WATCH LABEL
Mi yaa pspr. a inmt It
dan bfr explrettoa U ardar to
avoid mieslag a (lag) py. -
THE WEATHER
- rttttt - Nrtfc - ftrallna Flr
Tsesday h4 Wsdaesday; 11 UU
tkaag la tompratar.
lime
server
SIXTEEN PAGES TODAY.
VOL CX1V. NO. 166.
SIXTEEN PAGES TODAY.
RALEIGH, N. C. TUESDAY MORNING. DECEMBER 13. 1921.
PRICE: FIVE CENTS
News aea Old)
1
HAMMER HUONG
FINE RECORD FOR
Seventh District Congress
man Boosted For Commit
tee Vacancy .
COLLEAGUES THINK
HE'S FINE TIMBER
Friends of Tar Heel Watt To
Put Him In Place Hade
Vacant By Congressman
flood's Death; Soy Bean
Tariff Propaganda Pnnc
tared By Congressman
Ward
The News and Observer Bureau.
603 District National Bank Bldg.
By EUWAKD E. BR1TTO.N.
(By Special Leased Wire.)
Washington, Dec. 7"! -That nitta
tion to business pay is again lllus
trated in the easj t. William C.
Haaimer of Anhchoro, Representative
Trow tne sr'vehth "Nbrth Carolina
district. Though this is but his
. first session of Congress his. attea-
Hon to affairs before it and his close
study of matters coming before com
mittees of which h is a member
has had its effect in drawing at tea
tion to him as a working member
of the House. Especially so has this
attention coma because of Ins work
as a member of the District of Co
lumbio, committee, his activity in
behalf of a five cent rate of car fare
and reduction in the excessive coat.
of mils, "in Washington.
Beraure he has leen fo'inl to be a
working membtr, aid bee use it has
been learned that ho has political
sense of a high older, there is bo
ing most serious talk among mem.
bers of Congress that he is the man
to fill the position of chairman of
the Democratic congressional earn-
pnign committee, made vacant" by
the death at Congressman Hal Flood
of Virginia. The only obstacle in
the nay is that this is hi: first term
ia Congress, but aguinst this it is
being urged that. hi is a man quick
to make acquaintances and friends
that he has the capacity ami the
political judgment necessary to fill
the position. It ij held that 1922 will
TERM
be a year when the Democracy has
; the opportunity to do big things at
the polls in the congressional elec
tions, and those wh are talking of
, Mr. Hammer any that he Is the man
-snf -whw-wwrtd make aa aWe TttidiT, that
" ie if real "lire wire" Democrat
who knows how to do things.
1 Ward lnveatlrates Tariff.
v Congressman Htllett & Ward fiaa
had communications from parties ia
North Carolina asking him to favor
a protective duty on soja or toy
beans. He investigated and found
that there were more soja beans
raised ia his district, the First North
Carolina, than in any other. Congree
sionsl district in the United Htates.
His investigation also revealed the
fact that there wero but 52,000 bosh
els of the beans imported into the
United States, rot enough to feed
the hogs in his county, about 25,000,
for one week, and thit incidentally
there are about l.Vl.mvi hogs ia his
district He replied to the com muni
cations calling for a protective t:iff
for soy beans that in view of this
he eould aee no rnasos for a protec
tive tariff for these.
In reply he was told that it wis
the oil from the beans tor wmen
protection was sought. He investi
gated some more and found that in
this country there was produced 64,
000,000 pounds of refined oil frem
aoy beans, that America consumed
M.000.000 pounds and that we ex-
ported !,000,000 pounds. Btating
this fart in hie eeeona repij n
added that he thought the protective
tariff waa to prevent excessive Im
port and ot to deal with exports.
He has had no. reply to hia knock
out statementa of facts about a pro
tective tariff for aoy beani.
Invite Harding Te Speak.
President Harding was today
waited oa by the committee from the
United States oOdd Koarts Assoeia
tioa and invited to attend the aixth
annual meeting in Phoenix, Arizona.
He stated that another engagement at
the time of the meeting would pre
Tent hia acceptance, but gave the
noaltivs nromise to visit Arizona on
his trip West next summer and take
mote of the roads. Mrs. Harding also
received the committee, and accepted
the invitation to accompany her hns-
"hand. Col. Venetian Cameron, of
Btagvllle, president of the Bankhead
National Highway, wat one of the
"eommittee which had OB it repre-
. sentatives from fourteen States.
among these Governor Campbell and
' Senator Aahnrst of Arisoss. The ia
sitatioB oa behalf of the two asso
ciations waa delivered by J- A.
Kountree, director general of the
United Statea Good Jtosds Assoeia
i - ties, G overs or Tatnpbell speaking
for Arizona, ia presenting the Invi
tation to Proaideat Harding, Mr.
CaaiDbell. wife of the Governor, and
' - Mr. Albert E. Therntoa, of Atlaata,
f saalrmaa of the Womass Commn-
aiea of the Baakhead National High
.j way dasoriatioa, exteadiag the iari-
Htioa to Mrs. Harding, who talked
' . quite at length with the ladiee of
, tlut committee.
'New GrBebss) ltanatoJ,
The long wait to Wars who m
the choice for poetauater at Oreoaa-
her seme to aa tad today wha
th ProrMeat seat to the Be mate the
" temluatloa of fceacee C Caadley
to he poetataater at that Blare, llr-
' 1 Chaadley otood third ia the bat of
eligible. J. H. AnaJeld beiag flrat
oad 8. A Bodgia. aeeBad, another
tiase ia which It koldi geeod tint
the M ahwH U Srtt. Tho pt
BiUoa parya $300 year aad Ure
kaa ks vaeenew aiaw May V,
W0. b odditiM to taes oa the
elifiblo Ma Ue aoor ppUeaata
who etood th xasslaatieei were:
.Uaaed aa jstga OUto J
Want PubUcity On Watts;
Propbse Primary Repeal
J. Elmer Long Introduces
Bill Calling For Notice On
All Tax Rebates
MEASURE IS EXPECTED
TO PROVOKE BATTLE
Her Direct Attack Is 'Made
On Witts Bnt Friends, It Is
Said, WiU Besent
"Pitileea poWieitj' for Qx act of
the Commissioner of Revenue and
the State Board of Equalization was
provided for in a measure presented
to the eSnate by J. Blmer Long. The
bill requires full notice by corpora
tions asking rebates, pjiblie hear
ings and teh publication of aa an
nual report. Called to the calendar
the bong bill went through its see
end reading but was held up on ob
jection by Senator Bams, who stated
he did not understand the bill. This
s.ud the primary repeal bill were the
Senate headlines for Monday night
These measures, which are expect
ed to provoke, heated controversy
were accompanied by a score of less
iaiportant legislative proposals and
the Senate indicated ita lark of faith
lit the possibility .of- aly ad-,
journmeut by tabling he Wright
resolution pissed hf the House on
Saturday providing that bo roll call
bills shall be introduced after today
and contemplating final adjournment
on Saturday.
The anti primary Mil was fathered
by 8cnator Hams, and is identical
with that offered ia the House last
night. CT
Tk mosnra was nroDoeed ia the
House at the regular session but did
aot reach the Senate.
The bill regulating the acta of the
- (Continued oa Page Two)
TO GOJN TODAY
Wilf Present Bill For Consti
tutional Convention This
Morning
Senator Harry Stubbs has aa
uounced that this morning he will
introduce in the Senate a bill sub
mittinr to the next r nl election
the. question of a e "al eon
veation. The bill i the af
fi rotative totee of t. of all
the member of each branch of the
General Assembly and it ie expected
that the Scaate. which passed it
overwhelmingly at the regular sea
sion, wilt De aiaea to aci upon
the measure today in order that it
may be sent to thi Hoaw of Hpre
secta'ives, where .'t wae defeated
last March.
First Introduced la 1M7.
Senator 8tubba first introduced the
bill back ia )SK)7 and it waa reintro
duced nt every subsequent session
until 1917 when the measure re
ceived the necessary two-thirds vote
in both branches of the legislature
and an election was rodered. How
ever, war waa declared betwoeB the
adjournment of legislature and the
next general election ana oy general
consent the question waa not euo
mittcd to the people and no conven
tion has ben held since 1875.
Senator Btnhbs, who has alternated
between the Housa and the Bennte
for the past fourteen tensions hae
several times seen hia pet measure
passed in the branch of which he
was a member only to have it killed
in the other body. This hsppened at
he regular aessioa of the present
ieneral Assembly, when the Senate
passed the bill by a vote of 43 to 4
but it was lost in the House.
A number of representativee who
voted aninst the measure ia the
reeular sessioa have already ex
pressed themselves as being favorable
to it now and it is eoBaidered mat
under the leadership of ex-Speaker
Walter Murphy, who haa also been a
staunch supporter of the bill since
it was flrat introduced, the bill haa
a good chance of paasage in the lower
House.
But while the bill ha formidable
support it ha also strenuous opposi
tion and a stiff fight is expected
when it reaches the lower House.
The fight against was led last March
by Representative Doughton, who is
reported to be still opposed to It
pasaage aad Governor Morriaoa aad
Commissioner of Revenue Watt are
also said to have actively aligned
themselves with the opponent of the
bill-
New Bin Dtfereat.
The new draft of the Stnbbe bill
differ ia two importaat particulars
from that pawed by the Boaato at
the regular seaeioa .Th question of
eoBveBtloa' or ae eoaveatioa'
wUl, if th bill passes, be submitted
to the voters at the general electioa
ia November, 1922. It wa originally
proposed that delegate to the eoa
veatioa be sieetod at the nam time,
bat it is bow provided that a special
electioa be held for that parpoae
oa the seeoad Tueoday ia April, MS,
it bsiag specified tV the ceveatioa
(hall oasemUej oa Wednesday after
the (ret Monday ia May.
Thi chaatja waa made ia defer aee
to the views f a ansaber of mem
bers ef both Hosjaea waa exprrseed
the belief that delegate weald be af
a aigher eaiibre If they were aot
toejaired to affer themselves a aoa-
dtdatM before the eoaveatioa shoald
Ueeata a certainty, aad if taair
eaeee eejl be removed freea the
that amwBHaaie a recast
rlcctioB. , i
Oaty Oa StttJag.
TV" other baportaat chase 'ro-
merc the sreviaioa, that the ooa
eoaUoa aboald reoea for tixty day,
after a aeaetoa af thirty day do
eatoi tolely to tha abrnhmieti of
Bameata to ta peoaeat
j(CaUaa4 fag. TwaJi '
STUBBS MEASURE
House Committee Will Hear
Primary Repeal Bill This
Morning
EVERETT ASKS ASSEMBLY
TO OPPOSE 4-P0WER PACT
Bnih of Hew Bills 'in Honie
Banishes Hope of Ad.
jonrnment
BrpwafTrf the State-wide primary,
defeated substantially, at the regular
session of the General Assembly,
took a eecond start in the House of
Representatives last night with the
introduction of a measure by Repre
sentative Neal of McDowell, pro
riding for the scrapping of the
present system of nominating can
didates for State office, but leaving
the use of the primary oa a piece
of county machinery to the option
of the county.
The primary repeal Dill wae re
ferred to the Committee oa Prop
ositions and Grievances and will
come up for a hearing before this
committee this morning at 9:30.
Within aiirht of tha exniration
of the tentative time limit for the
introduction of Btr legislation1,
members of the House rushed across
practically every piece of legisls
tioa that is ia sight for the present
sitting of the General Assembly.
Many aeats were vacant, members
having aot yet returned from their
week-end tries home, and a num
ber have obtained permanent leave
of absence.
Condemnation of the strongest sort
of the Four Power Treaty adopted
at the Disarmament Conference last
Baur'day waa offered in a joint re so
(Continued on Page Two)
KELLY TESTIFIES
Denies Transactions Alleged
By Government Witnesses
In Automobile Case
C. J. Kelly, Sanford automobile
dealer, one of five , defendant on
trial in Unjted State Ds'.rlct court
on charge oi interstate tram- m
stolen automobiles, took the stand
ia. hia own behalf yesterday aftor-
aooa OS the first wUness for th de
fen. When court recessed for the
evening he wo ftill en th stand,
after an hours examination, counsel
for the defense asking for more time
in which to review transcripts of the
evidence of last week. Indications
yesterday were that the rase would
not be completed beore Thursday.
Kelly declared that he had never
made arrangements with A. W. Hoff
man, major in New York National
Guard, one of the defendants who.
testified against Kelly as a govern
ment witness, by which Hoffman
would act a hi agent ia
New York for th purchase of ears.
He denied ail knowledge of the
Cadulae touring ear which Harry
Craig, another defendant and gov
ernment witness, testified he had
sold Kelly in exchange for three
stolen Fords. He d ied ever having
aay conversation with Frank Moran,
defendant and government witness,
or with William Nolan relative to
securing etolen automobiles fcr him.
Since 1919 when he went into the
automobile business in Sanford, the
defendant testified, he handled
1100,000 worth of ears. About fifty
of these, he aaid, he aecured through
Hoffman aad ninety per cent of the
fifty were pew ears. Not all of these
were sold la Sanford, he testified,
some of them being disposed of ia
South Carolina.
Hefsnaa TostiSe Agala.
When th automobile ease wa re
lumed in the Court yesterday after
noon at 2:30, District Attorney E. F.
Aydlett, who announced that he
would rest his ease Friday, with the
privilege of introducing a little
more evidence a sooa aa witnesses
arrived, offered several exhibits,
principal one being registrstion
cords which Major Hoffman alleged
George Scott, one of the defendants,
snd former member of the 7Tew
York Automobile Squad, had given
him when, for a eoniidertkm of
$300, Scott agreed aot jn follow np
laiormauoa ae naa secured that
automobile Hoffman' .hid bourht
from More sad Nolan hid bees
stolen.
District Attorney Aydlett oue-
tioaed the witaeee furUier eoaeera-
ing the alleged arrangement be
tween hia aad Scott, aad oa cross
lamination Jaae W. Osborne,
attorney lor Beott, continued the
probe.
atecttos CeavarBattoa
Asked a to th exact eoavenetioa
which passed betweea him aad
Scott, the witaees declared eould
aot recall what was said verbatim.
H related, however, that Scott ap
Breached him, asking if he knew
that all th ear h had bonght from
Moraa aad Kolas were it o lea. Whea
th wita expressed sarpriae,
Beott, a aiid, assured him it was
a fact aad farther that h weald be
arrested.
1 aaked him If there was aay way
to atraigktea it at," testified Hoff
man, who declared that Scott agreed
to Bocept snoBey aad that,' aa th
spot, he gave Scott betweea 7S or
1100 aad at ether time gavs aim
eaoogh to mak W00.
T mtrer aa aa JUloa tat tw
ford which h alleged was thea in
hi peoaoaaio, Hoffaua "said that
Scott gars aim' six rogiet ratio sards.
tw t Which a thea tiled at, aa
tea to Cedilla tad f or a lord.
IN OWN BEHALF
any Taaoa at d -TaklBf
th Btaad la hi own behalf,
XCoatlaaod aa) fag ThJxtoaJ
FIRST DEBATEON
FOUR-PLY TREATY
ON SENATE FLOOR
Senator Borah Attacks Ar
ticle Two of Agreement
;. With Japan
REAL DISARMAMENT
BECOMES NECESSARY
Senator Jim Bead, Another
''IrreconcilaDle" Also At
tacks New Treaty While
Senators Poindezter and
Robinson Defend It; Moral
Obligation, Says Borah
Washington, Dee. 12. Th Senate
got its first taste today of the fight
promised by several Senators on the
new four power Pacific treaty. The
pact was both denounced and do
fended in the course of two hours
of discussion.
As st ths opening of the long
fight on tit Treaty, of, Versailles
and its League of Nations covenant
practically all of the new quadruple
treaty wai read ia to the Congrei
sional Record la advance of formal
submission.
Borah Breaks Silence
The attack today came from two
"irreconcilables" in the Versailles
covenant controversy, Senator Borah,
Republican, of Idaho, and Reed,
Democrat, of Missouri. Breaking
the silence he had maintained since
the treaty was laid before the world.
Mr. Borah spoke more than an hour
devoting his attention to Article
two of the new treaty which he
compared to Article Ten of the Ver
sailles covenant. lie declared that
the treaty compelled the armament
conference to make "real disarma
ment" an actuality or make the
treaty a "straight ont military alli
ance." i
Mr. Borah xplalned that his atti
tude toward th treaty would be
governed to an extent by progress
of the conference toward "real dis
armament'' and settlement of Chi
nes questions. The work of the
Washington conference, he said,
would be "discouraging" if it ad
journed without barring, by terms
of th treaty, the use of submarines,
poisonous gases and other bar
barous" weapons of warfare.
Defends Article Tw
Defense of the pact, conducted
largely by Senator Poindegter, Re
publican, of Washington, resulted in
th opening of ths whole question
of what obligations were entailed
upon the United States by the new
agreement. Senator Poindexter told
the Senate that some seemed unduly
alarmed about the pact and de
clared that Article Two could not be
construed as ths equivalent of
Article Ten.
- Senator Reed, breaking Into the
debate at this point, said Senator
Poindexter 's statement- meant that
th new treaty wa worth little as
a binding agreement. He aided that
if the United State wa not going
to obscrv it moral obligations,
such as he contended were contain
ed in the treaty, the country would
become "the laughing stock of the
whole world."
Mr. Borah said be regarded the
moral obligations of Arti-.lj twu as
compelling the use of force, as
trongly as did Artirlj ten ef the
League and in this wis support?!
by Senator Robinson, Democrat, Ar
ksnsas, who declared that take" to
gether articles one and two of the
treaty were "even stronger" than
Article Ten. Mr. Robinson added,
however, that he was entering no
objection to llio psct. 1
"How woul they oppose an, ag
gressive policy on the part of pme
nation, for instance," interrupted
Mr- Seed, "in event the conference
(Continued on Page Two.)
Col. J. Bryan Grimes Favors
Constitutional Convention
''Considering that we have had ao
much patchwork and so many make
shift amendments to our Constf
tutioa recently, I think that we are
in need of a Constitutions! Conven
tion, if it can he properly safe
guarded," say Colonel J. Bryan
Grime, Secretary of Stat, in a
communicatioa to The News and
Observer brought forth by Sunday'
front page editorial on the need ef
such a convention. Colonel Grimel
thinks that the fatal defjt of other
constitutloaai convection bill haa
been the sbeene f a provision for
its ratification.
Ia hi letter to the editor Colonel
Grime says:
Sir:
"I bar read your editorial for th
seed of a Constitutional Conven
tion. Coasidariaf that we kav hod
so mnch patch work and so many
makeshift aasendmenta to our Cos-
sfltutUa reeeatly, I think, thit we
or la aoed of a Constitutions! Con
vention, if it can be properly safe
guarded.
"Ia aa act to eall a Convention f
Ik peopi of North Carolina pas
ted by th General Assembly i
1917 there' wa a fetal defect ia
that, there waa bo- protiiioa Is th
set for a tatiSratioa by th people
ef the work af th Coaveatioa.
The bill calling a Coaveatioa,
passed by th Seeute ia 1921 aad
defeated la the Eaa ef Bepreecsta
tivoa, did aot prwvid for th rati
leatioa ef th work ef th Conves
ttoa by th people f th Btst.
If th Omattoa I to to tsksa
a gatkeriaf af rf raUiivto,'
PRESIDENT NOT TO
CALL CONFERENCE
ON FOREIGN DEBTS
Neither Will United States
Be Represented at Euro
pean Parley
REPARATIONS IS KEY
TO WHOLE SITUATION
No Beal Progress Toward
Eeonomio Reconstruction
In Europe Until England,
France and Germany Can
Get Together On Payment
of Penalties For War
By FRANK H. BIMONDSf
Washington, Dee. 12. President
Harding will not call an economic
conference to meet in this city at
the cloie of the present conference
If, as seem likely now, aa economic
conference i called to meet in Brua
Psels or some other European capital
early in the year, the United States
will not be represented unless there
ia a very radical change of mind.
These two circumstances which be
came known 16dy' constituted a
very severe disappointment to not a
few of the representatives of the
foreign countries in this city, many
of whom have recently expressed the
hope that the United States would
st lesst share ia a European econo
mic discussion, which has been msde
inevitable by the rereitf German de
fault. The American decision would seem
to be based upon two factors, one
foreign and the other domestic. It
is the prevailing point of view, ss
I pointed out in my last Sunday
article, that no useful end -can be
served by any economic conference
as long as the reparations issue re
mains unsettled, and there is no
American desire to undertahe the
responsibility and the obvious dan
gers incident to bringing abont such
a settlement
Reparations Famishes Key
From the American official point
of view, the key of the whole situa
tion in Kurnpe at the present time,
though the United States Is only in
terested in the economic acpects,
must be sought in the reparation!
Issue. The idea that the watch of
the world can be set to ticking again
while Great Britain and France are
at loggerheads over reparations is
held to be manifestly absurd. The
United States hat very great inter
ests at stk, these interest repre
eented, by her foreign trad which
continue te declln with obvious
evil consequences in all directions.
But the eontemparary question is:
What useful purpose ran the United
States serve by participating in any
conference as long as the fuudamen
tal conditions remain both unsound
and unstable t
There is a very widespread belief
here that no real progress will be
made toward economic reconstruc
tion in Europe or in the world until
England, France and Germany ran
reach agreement on the whole sub
ject of reparations. There is no dis
guising the fact thast American ex
pert opinion is on the whole fnr
more sympathetic to the British
than to th French point of view.
At the Taria ronfetrnee and since
the Pari conference American .ex
pert opinion, official and unofficial
has continued to believe that there
was not the slightest prospect of
collecting from Germany anything
like the sums which were expected
at Paris and actually named in the
decisions of last May. But the Uni
ted States is not one of the partjes
to reparations and haa no intention
of undertaking to participate in a
discusson which would obviously
lead to a request for American assis
tance, financial and otherwise.
Beetile Te Caacessioas.
Th decision not to participate ia
on economic conference ia also
(Continued in Page Two.)
or 'a an assemblage of the people,'
their ordinances wall be final the
organic law. If they are regarded
as "delegates," which is becoming
ths more generally accepted view,
the Constitutioa would be submit
ted to s referendum of the people.
A requirement for popular ratifica
tion would strsngthea the bill, and
I believe, the people will expect to
vot upon th new Constitution.
"Th Constitutioa ef th Conven
tion of waa voted apoa by the
people. The Convention of 1M5
amounted to little, though some of its
proceedings were declared valid. The
Constitution of lSAS was ratified by
the people. The eall for a Conven
tion in 1872 wss defeated by the
people, under Grant' threats. Tho
amendment of 187S-T3 were ratified
by the people ia 1873. The Coa
veatioa of 187S wss ratified .by the
peop'e. Tier has never bees held
a Convention who work wss not
submitted to th peopls, Bales it
ws ths Convention ef 1861 i aad
Chapter 17, Laws ef J 80 -J1, "Aa
act concerning a eoaveatioa ef the
people' ia lectins tea required the
rdiaaaaee ef th eowvewtioa to be
ratified by "a majority ef the
qualified voter." Of. eoarss, all th
omsadmeats la tit past hav bee
passed spOB by vet f u peo
ple. . .
"It argaed that th CoBveatloa
would be ,-Bprm" aad eould aot
be required to wbialt ft Coasti
tatioa to the people. Thi eon be
easily remedied by Twqmiring sack
(Catlaa aa Fag Tn I
JAPAN RETAINS CONTROL
OF ISLAND OF YAP UNDER
AGREEMENT WITH AMERICA
New Four-Power Treaty
Beginning Of New Way
Distinctive Feature is Participation of Two Possible An
tagonists, America and Japan, In'An Agreement With
England and France Called In To ;AssiMf;Hr'Gr! Wells
Says.
By H. ii. WELLS
(By arrangement with the New York World and the Chicago Tribune)
The read rr mil have seen verbatim reports of the speeches at the
fourth plenary session of the Washington conference and he will knon
already what decisions were banded out to us from the
more or less secret session that prepared them for us.
There has been a" good deal o(. discussions hen
about the secret sessions, snd certain indignation at
their secrecy that 1 do not share. It ia a matter of
deeenry rather than concealment that men speaking
various languages, representing complicated interests,
and feeling their way towards understandings, should
not be exposed to embarrassing observation and com
ment until they have properly hammered out what Ithey
have to say. It is far better to digest conclusions un.l r
rover and to present the agreed upon conclusion. This
wv af
m..
1 no. offense against democracy; no conspiracy against juiblicity. Thr
mischief of secrecy lies ia secret treaties snd secret understandings and
not in "protecled' interehangesi There b no sound' objection "to secret bs r
gaining in committee, provided that finally the public is informed of the
agreement arrived at and ef all th considerations in the ear gum.
"""" " The conclusion nnivniincad are im
BIG INCREASE IN
COTTON ESTIMATE
Government Dept. Claims To
Have Been Misled
Previously
Washington, Dee. 12 In announc
ing it final estimate of cotton pro
duct ion for thi yer a 8,140,000
bales, which is 1,800,244 bale more
thsn given in th preliminary esti
mate in October, the Department of
agriculture placed the blame for the
estimates earlier in the season on
"persistent and widespread prop
ganda at planting time aa to acreage,
and lack of travel funifs which pre
voat4 statistician of th govern
ment Jfrom personally inspecting
and checking reports.
Ths crop reporting board, th de
partment of agriculture announced,
"wo forced to accept growers' re
port! of acreage reduction, which
were biased by propaganda and gen
erally believed."
In a statement issued with the
government's estimate today the de
part ment of agriculture said:
"The December eottoa report, for
casting a total crop of 8,340,000
bales, is much in excess of earlier
estimates during the growing les
son. It may be will, therefore to
explain the principal factors whirh
account for the difference between
the early promise and the last esti
mate. 'Acreage. (1) persisteat and
widespread propaganda at planting
time for a reduction in cotton acre
age of from 33 to SO per cent as
compared with 1920, (2) Propaganda
supported by large carry over from
previous season, low prices below
rost of production ia 1920, reduced
foreign construction and demand
with great financial loss to growers
in IS-'1! and lark of credit at plant
ing time, (3) acreage reduction re
ported st planting time by growers
affected ler propagnada, (4) lack of
travel funds prevented statisticians
of the bureau from personally in
specting and checking acreage in
their states in 1919, 1920 snd first
half of 1921, (5) crop reporting
board forced to accept growers re
port ef acreage reduction which
were biased by propaganda and gen
erally believed, (6) since July 1
field statisticians have been able to
travel snd their reporta indicate that
the growers reports on June 23 ex
aggerated the reduction in acreage.
It appears that while many growers
actually reduced their acreage,
others took advantage of the props
gaoda sentiment for reduction and
proceeded to increase their own
acreages, (7) the estimate of the
seres Be in cultivation of June 26
was corrected when checked against
data submitted by growers nt that
time, but it now appears thst the
data opon which the estimate waa
(Continued en Page Nine.)
20TTON ESTIMATE TAKES
MABKET BY SURPRISE.
New Orleans, Dec 11 The crop
estimato of S,S4a,M bales by lb
Desartmeat of Agrkaltw took
th eottoa market completely by
ssrprm today aad Immodistoly
after th lasaaar af th Sgaros
there wa break of III to 111
Bwiat or Ja sbwit M M s bal aa
the reaast of seillag from all parts
f th belt.
Th trade amorally expected a
report of vary Mttl ever eight
saillssa bale, th average gwess of
III akssab of th easts -raaag
ssard stoat aa boar be
for Ah resort was assess, being
MMN balas-
Jast before the Scares were pat
sat Jaaaary stood at 17.14
a aaaadl ha toss taaa Sve mlaataa
it draapad to IMS. March stood
st 1TJI bad drapped to 11M.
It waa aa af to sat stropa
aaa ssastoa laarroral ssMtas aad
a tremsadaa vwlaat of hoe Is
wsa a Mtowtag the
heavy astllBsj l lg fi
th Wag sad wall t
Trtaa
portant enough in themselves; but
to all who care for the peace of thi
orld they are far more important
in the vista of posnihilitiet they open
up. Certain nojshle precedents arc
established. The four Knot rrolu
lions do put very clearly those idian
of withdrawal and abstinence whirh
must become the universal rule of
conduct between efficient and po
liica:Iy confused or enfeebled States
if the peace of the or d is to be
preserved. That is the New Way in
international politics. It is the le
ginning of the end of all Asiatic im
prrialisnis.
And following up its assent to
these resolutions the conference
oted upon certain special applica
cation of them. The abolition, df
the eitra territorial grievance, the
right of China ss a neutral pomr
to escape the fate of Belgium and
the right of China to be informed
of the articles of any treaty affect
ing her, were established aa far na
a resolution of the conference eouid
vublish them.
'reataree" Senator Lodge.
And- thea came Senator Lodge.
tor the fourth plenary session
"featured" Senator Udge, Just a
previous ones hsd ''featured" Bee
retsry Hughes, Mr. Balfour and M.
Briand. Fifteen years ago I came
to Washington and Senator Ixidge
showed me a collection of prehistoric
objects from t'eutral America and
tolked very delightfully about thoui.
Fifteen years have changed Wash
ington very greatly but they have
not changed Senator Idge. He
seems perhaps just a little slenderer
and neater than before, but that
may be a change in my own stand
srils, and it was entirely in charac
ter with my former Impressions of
bim that in putting ths Four Powers
treaty before the conference he
should indulge himself and his hear
ers in a vision of the realities of
the Pacific, the multitudiuus interest
of its innumersble islands, its in
finite variety of races, customs, eli
mates and atmosphere. It wss a
most curious and 'attractive phase
of the always interesting conference
to have this gray headed, cultivated
gentleman breaking through all the
aUtract jargon of diplomacy and
ins'itarism, ill the talk of powers,
radii of action, fortification, spheres
of influence, and so forth, in his
sttempts to make us realir.e the
physical loveliness and intellectual
charm of thi enormous area of the
world s sorfaes thst th Four Pow
er treaty may perhaps ssve now
forever more from the fesr and hor
rors of war.
The proposed four-power treaty
which thus starts upon its uncertain
but hopeful journey towards ratifi
cation by the Senates, Legislatures,
and governments of the world is es
sentially a departure from the nor
mal tradition of the treaties of the
nineteenth century. It ia the first
attempt to realise what shall I call
itf The American Way or the Niw
Way in international affairs. its
distinctive feature is the rjarticria
tion of two possible antagonists,
America aad Jcpaa. Instead uf a
war, they make a treaty and call in
Britain and France to sm' It is
a treaty for peace and aot sgainst,
an antagonist. I think tha tthe dif
ference between "treatire for" and
"treaties against" is one that seeds
to be stressed. The Angti Jparie
treaty was s "treaty against," a
treaty against first, Bussia, thea
Germany and thea against soma
vaguely conceived assailant. It is
a great thing to have Japan and
England cordially immolating that
treaty, now that this four power
treaty of the New Spirit may be
bora.
Greet Speech By VIvlaaL
After Seaator Lodg tm V. VI
viani with i very fine, if guarded,
speech. M. Viviaai is n great spesk-
er, bat he is not merely eloqueat,
aad I Sad people here sayiog little
about his woaderful voice or his
evertoBos ssd sndertoses or hi ro
mantic charm, but mnch about the
subtle thiegs hs said. Ia a gathering
that is teas with Sttention sas is
opt perhaps to transfer oas s
thoaght sad expeetstions to the
gathering a a whole, bat it seems
to m that whea M. Viviaai rose te
weleoas thi great bogiaaing the
Pacific w were aU thinking: "Asd
hew mock farther sad to what ether
regio ef th world are yea pro
pared to xtsd th spirit aad
method ef this Pacific haadf There
hi axtbr rather thread bare treaty
(Caatlaaed a aaa) Wa) " .
United States Secures Cable
and Wireless Privileges
His v a. . .
rur wnrcn we ttas
Contended
ABSOLUTE EQUALITY
ACCORDED BY TREATY
TO TWO GOVERNMENTS
No American Radio Station
Will Be Installed So Long
As Japanese Plant Is Ops
rated Without Diicrlm
ination; Immediate Valns
of Arrangement To United
States Lies In Conces
sions That Insure Ameri-
can Control of Cable Be
tween Yap and Guam;
Text of New Treaty An
nounced In Washington
Washington, Dec. 12. (By the As
sociated Press.)- The American and
Japanese governments have compos
ed their differences over the Pacific
Island of Yap, and sre urcnarinn
to sign a treaty by which Japan
retains adiiiinsitrativo control over
ihe island and the Cnited Btates
recures the cable and "ire less priv
ileges there for which mUm haa mm.
tended since tho Pari -conference. 1
in the same treaty Japan s League
of Vtions msndate over Yap snd
all the other Northern Pacific Is.
ijuuti foriiw.rlv im.lap I
eruignty is give'n recognition by ths
i mien rentes on certain stipulated
conditions. ThetA rnn.litinHa In.
elude provision far free admission
vi missionaries ana protection Of
American interest in tha tn-nlaf.l
territory and require that Japan,
snail report ia me Lnilea wtstee
s well as to the league en detain)
of her administration of the mis
date .
The Yap cable and wireless rights,
regarded as highly important be
reuse' of the Island's advantageous
position ia the center of the Pa
cine group to the south e Japan
are accorded liy the treaty te ths
American ami J.-mnnoM
mcnts and Nationals alike, on term
ef absolute equality. In the exercise
of thess rights American Nationals
sre to be free from taxes, liccsiiug,
censorship nnd every form of dis
criminatory supervision-, snd in ad
dition are to be aided by the Jan
anese government in securing th
needed property and facilities.
The immediate vslue of the ar
rangement to the I'nited State
I- truiiecBsiuui w un mgasa
to cable communication hati
they insure complete American goa-
iroi or uie existing ralile betweta
Yap and tiuain. 'oniilrhla km.
nortnnr- uAma ia a 1 f l.d - i -' --
can officials to the radio privilege.
aiuiougn ii is to be agreed la the
treaty that no American radio sta
tion wi'l be installed an la a.
the present Japanese plant is ep
crated without discriminatory ex
actions. (Signature of the eonvenlioa
is expected within a few day,'
easing of the principal canter for
controversy betneen Washington,
and Tokio and bringing to as sad
negotiations which have covers!
period of several months.
rinal instructions to the Japanese
delegates to accept the latest Amer
ican proposal for a settlement are
understood to have been received
from the Tokio foreign office last
night. .
TEXT OF NEW TREATY IS
GIVEN OUT IN WASHINGTON.
Washington, Dec. 12. (Bv Th As
sociated Press). The text of a
treaty between the United Bute and
Jspsn covering an agreement as to
the status of the Island of Yap wa
mnae punne roaay at the rttste De
partment. The points of the agree
ment are ae follows:
1 It is agreed that hs Carted
fitwte shall have free oceest to th
Island of Yap on the footing orSa
tire equality with Japan or any
other nation, in all that relate to
the landing and operation of th
existingYaj) (iuam cable or of any
coble WnVh "may hereafter be laid
by the I'nited State or its Bstionab,
t It is also agreed that the Uai
ted State and ita national srs to
be accorded the same rights and priv
ileges with respect to radio tel
graph ie eerviee as with regard to
rsbles. It is provided that so long
as the Japanese government shall
maintain on tha Island of Yip aa
adequate radio telegraphic statiea
ro-opemting effectively with th ca
bles and with other radio station a
shin and ahores, without discrimina
tory exertions or preference, tha
exercise of the right to eetablieh
radio telegraphic station at Tap by
th United Htrte or its sitings! .
hall be suspended. : ,-
S-It is further agreed that th
United Slate shsll enjoy la th
Island of isp ths follow lag righto,
privileges sad exemptions ia rehitioa
to electrical eomauaieatioa:
(a) Bights of residence witheet r -
strirtioa; and rights of acquisition
aad smjymest ef aadistarbed pee-..
a -auvH, ,wi m iMa a. watu j .
- I: T .L -
rnjHaUll -Jii m , H va m mJ fMH M-fc
tioa sr their respective aatieaali
an ytvywt i j a vi Mmvn ia pvi-
seasl sad real, including had,,
bsilding, residear, . Deas, Work ,
asd a pp ateam aces. . . :
(b) N permit r Ucaas to b re
quired for th nJoymBt af aar af
Use right aad privileges. . T -. --"
() Each asaatry to M free to
yrta boU ad af tt cable, sithw
j.CaiUd aa pog Olrto "