I
EXECUTIVE TATRONACE.
1 AnsTR(rr or-MR. ruiA:s'&
llKlt'ltT ON KXUCUTIVB P AT RON At E.
This mmtuti of Cvwgress ba, wi fur a iImj rico
ate w esteemed, been ilfiiii'jtliu by whim of Ihe
tsoat elaborate m able reports eve r mu'le in either
branch si" the National lycgUUturs. (4iptcui
among them will stand tl Rep-wt nwito by John
t'. Cslbooa', from I rWh-ct Committi ! ptii('
id, up his motion, to Inquire iirto the exUml ami
operation of the constantly increasing patnsiage f
(he Executive of the United rM.itmi, la presenting
r.ioculive ot tlie "JnilcU rM.ite. laun
Report, Mr. CIlMtiti said tUl U had the
I'm)
uiian
iouus assent of iKe committee on every point of it
b'tl one, and on that mm, a single imnuUr of the
committee only dissented.
The Report sets out, very properly,' with an if
urt la ascertain the present cicol uf the Exoru.
Jive patronsge. rV this purpii,lbe returnsof the
-yea-lS;Jl,. not. being couipltlc, Ihcy like lb"
jear 1833, the year adordwg the neceanary
data t "hicb data are, fir, the revenue of the Co
. neral Govvrpment from all sources; secondly, the
, t xpemliturcsof the Goveniiocnt. exclusive if pay
luent of the public debt ; and thirdly, Ihe number of
person who, at officers, s gents, contractors, or in
other forma, are in the receipt of the pullic mo
ney. The revenue of 1933, the Report states In
have been over thirty-five million of dollars: ami
" 't!ie number of person who are recipient of the
. i .public lU'HH-y, to have bern sixty thousand two hull
'.dred and odd, of whom belong (as nearly aa we
-caild catch the number) to the Civil Lint 1,141;
. Jo the Military and Indian Dertmeuis 0,6 1 J ; to
the Navy (including Marine Corps) 6,100 ; and to
- lbs. Post O.fiee 31,917 all of whom derive their
"p'ace iliroctly or indirectly from lite Exicutive;
M w, with the exception oi toe Judicial othcers, are
ViHjoct to removal from office at the will ami plea
sure of the President. If to thete he adilcd .'!,.
' 6(9 pe'wuxKMt an aggregate appear uf ihio Iiuu
' flnti thousand am) seventy-nine persons in the em
'jftf of the Government, or in the receipt f mo.
my from the public treasury. If to tln-an be aiMeil
.-tlifl counties boat of those, who are necking to dis.
flace the present racipisnt ami beneficiaries, aome
lea may bo formed of the extent of the influence
,in Ije country of the pntrnnagq ri'wiliing from mh-Ii
dtburMOMiuU of wotMiy, u which ao nwny
iiiilividuala are inlereted.
.U The Report tlien p rococo toahow the grroi in-
ertuit of Ike publie tiprnditurt hi eight years,
from to 1833, incluxive, carrying with it a
. C.TrrenpooJing Tocroaxe of the number and compeit
eition of agwnta, olhoera, contractoni, and othera,
-depending &X anbwirtence npon the Government,
, and of courae upon the pttronage of the Executive.
JJofore inMtitutmg thia compariaoii, however, the
repart advnrta ta the rapid increaaa, by Lxlmii
wrealie, of rtttrtationa of land to Indian, to be
jiponed of by then) only with the ronaeiit of the
Kxecutive, than which it ia dilucult to imagine a
device better ealculaled to enlarge the Executive
xtronnge. The practice of removing from afice
1"ToiW wko r? wcW quahfrd for and have uth
fully perfurtned their dutiea, in order to introduce
jnlhera in thrir aad, who are of the party in power
,. practice of reeent date ia alao the aubject of
crave censure W thia view of the Report Caaea,
t ;jt (a frue, may be (tnind la tlie early atagea of thia
.iovammant, in which removal from office have
I r-r:bermadey Vuflhiy "ir' ao ft to twiiriVr aa (o
iTTjtoiwliute o!rtncef rattwi 'thai a practice; aw! it ia
i only withio few years, that an opportunity haa
: ' ,..)eo aflorled of testing the practice, u a ijtiem, by
e'eftlicifc--" r-: -" " ; '
: ' .Fn"erlyt the patronage of Jha-Executive waa
; ' wfitwcl, jo, point of .fuel, to the .power of oomiraK
. , ,tmg persons to all occasumai vacancies to the. pub-
"TtZ "' J"0 ncea-i Coder the contrary-practice, the otfi-
cea of the Government, instead of public IruHta,
.Ji'hoso Ciithful executkw. is inninly to be held in
.view, cpme to be considered as the spoils of vitlo
iV ader a political conteat-lhd rewarda for faith-
.JTmI servicijn the ranka of partyi the recipients of
niriTnii Mtndv Cif an aarvicA. however corrunt.
Ater This praetiee, tWrefure, the Report goes on
71 o say, U a aytem to encourage vice and discourage
-..virtue, and must endjif not reformed, by overt urn-rr.-2'iing
the Government and raising a dcdpotiaiin on its
rims.' -Taithfut performance ol auty bwng no kng-
...W a'recommoadation to cootinuance, tlie puJJic of.
cen cAwcquently foci thlV dcpcndence on the
nere pleasnfe of the Executive, and resort to all
those acts of compliance and Buhscryiency which
- they learn to consider as recomniendationa to his
fiYor. Atfl. . , -w. ---. - - .
i "" .Tlie Report llieq adverts to the circumstances of
-the increased power which the Ivxecutive has ac
-xj'iired bjfe rmrnrf which 4ntevnt harepven
.to. him iter ik. publie fund. Without mouting
b'r the q'uestioB of the plUy. or illegnlity of the
"action of the Executive in.. removing the public
(itfMieys from- depniile-it the Rankof the United
tates,'the tmnpiittee" any that thorn can be no
uibt uoon the romd of any man .that the removal
, ,t!1 puDllC aeposiies ma inQrcnmrti mo power oi
' . i Jl : : J .i
- vhich become the corrupt and sxipnlo inatriimenUi 'ettyy whick thCoremtt tpr4t.
-'"f 4ieHin;y th he 6f lifce reward, is "ireV They li'giii by taviiig :" Awn, as a general
: treated a host of hiingfy, greedy, and subecrvient principle, that it is the duty of a Government to
" le and unlimited control, as they mi'isfcotulwte
J be until otherwise provided by-snine action on
the "part Cimssir VndeeJ any act cfongress
be passed of greater efloct in this respect
puTHic ItHHivys wore
-rnnwe, di recred whsre they itiutd1 feeptr-Triis
. i Jbport. gvs oo to stnte some facts snowing the ev
tent of pitronae exercised through, this awuined
' piwer of controlling- the- deposrtea ef-th publie
jmoney, Axe. Ate. - '-;f ;
-Ilavinj thus shewfl, hf i-vtrjetinof factsand a.
fjura'ints, of which the above can afford lwt very
tiirt-idee, thenormmis extent of. the Executive
the subject. Patronage, in a Goveraitvjflt, jroys
(the rport, is at best but. nereuarg eeu:; the ten
.done? of which, even when comparatively irestricl.
cJ in its extent, is to debase and corrept "the mo.
jds the TOrnrmjnlty.-" In all weft fyitat4 free
f!vernmeots, therefore, no more of 'it vdll here,
laiaed than: ia jieceMnry. to.tlieir k?:dt&il xist
,eTce. The idea tha large ExTeuiive patronage
i$ necessary to give efficiency --tothe Givernmeut
is combated as a fallacy, c-emonstrrtted to hi such
by a comparaaoa of the present with the jmst ex.
4ent of tbab patronage i this Governmenf: : For
his comparison, the Committee select the years
' I S25 and 133, the former year feeing one in which
theextEit the Executive patronage already be-
; pan toi be.thb'ugbt too great, wd the latter, because
ir ia tb lafet yif Vbich tbey can obuio correct r.
turn. Trom thiic'iiipsiUooit appears that tlc
come of the ttovrrnmeiil, it -ludiiig the l'.t f )lin e,
was. In I frr.l IT.WW r tW, t3C,fi57)0
(rij'ding fr tisw.) That llm eieuililiire of tlie
tioveriiiiH-nl, (eicliiMvs of the public deM) was, in
IA U.Utf.WHM in IW33, $i5.fi'5,tM)0j and
that the number of pi-rwsia receiving enxiliins iil
or ruiiieiMuiin from the (Jovernmenl, was, in
1 J, fiHy.five llnsiwind seven humlrml nun seven-
ty.wven ami in 1 H'A-i, one humlred lhouand and
evenly -iukc raiiim, .
MMUHirmg the exlei4of the public patronage by
these elements, cofulsiksd with thst of the gross
expenditure, without adverting to other eircnnnlan-
ces wtiicti hsve U-en shown stilt lurther lo enlarge
it, the result is as sixty-five lo eiahtytiinn, shewing
an increuM if patronage between those years of
lliir1V-it perweut. 1 he pnigressive inrresse ha
ving been much greater within tlie Is it lour years
limn within the (our yesrs rneding.
AuticipNling the answer to Ibis statement, thai
tlie inrreateof pstrousge, Ate, has wit been greater
than the increase in the growth and population of
the Country, the Report gore on to show, by iha
oj leral khi of I he several causes al ready et woerated,
that the patronage of tlie (fovnrnment has more
thsn dsihled, within a space of time wherein the
growth snd pollution of the country have not ro
bablv inert ssed more Huui 21 per cenL lint.
whilt shewing this, the Report dmiies that there
is any subttantinl reason why the patronage of the
(tovernment sImhiIiI increnan in proxirtim to its
Increaiof population. This iilea, the rewrt goes
on to show, is an asumrtinn dsngersis aa well as
erroneous. The danger of a patronsge, thus in-
eraasing with the growth of a country, arises from
the great advantage of an organixi-d, over an unor
ganised mim ; the great alvantage w hich, in a
populists cisint ry. piwer thus acquires over liberty.
The Report dilates on the pAier which such a
swelling patronage, all wielded by a single individ.
iml, gives him lo corrupt the people and seixo on
their lilyrtie, A:c. Under a cmilinm-d progrensive
increase of patronage, keeping ce with the in
ereae of iair p-puliiiiKi, litwrt y itelf mul certni il
ly lie im. Nothing Isit reftrm can save it. The
action of the Government muni, then, lie modera
ted. This, the Report maintain, i the principle
on which our political exigence depend.
- The Report ny, that the Omimittee are aware
thst it may be urged against their statement, thst
since 1!.1.1 there has b"en a great direase in the
public revenue by the operation of the Ut tariff
law. lint the .revenue is yet as great, now thut
the public debt is extinguished, asjtwaawhen the
politic dclit amounted to a hundred millions of dol
lar. The difk-rence between thai lime and the
present is, that the surplus revenue then went to
pay the Miblie creditors ; whereas it now goes into
the pockets of those who live upon the Treasury.
The Report next proceeds to examine into ike
eject of this enormous extension of Kxecutive pat
ronajre. The Committee says, it has tendud to Kip
the foundation of the Cisistitution, to throw a clowl
of uncertainty over the future ; to substitute a de
grading subserviency to power for the attachment
to liberty and our tree institutions, tor winch the
American People have boeu heretofore distinguish
ed. There never was a period in our history, in
hort, in which the prospects were more gloomy
lor uoeny, awl oevotimi to party ami to power
stronger. With this increase of patronage, the
whole structure of the Oovemmeut is undergoing
a changn. Admitting the necessity of a strotur
Executive, the Report enters into an irgumcut to
show that an Executive has become too at rung,
when it begins to regard itself as the paramount
power in the Government. . Nor, in our case, could
the aid of the several States be successfully Invo"
ked to XCiiLst the apfinch of dcnpiiic power in this
lorm. : oo for from op posing" It; they will m more
likely, to aid knd strengthen tlie Executive and,
acting m conjuction with it, constitute a joint force
Uilticult to be resisted by any other authority
For theso evils, present and prospective, die Re
port says, there can be but owe etfeetual remedy,
ami that m, a prompt and great reduction of Exe.
cutive patronage, uito the mnt expedient mode ol
leave the mtsiev. as fur as oraoticahie. in the Dock
ft? of Jhe people, from which Utf wy tt csnnut be
reimived by the Government, except for its essen
tial waiitsithoqt violatiuii uf Jheiighcst trust
of the Governmenr, and manuest injustice to the
people. - - 1
The Report then enters upon an elaborate and
comprehensive view of the finances of the country,
to show to what extent the revenue of the country
may be expected to exceed the amount nccessar
to the support of Government. In pursuing this
inquiry, the Committee to on ta show that, doting
1110 oisieuce oi in compromise law, so cauea, re
'gulating duties on imports, and after all the reduc
tions which may te nmite by rediicing the'dtitws
on articles which do not interfere with protection,
.there will still be au muavoidable annual surplus in
the I reasury of about nine millions of dollars.
1 hey do hot propose to reduce the income by re
ducing the price of the public lands, because to re
duce the prjee would not only tempt great specu
lotions therein, and affect the value of all other
lamtwd- oronertv-tit-the lntoiT.-ptrt would- have it he
etrnci w uicti'ase i.insieaa ot aimimsniag inc incon.e
iroiu incir siur. . as, inereiure, u is uucmoa im
., , . - - , -- --,
possiote, auciiig me exisiencejot ine compromise
actTaniTwithout disturbing that act, to prevent the
jinminl rrrripf intn thn Treiisury of "PWtra
nine millions, even afior reducing tiie expenditures
pf the government within proper limits, the Com'
roiltee go into an ivuiry as to the most expedient
mole of applying this sum. They protest against
its remaining and accumulating In the Banks where
it is depnetted ; and they do not recommend its ap-
plication .to the purposes of Internal Improvement,
tbfr difficulties in the way of which have been in
ereasstr"
l!th?xeet
apjiroprinrirms for that ohjoct.
sanction
Tlie Committee', therefore, come to he conclu.
sion that the only, and the Jeast objectionable mode
of disposing of the surplus revenue, is to make an
mwiaet''srrtyiift( MmofaMmziktMatmUStakt
tie, to aontinue until the year 1942, which will, ter
minate the existence of the present compromise Act,
and leave Conirress at hhertv to reduce the -income
to the actual wants of the Government, ,Th Com
.. ny, . .L.- . J
rnmee proposs 40 etject. ineir ootect oy bh a menu
meirt of the CVmstltution, giving, power to Congress
to mke such distnbunnn, which a roaionty bttbe
Coinmrttee deem not now within, the. competency
of Congress, For that purpose- they report a loint
Resolution, and propose to divide the annual sur.
plus .revenue Jn1 auck imiiiher of shares as tbe
iu-.aro i' uuturs ajJ Upn iiitir, to he diilJ
i among llwi ftMle in proportion to their rrpresi lita-
1 Cn'ml with' two sliar.s to each fttttiuty awl the
I)mtrict i( C'olumtii
lie Oiiniiiiitt proiMMe, also, tlie enactment of
a law, for wlm b they reprt a bill, to regulate the
ItcpiMiles of the public money ami the rnaclnn-iit
of mm of the Utls n .rted by a rMeci Coiitmiiteo
in ll'.'O, to reguLtt the patronage of the Govern.
Burnt.
trtm'-a. :
M'tikinglnn Vuetttfomdmrt of 14 Richmond Whig.
WaaNiiNiToa, February 12, 13..
Dear 8ir 1 I have just witnessed one of the moot
exciting sceitee that ever occurred t the tkoate.
1 lie bills reported by tlie Committee on hxecuuve
patronage were the order of the day Air yesterday.
At an early hour the Senate was fillod to overflow
ing, ladies who could not obtain seats, stood oa
their H-el ir teiura, anxiously expecting the debate.
Tlie bill from the Committee on Commerce inter,
verted, and tlie Honate, after a king session slj(uro
ed. This moniing the hill reieahng the four years'
law came up, and Mr. Calhoun, n a fi'w brief re.
marks, rccurrej to (lie report of 1920, made by
Mr. BcutoA, as chairman of a committee composed
of Renton, M'icim, Van lluren, White, lloluma,
R. M. Johnsiwi, DickersiKi, llsyne, aixl one other
not recollectiMl stated that that committee had re
CominoiKlcd the same' prirviwitHis, and hoped that
the bill w i mi Id pass without opposition. Iknlim
r, ami, with a amnli bsA of notes, said that he
was alrt to mtpply what he had omitted to say on
the introduction if the report on Monday, and
axknd the Senate to lake it as part of that sik-ccIi
indulged in a bold mikI unqualified deiiunciatioo of
the n'Nirt asserted that it was a party pnper,got
up fir political i i t clisrw leriwd it as an attempt
to buy the people by the bribe of four shilling,
and tii pence each, in pujier money. ' Mr. Calhoun
replied defending' the report ami vindicating its
details. In the course of his remarks, ho said that
nature had emlowed the Senator with boldness
yes, boldncNs of auertion. This llenton chime to
coiiHiik-r M-roiial ; and when lie rose to reply, seized
ujiofi a isirt of tlie n-ort, which sM-aks of tlie efloct
of rciHlering the nlhce-holdcra di-peiMlnnt upon tlie
Executive, and a remark of Mr. Calhmin'a, in which
he had alludgcd that ilcnton was the advocate of
tlm ofbciHl corjis (lemsinced it as " a Imld attack
Usn truth." t)n this he was called to order by
Mr. Poimlexter. Tlie Chair decided, that as Mr.
II. did not intend to itns;ach the jiersistal veracity
of Mr. t'albisjn, it was m4 out of order 1 ,Mr.
Webster took an aipeul, ummi the grmiml, that tlie
words themselves used, not the intent of the Spea
ker, w ere to be considered. The opinion of tlie
Chair was overruled, and then a scene occurred
which diackmed the fiendish purixise of the attack.
After having traveled out of the way, and out of
order, to attack the report which was not under
consideration after having assailed the report, and
dciiiNinced its conclusion as an evidence of hallu
cination; after having stigmulised it as unfair, un
camlid, deceptive, fuUsj, he preUMsbsl to consider
Mr. Calhoun's defence of the report, in reply to
his attack, as a premeditated attack on him, and
assumed that Mr. Calhoun was bound lo huld Atsi
to personal accisint for what he had said. During
the enactment of this scene, there wss a deimsiiac
grin, which plainly disclosed Mr. Bentim's purpose
of bullying down all those who dared to expose the
corruptions of the oflicial corps, whom it was his
purpose to rally around him a a Pnrtorian cohort,
to eoforc.s the purposes of corruption.
.To this, Mr.Cafhisin jroptod-, By a luoid illustra
tion of the trjuh of his report, reasserting and re
alnrining all that he had said, and showing 'that it
was; JHL sq. aiuch what he. had said, a aba. truth
and consequence of the exposure that had given
offimce. There la but' one opinion, AU . parties
here admit, that unless Mr. Van Buren succeeds in
rallying the party, and putting the resr( to death,
by premature denunciation, the report will put an
end to the party. It has brought to light such a
mass of facts, and has arrayed them with a force
that it is imposHihle to resist, unless the prejudice
of. party and tho avarice -of the office-holders can
be enlisted. Their craft is in danger, and he who
ca tjrowbeatX C. tillioun,or niirrder his report,
will have rendered Mr. Van Buren an indi.eiisa
ble service. . -
" The Senate was crowded to overflowing many
stood fif hisjrs, and did not not tha flight of time.
The debate was continued until it became so dark
that Mr, Calhoun could scarcely read, and will be
resumed to-morrow.
The efficacy of Mr. Calhoun's report, and the
force of (he alarming troths ildisrtowes, are demon
strated by the 'panic" it has caused among the
office-holders. Its truth, its value, its unanswera
ble reasoning, are in the ratio of the consternation
it has caused among the Treasury leeches. They
are combining all their forces to crush him, and
kill that. The People, whose interests Mr. Cal
houn is endeavoring to protect whose liberties he
ia mooring 10 guaru agaumi ine inroaus 01 corrup
tion, far more to be dreaded than. the opei assaults
of tyrants ought to reward and animate him with
their gratitude and confidence, and frown down the
bravoe who are attempting to a we him into silenCe.
His report ought to be placed in the hands of every
citizen, ai a beacon light in thia moment of outer
political darkness. r - v .
TTiswiwro, fcbreary 14, 1885.
In the Seriate, after the usal morninj? btwiness.
one of the- bills reported by-fr. Calhoun from the
oelect Committee on Executive patronage, came op
as the special order.. Mr. Clay , rose and read to
on the table the substance of which was that,
whenever the President shouhTrenibve any person
from office, and nominate another to fill his place,
he should state his reasons of the removal, to the
Senate, and jf that body should refuse Jo concur in
thero, by rejecting the person nominated, the per
son removed should continue, in office. Mr. Clay
Said Kg waa Aillv nrenarhit ta uistain his nnmsi.
nn,ji Monday, when he hoped the leaders of the
Jackson party would come prepared to go into the
subject. .
In the Hi
S House of Itenresenlatives. an animated
debate. tmik pl,ooa aioo to prmt 3,000 copic
pt the fost Ottice Report and Documents, and 20,
000 without the documents.' "Both motions were
decided in the affirmative. During this debate, all
sides 'admitted f he foulest corruption, in the Post
Office j but attempts were made to screen the Post
master General from his. share of the blame. But
this would not do: it was evident that he bad evin
ced the most criminal negligence m the affairs of;
the lepartment, and had connived, in many instan
ces, at acts of corruption, His friends are anxious
-that he should resign and I have been informed,
Jto-dny, jthat lie intended to do so. "
ie'nmtU iUdSii t,itiih. r,Uunrf II)
The rk isitfl on wie n isi is u,". ".. .
f..-.1ii. Pslns!!!. was rssuusid etcriiay 111
tlie Henate. Mr. Ik titon, in studied 'sch,
which he begged I be Hcnala lo coinMr as a pan
of his Sjieer h upon I bo first n-admg ol me resin,
aiain asih d it 10 the bitterest terms of dcnumia-
Imn J repealing M lormef oecisraiHsi, ini " 5
port was rwule Cir party purposes! that it waa a
tissue of fallacies, intemh-d fir elctiooeering pur.
pwes. To this Mr. Calhoun replied, vindicating
the truth of the report, and in tlie csirs of Ins
remarks took occasion to say thai nature ewlowed
individuals diffrrenlly that she had giveit tW Be
nator from Missouri b.4dnes -yaa, IssVlwaai of as.
sertion. Mr. Ilenlon couided this declaration with
the remark tliat he had Mtenliood himself with list
official corps as their advocate, assuming that Mr.
Calhoun had Imputed falsehmid and corruptim lo
him, assumed bullying tone and repeated bis as
sault upon the report read that part of it which
spraks of the temleiry f making the office hidd
en, as a 'jisly, des-mlant uww the Executive, de.
ctared it lo be "a bold attack upon the truth ;n tut
this he was called lo order by Gov. Poindcxter, and
the Vice President al Ihe same time Gov. Poin
dexter bavins teduced the words to writing, Ihe
Chair decided that if it had been the intention id"
Mr. Benton to impeach the personal veracity of
Mr. Calhoun, the words would have been out ot or
der, but thai inasmuch as they applied to a deduc
tion of Jb.e repot t, they were iM personal, and there,
fore w4 out of order From this decision Mr. Web
ster took an appeal to the Senate, which was sus
tained hy a vote of 24 to 20.
Mr. Ileiitisi wss then permitted lo proceed, when
a scene, such as was never In-fore witnessed in that
body, ensued. It is manifest that Mr. Benton be-
lieves that he must kill the report, or the report will
overthrow that corrupt state of things upon which
he has placed his hopes of reaching, to use his own
words, " th a tmbonr. Inwards Mr. Calhoun
and Mr, Webster he endeavored lo lie particularly
olTcimive, giving it distinctly to be understood that
his purpose was lo make a persrsinl affair with Mr.
Calhoun. To this bluster and bullying Mr. Calhoun
replied, by defending, in a firm and dignified manner,
the statements ami detail of the report. He said
that lie was aware of the reonibifiiy he hail as-
snmed when lie entered opm the duly ot mnhmff
war umjabuses of Executive patronage; lie stissj
there as the advocate of American liberty, not to
be intimidated or driven from his purpose he iei
teraled ell that he had said, affirming its truth,
leaving -others to. ajtfdy it deihietioos.
POST-OFFICE CORRUPTIONS.
From Ike Salionml lnleUigenerr, of February 14. J
TIIE POST OFFICE.
In the House of Representatives, yesterday, the
hill which passed the Senate (uuaniiiKHisly) for re
forming the administration of the Pisit Office, re
ceived its first snd sectaid reading, and was referred
to the Post Office Committee.
It was a concurrence of circumstances rather re
markable, that, 00 the same morning, the Commit
tee appointed by the J liaise of Representatives in
June lasf, to examine into the a flairs of Ihe Pt
Office, should have brought in its report. - The re
port waa presented by Mr. Connor, the Chairman
of the Committee, and, without reading, (because
of its great length,) waa ordered to lie on the table,
and to be printed. Mr. E.Wiuuhmnrrnirhehalf
tof the- Minority of said Commiltee7 who, he said,
had not been able to take, in all particulars, the
same view as the Majority of the Committee, ofter
red a. report on their, part; which waa-elao ordowd
to lie on the table, and to' be printed. " '
We have nut, of course, bad .it in out power to
read any material portion of these important and
voluminous documents. . But, desirous to soe to
what conclusions the Majority of the Committee
had arrived, as the result of their investigation, We
turned to the last pages of the Rcfiort, and found
them there stated in such frank and manly terms,
a lo do honor equally to the spirit and Intelligence
of the Committee, who have dared to oe noriest in the
teeth of party-WecnpjMhe eooel4im7sTgraphs
of the Majority Report (thai oT the Minority we
hav not yet examined)-Hlo which there isno
occasion to ask the attention of every render.
The Committed, in enne lading this brief ana."
lytical review of th'6 wwilts of a very jwtient and
luborioiis investignrion of the Conditiisn and procee
dings of the Post Office Department, should not
consider therf duty as folly discharged to the
Honse, and to fne coontry, without frankly submit
ting the general 'conclusions, to which their minds
have been brought. The propositions which follow,
and which condense these conclusions, this Commit
te doubt not, if examined, in a spirit ofandor,
and1 ImaAlaTnywuToe admitted" as "just corolla
ries ol tins report.
t. .ThftfinanCrg of . thuDepartmemV--lwve
hfllierto been managed without frugality, system,
intelligence, or adequate pabUc tility,-r The car
dinal principles of an enlightened economy have
been violated Ignorance of the real fiscal ability
of the Department has long-prevailed. Expenses
have nol been kepi within the limits of income.
Means have not been proportioned to the ends
sought to be obtained: expendltiirea.to.the.oenefits
to be purchased. h DpaHmenti
iff this vital particular, have not been kepCwrith
memoa ana accuracy : lor the, data they lurnish
conduct to widely- varying resultsTTne accounts
of the receipts, exnen'ditiirea. and tnasea nf iKa
Department do not, in fact, illustrate, with certain
ty, the actual fiscal condition of the Department.
No common test or standard appears, at any time,
to have been employed to detect such casual errors
as.tnigbt creep tn to derange the balance between
receipts and expenditures 1 and hence the existing
unfortunate excess of the latter over the former,
The absence of such a test produces the ffocts,of
accuracy- ot the conclusion which it may reach by
any ordinary process of investigation; and upon
the practicable operations of the Department, of a
perpetual liability to fall into error, without any
certain oiodo of its detection.. The evil is within
the rench offegiHTafion, and should be corrected
by establishing a proper system of checks and balan
ces. 2d.. The negligent and unsystematic form of
matung an preserving the mail contracts, is such
that oo human mind could comprehend the whole,
and maintain in order, so vast and complicated a
machine as the General Post Office. The contracts
are now, and have, at all times which have fallen
under the observation of the committed been most
loosely conducted. It is occasionally impossible
to penetrate their obscuritv : often difficult to dwi.
jihcr their interlineations jiad marginal mites; al-
iwiii o ldvuUcd aUtlr tl are so o. j
I" . '" '-' msuawa ja twt
IUr IIWIH-I lltHl III Ilkfl llaill '.l. i II 1
convey an adequate idee of the 1
- '-.s ssiriH:i lUmik
run iL
ed state in win, h , they are kept. Certain i,
... "w wa gem-ration of UU.rer. , ,
branch of tl.e yf the off, C1MIIM U
nutted through him to another. Km.wkU
acquired) is to be s.Uained miliar from ol
who keep Ihe books, than the books IliemwbJi
and the ciswequence is, that the bssj of fa V
keeper is the extinction of all certain light
-The Head of lh, De,rtmmt est, aluu. n
the eornwjtive lo Ins rul. ' iTf
- - M. I be moile of preparing advertiw
Pr mail contracts has practically trvt,ra -
emls of lh law which enjoined il. Tlie mm i?
aigio 11 as treat sal.-guard against fraud u
imptsNtion.Tiy bringing Hie salutary priiripkTi
competition into active and beneficial eperatjjal!!
Tlie usage of Ihe Department n eonjunctioa .
, e,- e.- w receitjft-
amalgamated bids, has frustrated the wUksa
Ibis precautiim, and irmlered the system of htmJt
in regard to Ihe more important routes, little feJ
than an empty form or a bitter mockery.'
"The interposition of the legislative power kU
the npoiiiion nf the Committee, uimeery ia rtas
instiuice, as tliey deem the existing enactment adr.
quale to Iheir object."
4th. The practice of granting ettra alWim
has at various dates in the hiulory of this IVp
MK-01, run lino nu cwmsi j siane HlegitimfH
and therefore without an apology, and others
timate, Isit very quest iisinldc as lo tlieirexpediean
To this sisirec may m ascribed, wilhisjl Sianrdaf
error, much of Ihe eniharrasMmcnt rsf the IVps,
mem ; ami, in whatever asm-ct ibis Conimiftes be
had opportunity lo examine il, it strikes tliemtk;
its practical oteration haa boen fiaught with ti
more of evil than of good. Among its otW
achievements, it has signalized, most eminently, fU
to ready faith and too If saw busiiwss aiethus' of
the Department. Tlie letter of a contractor, s
grating an improvement and soliciting an extri it.
lowance, ms unfrequently has served the double o
fice of an authority for tlie grant, and of a meon
of its existence. fitricdaj-kroexoLaeariitek
or loose scrsp of paper is commoly the oolv officiJ
evidence- of the order for large disbursement! of
nwsMy umlcr lbs nam of extra allowances, b
a puzzling problem lo decide whether; this far
tiiaiary, power thronghoui its whole existence, ku
(haie most mischief in the character of importer
npon the IhrtmernVnr aedurerto tonlractwiM
It has, disibtliiw, beeu an cvilJoer io both fnr
"The committee have not deemed it within tht
acojs of llieir authority to prepare a silL" Toil
duty comes within the pnivince of a Btanding Cco
mitlee of the House.
"The Committee, in surveying toe wide nAl of
their labors, regret only that their reward bad ' t
been discoveries of a more pleasing chaiwtn
They had Ikm,! that their researches would I
brought to light the fruits of an enlighten .
well directed labor, instead of proofs of errn" 4
neglect... But they, have fiuutued ism tosli t j
them with an honest purpose and to the best of iWr
ability. 11 remains lor I ontrress tonveaai
perfect organization to thU IVpsrtmeot j arwl (
those who administer it, to bring to its renowio
the most efficient and preservinir smdicalina al
practical talent and business like halslf -wrlhip
weal m) VielMt iwrwsmt iwn iiileistence.' -
The ComTnirtee ConsiMed of Messrs Connor, fksi
dert, E. Whhtlusey, II. Everett, Beardsley, Witineajfi
sad ilawes. --srrrr
. Pram tie Saliunml ItlrUigenrrr, Frh. 21
- . THK fOHT OFUCE REPORTS.
We have had, since our last, "an opportunity af
looking over the llrport of The Miliofity II
Pil Office C011111.il lee. It ia a work of great !
bor, exhibiting evidence of unwearied industry.
with the result nf smirate research, an far lips'
Committee were allowed lo carry it. The Report
consists of a series of s'atements under virMM
heads, exhibiting the particulars of abuses, such
as have led the iiiujority, as weft" a theTiiioonty
of the Committee, to the withering concliisicei
which hnve'been alrcudy published, slatementi of
great interest, but which cannot be cimmIcmn m
made ihe subjecll' of. abstracts, witlnnit the te
sumptmn of more lime snd space thsn wesrssW
no 10 give to Ihe subject. We reserve, there
fore, till after the adjournment, the details, nf whkk
we shall then consider it. our duty lo.prrseot tt
ample a view as is practicable. ' r
Notwithstanding the extent and enormity of lis)
disclosures made by the Committee, it sev
that there is much yet to be told, if the fac'li coals'
be full? arrived, at . ,2 bus, Jhe JWiaority
tho outset of their 1Report;r",,It is doiogne-inj
lice to the Department to ssv. thn! they receive'
00 vokwHar y aid from -any- ttf ;tt3W;flkers W
they have been able to find out, they knowjii
from what -fa known; : ft"-niay ie roferred tkst
much remains to be known .V-----The
Report of the Minority further states "
will be apparent, from the recordaof the Con"i
tee, that from an early day of thefr isinn, tb
waa a mnjority and minority. Th minority
not rluim anv ihioa dT iknmnnlvfia that theT
''nott'rtlie' majority.' Tticj disclsim ll
Prtlji'tini.Cnteringupon.
examination on thpir nsrt. nnd shall cive full CrM
to a similar disclaimer on the part of the majority
Thn fact, however, ia meuiioweoVsf sccoutttins
in lAm, ftnrrpM. ft mutd nf tirinmmr forWatf
the examination, the prolixity an4 irreWancJ 4
portions of the testimony, and the fanner in mhf
it was taken. The minoriry belioed it lo bejhr
duty to go forward, and examine' into the procee
mga of the "Department, to see w he'tber they e
right or wrong. The majority woreof opinion tl
il was" nof Yequired lo search fpTaJiuses, but
examio.only. where proUble auae was sIJeW
this would, in fact, have limited jdie exaroinatwt
to abuses already discovered. The effect of
difference of opinion will be seen to have i'"""
to the calls on the Department for information,
to the .production of witnesses. Vrifci
partment to answer interrogatories, absolutely
feated, to a certain extenf, theWiject of the tnVM
instituted by the House of Representatives. Tn
says the Minority Report! "It is but j'"':
themselves to state, the Minority are not rets
sible for the course the examination has uk.; J",
direction of which was beyond their control,)
that so little has been done, and so much has be
left undone they do not say which ought to M
been, but which could hot be i5.I0R!
the neglect of the Department to answcTnJ
solutiojia of the Coipmittce, . : . ,-.