X mmmn It 1V -., iiti w.i'JtM ofiiKvj'ljj which fnl no respniae In the heart ol the citien, mil Uch will be evaded with little remorse. ' , J)r, Chainnng, : ' t Jn!l KV.VUKUA KAMStl'ltV, nonAN'COUNTVf.N. C.....MONUA JLLV . VOL XIV o:.m;; t I f u i a. I I at k . . 4 f 1 U K - a ' .1 it it X. 1 U ike ".I id Mhe .'ortl hi. 1M 77.7M. -a-ji '. l'r' r . a."' T ft IZt'T rf-f ... l f..lV .,' f ' ' 04 j i N fir ( 'i '. r" t, j ,ff J A. , u , ', i I - mt. 1. 'i'r- 1 1. J I, ill IW oHlo ( I l,"i lnl !-n tuti. alt iiM it fnl il ki:! JlH 'i"l "" I" I -I"! I., llfl l M I J ,. it iImi. 9cr i if ilutr iiii ill Hf mift Wl u-i ii r fftilii l' j, , , rw4i I ii ihbl tl. in' i ti W Irll1 " l trttr--"'' hh' ll" f- ! I" I.S" i o , j -4 lU- rminln 'I 'h'' !mi mi i4 ir 1 J.mr f t4 ifckl lU iIJ t4 - l7 Iiu il tli MM 'f ll'" I"' " tenliMll lir rtiriili rffclrtt'S i f !$ W S-uM mirfff it H" H : j'jjTI ;..l )( M . K ill.l I l-XI i fMlf ) t n.iulir I, il 'i 4 n' lii jUrf I fia u l utU Klr! i.kLl tr M t I lhC1ll J I ,!t;ri.Jrwi. I sif r I 'inFlraIrd a l niiiv l'.,,ir if ny lKin,Mifll a Hiij"fiH I Itic f mh-, a-i'ltipv win im;nl iM' li in'iu- y 4 lif if I'l ( .irii'il , ! IH'I rtillllHil-ll f iiT.lr-. I linr at.f Pr Im'- ; ! ri-rf uurl'Mi. TlK nr" mi et, !? which ruri IhrpM'int'viinJ hdM 'j, i ' ii-iu i4im tyyi'ntn, niii-l(ioi imhI in UiilnnU')7r U iiuV?iti4'if hiWr Ltit ua umjfri r hh.m k fn liiiiJ(i4i ; . it ;,) iny sjurit nu'J georujdiciil diri 4mmun uf ihtsinjrtroui inlluwrc aiiumfl ' t r'l Mlwrvo.- (uvi (xiioin-l ' r.trt l uim luMi, in iie j uri ulMvrih Camif ki, has iiKin; i"lit in its CMincil.tlnii7 trrni rihrr;rHfimTttorrr tf irt rXr. riuil l!ie M'iiilrCI cmn I wy tlm-rof 15 l rulo nvt:r thorn; ai.d iSnlliii-v of '.'U founder, do lint CDlitribulf n4t-lfir -mf)'i- ftim ftqiml l clt V'i'ettTrtd: 15 V :rtitlrv'dtfi1giiu' owl- ii' far ir.ifw,njiin (ifTtK fust of ii-ii' iu .mil rcHiugthc i-chr.lii uhich llirv jiniiiiiilnati1 fcf liw iiivrniniPiil' "Vf fitl'."' Tlial lliiij, (imi'i'i rt.i'l I ix Istn lliinU of tii Y ii! iho JSuif tr. Tlmt ilit" M i))lj ar! Udl by tlinsr lnm tlioy ciinnol mil to .iferiini fur tlirir r iliicti Tlmt nw; r lw of them py the tnvps tt hinh another ilfi u. And i.ow let mo a.k ymi, W y v tin tin o things M'riiulri' In U' mi ' 1 call frananswfr. 'l'lu w hic tmtcvila which tf,', iini the lmr( iixsirtioti of liny one .kuuf i4fmtt, - 'I'lH'y tcl tire httrt If W'j.2etiHi of iarty ismliusinmn. 'I'liv IffsnU r Irutlig, siHcr jiiibli! ul the clfan'i Y"f, ami mndo pliu to the humlili't ca. lily. I .vt im therefore rnprnuhfl en- J'ury, ii v nr they allowed to continue? lllie oppoMers of Refirri'i or,t nmnftillv. indnk nut tlio real 'rulh.llioy must toll thitt they can be -inniiitxiiH'd for no K&4iutpixJhttjMu of a nua.irriv ntnl't .ci,.lu ue a denial of r. a IA.Umi IT l tlK people. HurdnCtfc Uitu is Iiim Uvu w fiiint thni l thai tlu so kviU evUk,!, bill they have. "1m(iii In iiie rease in tlicir Inajjiiiltidfe un- tlmrmter will deny iheir exisli.'iico. Yet ,1v ' 1 1 r i Spilt ii' f i 'I? t"s TifW e "(iijilolfave'iiK VnnifK n'tiid a . remedy, 'fhefy who frn'iei.t amajurity, 'huve ' profwswl thatj tnr t'p (fircction of lawful authority, the IVri- miht htJTfiiir"d tfl Vot6 " for iixmitxt it Contention, and that xucli n nf (i-er,iii's mi uthr be convened if a f j'Tity uf Iho people Toted lor it ; but ' im.i bi-rh rcjuctecl. i hoy have at '-r litni-M suhiiiitKsl the pna "of calli: ' itivriifi hi. t. lui II, I i,. k : J Miirn pan. -rit our l onstitiftfon "Twit. v.They linve P'K'inrntt (em- V ,1 "Si. M; I.1 aa-ji f-H I Urn UtUa(i' v y J Lit X faia n, la.-aa.rt.a4 . aat a fa. 1 i ai;s.,ra lata tat j.M.lfl ahtrh rt ,(t.a,l1, ,( , . it 4 i f trf tut,, , r, ,,, ,. iw i'lflftt t!tflll l lKa n i I "' I r n f'r t, a Mi oat f 4iri.il i in m , , if.e.il I'H I I,M llpr.h. l ifti q la aulli i' ul ll.l lirifl .1" l,i g.mmi fia4a I.V IV I al.ail r- a it .4iTf .Uinil, Ull llir ( t,, i j. t a4i fi.f u M 'I); '' turn a I. i t,ji l -ti Ii- 1. t I. f f-l-r. l, ! !fl i lP Mi It '- . ". ,n .'ffc t fl!,! a llril V h 1.- . I ii-g.t ( ii rirrL- hilars I f '.I ,u '.,1. ii.iii. nl a MJ r.i. i .i, n . I M ii ,!( , ,, ,,, li.il' . I,,j( f,.- mim ra'liii I'1' I r -if hf id, I ( ii- ittul lit i m e f- ii,...t.i win. M::t: M'l. .'. I rl h.r in Ui in i. i . f ,. -i.U'i 41 la J. maii-li it I v r ii. , r v - f jiuIk-a I.I A lire (nt i-r ft " I' r-'Ji'tullSn l. ii t , Uil lit . I. in' t i.l 1 1,- ,,(., ,,(" il. ,r li( '. i :;n i u hm i;i.v i:-. a f.,.f ,i..,u..i ii ,.11 u i.i. r i .ii, ni,.-,. ii nitiK'-l I if a ! Hi lni-, ti. , iu I iii-t iiu '2li' I ! tmV lii:!i i4uHticl I y -Hil.!.. "(i."M-ti all i,i f Cik .1J. .riiti II im 4 l.mU lo tite-t ItiiUm rr-tMlnl iH op irn lj"l uli :l to, in.l.l tin- pf, niMciHK ij'thetr iVi nimciit wf thrr.irriM f, li-n llwklslf .'..frf.i Ji-nVe irf 'a r- liaiiMi.i, .M I !. r 'in 1'MMi' n lnil.e !' i!r,it ( -J.it It.,-;, " liifi! 'iali rr ! ul l in' 1 1. 4. j i I f Hie a-iii,;-, 1 1 II h tmii'il i, !;.' I le li-1 f ji A-'ii.h i -I N'.rih III- ' i 1 ul.l li.it In tie e. i,, :n-fl In I., , ' I 1 1 t lii -..(i ; m h I pi raftering i" I-: .-.re tu id i m; r biiiioT bi iiz iii'!.-ii in I f I nn tKi. tlun in die ii nnr iiiit if it kinnrrh. ltii h"' re .win Ut fil, Hint when I av.t i,f" daiii r, n On, sl.ili ," 1 .'in I'ltwllv niHui'.ili to h think- m? M 4mrfarf ami rtru wwr" W wtiMfr lute c .i.iiiui:i.ii4 HilleKil anhng A UuJ; ap may liiitc iliiiiiji'roiM etprriineotlt iiixmi wrlitwrty otid ujvm ,th pernanciicy tf n-jrirm inTiimiorn inintf cotirwry, wirn Kit tlm Iwrukinj of iHitlca, fr Unngling-, urMncin; ovrT't; . Tjie.'Btt tKTli: uf "Ajuil Biitllii ij'j'jti'iittof fwer liutyMmat iis tu wii',nt,ij jti-lipe aoJ ln. nv I'tU'.i Uiitit llifl a,e.cf Imwi if il r "jvf.ple aWlho vctMiil Irinn t!i Sii-mti lu;y wilHieiiiiluccd IJasr their claiinji hv a wit, tut . tJoriiui; Hi .tuatetifs and its p.itvt-n' llirf cl!ifrotna maJmtuofthcvrA- llc. . A rv i you rvnily to provii iULjwcUa rour-wio4n-nnt'i't'W'iviiiil 'Aro yw (uep:ired to Juiiioailrute that purh a . U p UHiuIti Ik) o!u.ixiuui lu th pfniwj.iVt f .mt (i .,-rmiieiit ? A re i he minority of North l'iir.i!iiiu Uind In I lit coiin'quencM of that i-oursc iiit'iwhlL'h tliey we forcing the m.l 1U m k mi e(wminHi irteo. inn my .1 : ' , . . I TL . ' . ' ' 1 eriiliieilU uf lliu country Imvn lind tn.iU e slita tci.t applied lu their pfrinaiicm y ami comtwl him to dniiiniiil the KiiirciHii r by atnhiuty. it haadaiigcra which 1 ntteO niiit, would it he a coodaiicwer fiom n Hull) iml depict to jui, and w hich 1 heartily ful agent ? " I will ive nothing thoiiii it ileprocnte. But reimiiilK'r that n people be jiM, becuie you have dared to t me who have been long denied their rights, I kimw I might ultinnmly be f.vreeil todoii'" who havo utisiUTespfnllv made all the pr, It a uianbas come into possession of a not h mmiiU tlmt are coiimsient with the practice j er's property by nccjdent.'in a time of coin and theory 'f liw tiovttrnmei.u in this I mou danger, can ha honestly withhold it country, are not the .most prudent calcula- from the true ownor, upon ".he pretence lots of :.tiMti)(HiH'a w hen thev are -cott- that he is justified, because, the wvnnr will lending ln- that whifh they have inherit 1 not go on lifs kiit:n and humbly ucaeech ed in comiiMii with their brethreru.. hut winch thov h re vet denied theciijitjmcnt of -KQlfAI. RJi.lITj. - i - Th(r friends of Reform have nn-.v tyken whai we huow to be the I jst step belnre they reach that pcriloiiH lnii,h' wliich 1 have hinted at. If thev i'ail here, I hey MIT, or sesort to the csert-.ise of Ihe hi- tan dnnsreroiis privilege of OIlltilN'AT IMG 4 CiHiveiitiou uuMm.tlwuisclvM by. ill'! vote5 of a majoiiiy. What then, is the psrt of w is loin and of patriotism ? 'They mure than 2") years : iis-rheir evil laW''a'';''''tht'y'"'hnTe: inands. Now, they have tunic with coo fiileiice to tin: PiXM'LE, and invoked their attention to the- things. Thev have up peah-d from the SRV VTS ol tl-.n It public to the SOVEUEItiNS o tlm State, amino 111 mi .041 feci indnf "rent lo'thd an swo'r that tliU iiiH!iil shall find, for none can be iiinutci osiied in its consequoiio9. The reauU ought not to prove, that a large- ion of Nnrlli Carolina are prepara;! t i maiuiaio .no may .o,,, ,.a,. ern. xwir mseiry oukiii iiui' ici-um lliat they, vhoVe fathefa yveronjH defy 1'ioiince thir"con!ik'nce in the capacity nnJ irtua of the people, ami their allegiance right of self government orj that -oian" tba ancient boast of otir frco - v-xhjit-" every: jneqiwliiy pay J Pteif evils msy lie curM action of the publie wilf." III thta rtpeat ia'irWteil'iaTjierti,- fir : newsi,aierif w Tth-'aiFa Vovcrii- 'JHyr - 'pUdl fml,,, f.tl.fi,! , -pfvtin "M "y'A'ftr 111. II I, 0 ,fjfrf , ,Nf,, Cr4iliati.il) In im, err ami f c if!i-. t fpr rih'4 at out ftni'rp kn rfri f Mihn . ; M( one, M h, liy ,m, 1,11,1, ! UlUII f.H ntt, tr i. ,,)... ,4 lMjr I w,., ra ' l"f", Uit I dire n tfif m If U'ipip, that tin, nt y mil a.M f kiiIi. lint. I I u Jo in-l.ii , u'fl mrrt the p-n, ..lii'.ily t4 mi , no i til, in ijnrtlv i-l'liie (i.lw (,. rriial-.iiH'l to .lllilv' tl,p 'llil(i!ra nf ln if e.-trriiin-lit, , hwi .i r-tiPti.'iin aaii.i llill In i-, laay 1-4 (win ill Hlirr luting tli. ilnl l Mti r It IT .ilia I -Hill,;, mi Mjlml (,nie ill Ida ti-rt i-rn-ix nl. ami iln-y Kijli.i.t (..ill ul f. ta of ilnfij;'l win ii fie v Ii.iV" oikp rr. loir I mi in "t.li u, I. ,fp !i,iii hi,, r of lailfi lut" I lli-iifil l in'i- UJMlll IM' inn .1 I' t jll-11 ol Una lilij iriM , ''Hot . ea. iii. I'.f lin y ha- I Dm r; ht ami lint ymirrr Ui UU' 1 1 A J Da I out i-iii HMi iin-l n .In iIh-iiim U I gr.-atfv ih cumil, if it a mil iplijipi .i prpaa tin e ii hji- m lh- a'li iilinii of !if i- opli- i.i r1 ,i ii (. otici.l u ji iM-li in Kileigh by ihe n-pteariitnn. a o l,..e ho have ,'p n loii' fluleij fimii a fuir aliaru in thr n iriiiKK-nl of tie Sule, I may indeed he mcliikpii, fur I r.oinol pjm' ili re culhtdrti, Iml I lone r',tnf,a Id dm. h una ai,i lint the iJoigil w.i n it turned ihiiu li.4i, Int. nu IPhiI,I,c ait"iiiiiii to.ni aflrr ii Ueui'iH' i huh Ii I'nroi-'d by tin; 1'ic.ii. ie-uti:it I'Jcti in. Th iof ii.ilit.-i of .mr roirw-iit id. mi r u- iniM'li jjrealer iIihii Dirt . ru n that day Ihe lem n tq f.iiii n ii"t iiuich rfliM'-r IlifoiiCeaiioin huh arr nu lf:rfd ure inorj Mitral; r,Hitjin oily, r tu-ol t accede to lliein mil Ui inur Ii inure I'lll-iHite. Hence too, ll.ff majority an; le-4 hkelr I' niihniit "m any fcfunl to do Hit ei j-iain c a:d the nun mil y will I e Iim cm-11-w.l.lr, fir micIi a r.airaw. r or one, , ri men teu imatj llu iga tut srttk ii an I in niy U(1g.i.etit, fboHcrer Ii aiaat Jii-i iMirii-no may b ) i hat mat) ta Mind lhe (.ym rT lina, a wo! I na nrli)f irriit to tint d"iiAiid of the inawt ordin.irj h" will, any longer withhold hm aaMotit to n. just com pmtntae of thiaapitnting qrir.gtuirr. ," J know that there aro ai-oio auionjyour to a attruiii tUie.it .ua! vr M. ciuutiu IUhcm W hat foroolh,l'a;.i liiia ax-.rih- btcr eTpect toahjntt tue-into hj terms f So my gooJiu'.itiy Lto an puch I cck not any thinjr of ttMraort. - Hut t how who wha are .ant .too., protd - ta tn n, wi wooli taicmhcrtiew f the.priTtwt.J5f r( JfetaoftrrthhuiditiJaU aJutUuJ right -wh flrHtaiiMjiM'U and ih4 political coxcunlw, way liud, lihiuk.ia tlii'x: lliuii juIjJ' lr reilerttiitfftmt nrgttnirttls to convince lliitin. Ki si n-isurrd' they htj not in. an: for yon my liljjf: niottlorl frientfc . ; If an acnt wPtc called . fi. .10 jireouat and aurreuder hi jiriw-er t)f. Attoniey, kiid he refused if llnn the Vain pretext fhal his iiraaiiMl liad accoinmimvd hia Jian.uid with ! luiu to restore it 7 Shall he pray tor it 'seventy times seven, and will not seven tiuius linger inn pn 10 m 111s n-iguoor 1 Alas how long n ust it b true, lliat men will perpetrate' injiiMicn in their political relations, w hich they wolll 1 scorn to prac Use in the private relations of life If a rartnei$ii!j ,ih . ' . i ;.i ...... ,1. l!n colli iiiiianci: i-jr 00 ve.ins io inu-is in . ihe partnorstflo iiot furnish funds sullk'ieut I ! . cotrrj. fluid are yearly sinking their capital 111 '.0-1 iVaymg-these exponsea waill-rt trenw- j lered iu-st in that two-thii'ds, fi refuse the entreaties of their coparliiers h cOnsoid o diuwiaii -iMiOsJpeiises vml ref .rm their ar-1 tieles accordingly. The answer w '."" plain, and who is so blind as n t to ohrve I n,p;ir.itlel to tins, in tho It .vernmei.t 111 111 t'OXCMllia I we 1. w .' .some of the partners, whosn ub-tance t let out bv this ruin mis coiwrtntrsliip, 00 not c implain, and yet .! es that, m any way tastily the iiid.etimi of tliia injury upon v .1. ,1 1:.... 1 11... .1 ....... I. a ..,,1 tl. ,t those wn.i do .. . . . .... 1 1 ..... 1 Jncomiil.il! 01 I" 'a iovJ hcoooi of party, stinnilatcd by jialoify and 0 love - . . . .. ,,.,,4 1-J and c m- cience aaswer the enqutry. "'i'ajyirlakee of i$tnner'-TM ha bits of our tjoVerninant, (says 'tr. JKfitiS 8QX, io a letter to Cob C.R8ts:tojj,) be inrf the opinion of the pe iple.tho very first tashiMildlieia keen that light; and wCr it left to me to decide Whetiier we sll'itild hate government- without news ''me!it, i sn um not, iicsiw'.ft a u"'"c u HtW'taUnf.' 4 V Kj()-i nON' "TPjTiXr TlriiTiillrltliilionM p 170"'. " No. III. TO TIIOMVS ItlTCflli;, r.8i, (rollLtli.J t nm rvw ti pruvn to joij, Hir, tbnt nub !il,iii--n tlie mi'y uhhIi' in mIik Ii the tianrp-iliotia .f :h I'l ih tal liiivetntuetii nmy he reit' tl by lh" Siai", in accur iliittc Hifh Ihn puiM'iph a of our rev-tu-tt-.n tif 17!)-. Paring n yai tiMiy coit-anli-r i!iim nii rpnae, I Ho not enter upon ll Wilt any fi-nr, ultliou;'h I approach with out fliHiriali of I, iini. la, ornnv oilier par a le. 1 am a pi tin, pnu lirnl iiiiiii, nod ite ire In atiit.' n'V opiniona in a manner hu h other iiUni, iirnclicat men mil tin. leralmid. ll am Ii ini-n are not (lie oriiu wridt A' the cituitrv , tin v are at b-.i-t it u ii ii i li aim fcu,inl. ami tl:e very x:-' i . Land ten iM-'oide p l-iii .i eiijaicily all rcooniiig iiM.t; jxi liln-.il aiil-j. rlt on-jlil to lie adilreae,d. I lie ymi to la nr in mind the principle which lime already Ut'ti Klated aa ihv'aei hp fr'Hn Iho reaolutoma of 111)". 1'i-r baw iair li- C'Hirw' ,, iro;i.eiling will bo In t lie tUnn in d tail, a;id we wh' tliCr nullification d'rf-a or duts nut Confirm to firry one of liieto. I. Tl " r a.'luiiors aaaert that there is irie to,l. inliin ihe (.'oualilulioii by wl'irh the u-airrmtiuna nf the FcderaHiov errtmerit may Int rrimluJ by the JSlalea, Now, it i Iniu thai niillinrutiim is denied to bn a CoJitilulioiiuJ icuiedy ; but the ntlthtVr jfrt th it it it rorisiitiitiiirml ; an I I tpetitmn the point ouly to ahnw that thny d i D"t jiiftntt li htcrl uny oxlra -ca. 'IUu'ioiimI or ii'i.'hiti'iiiary remedy ; uml Ui.it, ao far, at J alJ, they ar within ihe r-'hitt of 1 7 :-!- H hetiicr th;tr rem edy iarototttirioii.il or iM't, MipjMisiiig ihe prtnetp'r of ihp rra.i,t i ma to be ao, miiM ep"tHl mi iomermrv with th"e prtrt. ciplea in the anbx ipc nt prop'iMliu.i.s. SV e rtmiatk, ihmeli.re, Ilia', Q. 'I'liH reinedv lintst he rich ns t.i ' orrfnt ihe progress nf lh" i nl." Now. . . i i . , . ., .' ,w (.11)lt(r , , L,.ur i(( nii,f mllllt lie jilciiseii i i OMir in nuuo, nun nullilic lion d-ie-i nal ir.aci'd up i-i any unmHiiri nr. hut Ukki tlie riiil 1. 1 a f?iale lo Jf rlurf ihut o wiro'tit'ttifitmat law realty it to, end lop fuse olmluine lo il for Uutt rriMov ..Jkbejou ti bear tiiu duitiiicuim in niiaL Jf nuiliiicaiion nripofer-ny thin nyee'rir le-fihau thhj I am it.i Wuf Nuw, Sir, nut tin 1 iara of a Slate (io deeidn on tie nstitiiuf immhty of an act of ht'iori" of 17tWf -ftay,- haa not Virirua iTii) a, if 11 1111 1 m-iliii-iii laws, and ami in regaul JijilTiCMrvci'y'tiiiirUvv-H llieuueKcaT U'e nit mtVt llial ieH is lite inn.- Ami was not resistance to such nuConsliiutloii ij Imv di.sliiietlv cuiteiiipl.ited in the -resolutions rf I'tU! I have already shown .Ihut it wa and if any farther proof is iiet-c.tr, it will b! found., 111 ill a biiiiduucc, k- ilt iiddiess to tIio -M!opbi which accoin;,aiiie;f thoHO r'"diiti... It- apjiears, then, 'that 1h! liftitvii'lt. pai . w iiieti nulb licat ion procicils, are (01 the abstract) in strict eimfortnitv wrttlt I'ttes' of the res-thttioitsdf tf4rV--Ri tiWe- nilH4ptr,'t''l,tHt- ted, must by limned M pialitied ky the object 111 view. VVo are, then, to impure wuether iiullili:alion dia's, or doea not, "arrest the progress o the evil.'' The evil is tlio cxurcisaof an uuinij power: n'Jlhfio iiioii declares that the uui jod S(ter shall no longer !e obeyed. Is not thm the beM ol all possible niodes.-if nnt the nao mode, in winch it coo be ' arres ted l'ertittps it is -net trx great n ferine incut to khv, that the "arrest" here Cm templated, is of the t.vi p-ition only, and of 8 utbrjtittf p,)(rfr. 4ju Mm words, it is not designed to put down tin IVdi'ml (ioverniiieni nor emhai rass nor impede its legitimate Oieration; but si 111 .K to prevent it from exercising a power I" which does notlielotig to it. Hence, no ' .. I , , . in iv measures which miiv siiii- m, ,1(S cieoo f that Government to (-,,.,,H. llstlti,oii tnti.-t all go 0.1 ns be- wMm ju , (1, ii(nji lliymj ,e stltlltio I tn'ist be " arretted, " Now, this is precisely and peculiarly the eilcct of .,h,i; , n -ri t .iir Am J; "'i ' ll is' .IIS very gr.Mmd tint voil"aud others Hw, 'hyth).v ussailod that doctrine. V ai sav- thai it is alwur.I to iireluud that a fJtalo ranba .1 the Latoti and out rofthe I;tiim at..l!ie same time; and t'.mt it is m'Mistroiw in a .State to cimtoiid for all the advantages of the Union, as to curtain law?, while she refuses to submit "to the buriiH!iis'i;uposed by oilier laws. Nollim iFTiature Citn be more perloctlv self-vi- d;m tfriTn""tftt this.- It " TTfiot wrprishl" finifii 'ilia s4wwl-JafekHVnie4iurtt-ut intellect and information should bo deceiv ed bv such a suierliaial view of the aiib- j'et but we had a rjglit to exjtect better tT.1iTirf7tiV ieteraif m politics, lite yoi'if self, henieniber, Sir, thai a law beyond the Constiiuiion it no laic at all, and here is no right any where to enforce if. -A $jite which rcIisea lo subrnit to siicfj 4 pretended . law, is strictly within the Un; ioo-lfcause she am ntrxtt oveAieuce to lepmtimlX"'X''U'atWirV3i lay' tl.qf Ktin ,l refosea to aiilunit to tm Knr. eus iaipse by any uw which i ior t. r i.T.i T1er. tlipn, yn'i have a wa-y ii. iaiaj,, i(;iJJ-a(ailua a nTaWninara Win -trai - n fun: i iiinliiif iiIcmi. ii accurn to the Stilts tlm rigid fi remain in th" ('niorti and to enjoy up, )f advantage which the Coiiililntioo and lnA-a can ul!-rd xubniit ting, at the aatne time, to all which that 'onlilttit"n and law r!hlfnlly njoitt) while it "arrmtii the progiciV'ijf usurped x,wer, by ileslroying ihh oltligatloti tif every pretended law ahirh the OtrtiHtity (ion due not aulhor'ue, and v which, lliprr forc, in mit law. II tliii i not the meaning l I'm reaiitiitiutiH of 17!H, I have much iiiHiiiiilcrliKi! them, ll ia precise ly iimmi tint (Miiut tlmt llii' puM.c mind ol Virginia hua la en most ntrangtlv minhd by lint iiiilh'irily of the Pi'i'MiIcnTa tinnic, and tht! "peci"tiHes. of yiHir paruirrndi'". Yiill owe I hit M'0ile H he.ny tlelit f ri paialMin, winch I hone yon will lie to - 'i. 'J'liia b'atU ii. to ,ilie miimiimI ohject ol the resolutions ol li!), ttimn H "to niiiinaiu within (lie limits of the ropeclive MiUes, ti e ai thoriliea, rej'ius, rial lilier ties Bjipi ftaiinii'g to the,-!,." I ltive al ready sh-iwn, in in v n eoiid "iter, that ihrse uiiilior,ties, ri'litf, and LlaTties, ale not in- rcly tlins- which U-lopg to ev- erv fovereigii Slufe, and which 11 my be enjoi-d 11a well in a Hta:u of separati ai as 111 league Willi oliii'ta, hut, also, all the ... .ii 1 - . .-, iniihotitic, ngnis- aim niienios wnu-riiue Elates n;e enli'l'-d lo, under the Constiiu- I iml, and a mrm!irx of thr f'n',01. No late, therr Tire, ni l possibly e(f i t this object of the reilut tons of 17IH, li any iris;(ling which rilhit vihl r.iu-x her fi-oid the Union, or u-tuktiulurju.it Hjtu litre in if. -. -- " The remarks oflered ttnder the prcce. litijf h;al, apply with erpml mrce and pro- pf.fty lo 'his. lou' Oiid the 1 lesplint both; aay, that- it r arroganw ttiitl pre- sumption in a irUi'.e to insist on retaining her place and inilui nee 11 t!.o I'niou, wl il" tilu r fuse t fihail! to a part of Its laws. A J. Hilling, ar'aii', tdat this is ieifei-llv In--, re-av-eititig Hint it can not npj! to tlie refa-ai of a Sritr to -oh mtt what is ver law, I h;iv to n--' von hew it i.s possible for a State to " maintain her authorities, rightA, and lilrHlioOrx fR5f-!irifhm'til 0(0 $ftift,onri vstt nirmbrr'vf thr tin ltd jftifra, ti the usurpations' of the I'ed oral (lovcrnment, or by an npjieal to arm's? i iVratr"'yco,"Sir,tii ailijfhtun my under atiiudinj opon tjhi gujij'tctw? If Toritlnot hoT. tne N..riiftjolher niodfl of jiroCi CiJiu-f, t tiilio it lor Viaoli d dial no wi eltiJ niuu At all event, until It ahall be done by aome WW -tl''favimu he commMlmJ to. con ! ' "... l-n. AA' L'r If .I-.1 t"i llliue 1M.II1X prcaein (ieiri f WBIJ.IilP meaning and object of the resolution!) of were'irt tr!nttimtt, 10 resist '.uCirsjfi'piij" U.Mis i lrlm Federat tJiiVurwiie'oi by aooKv mean which, s jhww linu t!nU 4t Hii. r.i7 tlie rril, xh-mlJ irc.n rrr t!te Viiioa unbrol.ot, I 111u.1l If icrimtti:d l, think that nullification, if it does 11M attain these lohjei ts comph tcl, cuiuca inucli inarer to it thi.11 nny otticr pr-icecilmg winch has. yet 4j c .proiv4l J tiioWi -Sir that y.00; od hntnireit s4'rfher , liuve1 ami iha roaolutiuiis uf li'Js have been insuu dcrUui. 1'erha.pa --- li -i trt-4beif to'tf JMmtl?Wr'H?5J. to iMOa-aVIHl 1)1 iftk crs like tne, to he extremely idiuiiaijd.jt is our own construction vf if ulone yyjiivvliX luisforiin.il our principle, let it is raissi. hie that it may hide soinn meaning dcejier t ii & ci wo have been able to penetrate. I pray you to lell us what it is. Op nol content yoursell with the tiii-!oky only, uut let u.i know the precise extent of our rights, and the prciiic'tjjxljMAlk(lt may be coastiluliinttl'it " "rt':Jtccurdins; to tlie rexulutiii.i of T JB. It has not escaped mv attention, that. according to ihosfl ieolulioiis, iho Btato interposition which they coiiteiiiilarr Is not nUihorr. Hl, except m cases ol "ilelib erate, palpalile, and tlangerotis exercise of lowers not granted." It will I obvious, iiowcver, to inteliects bss cli:ar tinin your .1. -.-.. i:l. c..., L'rec, the piiucipb; upon which StutJ rc jsistancH is jusiified, nor even the tnotle in which, it iiwv lie e xc rid. It - merely poui'sTiuTThel for tllrt J" pliralion of the principle. And .il will be sullicic.it hero to rental k, thai, Hccoidinu lo yir own tliwry, wliich in Ibis resn.-ci the errhisirejitilzefivjtiK'lf, ifhethrrlhe munprtion is dchbrriitc, palpdble 4' dun geroiu, or tt. ll tdbuvi, ol wuese, that no objection to nullification etui be derived from tins view ot the subject. I have now, Sir, to presetif to you di lemma, Co.mecteil wilh this iwrt of our im, .iries, and to ask you in what maimer yon pVope tscape its horns r S sith Carolina says tlmt un uncon-flitu trWvl' Wt 13 vo1d,lfrtr sfm f he"Virgffiia 1&iiiIiwiii each State has a right to dScide for itself whether a law ia const i tut ioual or h it, and ao say the ---Virginia Ri-solation i South (.'aroliua, in the exetc:seor this -iglit,1ias dtlared that tlio tantrfaws KJR Uuconati tutional.and so sjiy the Virginia Resolutions of and , 1829, (have forgone 0 the date;) aniaailr Ritchie, a kt - Tup. How. tlien,raB yot eountenance the I'resi' dent, in mfyctinf the. cti;ttt of South Carolina to the tvrori f'r iSr Iiihmiitinir I ut n.,.,1f L. i. u fn L .1. vtifHononi&epurt tfVii fitkrtt Cop- - A . .I r . ,,- - ' trnmmt 1 Do, Kir, in fiiv to our oppiemdT ' irr 1 w--J&3UfrWrr- ' tit' tii. in. an-f Jiniaaitfafuifc aaiiaisJSiaiiawl piius, anawer Una miuaiioti tou will not anasier it, (Kr laViuiie yntt cAjtsof nawrr it, without eonvjetintr yreirHeif of inconsialency. Tin I wii t ffiot K--for 1 do nol mean to ullow you uny refuge front tliia dilemma, oijtli Carol i It. ia'jilhjr . right in her pF.cee,!uigS (prior iplea np all,) or else ahe w wrongi If blie ml:iiT, tin-it there enii lie no pretence whatevcf for innkfiiif war upon lier ; it ahe ia hhii: hmr dort tint fort uptar ? Il 18 iidniitlej that the other fstu1ts, co purtiea with her to the CoiUitiiutioti, bate iiot aaid ao t t'otigremi alone, ami the rresiilent,or fath er the b'ltlirftl (Jorerifiiirtit, hut tfiid it. ' Do ymi, Sir,atkiioli.ng(, uny aurh rip lit in the Fcileiul (I'ovcrmiieiilT la it not is r fei;t!y dear, tlmt if mii-Ii rijjhl enirfr '! I'ederal (iovi rinneiit is an upH-lhilr tri- bull!, W4llu ftiM'tn TO.UKt'lbli, HI-111B LtsT I1BSOUT, I rOX Till! Cfc.sjsTlTI TIi. NIL 11 v of iriow x aits? Of, what avail is inn right of u Slate to pronounce that an tin, constitutional act ol C'ongresa ia realty t II Lonsrress may overrule lliat decii n la not this, Sir, the very essence of lliat Con v.lidatioti iigaiu-t which the Virginia flea, olutions, MiiUuoii's Report, and your ewit taumttle laliort, have ao long contended T Itia iiiipoKsiiile, then, Irir vou to iiisiily Congress and the Tresidcnt, ea aj,t by as aerlin;, aither fhal (amrta tinty pverruto the tlecismu of Niiilli larohna, upni a (piextimi touching tin ir 7own powera, and, by the sume rule, may overrule tlie deeas 1011 of every oil.-er fctme, and ibus liKMime tfie 'nJi jiith'riidf the ettmi tif their oirit power; or by ar-scrlmp t1inr: itiiy -6Tv" ' riwiaiKioii'iiuii 7 rninrreun VIICOIIS irilllonut trt'r.v Can ymi, iSir, cM-apo this rlifficu'tyj without obid.Qiuia.i'ifiiry primunla.. tbr. vhich mtt have i-tjes.t! tq-crnileiid for ' niirty years r 1 am ec.eei:ingy box ions' !o know 111 what mauiit r Jon w ilj do ittiv'f mvscjf, I ran' discover ln.t one o a blei hop hole o ftreat, and even tlmt I v. ill endeavor to closa upon vou. IrCbcivn this, howctcr, for a Mlececding letter. " No. IV. alOlttS-liart-Jktft vmir nomtion, a proposition vrtipliappf,!tr9 ' ' " to me to pluco you in cousiderubfe ditieU. .....j t 1: ... ., . .. .. ' t lyihM mm in urn ois m 'it irtpetji-ct g 111 sist eney wit !i .bi? clia tiicarw fM escajie, tiirougli b-ar of eoiumij; . 4 . ,: lneir,hir. ti t. au.y Wn:R;ib v'-'i 1 -''.,.'..: couriicV (bte.viiijr'-'fhal - yiinu alreadjt' "-r Jr' deferinined on puvmuW it.f I nnx t d "i tpfwtil.- - - - -1 ' - " ... --"- - I mt- Will -nerb ri ri " tn it 11 . ,--,- Vj ' rr. a 1 1 . . . stttttliotmlrl rut HH-htrbrCwiai Os4 yet it ... ..... .n...T . 1 1 . r . -.. the. President and (Jiui rpena. Ik a which I Imvo alrwidv alluded la aa r,,i. lwWittBrdhVdra oir, ir may lie usotui ur you m knowt,h.-if ar.trcat uiaiiy of iho wno4-.MiA!wiii jWrDTifi?a:t it, rn'r r TCiitrwinrr,TinTii trrPacTis tT'i" -oT; t- f. rll I ; ... j . I Irwillanrteurtifuow t.f-hoWyoii tiiui ' e is no, sort iut rta4iin lor sVouratina 'u e : and Tf I slutuld succeed in this t IT r! , may rtly lipon iOIiat a vitst tmeir v no are now in your ranks will de.it l Vim. I attirm, thcrelorvj that fl e R. i,lu't iir 't).'i it SI ... . 1- r. fo obey that law, vutil thf olheria t shall Mu-tim its deusion, J ditii,,. f,y( a.wr f.c irecisr. rcrcrne. .i'liis. I $ uDt not, Iliall prove. . ' ; , I presume will readily lw'uduJu,,!. thal M idis-ai's Ui ort.;whicb Wna Fivi.l.i et le'HJiiutiewj, imtmatonulnnmo Bfl KCt 'rJr .' stt prortoimeei to to i3nr;iri3riturt..;at,T(flri-r tk other Siiiift tttttll hnrr vimtioticd it$ Ji-daio.,.; .This, it a ;eru4riia,'.. juiht ex.reely to sustain tln resolulifHis, ft ' ' iair inierpreier or tHeiKjueauiu ' "'"Mint " where- retort inn.tW huA : . r . - . T naiuiiM superlof lo the amafrTtj l-Srl, thu - n-i ,-tlAa ltuJ.i-ivd..fu.w. ..... .. .1 . . ' llie latit, fesiirtl Wheiiior liTe f.,i,- T." u' ' has b. en pursued or Vhrf.itul p10u . ds , . ; uv.hi'.L.i, un it, utiiiif 4ini wr li.. ... II. n fc i?ia,teJ.iift.jctfitettfMiitniar. Colla,rt tn,A ia .. 4..' Miiyrinuiim-recaa,ll)trilUnil( . ineir aumonty, to 7 tkctasU Tl -w ht'ther liitj conipact ttiado ly them be t obited j aud, coiwequetitly , tii'at, as the p f- - ' ties toft, they 1nust.ke1.ie, in.thr c , aorf; Buch fjueMiotw as niay be of sudi ,. t ' v J' iiii.gmtudn 10 require 'that mterpoMi,,, V - 1- com iiiis view tt tiie rcaolutioo, it would "Oeuiiiieviiceivuble fhut at Mm m..i.. just disapprobation frbiri those who, Javih ... . vvkhu misutuiiofi; Khali taiitiiilv -an4 accarately iiitcrpnH the tB.an.n- oY ' !!S!sillJl the ileliu'ala, - J jda"Kt!" Powers, V.hly withheld by, the Cou-i.tuiioti, ekj aJl justify the partiea o ,t, j0 interitaiinig, rr-' ea aofarasjoavertlie pnrcas f tl.n eviliuidihereby td preaem t,e C0!ti. tution iliitHt;! WeDasloyrorite for ti ', ("tojfe'Jlwra VMiki . U an end of all relielt Imui iiKnr.,l ika l....1...l - . . . - - right iCai f-eco'viiani iHultf aU Hit ,SlaM . r. :l n ft-. ;- 1 - . s" . .Mir"- . ,-.i. ... .t.rr. ,T:.-.-x-;- 11. -.Vi. T !. 1 ' 1. f v,j. , 1 r v, ... a ... j V '1..1 t J t ..,a,,.--. . ... ' : v.- v .... - - v--V ' "' .' - .-.''-...: ? f 1 -.'.:.' '-,-"-;''-.." 'A, . , y-:-7-'A--'-:'-,---,--' -, . '.::. . - . . , . u, - . ' , - '.- : , '- r t 3 t, -v-s- ' .i.CaraSliiSfc