1
k
4
to
t
It 14 f wi H ab-rtain from U, which howe r wi al fwi ia taitves, hs U aea'Jfaoeo of iturty which And ai retpon in lhe heart of the citiinn, and whkh will be evaded with little reroon '
T'u wisdom of itllioi especially Been U g raftini law on conscience. ; , , . Dr, i'ianning. -
hs,
4
it
3-
rdj
ia..
V
!!
rc
Hi
!
I
!ir'
i
,4
,7-1
u
i-a
at
Jt
V
if
vet
f
,HV IUIHTON CRAKJK.J
8AUSHUUV, UOWAtt COUNT VN. G:...N,().l)AY l .VaClLtJj-
imwaHPwwM
- ...
. ,f .- . w-w -
Vfrl I HI V" ' I fw' -tHMil clwngJ. Iim be our
... .......a... ' . ..... . V 1 I kial that In flMI MiliMra kjtl k iluiiu M.
TV HiiJtJC"' t.lWIl Ml " "
. . . J I . . I un vr. raiiiri I I K
i attaining wllkneul
. . J. - 4 . J I . . -
... .f iHiul ititkt tkrtt montkt: or me
tktynr. Mo I'axr ttill
, OijfsiiM'i biUil all rrcorar ar
r . .1... at lit FA'Aut'l Jitrrrtiun.-
' l ; r trill fie rrrAatA f&r li It it
UliHO iijtii
... mtt yriW.
.1 . i-,.1-' ........
mri1" to ike CWllia, thill kilt a
i !n-riiiiir III
i, (t'llrtutJ (hi VMar "
lf r.tf Hii'f r thry vlU no htiUlrmUH to.
r flic, term wtit-i tftcll liter.
SiiNVniOFTHti lj. &
bi'.xcn ofmr. r,nv?irop
f, iht Lill fur(kr to prmidtfor tkt col-rvM-f
dutirt on t-npTrll-'
Mr. HROWN.nf .N'rlh Cji1in, toi.k
fl.wr. U J"l ! Lff'1.
ftr-lllH- lnh iultlltuai i-iil.Tiumiwnt
IkIi tlie K",I,!"M,n prfr-J-J' him
fpbrt diwuwi ,litl. funuslied to tbe
lkt ie w-iuMnnimiror to rfmti
L..I- luinLr iattuttHi the Siwm
gifcUt gie tJ hit plain, homely Itirt, by
... .SAnlv ha t(mu I ht1 n-r
. f in Ihuaa of nl!oMi f nuchr ft'!
I idMhtd bihty. But !! bill b.
1 tw'miia invnlt onenliofw of rh nwtf-
i . . - ,
mflK.frhu couH W"t cqqt""' rumn-'n
of hiih pitCTM lo th State which he
.' ih. L.,mSr irt imrt 10 ffpn nt, b..tli
krHinbttriirino'comirtrtn vnioii, ami
s,v leeithnioo r" l,.w
. ".'.LuSMia ff'tha State f
swtinj'njiiv iwi.."- ,
5r!i tirnlin,' mrort.ner AmIam
t -Xrrt Jheir iuiltiwu-e to obtain 'ffa;
fti.i-.Vua Mtrili'i-f bartiv'y ,,s-
ifH i)is.FJirl flrpwnl ao4 iho
of S.AA Caniliiia; 'AV'hile A
riTiJtf'jl im plcaaoni la po"'.'y
I ma tuefeqoewt of b.i" ' orenitaeiif a, it
e)iujf IBpu iiunijLiuu oa tli occMwtt,
W f J.iwmJ u! tkt dictate; of hi nvn
ftVmnnt and ardi, wi. I wis .bm.
I' ' i - i -..i..u ... .;
ru-t ti'e tnai inta cjuiubi, mt ,w.
a aiiHii an anjrry aoJ iRrcdTeniuj
Bwtf, tihould be titled in Ikaccie
niwrr -fit? nd ntit tay thai he
4Cllil IO'kIu
tU quetKiu
and Ut tln judicial irilMiiialt it cmuiBiiU'd
th adinimtraom A IbvM pracfuJ unt-
a a i
ur. lit did no! at U vbirl la llta a-l-
ministration am) ot)trti)U U tb Ua uf
th Unitiul Stnto't. .. wnM Iht U tu
find Upirt in ibn ftiwry if th OiMMtdt.
hnn. It wa vain . any that corrivt
uwaiMirim ara rweaaary m this raaf, f.r
tlmrt in an int.f rent mur.rgy in ilxa Cmmii
tuti m which wiU'nikblti ttM law la In
uinh ith"ul ii aH.4l t i G.rc.
Tlte Mutator fr n PnnnayiVauia akej
li thtf otbar day, if we wore unwilling
thNt (ha powrra pntptwn to w given to
llw r.Ttitivn bv lh! hill, lu'i Im confl-
Ivl to th irMil Prraid'Mil nf lb Unit"d
Sl'ittn. that wat not lha qu atn.ii
II wfMild my that I' C"Ur of the
ProtnlBfit had bwi aurh, at lu fiititla him
lo tmli'nitatl r-ofiMrnr", bim! tliere wiyw
iiidividiml to nh'Mii hi wmiI4 more wilTng
Iv oxifvU ihn iHiwcf than to the I'reii
dVni. But th'r wat ti man, howfcf .
evaKxJ in taiifl ami nii'lili'd hyjrirtiie,
bnvrft r IKiWhit "mtVjjrit") aiwl Vmrat hit
ptiriMitva, lu whom he would aiva a powwr
which wat uowarmnli'd by 4ie Coiwlitu
liv We are told thu a jfal iu watch
or Ihwf pwilorie f pjiwt'r, it the only
way of pretrrvini lilrt II" could nul
bflieTeXor a im-inent, that, if Una power
were eiven to the Pri'tidenl. h would
ii in i i i .'JLmaaj
Jltilri4, Thai frai' lhi rm t mr
tion the United Stttee r."irt a'e, to their
power, lha harmony i( the mat a, if tUe
rewtt wicroarhftKfitt on their rijfhu, will
fiwjiirntlyba interrupted, and if, Ihia evil,
lhe should, on all ocmioni, yie ti,
trwtchea of owr, tf , rtrrve.1 ri.'litt 4
io oi ww win nepena on w arwirar pow
coflhe OaiM. ' .
" Rrtnlnrii That, elioiild the indi-petwl-
ence of the Htatnt. at wvured lv thet.oo'
titutim, brdoitroyed, the lilwrtift of the
pepl, in o fttriiive a rowitry, nn'iit
long aumve. To aufR'r th" I'oiied Siit
Court to decide uu Htale Kijhl', will
Croin a bajiit in iar d power, mt nrily
dt'tlroy the Ke.lfful prtof tr Uaverfi
meut; and whi-iM-vcr the t.,vriiiiiiiwHjt
of the (Jlilli'd Slater t.Tniin i:oia.il'lii(ed
we mny le rn, from the hitory f nulion;
wfmt Mill be the event.
'I llv piper iihow mli.it m ere the dV
trinet of Piiinvlvniui at Ihn' time, ami it
it well kn'iwn that he aent .n In rtrry
th.me into iiniriM tf niwratwii. Shcctilled
out her whole inilihirv ftowar to roeiiil llm
decree of the tourt, and lepi wit ;ilen
to hrin,? her mditarv (orrtt nit actual
vire. Ii did not addorn tin furf lierait-e-
he aporoved of the dorfnn't of Pniiivla
uu, for, in hit opinion, thr. wcat loo UtA
Rut hn meant to ahow her f tiline did ie4
draw down upH hr tde power of the tin-
ion. The aliniuittratioo of that Uy had
not rerourne to mih'ary cjerciun The
(IrCi'led Maud h-h the State had taken
wna known to (lie (iovenmieiit and to Con
in(le rirrumeUore hed niiirh liarHt on
(hit itije.t. TlieHl.i'e of Rhlu !!4ihI,
I email Htate, hot little tarn, r in p pula
Hitt than eomenf the toiitli' lu Si m ork.
Yet rterciin( ofl that irmaoo-a noverei.
iity r einivo will, that of New York,
I'lTiniy Wiwia, or any other Hiatn iu lite
Pniofl. Anether Mi reiHldmlea (lie d,-
tnoa ( em a Ivitve l, that IV-1 ' mtituti4i
itthe work f the pei.ie. It mily n
ry fir a iim.rity f ti e 'lutea, c
utttutlllil ime-f xirth of the (wople, lo re-
Iiim to eli ."VMiiitort, ami an fid l pit nt
tfw, lo I lie In ii.rnl ti.virniiHiil. I In-
eouid'Talion jrtiU to (lijht all the aritu
tnenU ori' I lit ir ,- licit lint it a coo-
tiduled (J.X'-rn'nont. I!'! Mat aware that
it had U-eii !, in p.pK to tln remark,
the inNiniMjf of the qonrnni, t huh wat if
reeary lo nnhl. t'e htit.tt" ! Ir.miirl
of f itiudinR upon il wana terminati a. and temritiea whk;h lh peifl had e
Ilwitti- -t that that he detiVd Ineutrr joyed called forth m.en-uil the in4 :
hitpritelj uiler Ihia uit'kfd battery he ((loritaielothw country that rao lm
w,that it wa intended to fit vpoft the gined. It drew forth the celebrated rf
rihu of the Maiee, (irnileiiMn iudd u(i port of Mr, Mditnn, a reports ll merit
the flag of iiullift. atinn, rang til the change of which he waa Matly iuuq,u:ite In 4o ,
ea Umo the word, eound-d the lomin of jo 'tire. Tile wat k nioeojfiit.f the
altrm lliroohout the neinlry.and preten- pinny prii of lha Btatw aoverHfnlie,
ted the whohi in4lt-r in a hht the mt bifii, instead of deroyinf Ih l'niat
uiiCtvorable to H"uih Carolina, in order to brought back the Uuverfibirttl to U 6il
juttify (u the other Ktatrt the war which prifciph. tio piwh, lheii tf ttt
they were diaixwd ! waue- ' pride. If that Mate pride had preaervedj
war, too, which wortld admit of no in-u- the Constitution at ilt k4 f ap it ought
Irtl. I be genilene-n aim bavo taken I not to have eaiUd down ( u eucn ea
the ttriMi ground, like NaMiin, bve I qualified r prubatu-u. The doCtfihc of
thrown out the Ui-clMratimi. that there Virginia auved the conl-rary in thai ,
duii-frou cnia. Tht'V produced fivii .'
rrvolutiiHi, wbu h brought into power th (
uiiKt be no neutraU.
I take roy atamt, aid Mr. B., on the re
M-ivrd righ!t of the htnte. 1 reiaeliule
r puumie,
the d'lCtrme ofriultificatiofl. I
laimiM-M, would, ,n tn ciw, l- r..iitru ! I Mo, the high toned doctrine of :he r ed-
temein a mti iriiv ot hi it i m iu.ilU
reprewnl"d ; tin the Sfatr not r'r-wii.
vJheabuS,l.ithe de? Jriictioa ofur -uu. cucaV
' (iii'tjaT! We may be told that the power JudKiaHribii
mrwiU be limited a to continuance and ap Ndiva
pliculwn
W. ii..
1yiaa h. . Itnt il iimrtit. in Worte Ii:im'
- -.r,,,., --, - . , . ... .,
than JBtae, and in worae hamlt than hit, t w JPJ.',m 001 r,mnta"T "'"
huonU had tried their remedy.
introduced in I HMignt4, no
Hut what de tint tearh utr "iwrelwommemlcd by lh. I reatdent
fbti Uie of l-la beeoroee prec-4Hr meetin; the meanurea o reunvlvania
dentil morrow. Our own hittory lif military lorrr. I hey trtnted lo the
V inatailCt'S Of power, wime Wf II yiD-l wr b i "ur ioi.iyi.nm nun ir min.n-o.
. r.mi.i,iii.u,l. which the Camera I - Should not tin rrtollertien vf hi-( tnn.
. . I---.. : i ti.r.....i. ,
of the Corwjilulion and it erlvrirenu;l acw incuicaio upon r:orniyiania mm
would have thrunk from with'tircal Tb$j 'ration, and uiiU(jed couli-lMre in a p-a
i:...r.l Coveniment has been KraJiiMlk I ceful remedy ? The ca) addreod it-lf
. m a i- a? .
druinu tojfJf the exurciae
- A-. . .i ... ...
ixiweri." B'niii inai inev arc
waild
BlfBiiiiitttional renmdy i UfHW the relue
nnnieoiie of iustice in the peoplo of the
Huiaera aadeaalurn Slei4, ud upou
fce.vhm and nairiotimn 8serablcd to
xi- 'u'iitive h.illaof the country But
I grUiyriy ceiui remedy ! 1 he cams ai.iraod it'll
ofdetildful particularly lo tliat Stale, and bound hv
ire not m I to practiee tM aaine inouVration toeranlt
veti'byThyCmlilqU.Sh,"; Jljey reply that Carolina which tiie Union pra.-ti-rd to.
fhey are, jSiiffied b pwlinit. rrdw her, when, in a moment of Irtgh ex
The h.MHtfabletpmflcina'li from Penn- crtemenf, the opKed hertrlf lo ibe Uw
Tat.ia, in the courto of hi remarks, onneunim. lie wouiq loiuunertuppuri
t'poke ot the aubiniwive ma ner in whjcli f hia view, read from apeech delivered
that tJtato would yield obwlience to the by highly diatingomhed citif 'ti SlLt'w
m,-t M,i,.ai and ioiiiriou Witlatiofi iof ejWi Baiiiga'wl'iicll waefranrbt with
ilhiitrited- by the tirtue and patritint of ddrM drtiverod Mm Hie literary aoci.
hnr ciia itf ; but lha Senator would; par- M College, t- tU nnwal
don him if be hottdny that 'thrttf ;1kfl,,;,lr
CeunaiivajiiBWMBoLquiU. Biemj-t from 4W lb-, Hm, Wilk.ni, Ie read t He fot
.1... tM whirH are linlMltml to"S-ruth Car lown-pgJ i.-..tU-I- -
TkAV.'nirhwVnavlvania in Ihe " "' with horror from audi
&nw Olmrtead caseV im aKency JJiWtuLcon-etlueoce,. lei rr eflorts be
" . . y I T .fT MtaaI t) Hurt Aal wawkiaata Lrltl mj
inbriiwiii? about iheprewnt iaie.otyHiPl.'V-,-!'"v-rMr .
.nwth Car.diim Tl. h S.wlhCaMli' pl'f"' ' " Ever ke-p id wind the
d lierimpuN from that I "P"11 ot compromite in wni n our oumi
ictriiiekduce cwt.uid.;.llarnutbdliad jta oriain. .Juatead of dolUite
nw drw-xi, tet ui adopt, me oi cu;i
vl, wWw-f rneficabHi. uf Co
iktcal of hunting up material,
aTooinpanaone betwee.i d iflirut
dicuoitnS.ajlh CVi'W, ..pttifyint "' rawnibef on.y
fc VAilwhatUiiUrKMisiiuthehittorT.oreiitiinatte
lmphr.apprabatiou.unon them, nor on In the aracter of each ; aJopt.ng h
rP.fni.;... M- Rrown then read hippy quotation of Lord Chatham, when
E.T.-.I-HCm ihe renort made inthe houte deprecating that atuhbura and cBniemjrtu
j iiraui a - - .
of Reprientativcof Pennaylvaflta, mum
r . j - ... L... in - In.
ted w -uld not U- rofimi't ii-d as ticlnii".
log lo 'ie I'm. .ii. I'nl l!itoli'rli .ii w..ulii
drive feiith nn-o t n amnon -f the
nghl of ei a,,. doctrine whidrp'T
hi they woitd tmf be willing to all-.w ;
for if a Sla'e baoiol ihe nirhi of eceion,
no act Hul he ln-r If mav do, it omit to
do, wau plwee her out of the Uiii"n
Hilt If Ihe uriuio and nature ofmir cv.
emnenl did nrf njt tin iilc t r. l. to
cliratUr aud etmt of our f.Kiiilry w.iulil
he toe n. IV people Mre wide ami
van. hi a surface Winild never have dele
iui the wtrt to utakea CoMei!iJalei
Uovcruiutiil. i bey . Juiew llial no uch
(Jovernment ceild end h?re. WimI wy
Mr. UainlU n in III Ki l. fh. ' What
wy Mr. Madison Ofl the ubji:ct 7 Why,
l!ut to adopt u Crivid.ited (Jovernnwni
wmil l be deetrnviog the prim uilen of the
revdutein, and would inevilalily lead In
munrchy. And why ' Uivniie wm-n-
ever a r njority, having adver inlrr.n(
to the minority, h!iihiiI comtun): I. ojiprem
the mnaller xrtioti, the l.iller would have
to intrench llieinwive dciiiiiu tucir r
ral party. I brliuve mt it la to ll al
lii-h l.jel doctrine that we are to retrib
ute nullification. I U Uuve that doctrine
wiet and tlie ablett aUitreniBn who ref
lived in any ctwjutry. line wa ihki i.f
the licnt fin which had rcaultcd from But . . . ,
pruW.
In the rate of the entabl 'itnenl if th
I 'iiited S'afe Bank, there aroae alao iron.
- .i I !... . .r . . .. .. 11ium an. MnM WM M.
nriH Hi fi II. I lie luireiil il ii. in h iiiir-" 7 - ' "
an impr. - r p e-ure .4" ihe Federal (Jo. '"'J ,ltt ' w n u'PllJ? , .t0Z?t
ciuuMiul ou. IU Mitola of thir butf, BH.1 Aeete-d Ul rArrCiertmmeii!f
,v ner. i-ii.g iloubtlul powert, that the )hio wiia .Hie of ihe Btatea which held that
Nate id .ui! t arol.na hat Uen thrown r,"'"n- Thia matter, ala... waa fiutlly ad-
into thia ire.iii.4i. Hu did uot rh..,. I.. IUul- "bt waa theneat j.e-rtion wmcfc
IIIMfifv 1 1 if riiifatJl a that M.i. It..i lui.IiC!t(ed the eoontry ! It wa the rtcr. ' '
tl.er ahewa right, or w,. th. r the wv, rie f the power fl internal inipr.. n enU
1 ual waa not an etprewjeo power granina
to tle Gnrnii Government. Il waa
mon the doubtful powi.ru, and the njjlit to
exercise it mi denied by aevcral t lle
Slatee. Il waadenir dU the Mteof Net
'I
wr.m;', thn furm-dicd htr with aoiiM llonl
nke i i V'tir! fjf her ciaulucl. lit be. I
In vn! ti.ut ihe principle waa a win-
reiiili!e hi ueiiHntraiion a any principle
id iiiaihrinaticii, tliat aluinnt any atlitmie ot
... ... I n......v.:. ..;.tt.u..u,u ,a..u,.iJ,Ln....
reianeeasainsi tne r eaeraiu.ivernirwni I 'io,wl -j - -" i"
in which Male had b.ii ae.,aroae imt of '" he N,w "rh. " held
llta unwarrai.liil.ln rxrrri of doubtful ' " one w iuouiuoinu piw.ra.--
iKjaer by Iho Cioled rjtatea. Tliey had
always K'en incluted to tranquillity. Thev
had alwayt b-en 'lo-powd tn make a child'o
bargain with the I'mted Slate if you
will letuiaf.oe, we will let toil almie.
I'ik-v would never have admitted the idea
ot riMllg "I oppieillon to the United Stolen,
unlet there had Imjcii ne exciting cue.
The whole hlsiory of the world prove thu
. .. i -i ... .i liVeJ . 'i'tuMW ia no wrecedWtt where tuuL
K;rvi-a,r,;aulUiU BUfc.ttfUMaice w nej- . - ,., . r
... t-, .,. t.n,.!.., U'h.i il" naro. arrnjeu uininrnn agnu.Bl a
I1IIIIM TW V i pmai- u iia I .
Fhe State of N't York, and aonie other of
the Statet, dnrMited, the right of the. Ftd
eral Government to appropriate ino.wy,
xcept for Ihe purpoc pointed out bv lit)
Conatitution. 8ux'h are the content i..n
which had ariw-n from the ejrrciae of
doubtful power by tbcFed'TaK'' V rtuntntt.
The cae of Georgia waa the next lo
which he would call thu atttutiat of tho.
&'tot.T?rkti iwurped powerw whn b tti
United State attempted toeiercnw ovtr
her, provoked the pride o( that Kiut a
well it luiaht- .Wbee the Government of"
the United Sute undertmdi to tell her that; 'J
thaw artlM full Mlrtiiul laawr llir Teh Ilf lltfl IlVPf
cu r .. -
aw
.mil
win J.
ii
i . i-.... . .,ui...a . ,.t , i iua. ayxwuv-fir- nrrniDEi L aii HHetii wru
. mi rciiuriircu iu v.wkii tniunwn:Rinnr . . '
i where a people wooae purauua are peace-1 .... t
I Ul. BO" ajriuunorrij ift vim Ply Jari, 1 . " t
"Hta" wlirkiia'ia cafrt'awav "ilia wJ.u U'oiicl T5(alC,'Wat ul ot.e iaou.e a p.'-i
in
nnhad not demc
Luif.vl the doctfl
br Penrrlan',rrrei artpeeled to vnyi
- 'ri:.. ....".r.i ......j. TL. ni
w.Ml.(he the coiiHMiMiice l thit rei -"pn-me power iiohii any occasion, Le-
aV .... ..n,, li.u if nul Iwialtr il miiLinil La W1
...1.mT.'4..,uuibi ! in miti..rifi dinkf.r M-; " ,,,tJ"M"
in thU the maiontv were f..r.:iuir inter ttwn rt,id 10 .""q'rH
...7. . i-.a.. I.. ii.,'... nn.t ii.au )..... oppreaaioii than lo reatet it. lie detir-
to refat the encroachment, the imhtar
trm ithC.ivVfnm -lit would immediate-
bLhe ?Ikilhened pndtjiftre FvfUdjKJ
KW !, OoyotM IBM W a utonarciiY, . I ', . n . , ' ' y r. R, awful n..ce.
. awe nuwaa. ii nruirpr. himi ir iiaw nura Ij kavaa) mi a awtwt w n - - . - - -
I Tha taut Imt. but not Ih least
er,od. lha-power; twerity time largcMfticU which, have antttl rn-ru tue exercit . '' '.'J''
tbBB- ItaelA-- Could-irenllcaaM- pMunelof doOUful pewen by-'-fb 't3rr.l 7o.S Vci-iA
an instance where any Slate, without pro- crniuiit, wac'rn, rtlattoo to ftte)' pmlottiy) fj
vocation, bad eyer oill'red remittance t the ffteioV Her the " Uoerrnrnent "bf tliB.H Jl
General Uoverniuent T He had thua, he nited StaUf) had aaiuniHl Ttht iyht JT 1 - .
believed, eMaUishcd tlie great principle unlimited taxati.m, of laiinjf nej portion)
that the State theinaetre were alwava iTtbe community for the beorCt pf -tuothtii - -' 5:
I.. r .i f ; .i . l
, g, , tlllica VI y m-Vf aim u uia iihiiv a.
(HeoweraaB jrom iw wwt naui , - . , . -tn m .,mrt; .M;-
lilinntne atmnngpride of Ihe I 'V.i... ... i:i.
vereigutio which bad led ta tuia
I'ffgn.
o(tl.e 'cuum uToutkriruWot fj, .rs-Tno opt- 4ybaklL,v'!
Wrhi : at.it dtrtpp'Wd of ifcf iW fllMi,-aiidVtuinpJeioi Kiiihavlvanm wlhe J
-,'h" taousUu had. been . nuh,.and d ; ks,) i e 'cited, tn; lie ft"" iit'-fuIco,
lied tor try the exigencj ui. imj juw
Vt1il::nBre: ;Sreiicd,; a - US', tipin
Slate
itate ot lliiug. ..The aapiring pride of Ihe
State aovercignlie I U wai an avowal ol'
duclriow uch these which wa aq re
iu:iaut to hi feeling. II waa. well
kn wu that in the origin ol the tioyern
ne' it the couutry wa dividoj into two
irreat partie. One uf Ibcso pariecon.
iMle4 in famf ol the reaerred rbhi of
wiTTingbj be quiet, and that minrt o'fthe jcr.aTid Cluofe'Tairurd frtienr-t-lie;'li9?
' T
itiveluIUol liw coilttnf. om .(,, fin .rnor. relative tn .Jtie
Muie ftt South Carolina thought dif- fc Hlirireme Court of the
fwitly, and. look rdrw into her own . wj ; jhectue of Uideon'Olm-
no wa Wpoi,.o.D r "T'4 atead.aMouVw,, . ., . 1
'-r Her course, r.lt V Horn. ousinew 10 ttfelui-M wferrid to thesfl btt
KB LutMmaat nnon dee. hilt til eXDMS I B SU'tf'T-l ' . . -
r- . . r I faiUt ia mmm their moat Mriqtniw
flectiorT." "They
out deflanee which led to the diamertiher-
nvnt of the British empire lot each Slate
in reference to every other,
" Be to her fault a little blind.
. Be to her virtues very kind
Iri -dwelling on the
the common ucrincea
nnni yiio.it nwr, i v. . K'"-t mnat --rioiia
:v"T i . l . .11.:.. u A o. I not iai ea io niana" : v.--
pit own part, ana maoiinu.D, - ... .i; .re,l t in even r..i r wtaI.
. . I neciion. ni nnv -- . f i -
'1-1 .r havn accumiilBlarl Tor the Whole eoilli.
imlntinn of her cour3
Tie bill, though propot
tow general in it ipplicatiot', was
I . ! l. . .il.t. it .rtiil.l l,a rnnaid-
bill, though proposing on it face pom. o. . n. , .u w -
" ! V . : I AlWl. II 18 OT IHI lucuua " .
IB llllllll- 1 . " . . .L.l I.UhiM
oppowtion which had "been' maiiilealed a I ped that he hadthul"ucceeJc4 latBUk.-!
, . , . I . III! Iff 1 1 11 v... I.lllij HiuiiHiHwnw m.w . ...... --- . ... - . ..
i?" MrK '7 JT" " 7C from the exercise brdaubtful power by that treraie which bad antetr, tiad. tScif ort- V
General Government. The other Waa fcr - . Ki .kioK hH k.. I twi avareiaa e alna'bKbl? tnaklia&S:
that State pride which IhgoutfeiiieWrx.in the Federal Guverdment, opertin; agai -New
Jersey lo earnestly denounced." nat those nghi which tho State d.em lie '.
Without that prido tin republic wauld now cewary for the preaervktion of their eii$. '
have been a nothing. To justify this tence in jovefetgn capacity ..
nrlnciiile that most of tho coiitfSMwiew . .Tbwientlemaa from New ' Jewey had;
which had arisen, have unscfront the hold tip the Cgnsti.tution io hi hand, and
circumstance of tho Federal .Government with till that patriotic ardor for which ho
taking their dt-baleahle ground, he would w JiHtingmtiied.aaid he alioald cling id
read an authority which would meet with the bond. I, too, aaid Mr. B. will.tilnj
the approbation of all pure democrat to the bond : and while I V, ill willingly al
It was the authontv ol Ueorge Clinton, a low live reutreman to rase iuii. uwwei a
name deervmg of atf respect carc7B et I hi Mj that, in taking the pound .'of (Jcih, ho
will not am II one droo of Moon. Iheiren-
...... . . . . . i - "
lenuui had also said thai old Home never
!.! ft. kj. ilielalinn ftf iinv l.rKtfe
. ...i I : . . u.ii - ..
ailliiacl. 1 ne Uisiorv oi muau uihoj
ciMHerniig ou the Genenll uoveramenl
WnHUited p-iwers. " Hii lait wa called
the 'federal party. With a kiod mite
thev proclaimed the necessity ol invevtin?
the lie neral Government with a vaat range
of authority. Sumo of them even went o
tar o to propose a torin oi uoverninem,
Which would have been substantially a
uionarchv. Mr. Hainilnm iu the Cunveu-
. . i .i j I -.a:...
Ltion wh'cn tramea me rooerai v ouauiu
lion, had advocated the appointment of a
Chief Exeqii'ive Maswtrate, and a Senate
V -4 -
IL -
m -
.f
ie comrooTefTirtB and duiingwd behaviour, which """I; ventrabiU n.wcna man distinguished for
;ea-on that prectOU lent to . apixnntin. . them for life. Such, hU g,ea(, ,dherance ju democ ratic doc- il
wolloction which two id Mr. B. is my reinambrance of the j Wheo he -was President of the
. . ... t . '1'U ..ni...,i j.r Ihoan timuj war ill " ...
"'Id.-... l. ldlil kaw'swaiarA kiai tuarllni ti.iln 1 hrmrinAHa. Thlal tarftal A IlimifUslfal rllflaa
try, there aiust be kiodled a geoerou and hew the fact, lne doenne ol atate . he It wa on that occasion nentary ou the rest ol his remark. No
' . ... ... . .. I .L.. ..J .Ylli. rnurwhl nnivpf nl i hi, I O . ..... 1
4 the following language : I wonder that na Daa gpoKco amparaRingry
.1.. ...nul .C n l,,r. . 1,'. I h.wa I .l 1K0 Rlnlaa. urhMI M nffllMrM tlll'ltl t
Wt'raav Durchase pence by rohiinud Mr. B.. that the spirit of com- leader ofthal party. 1 uey did not, how- , , , Government ia not to b? trenr: Rdinan jirovinee. Tbiaiudiciently sc."
a surrender of right, or exhibit to the and conciliation ia the strongest ever, succeed in carrying tneir "-rgca thened hy lhe awumptiMI af doubtful pow- counted Pr the cdno!ilatory principles of, v 4
present times, and to late posterity, an aw DM1(j nicn Dll,j, u together, ana it istnai " " - - ' er,outBy a wise ana energetic execution the gentleman iron bw Jersey. v .ffftaj.w;;
ful lasson in theconfliet to prevent it. It lia wtiH unite us, and not tlie strong arm characterize the whole ol that party aa en- lfito-e whio(, aM inClestible (the forH Rome was alwayi readv to extend justic v i ,
become a sacred duty we owe to our com- rmiltarj newer,. .,..,,,,.,.,.. ----- mer never tail to produce suspicion ana to tier province., ." nenever me ia.uea v
moniltry.-toM.T'teT'"' : thegehtleman from New Jerseyo the the aentiment of some of it leader. ji(4lruat whilst the latter inspires respect of a province came before her sci,te,h . '
the one hand, and rathness on the other. courM rfhi, remark, .aid that the Consti Nor did he intend to impugn the motive coufidence. did not fear to do them jurtice.; ! We maf - - ,
ihcuuoiwiiu,, i. v . ... ... .,.:. ,.f iKa unnlHinen. thoUilh he doubled ... . . n l. :'.l..c..i....U
In either case we snail iumiu ... tu;,n wat raiineu dv toe peopis, mai u w a - -- . MRa, u if, however, alter a lair experiment, I"" uews'j 7'-6 rVv--i-
f.v,hMirv:arulfutuiolime must ..judee :Ubmitted to the States aerel from cun-iiwtt hy were m-" General love"rti-louW not fear to . j!. JjS:tX
of our wisdom, oour weakness. A.e.itveniei,ce, and that the people had clothed 1 node a thoae ic ,,; net .hall be found incompotont to the at-1 'Iijealieian from Nf. lBry-4iad
.'!...... . ki lA.nninTiire .: .i...:. . ..i... .,i,:.v. i i rmnu. ina oi mo incimu i .r -. ...
! i i : jiuj.. o.ii, t terence. in wmiwi j .. ivmoniunub amm wm.-n - - imaionum.
?ly intended I U1 todlled to ' h -be in the highest degre ZJtpnnr ofcentri petal force, I agree, State wvereigntie, wa abh.yrent to the o h(
VOJ.
no
t
lata nt.inn
. , . .....
h'teu under the picture, he who runs impon..i.
y easily reaa. n is me proicr wBj
fwtthng thi question t, What curse is
likelv to lend to a nenceaiite aujun.
ol it 1 This is the question before us.
..... . m.:c-. it-Mmtr-vi
.sonmtttee'Atiluv 'jauicrary musi
him. if, notwithstanding the high
Nict he entertained fot their talent, he
Auuld wholly dissent from the specific
rmedv iliich thev Drooose. He did not
V .11
f t that the biil4y llwm present
r Jennie, umt calculated to 4arrv out
, . i i
But it was
I . tf f ViiW Pun. I .i dX 1 iln..nwianl iV'ittt ilo niiMPei
I jtTi ihiii rTiiniiTojMHinir v mif T iiryiiTvlTTrTii ii ; i "rii ir h n " ' i i"11 '
HIL I awt-"- m . I .
, wen Known rT r f ... u.,mi ior w.ch. Was ,d he would not strike a sister State, Imt
- laawajj swill i ill I m vimumiv... - j . .,
. V.I'"'Ilf- ... .ir ,., instituted, the Constitution happily lurnislt- would re'ire to the wall. lie,, Mr. B..td.r,-t
l i i e 1 ...... I . . . . . KnimMlRU-v .1 Id uouuo iu w-ii-f..... i , - , . ..... I .... - i. L.' I. . I : i r v
... , . 1 . . -i a ..... ,i ik.a tffeat etperiineiu uu, .. i nrin up me jrreai ginamu wii" r i ,l. esthe meanaiur remeuyinff me evu oy a-1 niirea mu pnucivio . ic piihij...u-
r "7,"'B7l"u"uiD " .vycrt to estahUh rational lioerty- wer. The establishment ot this aoc- awm. j - - - - " J'"r, . ,u0ud,ridnls and I have no doubt that, in accorded with what be knew orth" vrre "i
- ?jS?,UU,,0S;- nUOt T TTme lUS oftta times give, birth tojeal- Ue utteriy annihilates the Constitution, m'ZhTuZ event oran appeal to the patriotism worth of the ienlteman ,.Vr ;r...v.;V
ntnilly pHC.lic i-s rente. . u erwovon .in our tl wa, pomHed by the m-.4enl.ght they said. W me f" aud good seuse of the coutmuniiy, it will But When the genlkman went Ob to r.
He iH-lievcd thai tin itsconsequeu f0 nknm of W. If that doctrine own worst eneuwe. imf --... - f
yi: , JO. woo-d b-v attended with jlotence, ht, rf , mankind. J d J.,,. cons,i,maUl T,?oriS "wtat wSe result of thai lhe s ahould be execu.4 Mlxll-
i. Jprlup. lead to civil war. Ho cihjcc,- foctw rCTne, -fTha th Cwtuti. should bo not eubscrtie to hat pntip,,lutjrbo V1 J',
l&ttl SWvcn liberty Usolf. SLj the re-jorlty ofthe people. The fJW,. tteofl S ! W!t conilal i-g eul ,,
by force of any attempt to ee- mfimi-P,e(iWlti the federal svtem, the ceremony of ubmitra the instrument for to self government, taat tiy were wuy ; , .he miiitary power, in bringing 4Maen, fc.to . ; ;
"tf. I 6 fS,H,,b Cr!ft b reftfr- S4rSSS With their inherent hTtifieation ofthe States wa. an idle hie to ' JSnSfder. S? he lllic( with r T -
;B,!bt!i& revenue. To that provision SS.ite isjver , prorttJ mockrv, (t tlie powers granted by the Cori begun, and ctrijJW that beautilut the Z" Vbrk fl4-W5iriM- cmtryWoTi,tne blood of ber clifldreo? X
Hf mly objected, lt there were some ntiJem- were iSgra.d by theW vtr Ifthatwa. the meaning of tho dimity otTt KZ
.d4 n.HrmarrMf 'ssertt. H any ;neniS . :., fril,ners, wh ch may W0iJdiiJa4ltaJst!ty.ld, Ihatraneac- crvpnnctolo 'Xr. "rTwWA thev hareWwavi mainlained. deliver tiim from sucH diijiiity.' . He eon- - . . , . '
V leah twlietK fiZl. IWroi .hat thedigui-y and the h of;
,cA Mfcr&l:TrTS S Th in'. Government like sntutron, ' constituting an oterVh.lm.ftff to all powers J htii he would also ouote fi5L'.-4 Whal was it the country would ; .beat promoted and ,?
t! ;hVm,,ttWwb?dl .wf.TteSa'rhere there are majority of tho-peoplo y bU jitill North ZnAr which eicited the . first oontromsy he- estaWi.hedJiy dg hUce .and carrying -
C fc1 , r tanSe General Govern- Carolina remsed , to rat.fI;.t,.,ldoM.d fff2 ThemsS t ween State Md. the. IT. 8.0 conflict outpeacefo .nd:etncteI,tty;the;pr
a a' vi w iw iirrnn it una mm. wnn Twinvi j . . Ai i. v j a m ai.ata iaai vn jibivcib imv i aa as iniiv - i. a a l rL. a ... .a . r . iv i ma . wltsv. aaf na -jf-
rtwai. It II TirMlft llUHJtT rviiii - V . . a . a J. 1 -.kU IkMatonod In tariAflf rillfl AR ineiDWIO UWe.ulwiiuipni-. iwiw' nwut'. -w.f r . v..
- - . m m. . a .. I I . 1 al. ... .-1. S . h A ltlI. TIMUin . SIB llHIKr I BV' I Bit-. IB
fr hich no emergency justified us in meot, and rights reserved to the Ma
W-;. . ... b 'L ... I ffom the tjioerfecti
mm: on. wnicn constituie-i n miw.-. -- . , .
..t.ir r.4n hfl Un'imaTe. so to dotine ttio timiis oi t -
i;nme,,and without whih free yi that difficult aho
the diietrine, t1v.it mi'ifarv authori- lamented that no provision, i-
'ection of
trine
rofid. their, sancuon tatt. in "TT 'rbe .UotrttrTond which was designated the wth
of the Senate W - Ta,,,,, it,, re;CT f Hirmr bvlhe -epum.cat patty, of which we have heard so n , V f
eorreeCNotth CoMa w, t this W 13 welMeierved- to. lie .baracleVized, would cli all the glory ; of Imptial
anii i w . - . .. .. , ...... .j vj;: u. l Rnlne. ami r.rtiuoiril Mtve. wnicn was .
Born aim kuuiui t,ii - .' :' --'; ;, ".
..!. ijt BaaidTnnrp in inn ijU'.Miiuin'u
8TIUIJ-V.-.V ------ - s,. rfjsji v:. ftW,.-uai mHiHith uat t no rtierrea roxne
laws. OiilUe Rhode Ila01 ji eumywj -'" v" " j .. whicb7w Jmirowff th- ewer -of tramp- nothing to the g.orj ra just; equal, am ,-:Lw..
itiontothe..
i .-.i mep i ri t . enfmf til'
'niciarv .wn)l c
..... . ,
9W8ndpirit if ourViuwtutiQ
;: 5 ..t '
5
fir;
i i ;
i