particularly menacing to
the fortress as the crushing in
of this line of the Verdun sah
pnt for any great distance
would spell disaster for the
fortress
The French defensive operations at
places have taken on the nature of
muni., ittarkn In th eattack on
Douaumont four miles to the east of
Verdun Thin development was fore
cast In dispatches which told of the
expectation In Paris that the French
when they had fallen back to posi
tions which they believed they could
hold Indefinitely, they would drive
back over the ground they had yield
ed In the face of the terrific German
artillery and infantry attacks.
According to ft statement by Arls
tlde Briand. the French pietnler, this
happened on the fourth day of the
battle, when the French brought up
strong, reinforcements at n unex
pected moment, and the (Trench In
fantry swept down on the Germans,
who already suffering heavily from
the effects of the French artillery lire
were stopped short, and even deiven
back.
The premier declared the French
have now reralned the advantage,
the counter attack marking the turn
ing point on the battle which Is In
Its second stage.
The German account falls to agree
with the French version of the fight
ing. Berlin announce! the further
srivnnc of the Irown prince's forces.
Including th taking of Haudemont.
ssst of Fort Douaumont, and the
Milage of Cbampneuvllle, on the Ger
man right flank, where a French at
tack on Fort Douaumont was
plllM-d.
The French themselves do lot
claim the rspture of the outlying de
fens of the main fortress, but de
clare the Germane, who had gained
a foothold on the east and west rf
the position were being hard pressed,
and wre maintaining their poettlon
with difficulty.
Accounts from various source
asrwe that the fighting la of a degree
rf Intermit r virtually unparalleled In
the war. Especially, la this true of
the artillery fighting, the Teutons
having broueht uo great masses of
11-lnrh and IT-lnrh guns from the
Xrbln and Russian campaigns and
blasting out the French positions
with a pimp bombardment of high
uploelve shells.
NT S
ID
STAG
the rata f shell fir la th. 0ep-
Portugal Allows Treaty
i
With Germany To Lapse
Lisbon Feb 25, via Paris. Feb 28
The Portuguese premier stated In the
chamber of deputies today that at
tempts had been made to damage sev
en of the Tonton ships which were re
quisitioned by the government and
that explosives were found on the
steamer Buelow of the North German
Time Limit For Hearing
In Behal f Of
Raleigh, Feb. 28. Governor Craig
In a letter to Judge B. B. Jones Indi
cates that he will limit the time for
hearing petitions for commutation of
the death sentences of Mrs. Ida 'Ball
Warren and Samuel Christy, convict
ed of murder of the woman's hus
band, to March 20. The governor In
formed Judge Jones that matters must
tember offensive of the allies ( was
without precedent at that time, but
correspondents near the front declare
It was feeble In comparison with the
deluge of projectiles which the Ger
mans are now pouring in on the
French trenches and forts from the
German batteries.
The progress of the German drive
is being watched with intense In
terest In the allied capitals.
Late Paris advices reflect the opin
ion of military observers that the
French line can hold out until a coun
ter attack can be launched.
London dispatches say that further
hews of the situation northeast of
Verdun, where the Germans claim
to have captured the Douaumont fort
Is anxiously awaited, as the strategic,
situation of Uie fort -to-twogniaeoV'-
Late advices from Albania, received
through German sources, predict the
early fall of Durazzo, as the result of
the defeat of the Italian Albanian
forces. The Italians are declared to
be hurriedly embarking troops for
the port.
A CHARLOTTE MAN
P. Heath, a Cotton Manu
facturer, Shoots Himself
Early Today.
A telegram was received here this
morning from Charlotte stating that
O. P. Heath, a prominent citizen
there, committed suicide in his office
at 11 o'clock this morning, shooting
himself with a pistol. No indication
la contained In the brief statement
received Is given of a possible cause
for the act. Mr. Heath was one of
the largest cotton manufacturers
In
the state.
COL. VANDERFORD
IS VISITOR HERE
Commander of Forces Operat
ing Against Blockaders Now
Stationed at Greensboro.
Colonel T. H. Vanderford, of
Oreenuboro, revenue agent for the
western district of North Carolina
and for part of South Carolina, Is a
visitor In Asheville today. Colonel
Vanderford was transferred from Vir
ginia the first of this montn to
Greensboro, relieving Colonel W. U.
Chapman, who has taken charge of ft
district In California. J. J. Drake
ford was transferred from Cincinna
ti to Richmond In place of CoL van
darford at that city.
Several years ftgo CoU Vanderford
was tatloned at Asheville In the rev.
enue aervlce; under Cleveland's ad
ministration he was ft deputy collec
tor In active raiding work and has.
therefore, had much experience In
problems connected with conducting
campaigns against those who engage
In the manufacture of Illicit aloohollo
drinks contrary to Uncle Sam's sta
tutes. tttltisill
X
t ITALIANS LEAVING Dt'RAZZO
- . St
st Rome. Feb. II. The report t
at that Durauo. the Albanian pert L
t on 'the Adriatlo sea. Is being t
t evacuated by the Italian troops t
t stationed there Is confirmed. t
st m
1 1
Lloyd line.
The premier added that it was con
sidered in the best interests of Portugal
that the existing treaty with Germany
be allowed to la se and that Portugal
was prepared for all eventualities that
might arise from the exercise of Por
tuguese rights.
Mrs Warren
be arranged for the hearing to be held
on or before March 20 and stated that
the defendants win have time for
proper preparation In the event that
his decision Is adverse to them.
In conclusion the governor stated
that he wished It to be understood
that nothing in his letter was to be
taken as an Indication of what his
decision would be.
COL. HODGES
FORCMITTEE
Local Man Attended Meeting
of N. C. Underwriter Asso
ciation at Raleigh.
LIST OF OFFICERS.
Col. D. M. Hodges, of Hodges and
Mitchell, state managers of the Pru
dentlal Insurance comany, of this city,
has returned to the city from Raleigh
where he was a represetnatlve at the
meeting of the North Carolina Under
writers association held there last Sat
urday. Col. Hodges was elected
member of the executive committee
Plans wer cmade at the meeting for
active work during the present year.
The association broadened its scope by
adopting a new constitution and by
laws, under which the privilege of
membership Is extended to any agent
In god standing who represents ft legal
reserve life Insurance company. The
membership was formerly limited to
general agents and managers.
The following new officers were
elected for the term f one year
President, R. E. Peters, of Charlotte
first vice-president, S. W. Sparger, of
Durham: second vice-president, A. W.
Fetter, of Greensboro; secrtary, B. W.
Marshall, of Raleigh: treasurer, E. G,
McGlnnls, of Raleigh; and an execu
tlve commltte composed of the follow
lng: J. P. Quarles of Charlotte; W. F.
Upshaw, of Raleigh: D. R. Henry, of
Raleigh; D. M. Hodges, of Asheville;
H. M. Humphries, of Goldsboro.
The work of the association will be
extended throughout the state by the
apolntment In each town of a state
committeeman, whose duty It will be
to co-operate with the state associa
tion for the advancement of the Inter
esta of life Insurance representatives
In general, and that service to the pub'
11c throughout hie local territory. This
plan of association has attained na
tlonal prominence, and it Is earnestly
hoped that the co-operation of all will
be such that the North Carolina asso
ciation will rank amongst the fore
most.
An Interesting address on the educa
tional tendencies of the Insurance bus
Iness was made by G. S. Hastings, of
Boston, during which the fact was
mentioned that sixty-four colleges
have established ft chair of Insuranoe.
A talk was mads by Insurance Com
missloner James R. Young on the
qualification of agents. The meeting
concluded with ft luncheon.
The following were present: J,
Ellington, A. W. Fetter, E. C. McOln
nls. W. F. VpshftW, D. R. Henry, Wll
Ham Bailey. T. S. Franklin. H. M.
Humphries, C. 8. Aulstcn, J. A. Sheets,
A. M. Newson. E. V. Marshall, C. A.
Creech, M. T. Bethel, J. E. McElwan
F. B. Brown. B. T. Cowper, J. P. Bou
.hall. Hal Haynes, Cy Thompeon,
IX Hulcer, G. W. Mumford, W. C LlnU
sey. A. Rosen, J. P. Queries, R. V,
McPherson, D. M. 1 lodges, F. A. Pet
ter, Bam Sparger, R. E. Peters, Cary
J, Hunter, 3. O. Guthrie.
ttMttKRKKtMStltBlltitfti!tn hour thes things, and that Is con
t
St FLOOD VICTIMS SUITER
m r , it
m Niirh.i Miu. Pah. Is tTra at
X ent appeals for help for the
at flood victims In Conoordla. mr.
K lnh where It Is declared that W
men. women and children are
st almost starving and clinging to
st the sides of leveea and houses. It
t have beer, received by
the
n Natch relief committee.
I ltlkill SIX UK
RASHNESS BAD
IS COWARDICE.
Ull SMS
President Tells Gridiron Club
America Should Enter War
Only on Demand of
Principle.
VALOR STRIKES ONLY
WHEN IT IS RIGHT
resident Declares That the
Point in National Affairs
Does Not Lie Along
Lines of Expediency.
-ma
Washington, Feb. 28, President
Wilson told members and guests at a
Gridiron club dinner that America
ought to keep out of the European war
'at the sacrifice of everything except
this single thing upon which her char
acter and her history are founded, her
sense of humanity and Justice."
The address was confidential, since
the speeches at the dinners of the
Gridiron club, composed of newspaper
correspondents, are not reported. It
was made public last night, however,
with the consent of the president and
the club because many of those who
heard It urged that It should go to the
country.
The president spoke of the nation's
affairs with unusual gravity. His
hearers, Including several hundred
members of congress, government of
ficials, business men, and correspond
ents were brought to their feet cheer
ing when he concluded with these
words:
"I would be lust as much ashamed
to be rash as I would to be a coward.
Valor la sallVreapecUn - Valor, Is - cir
cumspect. Talor strikes only when it
Is right to strike. Valor withholds It
self from all small implications and
entanglements, and waits for the great
opportunity when the sword will flash
as If it carried the light of Heaven
upon Its blade." . ,
The address follows:
"I have very little to say tonight ex
cept to express my warm appreciation
of the invariable courtesy of this club
and of the reception you have so gen
erously accorded me. . I find that I am
seldom tempted to say anything nowa
days unless somebody starts some
thing, and tonight nobody has started
anvthlng.
"Your talk, Mr. Toastmaster, nas
been a great deal about candidacy for
the residency. It Is not a new feeling
on my part, but one which I entertain
with a greater Intensity than formerly,
that a man who eeeks the presidency
of the United States for anything that
It will bring to him is an audacious
fool. The responsibilities of the office
ought to sober a man even before he
approaches It One of the difficulties
of the office seldom appreciaiea, i
riarMMv. Is that It is very difficult to
think while so many people are talk.
lng, and particularly while so many
peool eare talking In a way that od-
scures counsel and la entirely off the
nolnt
"The noint In national arrairs, gen
tlemen, never lies along the lines oi
expediency. It always rests in the
field of principle. The United states
was not founded upon any principle
of expediency; It was founded upon a
Drofound principle of human liberty
nrt nf humanity, and whenever it
hasea lta DOllcy upon any othor foun'
datlons than thos It builds on the sand
and not upon solid rock. It seems to
me that the most enlightening thing a
man can do Is suggested by sometning
which the vice resldepnt said last
night. He complained that he found
men who, when their attettion was
called to the signs of spring, did not
see the blue Heaven, did not see the
movement of the free clouds, did not
think of the great spaces of the quiet
continent, but thought only of some
Immediate and pressing piece of busi
ness. It seems to me that If you do
not think of the things that He beyond
and away from the disconnected from
thi. arvne In which we attempt to
think and conclude, you will Inevlfr
ably be led astray. I would ft great
deal rather know what they are talk
ing about around quiet firesides all
over this country than what they are
talking about In the cloakrooms of
congress. I would ft great deal rather
know what the men on the trains ana
by the wayside and In the shops and
on the farms are thinking about and
yearning for than hear any of the
vociferous proclamations of policy
which It Is so essy to hear and so easy
to. read by picking up any scraps of
printed paper. There Is only one way
It'stantlv to go back to the fountains of
St American action. Those fountain, are
not to be found In any recently dls-
covered sources;
Hj "Senator Harding was saying Just
si now that ws ought to try when we are
ft hundred million strong to act In the
same simplicity of principle that our
forefathers acted In
hen ws were
, three million
thought, the hundred
V million will be saved from an musiri
st'ous future.
at I They were reaay xo siase every
. .(Continued on par. two).
REPUBLICANS LOOK
FOR AIM CROWD
Growing Sentiment That State
Convention Will Not Nom
inate Business Governor.
(Special to The Times.)
Raleigh, Feb. 28. Hotel arrange'
ments for more than 1,000 delegates
and visitors to the state republican
convention here Wednesday, March 1,
promise a bigger attendance than a
few months ago any republican hoped
for.
Many democrats are coming, it was
learned today. They are greatly in
terested In th platform to be adopt
ed, the method of attack to meet and
the personnel that the nominees of
the dominant party will have to
match. It is the decldely growing
view here that the republicans are
not going to nominate a "business
man' because the business man has
so little authority to brings things to
pass as governor. The republican
view leans to a talking governor.
Nevertheless ft very considerable
republican sentiment would give to
some business man like Elwood Cox,
John Motley Morehead, B. Carl Dun
can or Charles J. Harris the manage
ment of the state for another four
years. They point out the vote of
1908 as evidence that the republicans
voted moBt enthusiastically when busi
ness was a candidate In the Elwood
Cox Incarnation. Then Taft carried
Wake county outside heavily demo
cratic Raleigh township and repeated
In Durham and many other strongly
democratic counties. But Taft was
running against Bryan and Mr. Cox
was the beneficiary of a large desire
to swat Nebraska yet another time.
There Is small doubt that either
Judge Bynum or Herbert Seawell
could have the convention nomina
tion to the primary if he sought It.
Both can speak and both voted for
Roosevelt Neither Is an affront to
the Taft men because the most hide
bound man could not blame Seawell
for voting for Roosevelt, the fine
friends of Seawell. And then Judge
Hyams always had a way of doing
pretty much as he pleases.
It Is announced by prominent re
publicans that the convention nomin
ation, to the' primary -will not debar
any candidates from running In the
regular primary. It will slightly han
dicap him, that's all. The convention
Is taking this method, prospective, to
guarantee the greatest degree of
harmony.
COLONEL J. P. KERB
CONTINUESJO IMPROVE
Miss Sarah Davis Critically
111 Mrs. Ellen Mordecai's
Funeral Today.
Special to The Times.
Raleigh, Feb. 28. Col. J. P. Kerr,
private secretary to Governor Craig,
continues to Improve since his sertous
attack of ft few days ago and he
expected to return to his office this : witness's handwriting was filed as an
week. Colonel Kerr'e Illness la much i exhibit The notelated 8-4-15 was al
less dangerous than first diagnosis! so dictated by Judge Jones and writ
indicated. ten down bv the witness, which was
National Committeeman E. Carl
Duncan and Capt. J. A. Duncan are
dally apprised of the critical condl-
tlon of their cousin Miss 8arah Davis'
of Beaufort, whose illness the lust;
several daya has given to all ,ier
kinspeople the greatest anxiety.
Mlss Davis Is 86 years old and h.ts
been for the last fifty years one of
the most prominent women in east-
em North Carolina. Everywhere In
the state she ivfll be recalled as
teacher and larllady of one of the
inns at the resort and everybody who
has enjoyed her hospitality has car
ried away a personal ' affection for
her. She taught the Raleigh Duncans
when they were children and by car
lng for E. C. Duncan when he was
barely more than a baby following
his mother's death became ft mem
ber of his family and all of them hold
her In the highest affection. The let
ters and telegrams Indicate the
smallest hope for a return to health.
From Christ Episcopal church an
nouncement was made yesterday thnt
Mrs. Ellen Mordecal, mother of Dr
S. F. Mordecal, dean of Trinity Law
school, will be burled In Raleigh to
day.
Mrs. Mordecal died In Durham Sat
urday at the age o tit. She had not
been able to. see In many years but
ft more alert mind Is rarely found In
a woman of fifty years. She kept Im -
mediately up with all modern move -
ments and commented upon them
with a brightness which has always
explained the wit and philosophy of
the dean.
- i against the woman detective.
stltttlslltttistltilltstttststst Jonn nMga said that Rlckman
l t' wanted htm to be present once dur
st RUSSIANS TAKE CJTT. H,ng a conversation he had with the
t i woman,
st London. Feb. 28. A Reutera
t dispatch from Petrograd says SPECIAL MEETING FOR
st storm Kermanshah, an Import- t
It ant Persian city In the neighbor st
n hood where recent lighting took X
1 place.
s i H
4lslsllllllftl(tstiAths Muonia UavsJa M, Broidwft,,
ASSURANCE FOR
UNARMED SHIPS
ONLY, U. S. TOLD
.-
Rid DENIES
r. SEEINGiETTERS
Defendant in Arden Case on
Stand Nearly All of the
Morning.
FRADY WON'T TESTIFY.
Court to Limit Attorneys in
Their Arguments to Jury
. May Go Over Wednesda.
The morning session of Superior
court today has been taken up most
Iy with the cross-examination of the
defendant Rlckman in the Arden
blackmailing cases. He was put on
the stand Saturday afternoon, and
after the direct examination during
which he denied the statements made
by Mrs. Pond, the detective, who
testified that Rlckman told her i he
had seen the letters which Mr. Lance
received before they were sent, the
defendant went Into a long story of
his actions at Arden around the time
of the burning.
He left the stand this morning
about 11 o'clock. It was announced
by. Attorney R. M. Wells that he
would not place his client Edward
Frady on the stand, although it has
not been stated by counsel as' to
whether or not Miss Pressly will be
put on the stand. The case will con
sume all of today and probably all
of tomorrow.
Judge Harding stated this morning
that he would limit the time for
speaking by each side when the evi
dence-was concluded.. That this time
will be sufficient for each side to sum
up its case. Is a statement by the
court.
Rlckman on Stand.
ProRS-exAmlnatlon of the defendant
Rlckman was resumed wrien court
convened this morning, Judge Jones,
of the prosecution conducting the
cross-examination. The witness ad
mitted, that he had asked Lance fir
a loan and Pressly for another; tnat
he wanted $80 from Pressly and that
he had solicited a loan of $100 from
Mr. Seals. He said that he heard f
the first letter the morning that
Lance's warehouse burned, but did
not know what was In It. He stated
that this happened about noon the
day following the fire. He went to
Christ church on a machine with
Miss Pressly, he testified, telling of
the trip and the route they took, In
which he stated that they did not
leave the Henderson road before they
saw Frady and Revls. The couple
planned to go to a picnic, according
to statement of witness.
In answer to a question asking him
to write he wrote several times on a
piece of paper, writing down the
words of two notes as they were read
lsk.. tj.. t tv,. i v.
also filed as exhibit in the case.
He was turned over to counsel for
re-dlrect examination during which
he stated that he did not object to
any evidence as to his handwriting,
This examination was very short,
Herman Souther was the next wlt-
Iness called. He stated that he knew
Rlckman and told of seeing him the
day Frady was arrested, as Rlckman
and Miss Pressly were going In the
, direction of Hendersonvllle, from Ar
den.
Loaned Money,
Mitchell Rlckman, a former post
master at Arden, said that after July
2, he loaned Martin Rlckman $5).
Th wllue( told of a conversation
he had with Martin, during which
tne aerenaant "Stated that a woman
had told his fortune and that he be
lieved her to be ft detective, and that
she could get nothing out of him.
The next witness Joe Reagan, also
told of a converaatvpn he had with
Martin, during which the defendant
told him of the fortune teller and
said that Martin declared the woman
was a detective, and he also said
that Martin had made arrangements
with Frazler Patton to stay with
him, "so that the woman could not
frame up nothing against him," In
endeavoring to show tha
Interest of
the state
the witness in the case,
1 brought out on cross-examination
'that the witness was ft bondsman
the defendant.
Frailer Patton told of the requeeti
he said Martin made of him, to stay
iwith the defendant so as to guard
MT. HERMON MASONS
A special communication of Mt
st'Htrmon lodge No. Ill, of Msaons will
be held this evening at 7:10 e'olock
Promises Given in Lusitania
and Arabic Cases Still Bind
ing for Peaceful Ships,
Germany Replies.
EMBASY ORDERED
TO INFORM LANSING
Germany Contends New Sub
marine Policy Squares With ,
With U. S. Interpreta-. , '
tions of Laws.
Washington, Feb. 28. Germany's
response to the request of the United
States government for assurances m
regard to the conduct of submarino
warfare for the future, Is in the
hands of Count Von Bernstorft, tha
German ambassador, who is prepar
ed to present it to Secretary Lanslr.g
today. The reply is in the form of In- ;
structions to the ambassador, and la
not to be put in the form of a note
unless the secretary of state desires
jit .
The ambassador's instructions were :
to Inform the United States that as
surances for the future conduct of
the Teuton submarine activity, as giv
en In the Lusitania and Arabic cases
are still binding; but that they apply
only to merchant vessels of peaceful
character.
Germany contends that British
merchantmen, armed ostensibly for
defense, carry guns for the speclfio
purpose of attacking German sub
marines and that they thus show
themselves not to be peaceful ships
and are subject to destruction. To
support this contention the Berlin
foreign office sends a list of several
Incidents where British submarines
have attacked submarines. - .-. ,-.,.
The Instructions call attention to
the claim of Germany that despite
the assurances of Great Britain that
her merchantmen are armed for de
fense, and will never fire unless fired
upon and will never attack any ves.
sel, such British ships are prepared
and Instructed, not only to resist cap
ture but to attack.
ONLY 280 SAVED FROM .
WRECK OF THE iLOJH
Patrol Pioks Up Baby Float
ing on Its Back in
the Sea.
London, Feb. 28. Of the total com-
nlAmftnt t All n.uAn..n .nil .ou.
of th)) pen,n8uIar Bnd oriental liner
Maloja, which struck a mine and sank
In half an hour two miles o: Dover
yesterday, only 260 are known to
have been saved. Of the total of 119,
sixty-four names of passengers hava
been received at the office of the com
pany to which the steamer belonged.
It was stated that It was hoped that
more names of persons saved would
soon be received.
The bodies of three more Lascars
of the crew of the Maloja have been
washed ashore, making the total num
ber of bodies recovered 47.
Relative of passengers are arriving
at Dover for the purpose of Identi
fying the bodies. Among thosa res
cued was a baby, warmly clad and
floating on Its back. It was picked
up by a patrol boat and was taken
Into the engine room. After It was
warmed, the baby smiled at Its res
cuers and seemed none the worse for
Its immersion.
BOY SCOUTS MEET
TOMORROW NIGHT
The regular weekly meeting of tha
Asheville troop No. 1, Boy Scouu of
America, will be held In tha council
chamber at the City hall tomorrow
night It Is urged by the scout master
of .that
all membors attend this meet-
lng.
It Is expected that reports on the
sale of tickets by the scouu for the
Asheville Baseball club will h m.ri.
at this meeting and the committee
appointed to consult with Dr. & Ves
tray Battle regarding relief work for
th Belgian Relief day, will also be
taken up.
Collector A. D. .Watts la sending
out from his Statenvlll office notices
to thos who have so far failed tr
mk return of thslr personal In
come tux. Th tax must b paid on
or beforn Wednesday evening, March
1. In order to avoid to psnaUlea it
th law,