LEG I SLAT I V DEBA T E S .
Wednesday, Dec 13.
Mr Steele's Resolutions being brforo ihe
llouso Mr. AIebane offered the following amend
ment :
"Resolved, That the just and rightful method
of settling the question of extending Slavery over
the Territories of the United Elates, acquired by
the recent treat? with Mexico, would be by the
continuation of the line of the Missouri Compro
mise to the Pacific Uccan
ltfo S-rcrtc thru took the floor, and spoke as 1
--
follows :
Mr. Speaker : When, some days ajo, I saw
proper to introduce the resolutions, which have
just been read, I did not intend to say one word in
their behalf. My object, in rising now, is chiefly,
to make some explanation of the reasons which
influenced me to bring. thern forward, and to dis
claim the object, which has been, by some per
sons; attributed to me.
fti trw'mcr the reason, sir. which caused the in
troduction of these resolutions, I shall be obliged J
to 6tate briefly why I think they should be favor- j
ably acted upon by the General Assembly. I
shall not touch, at present, upon the constitutional .
Question involved, but, if at any other period of j
the session, I shall feel called upon, in justice t
myself to make any other remarks, I shall then
give in extenso, the " reasons of the faith which is
ia me."
It was supposed at first, by some members of
this House and by others, 1 understand, that one
of the objects, which I had in view, was to con
denin, by a solemn Legispative resolve, the con
duct and opinions of one of the distinguished gen
tlemen, who represent North Carolina in the
Senate of the United State?. Sir, I, disclaim
having had such intention. Nothing was fan her
from my mind. I trust too, Mr. Speakor. that I
would be one of the last men on this floor, who '
would attempt to inflict a blow upon a talented '
eon of my own State, by a means so indirect. I
have too high a respect for the intellectual creat
ress of the individual in question too much re
spect, I hope, for myself, to attempt to infl ct a
stab in the dark. No sir. If Iliad designed a
rebuke of the course of that honorable Senator,
I trust I have friends enough here and elsewhere,
who believe that I am above such a step who
think that I have honesty and independence e
rough to attack him openly. This I hope, will
be sufficient to satisfy any man that a covert as
sault was not intended, upon one or the ab!o n;e:i
who represent this State in the Senate.
Sir, we are in a critical situation. The true
issue presented, is between political independence
and political degradation. Suppose these Peso,
lutions are not sanctioned, what will be the re
sult 1 Will not that fact be known bv the people
of the North! Will it not be said, that a set of !
Resolutions, declaring that the Congress of the
United States has no power, under the Constitu
tion, to interdict slavery in the acquired Territo
ries, was introduced into the Legislature of a !
is u Ltiti t j i u l uiiu l uvii i i.ic I; ;i iiu.- i i ; ; 1 1 1 di .1
-, f i ,, ,, , . , i
"r""1 ",c "'cu.ui.-io, mat nicv wcic n-it-Lit-u : ;
V ill not thp nponlp of th Ann ipm Si- i-pj r.-.
gard this as evincing a carelessness or. our part, j
..... rr - i
as to what course they may pursue J There can
be no doubt of.it. Repel them, and you add an !
endorsement to their fanatical course. Vou will !
make them believe that you care cot if they bind
yon that you yield your assent to a law which
makes you " hewers of wood and drawers of wa
ter." Mr Speaker, can any man suppose that a
concession oa our part of the Constitutional au
thority of Congress to pass an act wh eh the
course of the Northern Representatives here.c
fore demonstrate that they are desirous to pass,
will have any tendency to deter them ? On the
contrary, it is evident that it will bo the very
, means which will expedite the infliction of their
tyranny.' They will regard us as too tame too
weak and servile to resist, by all just means in
our power, any encroachment upon our rights ;
and yielding submission, they will place the yoke
, upon our necks, and bear upon us forever.
It was admitted in Congress at the last session,
that the contest was for power. This is not de
nied. Yes, the contest is for power. Concede
their right to keep a Southern slaveholder from all
participation in the Territory of the United States
and you grant Northern fanaticism all it demands.
Can it be doubted that they will use this power !
Will it not be used to our injury ? If you ac
knowledge the right of any man to do what he
desires to do, you have the best reason to believe
he will avail himself of your concession. Ac
knowledge their right to restrict slavery, and it
will be done; and when done, we shall not even
have the poor and unsatisfactory consolation
"thou cans't not say I did it." When men o-et
im.o uve aaou or aoinff certain things, they know
not when to stop, and although now. it is argued
on all sides, that the Congress of the United
" i iu& oi nit; uiilltil
States has no right to interfere with questions of
slavery in the States, it will not be lonf before
some shrewd enemy will be blessed with a lucid
interval ; and by some new discovery, or a reve
lation from Heaven, pronounce the judgment of
the past an error. Men's views upon the pow
ers of Congress undergo great chances some-
tunes, and the opinion of to day will not be the
binding law for the future. Sir, if we concede
now the right of a majority to do us an injury in
one respect, and we ad certainly agree that what
they are disposed to do, would be a grievous one,
we have no guaranty as to what may be their for
bearance towards us hereafter in any other. On
the contrary, we know that one of the objects
for which our Northern brethren desire so ar
dently political power, is to enact such restric
tion laws, as to bring about a forced abolition ot
slavery in the States. Sir, let uj beware, before
it is too late. Let us remember that if we vield
once df we tamely submit to the imposition of I
tue yoKe it we oear the lash without a struggle,
our slavishness will be quoted for a precedent,
arid many an error, by the same example, will
rush into the State
I have stated, Mr, Speaker, that one of the ob
jects, in truth, 6ir, the chief, if not the only one
which the agitators of ihe Free Soil movement
have in view, is Iho attainment of an overwhelm
ing power, in the Congress of the United States
Now, sir, I would ask for what can they design
this power? To pass laws "necessary for the
public good" to carry out Fchemes of Internal
Improvement, by the Government, or in general
to do all things, which may be advantageous
to the whole Country. I cannot believe Tt. I
learned from an intelligent and highly estimah'e
gentleman, a resident of one of the Roanoke
Counties tu this State, thai he heard the distm
gutshed son of a disliogushed and wily states
man, say during ihe Ust summer, that the main
object the Free So.lers had in their movements,
was to produce, after a while, a forced abolition
of slavery in the 1 States. The word of ihe wily
statesman, to whom I refer, nii.hl once in lh
latitude" have stood against the world.
"Now none so poor as do him rev-rence."
To produce a forced abolition of slavery in the
States ! And how is Ibis mighty result to be ef
fected 1 By confining it to its present limits let
ting the slaves increase so greatly in number that
their labor would be profitless themselves a
burden to their masters, until the owners wouM
be glad to rid themselves of ihe incubus. ler
pJKlL1!? exuberant fancy of this quandam
wSif P,ClUred to' lne feekin b,a-'e. of the
AT.it 1"7ro'ed wi,h the M f the white.
Staieiiyorct.lne abo,i,ion of slavery in the
byhichiu!.0Tct l,,en P'r. if not the means
themselves bei be,ac:onplished, " our enemies
I canaoUh:nle J'JdrL3 " U ""constitu.ion
lhnk "difficult to UcmoMiraic
that the means ia also prohibited. But I prom
ised not to touch the constitutional qu-eation.
Mr. Speaker, I hold it lobe the duty, the bon
den -duty of the Legislature of this state, to de
clare the solemn protest of the people against the
enactment of this most loathsome measure.
Many of the Southern States have already done
so, aud shall we, still preserve our sleeping
name! Shall we be Rip Van Winkle slili !
But, sir, it is objected that the entertainment of
these resolutions will produce an extensive dis
cussion and their adoption will lead to no practi-
till iuuu uui in try it v'
do jrood. i nev will
show to onr ienreaentatives in Congress that
their constituents fully endorse their opposition
to the Wihnot Proviso will show to the North
ern people that we know our rights and dare
maintain" them. 1 do not know that they will
result in good. If I did if I was certain that
the passtfiie of these and similar resolut ions, would
.
j quiet the present alarming, and I fear porten
j tous agitation?, of the coontry restore it to that
I tranquility, which onr common destiny, and com
mon weal imperatively demand, I would be will
ing tint their discussion should ab?orb our an
nual revenue. Even then, we should gain and
serve our constituents wcM.
I solemnly belive that the conduct of the north
ern people lias been designed as an insult. Else
why did they legislate upon the qucs-tion before
Territories were acquired J Von know, Mr.
Speaker, t!iat a very large portion of the North
ern Representatives believe that slavery cannot
exist in the acquired Territories, having been
abolished by an act of the Mexican Congress, un
less by a special act of oar Congress establishing
it, or permitting its establishment. It they arc
honest in this view, they must certainly design
to insult us. One thing is certain, they are eith
er dishonest or disdainful, and I belieie they are
both. Shall we dishonorably submit to he tram
pled upon? Shall we make no resistance. 1
should leel unworthy of the trust conli.led in me
by tnv coit ituents, were I to fail to struggle lor
the recognition cf their ri"!its, on so important
a question as this, or any or all occasntis. 1
Mr. Speaker, I dire to say r. few words upon an- ;
other matter certainly not a very pleasant one to 1
me. 1 have un.loj-tool that my cou luct in intro
ducing these Resolutions, has been objected to, by
sonic member of this body, and by others, because
i I did not consult rvith the leaders of my y utij .' Sir,
I feel under no obligation to con. ult with any one
: in the discharge of my duty. I will do as 1 please ;
and 1 can assure any man, who supprti.vs that I am
' to shape 1113' course, at the instigation of any one
to do as I may be hidden that he mistakes the man.
I Mj first objfet is to see whether I am rrzht, and if
i I believe so, I shall carry out the convictions of
judgment, 'uncaring consequences." I am an in
dependent representative of an independent constit
; uency. I know the feelings and wishes of those by
whose urn duos anil confidence, I nm .McgiteJ here
to represent their interests, far better than any man
here, and I can permit no man to determine t.r me
what 1 sh:Jil do. They have confided in my judg
ment, poor and weak though it be, to dj for them as
1 may deem fit and that confidence shall never be
betrayed, so long as ,: reason holds a seat":
within
! I ac-
- . . . ,
me. Consult with the leaders ot my party
, ii ... V, l.t ; 1 , ,. , .!;,,.,,,-,
- J J . .
tmt li-v MP.('Knpp. find never v ' 1 nm wii'inr
t0 g.WitU Vny party upon all questions of a p u t?
character. I am willimr, nay even desirous to hear
the suggestions of my political friends thcu but
upon a subject like this ubove party, I mast fce
permitted to do as I please.
Sir, I have said more than I intended. I may
have been in my course, guilty of imprudence, but
I trust, bv all riiiht-miudcd men. it will bo attribu
ted to an honest, if inefficient zeal, to see the riht3
of my constituents preserved the sifety of the
! .South maintained the compromises of our national
j compact fully carried out. aud the great ends of jus
' ticear.J equality subserved. I have believed that
j the conduct of the North, was not instigated by a
: love for the slave by a holy and christian desire to
1 see bis bonds fall off and himself ujust and free."
! It is not because they think slavery a moral and po
I litical evil corrupting the owner degrading his
moral character sapping his wealth and enervating
the growing energies and prosperity of the country.
And, I believe sir, that it is quite time for us of the
South to show them that we are freemen, jealous of
our rights.
This amendment having been rejected, Mr. Me
bane introduced the following:
11 Resolved, That his Excellency, the President of
the United States, did not violate the constitution in
giving bis official sanction to the Oregon bill, not
withstanding the clause in said bill prohibiting Sla
very in the Territory of Oregou'
When Mr. McDowell, of Iredell, aJJrcascJ the
House
Mr. McDowell would express his views before
the vote on this amendment offered by the gentleman
from Orange, was taken. He was opposed to having
any such a clog attached to these resolutions, plain
1 he design of these rcso-
lutions is to shadow forth in unequivocal terras,
' the decided voice of the people of North Carolina,
! for moral effect upon the action of Conzress.
i lor moral tut'tt uj'uu iuc ;ii;wuii vi oilgr
The custom of discussing national politic in
Legislatures, had its origin at an early d y. A
Stat,e
vuiee
from the ol 1 Dominion, where weeks are still con
sumed in debating national affairs, once told with
power, not only upon the action of Congress, but
upon most States, though at this day the voice of
any oue State is but little regarded, and the resolu
tions may fail in their design. Though opposed to
their introduction, having the utmost confidence in
the patriotiim of our representatives, touching this
great question, yet as these resolutions have been
introduced, he" was unwilling to reject hj?m, lest
the fact might be construed as a virtual abandon
ment of the constitutional question, as they did in
the case of Mr. Polk:s signing the Oregon bill with
th proviso attached. These resolutions in plain and
poiuted language, declare that Congress has no right
to make any law cr doany act, that shall diiectlyor
by its effects make any discrimination beteween the
States of this Union. The Constitution declares,
that Congress shall have power to mike all needful
laws and regulations concerning the Territory of the
United Statcs: but the Ncrth says, to throw the arm
of protection over the slave holder, is not a needful
regulation, while the South declares it is. So the
dispute turns upon the point of utility. The Con
stitution settles this question, in the 9th article of
the amendments, which declares the reservation in the
Constitution of certain rights shall not be construed
to deny or disparage others retained by the p'ople
ov, sir. if a citizen of the orth and cne of the
South, should emigrate to a territory under theju
risdiction of Congress, with their resncrt ivr n;-nn..r.
I tics, and Congress should thr;.w the arm of civifhiw
over the one. and withhold it from the other ilwr
would beau exercise of power disparaging the rights
which the southern citizen has always enjoyed.
Now to avoid this conclusion, some have denied that
slaves arc properly except by Statute law. Mr.
McDowell remarked, that, without going into the
abstract ques;iou of what constitutes property, iiias
much as the Const itutioa under which Congress
acts has not defined that question, they cannot de
cide it, nor protect the citizen of the JN'orth in his
property acknowledged as such by the Constitution
of the State and refuse the same to the Southern
man in bis property declared as such by the Consti
tution of his State without disparaging or denyiuT
our rights; for it is expressly declared elsewhere
that the citizens of one State shall enjoy all the pri
vileges of citizens of the other States. And certain
ly, sir, it will not be asserted, that these rights and
privileges are removed by a removal to a Territory,
which can in no sense alter our responsibilities to
the General Government. If Congress has the pow
er to throw the arm of the civil law, over the citi
izens of a Territory nnd protect their property
against violence, it by no means follows, they cannot
withhold this protection at pleasure or exercise it
partially, as respects pcrsous ; for certainly, this
power of legislating must be controlled by the prin
ciples of equity, the spirit and letter of the Consti
tution. The power to govern, grows out of the right
of possession, but partiality or discrimination can not
oc justified under any clause of the Constitution
I f any other principle be admitted, tbe conclusion
dt-anu wculi U 50 monstrous, that reasoning back
against the deductions, would overthrow the premi
ses. But it may be asked what avail these resolutions,
when the Territory in dispute, by local law, forbids
the introduction of Slaves. This can be answered,
by asking another questson : Shall all the laws of a
foreign Territory' remain in force after its acqui
sition? If not, what shall be repealed ? Evidently
such as Congress has no authority to enact, under
the Constitution, if any such exist. If it be asked,
under what article Congress is bouud to protect the
slaveowner? Certaiuly by the same that requires
protection to any other property, ns they must act
impartially in all cases, be it slaves or other prop
erty. But why assuT. a position on this subject which
in the event our rights are trampled under foot,
we may not be able or willing to maintain. If
such an event should occur, what would be pro
per and expedient must be determined at anoth
er time, but the North should now know our
views, our feeling and our position, that they may
bo induced to pause long, before their acts should
keep us longer in the troubled water of political
strife, beyond which verges a dreary desert,
where anarchy and civil war hold a terrific sway,
with all their attendant train of horors. Ves,
they are a calculating peoole, greatly influenced
by the considerations of dollars and cents. They
ran readily perceive a change of our political re
lations woulucut oil onr commercial intercourse. '
Diverting onr channel of trade to England, vould i
rum their Cotton Mills, throw out of employ
ment hundred of operatives, and blight the pre
sent fair prospects of their fanners. Ves, all
that is wanted is a firm and united stand on the
part of the South, the North will yield us an e
quai participitio:'. of the Territories. Ves, her
interest will fore her to yield.
Mr. Ravuer begged to be excused from voting,
and 6tated his reasons for this request. The
scene witnessed here to-day (said Mr. R) had
been any otln-r thin one of pleasure1 to him
He thought tno in; roduction of these Resoiut'ons
ill-advised, and their consideration would he to
promote pariy ends and party purposes. These
Resolutions (said Mr. R) involve a grave ques
tion which should unng to their invest ration all
the ability of the Statesman and Patriot (here
Mr. R. was called to order.) Mr. R. then said
he was unwilling to appear to be against the sec-,
tion of country in which he lived, in which his
destinies were cast and which held his all ; but
as he was forced to vote, h ? would, no; withstand
ing Mr. Poik's own friends had deserted him, vote
to approve his ollieiil conduct touching this ques
tion vo'e as his consience and his heart told
was r.ghl lie would vote aye.
Mr. Stanly said he desired to stale that his re
fusing to vuie proceeded from no feeling of dis
courtesy towards the House Rut he took his
original position not oo blow the blaze kindled by
the introduction of these- Resolutions. lie
thought that the interests of his constituents re
quired him to oppose all agitation of this subject,
and he still occupied his fir ;t ground that this Le
gislature ought to leave this question and proceed
to the transaction of the people s business.
Tho amendment did not prevail.
Mr. M:!!er hero moved to pjjtpsne the whole
matter indefinitely.
Mr. Rayi.cr said ho was opposed to indefinite
postponement, lie thought that, as the Ilesolu
tions had been partially acted on. thcUouse ought
to consider and express smne opinion in regard
to the q',:s:io:i. Ho did not believe th .. t both
sides of the House would agree on the Resolu
tions, but that iii'y ir. ht on some omendment.
He could see no reason for introducing this ques
tion so as to bring about a d scussion that would
arou-e all the feelings of party. Doth parties he
thought, might aree on the first piopositioti of
the gentleman from Orange, ( Tins proposition
was the Missouri compromise.) and he was, there
fore, in favor of considering the Resolutions, and
would vote against postponement
Mr. Dobbin said he did not rise to discuss the
merits of the Resolutions before the House, lie
approved some of the remarks of the'gentleman
from Hertford, that the matter ought to be dis
cussed without parly feelings. But why, (said
Mr. D ) should Mr. Polk's conduct be attached to
the Resolutions? They contained principles dear
to every Southern heart; and wny encumber them
with such a proposition as that of the gentleman
from Orange "t borne of us on this side of the
House iconimued Mr. I)) voted at first for the
position because it approved of the conduct of the
President, hut on rellection we thought it best to
disencumber the Repolutions of any other matter.
He, tor one, was opposed to stirring up party feel
inga tie uiu not desire the demon ol party o
enter these halls he would be an unwelcome
visiter. But as the Resolutions had been intro
duced, he was opposed to postponement, and to
do so, he thought, would be virtually to vote a
gainst the principles of the Resolutions. He was
willing to put a stop to debate, and thus meet the
wishes of the gentleman from Beaufort.
Mk. Stanly said the gentleman from Cumber
land was for laving aside party but seemed to
forget that the Resolutions brought up party feel
ings and consideration?. Where, asked iIr. S.
had they their origin ? They sprung from South
Carolina they were a copy of Mr. Calhoun's
Resolutions they were Locofoco Resolutions
(not meaning by this, to call my friends over the
way by hard names ) The very source of the
Resolutions excited party feelings. 'Twas the
hand of Esau against Jacob and party feeling
would be aroused and the bitterness of party would
ihow itself.
When these Resolutions were introduced, the
chuckling of the Members on tiie other side of the
House was very apparent thy were pleased to
see the Whigs st.-t at logger-heads and smiled
to see a trap, as they thought, placed to catch the
foot of one of our Senators in. And even the
gentleman from Cumberland chuckled, and smil
ed and showed signs of pleasure at the state of
things in which the Whigs would be placed.
What, asked Mr. S is to, or can, come from the
consideration of Ihe Resolutions 7 Nothing but
mischief waste of time and neglect of public
j business. And does not the gentleman from
I Cum'.)'rland see that lh'se thing will be ? Al-
ready h.ive we had the conduct of Mr. Polk, the
I Constitution -.he past action of the Government
! and iho Wilnmt Proviso brought before the
; House. Can ihee things be and party feelings
remain unexciltd ; He had loreborne to discuss
j these Resolutions, and""would again appeal to the
House to quit this business and take up the con
sideration ot matters which they were sent here
to transact.
He was not like some of the members of the
House, afraid of the influence and action of the
Northern people. Ho knewthem he had been
among them and believed that they were devo
ted to the Union of the States. And he desired
that North Carolina should not take a position
Dy me siue or aouth Carolina on this ouestion.
Rather, said Mr. S. let her stand as a barrier to
the foolish excitement ever r lised by South Caro
lina in the bouth, anj the waves of fanctacism
pushed from the Norih by Jno. Van Buren and
1
n;s roacjulors.
Mr. Dobbin said he would say only a few
words. The gentleman from Beaufort had said
that i lie Resolutions would assume a partv char
acter and that the Wilmot Proviso would come
up&c. But why should this be? He thouaht
this a question on which all of the South should
be unitedthat it should neither belonrr to the
wings or Democrats that it was not a Whig
question, nor a J)emocraiic question. Why should
uoi coin parties of the South, on this question
meet the iNorth. in one solid phalanx shoulder
to shoulder? He did not think it necessary to
make this a party matter, nor did he believe it
iyould.be done, unless by the- introduction of a-1
mendrnentslo make party traps. But the' gentle
man from Beaufort says these Resolutions are
Calhoun's fiicofoco Resolutions. Well admit
that they were originated by a Lccofoco.they weie
introduced here by a Whig and it would seem
from this that they had not assumed a party char
acter. The gentleman from Beaufort had spoken
of the! chuckling produced by the introduction
of the Resolutions, and said that (Mr. D.'s) side
of the House was pleased with the djscord and
division they caused in the Whig ranks. For
any disunion that might prevail among the friends
of thelgentleman from Beaufort, his side of the
Housed was not responsible. And as to any cen
sure implied in the Resolutions against Mr- Bad
ger, for it was to him that allusion had been made
thalj if his object was to reach that Honorable
gentleman he would do it by no indirect means.
He would favor no such thing. He thought the
positioh of Mr. B. a wrong one : and if the Re
solutions contained right principles, ought he to
desist from advocating them, because Mr. B. dif
fered in his notions from him in regard to this
subject " Fiat J'aslilia ruat cerium" He would
vote fyr the passage of the Resolutions because
they contained principles in the truth of which
he sincerely believed, and not because they im
plied a censure against Mr. Badger. IPs fame,
he did 'not suppose, would perish, because these
Resolutions implied censure. He hoped tney
wotildjpass and that the House would proceed
with the public business.
Mr.wMfcBANE said he approved of some of ihe
remarks of the gentlemen from Cumberland, and
that he was opposed to this matter's becoming a
party question; he had only to refer to the propo
sition introduced by him. lie handed out the OI-ive-brajirh
he had offered a proposition on which
all could stand he had presented a compromise
He asjmuch as any member in the House was op
posed 'jo party excitement he was no man to
stand fire. But (said Mr. M.) when the compro
mise w is rejected, I thought U right to introduce
i 1 ho second proposition that was presented. And
j this h.is been styled a party trap! Wrnt, have
! we no! right to pass upon the official conduct of
I Jas. I. Polk? have we no right to obtain the
sense of this House 0:1 the past action of the
General Government 1 The Ollive branch had
been spurned the compromise was rejected by
the friends of Mr. Polk, and he would never have
introduced last proposition if this had not been
the cafe- And then the gentlemen from Cum
berland, gets up here and makes a compromise
speech, alter voting against the compromise.
Mr. Jonts of Orange said that it was the first
time that he had ever heard that the Missouri
Compromise was just : and when he voted
against striking out, he voted against justice of
the Compromise. He was willing to abide by
the compromise, but not to admit that it was
right. It was, continued Mr. J. brought for
ward, by the distinguished man of Kentucky, as
an Olive-branch, but no one from the South, at
that time, thought that it was just. This' was the
first time he had heard that it was just. He had
intended saying nothing about the Resolutions,
but when he heard these taunts about rejection
of Olive-branch and compromise, he thought pro
per to explain his vote.
The question was then taken on indefinite post
ponement, and the House refused to postpone
iFROCttEDIltfOS OF OURf
STATE LEGISLATURE.
Tuesday, Dec 19.
SENATE.
Mi-. Shepard presented the memorial of William
1 .i . 1- . t : , c
Glover and others, in reference to the navigation of
the waters of the Albermarle where Fisheries are
situated. Referred to the Committee on the J udi
ciarjf. M'r. Patterson, from the Committee on Internal
Improvements to whom wa3 referred a resolution
proposing a surrender of the Clubfoot and Harlows
Creel: canal, reported adversely theron, and asked
to b discharged from the further consideration of
the subject. Concurred in.
Mir. Shepard, from the select Committee to whom
was referred the Message of the Governor relative
to the extension of the Italeigh and Gaston Rail
road; to Charlotte, reported a bill to incorporate the
Norjh Carolina Railroad company, and for other
purposes. Laid upou the table aud ordered to be
priujed.
Mr. Patterson, from tbe Joint Select Committee
on Cherokee Lands, to whom was referred several
petitions from Rutherford and Burke, and so much
of tiife Governors Message as relates to those Lands,
made aletailed report, accompanied by a bill for the
relief of the purchasers of Cherokee Lands; which
passpd its 1st reading, and was laid on tbe table and
ordered 'to be printed, with the accompanying re
port
Air. Thompson of Wake, presented a resolution
in fdvor of R- W. Haywood, which was referred to
the committee on claims.
Mr. Speight presented a Preamble nnd resolution
instuctjng the committee on the Library to inquire
iuto;the expediency of providing for a New Map of
the State. Adopted. ;l
Mr. Rogers presented a Preamble and resolutions,
requesting information of the Governor in relation
to tile interest of the State in, and its liabilities for,
Railroad Companies, Sec.
Seme discussion ensued upou this proposition, be
tween Messrs, Gilmer, Conner, Shepard, and Thom-
as, qi iaviusou. c uiu noi unuersiana any:oi me
Gaqtlemen as objecting to the intention of the mov
er to obtain information but some were of opiniou
thatj mojst of tne information sought by the resolu
tion hajd alraady been communicated iu the Govern
ors iMcSsage, Trcsurers Report, &.c. and did not
wis& to j impose upou the Governor the burden of
compiling over again, that which a Committee, or
Clefk might do. Some of the information was:refer
redUo, ):ead, &c. !i
lne question on their adoption was taken by
Yeas and Nays, aud decided in the affirmative
Yeis 2& : Noes 19. !' '
Mr. Miller introduced a hill to anthorlsethe erec
tion, of a Male and Female Academy, iu or near Shel
by,iin Cleveland County ; passed its first reading.
.lr. jSmith, a bill to confer upon Courts (Jertain
powersjover imprisoued LuBatics ; referred to Com
mitiee 0n the J udiciary. ' ii '.
Mr. Shepard, u bill to incorporate the Trustees of
reiquinans Academy ; referred to Committee or
Education. Also a bill to extend the duration; of a
charte? to build a bridge over Pasquotank rifer, ;
refirreil to Committee on Internal Improvements.
Mr. Bower moved tbe reconsideration of the vote
by kvMch the bill to clear out and improve Lumber
rivfr,was rejected ; which obtained, and, on motion
of Mr -Rowland, the bill was recommitted -to the
Committee on Internal Improvements. : i
Mr.fThomas, of Davidson, moved that a ntesage
be eot to the House, proposing to vote immediate
ly for tTnited States Senator. ; ;
Mr.-Jlogers moved to amend the motion by sub
sttatinjr to-morrow at 12 o'clock. ;M
Mr.rThomas, of Haywood, moved an adjournment,
which Sdid not prevail. I
Tbequcstion was then taken on the amendment,
by ayes and noes as follows : Yeas 24 ; Nays' 23. '.
The motion ns amended was then adopted. j
Thai Chair announced a message from theHoase of
Commons transmitting the Report of the Attorney
General upon the claim of the-devisers of Cat heart,
witii jai proposition to print. Concurred in. ; j
Arid, thon the Senate adjourned.
j i I '
Vi HOUSE OF COMMONS. ;
Mf.Ferebee from the committee appointed to wait
on his Excellency Cbas. Manly, reported that they
had discharged their duty, and that it was the pleas
ure of the Governor elect to meet the two Houses on
the tst day of January.
Mr Dancy from the committee on Private; bills
repotted favorably to the bill to incorporate Union
Chapter No! 17 in the County of Duplin.. Passed 1
2d reading. f 1
Also, favorably to the bill to empower the Justi
ces of the Peace to sell the Poor House in said Coun
ty. Passed 2d reading.
Also favorably to the bill to alter the time of hold
ing tbe Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions in the
Cotrnty of Lincoln.
Mr. Reinhardt moved to extend the provision? of
the bill to Catawba County.. Carried. The bill,
as amended, passed 2d reading.
Also, favorably to the bill to amend nn net in re
lation to fishing in Roanoke -c. "Mr. Hackney mo
ved to lay the bill on the table. Carried.
Mr. Hicks, from the Select Committee to whom
was referred theesolution in favor of the growers
of Irish Potatoes, reported back to the House the re
solution, and recommended that it do not pass.
On motion of Mr. Brogden the resolution was laid
on the table.
Mr. McMullen from the committee to whom was
referred the bill to incorporate tbe Milton Savings
Bank, reported the same back to the House and re
commended its passage.
Mr. Satterthwuite moved to lay the bill on the ta
ble. Carried.
Mr. R.ayner, from the Select Committee to whom
was referred the expediency of enclosing the Public
lots and repairing the Governor's House, reported
a resolution on the subject.
Mr. Ballard introduced a memorial in relation to
ftshing in Albermarle Sound. Referredto Commit
tee on Lay-days.
Mr. Williamson introduced a resolution instruct
ing the Committee cn Swamp Lands, to inquire into
the propriety of grading certain lands. Adopted.
Mr. Ferebee introduced a bill authorizing Wil
liam R. Adams to cut a Canal and make a road in
Pasquotank. Referred to Committee on Internal
Improvements.
Mr. Newsom introduced a bill to incorporate a
Volunteer Company in the County of Wake. Re
ferred to Committee on Military affairs.
Mr. Coffield moved to take up the bill, just laid
on the table, in relation to fishing iu Roanoke.
Carried.
Mr. Biggs then moved for its indefinite postpone
ment. On this question there sprung up a debate,
between Messrs. T. J. Person, Biggs, Sutterthwaite,
McCleese. Hayman, and Paine.
Mr. Biggs withdrew his motion for postponement,
and moved to lay on the table. Carried.
Mr. Coleman introduced a bill to amend an net to
lay off a road from Ashville in the County of Bun
combe, to Burusville in the County of Yaucy. Re
ferred to the Committee on Private bills.
Mr Stanly offered a resolution instructing the
Speaker of the House of Commons to inform Mr. J.
W. Ellis of his election as Judge of the Superior
Court, and inquire of him whether he accepts of the
appointment.
Mr. Courts opposed the resolution in a very ani
mated speech. Mr. Stanly replied in equally as an
imated a style, nnd in a verj' forcible mauuer. Be
fore Mr. Stanly had concluded, tbe Speaker announ
ced the arrival of the hour for taking up the orders
of the day the bill to increase the Revenue of the
State, and the bill providing for an Insane Asylem.
On motion of Mr. Caldwell, of Guilford, the Rev
enue bill was laid on the table.
Mr. Mebane moved to lay the Bill for Insane As
ylum on tbe table. Lost.
Mr. Steele offered an amendment to 5th Sect, of
the bill, which was rejected.
Mr. Stanly offered an amendment to the 1st Sect,
by inserting the names ,pf the Commissioners. Adop-.
ted.
Mr. Wadsworth introduced an amendment to
strike out Raleigh and insert after "and situated"
"at such place as shall hereafter be designated by a
Bupplimental act' Adopted.
Mr Stanly introduced an amendment to 2d Sect,
to strike ont " or unhewn stone." Adopted.
Mr. Kelly moved to strike out 5th Sect. Mr.
Hicks moved an amendment to come in after 5th
Sect, provided the cost of said Building shall not
exceed 30.000. Rejected.
The question was then taken on Mr. Kelly's mo
tion to strike out and prevailed.
Mr. T. R. Caldwell moved to lay the bill on the
table. Carried.
Then on motion of Mr. Spivey the House adjourn
ed. Wednesday, Dec. 20.
SENATE.
Mr. Thompson, of Wake, presented a petition in
reference to forbidding the retailing of Ardent Spir
its within three miles of Wake Forest College.
Referred to the Committee on Propositions and
Grievances.
Mr. Walker, from the Committee on Propositions
and Grievances, to whom was referred the bill to.
amend the existing laws relative to the inspection of
Turpentine, reported the same, with amendment,
Lies over.
Mr. Thompson, of Bertie, front the committee ap
pointed to wait upon the Governor elect, reported
that Governor Manly would be Tead.y to sppe.ir De-
fore both Houses of the L.egislature,4and take the J
oatns ot omce, on the 1st ot January next.
Mr. Speight presented a resolution of enquiry in
relation to Deeds of Trust, &c. which passed its
first reaping.
Mr. Moye presented a bill to incorporate Tossnot
Depot and Hickory Grove, in Edgecombe, into a
Town by the name of Wilson passed 1st reading
Mr. Drake, a bill to increase the compensation of
the Chairman of the Board of superintendants of
Common Schools. Referred to Committee en Edu
cation. Mr. Shepard, a bill to incorporate Accora Lodge
No. 14. I. O. O. F. in Elizabeth City : passed first
reading.
Mr. Spicer, a bill to revive an act passed in 1842,
entitled an act to incorporate a town at the County
seat of Onslow, by the name of Jacksonville. Pas
sed its first reading.
Tbe Chair announced a message from the House
agreeing to the proposition of tbe Senate to vote for
United States Senator to-day at 12 o'clock.
The engrossed bill to incorporate a Female Col
lege in the County of Anson, was read the first time
and passed.
The engrossed resolutions in favor of M. O. Dick
erson, of Rutherford; and for the relief of Pender
Griffin, passed their first reading.
The Chair announced a message from the Gov
ernor transmitting a communication in relation, to
procuring and preserving Colonial Documents in
England, which, on motion of Mr. Washington, was
referred to a Select Committee.
The following bills passed their 3d reading:
To incorporate Lumberton Academy ; To repeal
and act concerning the Wardens of the Poor in the
County of Lincoln ; The following passed their sec
ond reading; 1 o incorporate the trustees of For
estville Female Academy ; To authorize the erec
tion of a Male and Female Academy at or near the
Town of Shelby, in Cleveland County ; Resolution
in relation to a day of thanksgiving.
On motion of Mr. Woodfin the bill to lay off and
establish a Turnpike road from Salisbury West,
was made tne order of the day for to-morrow.
Tbe Select Committee on the Governor's Message
in relation to the Colonial history of the State, are,
Messrs. fcuepard, Ashe, tialsey, Graham, and Beth
el.
Mr. Woodfin introduced a resolution authorising
the Doorkeepers to purchase Chairs for the Com
mittee Rooms. Read three times by general con
sent and passed.
Mr. Thomas, of Haywood, presented a petition of
citizens ol Cherokee County in relation to Cherokee
Indians; Also, of citizens of Haywood, aud Macon
bounties, prayine for a new County : Also of citi
zens of Haywood County praying for a burial ground
on the public lands ; which were referred to the
Committee on Propositions and Grievances.
Mr. Woodfin, from tbe Committee on the Judici
ary, to whom- was referred the bill to authorise 1
further taxation on suits at law, reported tbe same
without amendment, and the bill passed its second
reading.
On motion of Mr. Shepard the Senate, took op the
bill to amend the 15th Section of the 102d Chapter
01 me nevisea. ooae, in relation to the collection
and management of the Revenue of the State.
The hour of 12 having arrived, the Senate pro
ceeded to me order or the day, and voted for U. S
senator as follows: Badger 24; Clingmanl4; seat
tering 12. t t
Mr. Thomas, of Davidson, . from tbe Committee
appointed to superiwtenct election of Unite 1
States Senator; reported the wnole number of yf,
v.K..L,eaKe n.uwards7; f isher 5; McKay 3
and Messrs.' Rayner, Baskerville, Dobbin. Swain
1 each. No election, 83 being a majority. 1
Mr. TLomas, of Davidson, then moved that a roes
sage be sent to the House, proposing to vote again
for Senator; which was carried, Ayes 25, Nav W
The House concurred, and informed the Senat
that the Hon. D. L. Swain was in nomination.
The Senate then voted as follows: Badger 24
Clingm.in 16 ; Scattering 10. e '
Mr. Thomas, of Haywood, moved an adjournment
Negative, Yeas IS , Nays 31. J ment'
Mr. Lillington, from the Committee appointed to
superintend the election, reported as follows: whole
number 1GG. of which Mr. Badeer had 75- Clin
man 55; Leake 10 ; Swain 9; Edwards 7 ' Fisher
4 ; McKay 4 ; Shepard 1. No election, 84 beine a
majority. 1
A message was received from the Honse, propos
ing to vote again for Senator. Concurred in.
The Senate then voted as follows : Badger 1
Clingman 20 ; Scattering 9. One absent. Mr. Reich'
The Senate soon after adjourned.
' HOUSE OF COMMONS;
Mr. Gambill, of Wilkes, introduced Art
amend an Act, entitled nn Act to incorporate the
i.wiv. ncie iv me uoninjittee
on Private Bills.
Mr. Satterthwaite introduced a bill concern rj,a
lanx Lodge. Referred to the Committee on Private
Bills.
Mr. B iggs moved that a message be sent to the
Seriate proposing the appointment of a Joint Select
Committee, to take into consideration the propriety
of altering the time for holding the Gubernatorial
Election. Carried.
Mr. Hicks introduced an amendment to the 1st
section, C4th Chap. Rev. Stat. Referred to Judi
ciary Committee,
A messge was received from the Senate, propns
ing that the two Houses adjourn si;ie iie, on the -2ud
January. Laid on the table.
Mr. Newsom introduced a Resolution in favor of
Hall and Kincey. Referred to Committee on claims.
Mr. Williamson presented a bill, appropriating
31500. for the purpose " of clearing out certain.
Swampsjn Columbus County. Referred to Com
mittee onlnternal Improvement.
Mr. Green, of Granville, presented a resolution
for inquiring into the expediency of so amending
the Law, as to prevent House-breaking in the d.iy
time. Referred to Judiciary Committee
Mr. Stanly moved that the Resolution introduce !
by him, on yesterday, relative to the right of Mr.
Ellis, the lute Member from Rowan, to retain Lii -seat,
be now taken up. . Carried.
Mr. Stanly being entitled to the floor, remarked
that he had no desire to procrastinate the discussion,
and that unless other remarks were made of a na
ture calculated to call him out, he should forbear
from further paticipation therein.
Mr. Courts said that in all his experience, he haj
never before met with such a movement as the one
pow made by the gentleman from Beaufort. Hs
(Mr. S.) had ransacked mustyitomes without num
ber, in order to find what he deemed a parallell ; he
had adverted to the resignations, in former times, of
sundry gentlemen, and cited them as precedents.
But, sir, 1 join issue with him there. These resig- -nations
were made by the mere prompting of gentle
men themselves, and if he would establish his pre
cedent, he must point to some Legislative action up
on the subject. This he has not done in my judg
ment, he cannot do. Now, sir, if I mistake not, the
Constitution of the'State says that the terms of offi
cers, who have been previously elected, do not expire
until after the adjournment of the next Legislature.
Why does it not say immediately after the election
of their successors! Because, it contemplates the
probable contingencycthat the person so elected may
be a member of one of its branches. To bring the -case
immediately home, did not the gentleman him
self, when elected two years since to the Office of
Attorney General, retain not a mere, common sent
upVra this floor but the Speakership of this body
for nearly orquite a fortnight after his election?
Why did he not resign directly ? If he has th
right to retain his seat two days, he has the sams
right to do so for two months. When the proper
time arrives, Mr. Ellis, like Mr. Stanly, will vacate
his seat, i
The gentleman has likewise seen proper to lecture
this side of the House for the defeat of J udge Bat
tle. We did it not; he should have lectured his own
friends. . J, although I entertain no less admiration
than the gentleman himself, for Judge Battle's ster
ling integrity and intellectual worth, voted for Judge
Strange, a victim of the ruthlessly proscriptive Le
gislature of 1846 a victim for no other crime than
the sin of Democracy. I am convinced, however,
sir, that my constituents will receive with pleasure
the elevation to the Supreme Court bench of J uJgo
Pearson.
I have been advised, sir, to amend the resolutiou
under consideration, so As to include within lits
reach other gentlemen who are in situations simi
lar to that of Mr. Ellis. But, desiring to see this.
as it stauds, defeated, I shall forbear doing so.
Mr Stanlv. I su'l "C-nbtless be excused for again
troubling the House, after the very witty remark
of the gentleman from Rockingham Onethingsir.
however, despite the fluent humor of the Gentleman,
is very manifest ; this load is much too great for him
to bear, and though he speaks so earnestly as a par-'
tisan, for his late fellow-member upon this floor, it
plainly hurts bis sensibilities as avian. If as the
gentleman says, there be no precedent bearingdi-
rectly on this case, it 13 for the reason that we have
no precedent of a Judge's holding a seat in the Leg
islature of the State. Entertaining the conviction
that such a course of conduct is derogatory to my
ideas of judicial propriety, I have offered this reso
lution; I desire to see the ermine uncontaminated by
the wranglings of political warfare. The gentle
man further contends that the resignations to wnicn
I have alluded were made merely by the promptings
of propriety upon the part of those who tenderel
them. I can only wish that our modern folic enter
tained the same nice ideas of delicacy. I hope that
this is the first and last case where their suggestion
will be needed.
1 insist, that we have precedent for this course.
In addition to any that I may have cited, I woul l
call your attention to one or two others. Hon.
M. Saunder3 (perhaps, he is known to the other siae
of the House) was appointed a Commissioner under
Treaty with some foreign Country France or
Spam ; resolutions were passed and he was compell
ed to resign. Let us. se, too, what the record says
about Judge Strange that individual for whom the
gentleman voted, and whom I esteem equally with
himself, as a man of honor and of high moral excel
lence. Pic was elected a Judge on the 9th of Jan-.
uary, 1S27 considered the matter one night .m l
tendered his resignation on the 10th. The body of
which he was a member, actuated, doubtless, by th 0
desire to retain, as lng as possible, so estimable a
person among themselves, refused its acceptance ;
but, that vote was subsequently reconsidered, and
on the 11th, his resignation was formally allowed.
Are not these cases in point ? the one of legis
lative action on the premises the other of that
sense of propriety which is so much to he commend
ed? Are these musty have they grown so since
1S27 1 .
The gentleman has thought proper to comment
upon the course pursued by myself, when elected to
the Office of Attorney General. Now, albeit the
Member from Rockingham is a most desirable np
pendage to our House being, as he is, our YoncK.
most courteous and affable the miserable system 01
Of caucusing, in which he has participated so large
ly, has entirely obliterated from memory his law
reading and perverted his notions of things, a
Judge is apt to be called on at any and all times
he may be required to issue writs, bench-warrants,
certioraris, &-c.
The Attorney General has, of course, no such un
ties to perform. When, therefore, I had the honoi
to be thus chosen, feeling some delicacy about tin
matter, I consulted many of my friends. Upon '.
advice, sanctioned by my own sense of what was rig y
I resigned at tbe time when my services were need
ed the opening of the session of the Supreme Court
1 not only did tluit, but so arranged the matter Pr
viously, as to provide that an election to supply t
vacancy should be, immediately held, An order t
my constituency should not go for any kpgth ot tin.