f
" . -TOTIIK rrBLIC. v
A fJiesnd 'garbled stateiitent' hajg
Jwrn give n by n of-the preege, and
tetfrr. writers Ironi Ibis city, a wall as J
V Montgomery .'relative to the difficu
lt between himself. and -irrlf, ;l the!
rratter fcavinjr.undergnne jnvrsu'gatinn in
a rmut of law, 1 hereby lay before the
tjtbUc the facte, aa proven on Jh trial,
shot. every one who feele any interest" In'
the affair ma J jud4nnrt'ul'j d
rectly. .v ( -
At fjMU .correspondence Ww ee,
-which to therfiflicaJlTi-the wble- f
' it wat. publish. I in -the jGloue of Mar
30th, and o it I invite th attention of
one oho withes lo know whit n
la LUtce in Ihe lostance
'""-lTwas for Ihe abusive language need
in (he letter, whieh-appeared in Ihe Globe
: r May 29th, that : I personally chastised
him on the next day. J object now
io show to Ibe wor d, that in cit ing an
ocroent f the adjur, he published a state
ment which eventa have tune proven lo
. JwfalW. On the SOthof May, immedi
ntefjr .ofler the difficulty, be prepared Jor
.betjleUe, and had published in the paper
iA that evening, Ihe following ttatrment:
Washijiotox, D. Ci May SO, 1840.
f in.- ... i n: . i ..I-
rorssr. iJioir-iiiu iii'ni -
that too will publish the whole of the let
ters f K. Rayner and jnyself in your
paper ttiifenTnp,Tfli " atitfment-of
what occurred in the Capitol this day.-
. . When the House twit a rereu but whHe
" ".still in "MiiJohi t "left my :4eif , "piiaed
hroh the hall to the post office, tiepoai
led some papers, to be tent to my lodg
. r.-.'-nrs. j4 WMsaintritbreush Ike, fa!fe.
Jo join my company in the Rotunda. A
.rnai. who was. standing, or meeting me,
- in the pasg, seized me by my right
arm. and at the tame moment struck ine
blow with a large cane, without my
K nowing who inflicted it. I turned round
ana uiscovcrry mm u ii my cuueagur,
1C. Ray ner, with a large cane, which af
. itcrwardt turned out to be a sword ane.
I struck him with a amall cane I liful in
my hand, not at large as my finder, which
Itrinke into several pieces the first blow I
, trork. A fight ensued between us fur
nme lime, until, we were separated he
with hit sword fane, and l with small
.. . ie of ny ease - I -4tveio - dim bt -my
- r n1 tea gu ha a plaeed hi in ieTf there for the
purpose of attacking me. I had no aword
.ane. Or arms of anv kind, not supposing
colleigue wouhf be guilty ol the cow
ardly attempt at anasiinatiun, in which,
1 fear, from Ms conduct, t wst mistaken.
" " .Had I anticipa'ed ihit attack, I might
liavc been prepared. Hit conduct hat
been that uf a mean, cowardly scoundrel;
" first in attackincr nie through the columns
- . ihat of an honorable man, bbUhat of an
-'iasion, WBtlaTin!r, and without the
r. .klightett notice, with weapon prepared
- -Cir too purpose, seeking in take hit re
enje, cut-throat like. From hit cow
ard4ce, or some other caose, he was una
ble to hurt me. lie lost hit sword from
his cane.ip the fight, which he . loudly call
ed for several timet after we were arpart
,tedj and I broke my cane into many pieces
over hit head." He hat acted the part of a
oase coward and an unprincipled scoun
drel. I proved the facta upon, him.
. titt the letters below,) Ho- h4t there-
lore failed pi yet to injure me, hiJo he
. hat, ty 4is own xnnducf, disgraced him
self, br waylaying and attacking me with
n deadly weapon; and 1 have inflicted
chastisement upon him by breaking my
cane over his head. He it, therefore.
welcome lo all he hit gotten to far, and
to aU hei ca ia any w ay gain. heceaXior
t ours.
W. MONTGOMERY.
1 published the following statement in
the.lntelligencer June 2 the Editor of the
13 lobe having refused to publish it in his
pspet. 5 ,
Ilomt of Reprtitntallvet, Junt 1 18 4Q.
7V Ihe Editor ofxht Globe'.
.1 with lo wake, simp y, the following
statement ibr.mgh vhe columns ol your pa
tter. Hit letter, over the aijnature of
SV. Montgomery, in the Globe of May ,
30. pretending to give an account of Ihe
difficulty between him and myself. is false,
in the main; both at to facts and ina nut-
tiona. Jlie limowin
f the rase. I met him n-irelr bv acci
dent, in the floor, "on my way to the post
.itSice.,. I walked - op- to him directly In
i front, and 4elii-tlr alspped his jws.
iVhereepon, he Struct me over the thoul
dei with a car which he held in hit hand,
and which broke abort off at the first
Clow. 1 then turned my canewhich wat
t aword cant of ordinary tize holding
, it by the lower end; and ave him a blow
oarer the head, tlriking him with the han
dle, or aword end. in striking this blow,
the aword flew out tome diatanre. I then
repeated my blows, three or four timet,
" prith the lower or barret end of the cane,
until we were separated !e retreating
,back wanla- all the lime. He struck ane
-but once, and that was when.he broke his
csne. I did not draw the aword I mm my
.cane, or attempt to draw it. I had him
.entirely jn jay power, but I did not wish
to iaJiet any material injury on him, and
' should have desisted, alter slapping hit
jaws, had he not at reck ate with hie cane,
have nothing further to aay. ' - '
Yours, .respectfuJly,
' IL UAYNER,
8uch were the contradictory statements
.of W. Montg .mery and myself, in relation
to ine aaair sou nappuy ior uut train,
ventt have a'utce occurred to teat and
Drove which w a incorrect, hit version or
mine. If his statement be true, then 1
ought to be disgraced man if my atata-
mrnt be true, then pe must forever aiana
digrdcedin the estimation o.f all honora
ble men. for having published what be
khew to be a deliberate falsehood, for the
jiurpose of attempting to conceal hit di-
graceT" Sioce the rencounler,Ue grand
jury of the ITircuit Court .fur this District
pirfeiieu we ior an "iuiu anu uauc-
ry ' on ine person oi tv. jtion-gomerT.
At whose instance tbia wat done, 1 have
not yet beep able to .ascertain. On the
I Gilt June, -the trial came on, before
... '
JuJge.Dunlop Francis S. Key, proseco -
lnr--both of them officers appointed by the
President, and both of them strong parti
sans of this Administration. I submitted
ihe rase, upon the. evidence contained in
the .following statement taken down dur
ing the trial, by my attorney, Mr., Rich
ard S Coxe: i '
Circuit Court of the District of Co-
lumbia, for the coiinry oj n aiming
ton. June 16. 1840.
ITNITEIl STATES tersMi KENNETH
RAYNER. Ikdictmjikt ton AfsactToi
Batteuv.
Tlio defendant anoesred. in obedience
lo the process of the Court, and submitted
to the iudiremenf.
The District Attorney Ihen produced,
on behalf of the prosecution, Phillip Haas,
who bein dulv worn; ears: He was
nresent at Ihe affray which occurred be
tween Mr. Itiyner, the traverser, and Mr.
Montgomery, in the Capitd, on SaturJay,
the 30th of May. M r. Montgomery was
Sassing from the direction ol the post ol
ce of Ihe House of Representatives. Mr.
Riyner came through the middle door,
and going tewar.la the post office. They
met face to face, near the.wster;8tand,
Mr. Rayner had a cane in hie left hand.
Ha dracribed the nosition of the . ranet it
was held by the lull hand, which thenJheJd
right arm, and at the same time, wim nis
own right hand, struck Mr. Montgomery
twue in the c heeks. Uannoi say, cer
tainly, whether his hand was or was not
clenched but, from the sound, believes
the hand wat open. Mr. Montgomery
disengaged his right hsnO, an-t wiih a
stick, struck Mr. Rayner. The stick
broke with the blow. Mr. uayner, wun
his right hand, sriicd the cane, which was
still in his left lnl, towards the small
end. and struck Mr. Montgomery. A
Ihe first blow, the sword, which was at
the large end; flew out, and the blows
which followed were inflicted with Ihe
barrel-end of tlie r Aiie,. ,r CoiiLd . jiotdis
linguish, nartirularly, the blows which
passed. Mr. Montgomery had his hand
on Mr. Rayner's breast. Several persons
rushed in, and the parties were separated.
Mr. Rayner did not appear to .wish to in
jure M r. Montgomery; had he been to dvt;
posed, he might hsve done so..
The Hon. George II. ProfRt was Ihen
sworn on behalf of defendant. He stated
1, thM he-. was iftvtlie uieigUborbuod ..ojtbe.
cimery in conflict; Mr. Montgomery
had his hand on Mr. Rayner'j breast.
The latter had the scabbard or barrel-end
fa awnnlrane in hl hand, with which
witness aaw him atrike Mr. Montgomery
one or two blows. The parliet were
speedily sepsrated. Mr. Rayner appear
ed cool and composed, and inquired for
the part of Ihe cano which he had drop
ned. In answer to a .remark made to
him br wilnett, Ihstaa the thing had oc
curreu, and. would probably make some
noise, he wished that he had left his mark.
Mr. Rayner replied, that he did not wish
lo iniure MoMimmrrv. but only lo dit-
irrace him. and had "slapped hit face for
having accuted him of falsehood. Mont
gomery appeared a good deal agitated and
alarmed.
' Mr. Coxe observed, that he had nothing
further, on behalf of defendant, to lay be
fTore the rofifCeltfeWilirarPbtieafjoo
made by Mr.IMontgnmerr, in the ilobc
of May 50th, the evening after the cccur
rence, which contained Mr. Montgomery's
statement of what had passed, and the
previoua publication between the parties,
which exhibited the eircumstances of pro
voration which bad led to the rencounter.
He asked the Court, in deliberating upon
its judgement, toesaminethis publication.
and estimate the. provocation which had
been offered.
Mr. Key, District Attorney, intimated
hit intention to wait until Mr. Montgom
ery, whom he had tent for, should arrive,
when he might determine, after consul-
rtation with jiim, whether or not he would
ley before Us .Court any 76ther"lestini6-
; . Some lime atter wr. Montgomery ao
nesred. and after some conversation with
the District Atlomey.Mr. Key announced
to Ihe Court that he did not deaign lo of
fer any further evidence.
Ine furegowg alatement was made by
me, from notes taken in Court, immedi
ately after the examination f the case,
and'ia I believe, strictly ccnratev
Jan If. 1840. . '
ntrit anrva riivp
' wwwowuw tro Vwaim
ft uihinMion, Junt tS, 1840.
We hereby certify thai we have exam
ined the foregoing statement of the - evi
dence giveo by us, respectively', o the
trial of the Hon. K. Rayner, and the aame
is a fair and lull "statement of our evi
dence, at given under our oath, before
the Court.
CEORGEH. PROFFiT.
PHILIP HAAS.
From the - following certificate, from
the Clerk of Ihe Court, it will be seen that
these were the only witnesses sworn on
Ihe trial. T;;t,;. .'., , Jir.':-:::.:
Criminal Court of the Ditiritt of Colum
bia, eivlng for the County of Withing-
ion,
ne rrtiVt4o
j dictmrat faT-an aanolt
j " and ksitary .on W il
Tat Urn? SjiTw
ium Montjwnefy
Itih iona.dwea rab
milted to lb Qgart
Juna, JaSjaoienl.
lUllba Dalradant pay
a fine of U0, tml eoate
fproMcuiion. "' ,
A L K 1 C I! 8 T A R , A N
( II apeara'trom Hie Winnies ol ine uouri.
, in the abo raoe. that Phillip Haas was
me vukj inm ' " r""j
prosecution, anu uic iion.
Mr. Piofflt
the only one ii defence.
Test.- : WM. BRKNT. Oer.
f On this evrdience, which was uncon-
ltradicted by Montgomery who wat tent
for by K. S. Key, the, prosecuting attor
ney, and refused to be sworn, after a close
and secret conversation with him for some
time I waa sentenced lo pay a fine of
fittv dollars.
---The foregoing evidence" speaks for it
self. It proves that the a for eta J Mont
gomery quietly submitted to personal chas
tisements, and then attempted to cover
hit dingt ace by using towards me low and
abusive epithets, snd by publishing a state
ment which he knew lo be false, and to
which he refu-eJ to swear, when brought
into court." I ak the public to compare
the uncontradicted evidence in the rase,
as given in it court of justice, with Mont
gomery's account, both of the manner of
my attack and of his own heroism, as con
tained in his letter of May SO; and the on
ly comment I hate to make is, that I re
gret exceedingly the necrssity which com
pels me to trouble the public further with
thia matter; and regret still more the ne
cessity which compelled me, in the first
instance, to lay my hands on such a
wrelih.
K. RAYNER
Washington Citt, Jul 20, 1840.
LAST RRLCHINGS OF AN EXPIRING
VOLCANOJ
letter from Ihe Roaring Lion of the Her"
mitage, in reference to an observation
made by Mr. Clay at the late great Whig
celebration in that city. It was expected
that the impudence ol Mr. Clay in visi
ting Tennessee, and partaking of a pub
lie dinner in sight of the Hermitage, would
kindle anew the slumbering wrath of the
old Hero, but we had hoped that Ihe pa
ciOc and even complimentary tone of Mr.
Clay's speech would have conatrinl
him, in common decency, to keep his tem-
EerundiT some little restraint. But see
ow he raves:
Lynchburg Vitginiuni
To the JiJtior of the Union f -
Mr Ifeing ioformrd that the Hon. Henry Clay
of Kentucky, iii hit pul.lic ppeech at Nathvilla.
yelerJy, allegro ili I hid ippoinled tli. Hon
ornbla Kdwaid Liringrton Hecretary of 8lata when
he wu a defaulter and knowing him to be one, I
feel Uiatlamjualifiad .indMlarin the charge to
tw falae." " Ina k oowu to ilf-tbV country' that the
nominaliona made 6y the Preaident to Ihe Senate.
ar referred lo appropriate rommitteee of lint botly,
who duty it la lo inquire into the character f the
nomineet, and that if there ia any cidonc otde.
low. MVn.WinV.lon waa a mrmW oTihaG.n.
ata from lU Biale of Ijuiana. when lie waa
nominated by ihe. Can Mr. I'lay aay that he op
powdllieconfirnialionofhia nominalioo, becauaa
he wa a defaulter? -If to, the Journal of ilia Sen
ale will anawer. Buf hit conCrmaiian by lbs Sen.
ate ie concluaiTe proof that no atirh objection, if
made, waa tuafaiord, and I am aatiafied that inch
a charge againal hinf could not bate beeo aub
alanliatMl. I am alio informed that Mr. Clay charged ma wilh
appointing Samuel Hwartweut Collector of Ihe
port of New lark, knowing that be had been an
aasoriateof Aaron Burr. To thit charge it ia prop-
lo ay that I knew of Mr. Swartwoul'a connec
tion wiih Aaron Burr, precisely aa I did ibat of
Mr. Clay bimaetf, who, if the Malory of tba timea
did not do turn great injaalice, waa far from avoid,
big an awAeteiien wilh Burr when ha waa at Ilia
town of Lexington in Kentucky. Yet, Mr. Clay
waa appointed Secretary of State", and I may aay
confidently with recommendations for character
and fitooM not more farorablo thin ih we produc
ed lo ma by the eitixena of New York in behalf of
Mr. Swartwont. Mi. CUnr too at lb lima of hi.
cmircieu, waa oirrcny caargad turougnoul the
Union with having bargained for It; and by none
waa thia.rharge mora earneatly made than by hie
preasnt aaaacialM ia Tenoeaeee, Maaara. Ball and
Foater. . - - - ,
Under auch elreamitancea, how eontemptiMe
doaa ihia demagogua appear, whoa ha deeeenda
frr-m hia high place in the Senate, & mama over lha
counlry, retailing slanders against lue living and
tba dead.
ASDHEW JACKSON.
Jltrmilagt, Jugutt Ig, 1840.
How different from the lone of hia great and
hated rival! The one al magnanimity and gener-
eroeity the other aa fierce and vicdeot aa a caged
tiger.
Since the foregoing waa in tvneT
we have received the Nashvitfe Whig con
taining ihe following dignified Card:
Your aarpiiae, I am suite euro, will haaaereat
aa mine was on llie perosal of a note, signed An
drew Jackaun, addraaaed to lha editor of lha Nath
villa Union, and bearing date on lha 1 8th In'tant, '
. The clreameiances of my oreaenl viait lo Nub-
villo am well known here. I declined repealed in
vitations lo allend the Convention bolden on tba
I7ih ioeuol, and finally yielded to an uouimal ap
peal, with which i waa honored, which it would
be dilBeuIt tat any man 10 raaiat. " w "
I wm called upon to aJdroaa the Convention
fa what Mrma of reaped, and br bis military err
viees,of praias I apoke, of tba diatinguihed Individ
al who la the occasion of tbia note, all who beard
ma can testify. Among tba suhjecta which J diaeua
asd, was thai of tba degeneracy in public virtue,
and especially the delinquency and infidelity in.
public o tlicera, or wblco wilhia me last taw year
wa kavs) had such lamentable proof. In assigning
the causes for ibis deptorabia atale of things, I
staled, aa among them, tba aubveraioo of tba rule
bud down by Mr. JeAeraon. sf honesty, rapacity
and fidelity to the Conatilulionud the eubetiiaiion
hie it of one rounded on daronoo ane subserviency
not to tba country, but to tba chief of a party.
That persona appointsd lo oifiea too often eonsidV
trad Iheaaealvaa as being only put impossaaaion of
iheir tegitimata share of the spoils of victory, to
atesd of fasting bound by thi oblijra ione rf a aa
ersd trust eon fi Jed for the benefit of tha people. Ia
respect to defaoltenj referred to tba eaaa of livings.
loo, of whoso atiainmeata as a jurist, not mor con
sistent with troth than my fealingvl apoke In ihe
bigtveet terms. Ha waa awe of tha earliast and ana
of lha graatest defaultar. Hia ease secured endor
Mr. Jsflerson'a administralion. Ths raeoeds both
of lbs Eiscotiv an Jodicial departments ostab
ashed bis default. He remained a defaulter about
a quarter of a eantnry, if not more. How ha finally
liquidated the bslanre against hi at. and wkasv t
do not certainly know, but I believe it wa by prop
erty and under the Art term o General ,lckaon,.
', ' X. :rm if ;XiS- i''i -
I) 0)U T If 0 A ft (I yNA.ib Z 11?' 1'
But 'whenever and however A a, a UtJy fsjymenl
, rempMiion of the lrW could not one did u a,t
etpingelhefsetof hisorigisalJefuU. ,
In argoing from csn'to ekWt, I contended that
Ibe appointment of Mr. L'uingslon waa a pernicous
precedent. That it was a sir oal praclamaUon to
all who weia or might be defaulters that their in
fidelity, ia a publie uejt, eoostiiutsd as ineiijrs
blo barrier to a promotion la one of tha highest of
fices in tlio Government. J did not attribute lo
General Jackson a knowledge of the default. I went
even ao far aa to say that hs migb not bare re
flected upon the consequences of ihe appointment
of an iodividusl s situate! I must now ssy thst.
until Gsn. Jack ion otherwise aaserts, ( am eoo
strsioed to believe that he coeU not bavo been ig
norant of a firt, so eonapieusua io lha annals of
our country, a that of ibe defaall of EJward Iai
ingaton, Eaq. Attorney of Ibe United Stalea, in ibe
District of New York, during the administration of
Mr. JeAeraon, to tha amount of about 1 00,000.
It waa in Ibe train f lbs anna thought and ar
gument, that I adduced tba appointment of Mr.
Swarlwout to tba office of Collector of Ihe most im
portant port in the United Hlales, aa one of the most
important and Injurious examples. Hi psnieips
lion in the scheme of Col. Burr, waa a fact of such
oitiverml notoriety that I auppoa.'dnd yst suppose,
Ihst oo man lbs least conversant with lha history
of ihe country, could be ignorsnt of it. But it was
not upon Gen. Jarkaon's knowledge of that fact, it
waa upon tba fact itself, thst I dwell.
It ia now aaid that lha appointment of Mr. Swart
wout was recommended by citizens of New Vuik.
I know nothing of these rscommeiidstioos. Wheth
er tbey were causa or onset whether they
were gotten up to produce or. to give color
and cover to the appoiotoieot, previously deter
mined lobe mode their secret history only could
disclose. Tbe appointment occasioned general
surprise among tba friends and foes of the adminis
tration, at the time, and the aequcl demonstrates
how on wise it was.
These topics of addrcaa to 'the Convention on
Monday last, have bean selected by Gen. Jackson
for comment and animadversion. He wa not pres
ent on the ixxatioo He has rw . ap plicion 1
re me rora correct account ol wnat aciuany aaiu:
but baa been contented to rely upon "being inform
ed," by whom, with what motives, & wilh what ob-
jecta,! have no mesne of conjecturing. V helher hia
Informer may not be aome friend of Mr. Van Uuren,
who, in the preasnt desperate atate of his political
fortunea, wishee to bring the General into lha field,
A to lorn the tide of just indignation on the part of
tha People from lbs General's protege, tha exhibi
tion of bis name only would' enable the publie lo
decide. - ' ,. t
With regard lo die insinuations and gross epi
thet contained in Gen. Jackaon's note, alike im
potent, malevolent, and derogatory from ihe digni
ty of a man who baa filled tbe highett office in Ihs
Universe, reapect for tha public, and for myself.
allow me only lo ssy that, hke other similar mis
siles, they have fallen harmless at my feet, exciting
oo outer sensation than that of acorn and contempt.
' ' H. CLAY.
NasbvIlii, Augut20, 1840.
Souther rr Men! Roptiblicnns!
Read! ! I
Prom ttie Cinciniiatti (Ohio) Rrpubliaan.
GENI HARRISON '8 SPEBCH AT CAR
THAGE.
We insert, according lo promise, ao much of
Gen. Harriaon'a apeeh at Car there, on tbe IOiIi
-ult. aa raJatedio
ciety, proposing to me twoquetione, which he
juesled me lo answer; but having from necessity,
arising from tbe absolute impossibility of my nu
merous letters t receive, requiring my opinion up
on poliiical subject, declined lo answer anv from
individuals, I willingly embrace the opportunity of
. u.nci i m.iu wuicn i in. occasion nee given
me, wi'bout violating the rote I bad found myself
uiiiivi tuv iinmiij oi adopting.
The qoeations are the following, viz: .
lat Do you believe the people of the United
State poases an unrestricted right to diecliee any
auhjeel, that to tbem may eeem worthy cf consid
eration! '
Sod Do yo believe tha people of the United
Slate have the right lo petition their. Legislature
for Ibe redress of whatever they may deem a griev.
ance, and fr lha adoption of auch measurae aa tha
petitioners may think conducive to tbe welfare of
ne natioiiT
I do not heeitate lo answer both of these que,
tiona in the affirmative. The Conatfution of tba
United 8 tales, and that of our own Htate, have se
cured to the people tba enjoyment of the rights
referred to in both question, entirely Unrestricted
bat bv, their o asutaa .propriety and the-feral
rules which proteet Ihe rights rother. The free
dom of apeech and of ihe press, ara ihe distin
guished characteristic of free government. With,
out them, w migLl eall our ooontry a Kepublic,
bat it would be so onl in name, like that of Rome,
under Ibe Ernperors, it might lie a mask to cover
the most horrible despotism. The right of the peo
ple to write and to ak openly and fieely upon all
matter of publie policy "i ibe palladium of alt civ
il and religious liberty." Tbe author if ,.ur
Constitution moat bava known that it would be
auhject la abuses to be used for improper and in
deed sometimes for criminal puieoaesf yt they de
clared it without restriction. Mora than half a
century naa passed away sioce it came Into opera
lion, and although upon one nwmorsble occasion
it was I snorted to-fat the purpose of giving effect
lo council tending to naralv xe the efforte of tha m.
.lion, ia the midst of. a dnngerooe war, and to en
courage tha eomy lo persevere in supporting thrir
unjual pretension, etill thesa declarations of right
in relation lo writing, speaking and publishinc.
have been soltieed to- vemsir in- all their pristine
lorce. l sboum oetne lest person woo could, on
dsrsny circumstaoces, consent to restrict thsm by
legal enactments. . ,
I most, however, take this occasion lo repeat
what I have before declared, that the discoaoioo of
Ihe right of one portion oflhe Stole which compos
our Union to hold slaves by aa assemblage ofciii
xn of other Statee, which, hold none, ia in my
opinion not aanctioned by the spirit of Ihe CdOati.
ration. " If H U tolerated by tha broad and unre
stricted declaration in the Conalitullon, to which I
bava referred, it ie forbidden by the general tenor
of that instrument, and the fundamental principle
ol Ibe government which dt has established. jUur
government ia certainly one of a very complicated
character, difficult in soma of ite as, act to be welt
understood. To foreign govern meals it present,
and was intended to present, a power clothed with
the most important attrihutee of eovereignty; and ao
far aa our relations wilh Ihen may be concerned,
tbey are to see nothing beyond thai which ie des
cribed in our glorious mott -K Plmritut Vnnm."
We are, however, not . "one," in the aenee that it
would be underalood if applied lo other na tiona'
which have been formml one from disjointed and
asperate part. Our Union ie not ihet which, tike
marriage, merge the wAsir right of the parties in
a common stock. . We are not
''joined like meeting riven
Which roll into ihe ea one common flood,
Ad are ao more dislingualied.'
Our Union is more properly like an ordinary re
partnership composed of a number of individuals,
who each furnish a portion of capital, lo be iu In
jected to Ih control of a majoity of lha partner.
not wno eacn also retain another portion under rbeir
owe exeloaive manacemaat. With tba latter nei
ther the partner eoliectlvely'oae individaelly have
any snore right to interfere than if there exiited
ao sort of connection between them Thi j, a,
ihe theory ef our Gsurral and Slate Government.
Over tbe power retained by I'm Siatea respective!,
neither llie Gener J.Govemment no ihe oller !let
nor ihecitixens of tie other Stales, ran exerrtethr
bast eonlrul. If thi opinion M correct; it rollnws
. . 1.. uf.:k. a.
thai oisrussions in yvmtr. pwm "m -
the msliiutione of older Male, wilb a view bt alter
or affect them, wa not in the contemplation either
of those who framed the Coaatitntion, or those by
whom it waa adopted. I apply the theory I
endeavor to m tiiitain lo thia anaemhly. We are here,
aeaae thsee iboosand persona, ia tbe double charac
ter of eit sens of Ohio ami cilixens of the Uuiied
itiotes. to tbe first, we csn undertake the consid
eration and discuwion of any suljecl ladonging lo
our State policy. emholy our sentiments in the slis;ie
of resolutions or petitions, and in Ihe event of
supposed grievanre, present tliSni to the appropri
ate y ale authoriiiea for redress. Aa cit:za s of ibe
United Htatea, we are compeiant to consider and
discuss any subject of national policy, end !y a sim
ilar precede submit the result of our deliberations, if
we should choose to do s , lo that department of
the Federal Government whirh possesses Ibe pow
er to give us if lief. But in which of these charac
lers. either aa rttisem of Ohio, or a citiiena of the
United Stales, eouM we, consistently with the theo
ry and spirit of the Consiiiution, disruts a auhject
belonging exrlnaivi ly lo any olher Slale!
There are many principles to lie found in the
Constitutions of some of the Stale a (other than
lha toleration of slavery) which are very much un-
like those of Ohio. The property qual.fication of
votera for melanre. 7 bis is a restriction upon tbe
right of tpfTrme lo which personally I am opposed.
1 would accord this important privilege lo every citizen-
Having ascertained that he waa a eitixen, I
would not proceed to enquire the amount of money
he ha I in bia pocket, or what other specie of pro
perty be might pos es. With these sentiments I
might offer for your adoption a resolution declaring
thai the restricted auffrag in aome of the State's was
en aristocratic! feature in ihoir systems of fjovern-
inent, and should be abolished. such a proposi
tion could not fail to create much surprise and bring
lo Ihe mind of etery man in the assembly that nei
ther ih bia capacity a a citizen of Ohio nor of the
United Stales, could he interfere wilh the people
oklJiUtlsetUy
management ot their domestic concerns. Should I
be asked if I thought that any barm could arise
from ouch a discussion. I answer decidedly in Ihe
affirmative. Harm in moie way than. one. It
would lend mors perhaps, than any thing else, to
deatroy tha idea ol the perfect individuality and dis
tinctness of the State governments, which has ever
been considered a one of the most Important fea
tures in our system, and prepare the minds of tbe
people for Ihe proatration of ihe barriera which have
been erected wilh so much art and care between the
Gen rsl and Stale Governments, and ihnse of the
Statee respectively, and finally lead to that dread
ed eonsolidalinn which, in the opiniona of our wis
est and best statesmen, would he the immediate
precursor of ihe downfall of liherty. It could not
fail, also, lo impair if not entirely d.-stroy, those
feelings of confidence and affection between the cil
izena of the respective States, which js ibe only
effectual bond ot our Union.
From the discussion of any question in an ab
stract form, no pus i hie injury could arise.
I conclude wilh the repetiiion of my opinion that
the right of the people- to write on, apeak on, and
discus any sulj- el which they may deem worthy of
consideration, snd thai of peuiioning- for the re
dress of any thing 'whi.-h they may consi ler a
grievance, ''are aecored to them both by the Feder
al and 8tfe Constitutions, and that these rights
can neither be impaired nor restricted. The ahure
of these right U nranmul for !oiiduvs . tfae4
separable irom I lie (rood to wmcn it ie allied, a
shoot which cannot be stripped from the stalk with'
out vitally wounding the plant Horn which it is
lorn."
libtrtot tl natale mlum."
THE STAR.
RALEIGH, SEPT. 9, 1840.
07- SEK FIRST PAGE.
....DlSTRlC.'I-GOMMI'rrEESv; -'
The Register, in publishing the Diatrtct Coni-
mitteea of Wake County, to make arrangement
for the Convention to meet in this riiy on the
5th October, having inadvertently left out the
Little River District, we cheerfully supply tbe
omission. The committee for that district is as
follows:
LtTTlK niTKB TtHTniCT.
Henry J. Horton, Levy Mitchell, Augustus J.
Foster, Jamea Todd, MoeeeTodd, Berinet Biinrv,
Samnel Strickland, William RhoeVs, sea. Wil
lis Horton, JamesTrivett, Azet Maasey, Owen
Bonn, Bud Bunn, William Horton, Wm. Mitch
ell, Calvin Horton, D. 1). Criffin, K. Goocloe,
Green Hih.
St1 of October Costvenrion! "
InteI'iont from all qua iter eon firms the be
lief that the Whig ' Convention appointed' to meet
in this City oa the fllh October next will be the
greatest gatherinjr o( the people ever witnessed
ih the Old North State. , From old Republican
Rowan, we learn that 100 delegates will be sent
from a single club. Democratic Chatham, it is
said, will send 500. Wc hear, aleo, that the
ruah of the people from RandoTph, Guilford, "Of
ange, Granville, Franklin, Halifax, Craven,
Cumberland and Johnston will be like the gath
ering of the hardy elana of Scotland when earn-
monec by the aignid of the fierj cross, to resist
Ibe invasions of their haughty snd lordlj op
pressors I and the worthy and patiiotic Editor of
the Wilmington Advertiser warns the Whig, of
the other counties to " Inks care that New Han
over does not send Ihe Urgent delegation to the
Convention which meets in Raleigh on tbe 6th
October." We know, loo, there are many oth.
er counties, from which we have no special in
formation oo the subject, that will be represent
ed by -numerous and enthusisstie aqnadrone of
their pnreat and most patriotic democracy. We
hope EVERY COUNTY IN THE STATE
WILL BE FULLY REPRESENTED t .
The jrmj- tongue of ike Brilith Toriet retmltti
aw JOHNSON. . ,
Read the correspondence between Major Cas-
neai. end the Vice President. It will be seen
that Col. Jonmoa bean honorable testimony to
tbe slill and bravery of General IlAaainoiit and
ia so doing aeals forever the lying lips of the un
principled slanderers who meanly anj wickedly
go about ei.J-aoiiii In destroy -the'iell.,
reputation ol that distinguished hero and aia-t
man, l,y charging ,i, wiih weaknea and
,Urir nuarrauio slanders il)
op.m ineir own frilly head,
Noble Sentiment Clear and Able F
position. .". . i
We bare the pleasure of preaenlm u
readers, In today's Star, an extract (Yoai , i
delivered by Gen. HARRISON at Cartba !
the 20th ultimo, ltdef.neahiapo.iti011,.'
ly and aaiifiM-torilyrrepcci,Hy to Uli
on three grand pointo, to wit: Aboliii0B,g"?"
Rights ane Domocracy. It containa more tZU
republican doctrine than we have s.fttfc -prised
within the aame space; and we majT,
ly say, though given in few word, t),at , ,,.
er, clearer, abler, stronger expoaiijo,, of the it2
feraonian Stole Righta principles, in nti
die relative powers of the State and Cell!!
Governments, and to the righta and priril
ot the people as rmzena of Urn Union and of ik,
reapoctive Slates, ia not to be found on record ?
givea him increased lustre as a aound, elVxL
headed atateaman. and additional claims te U
confidence and aupport of the South and of U
great republican party throughout Jhecoomir
07- Wo ask Ihe honeat and candid .
the Administration parly to give Uiis ableax-.
an attentive penisar. "'
37" The Editor of the OhioSuie JooX""
confer a special obligation on us by finwardio-J
to this offices Copy of his paper which appeal
in the eariy part of July, containing the first r :
twQ most excellent and ahlo
. " ' "c r""y "n power reu
aure io ine currency. The number which be
had the kindnesa to forward us, ha bcea acci
dentally misplaced.
British Tory DiiTtatlou.
There is scarcely a pilch of audacity so bijk a
to forbid the expectation that the British Tory .
en may not reach it, before tbe termination f a.
pressnt eanv.m. what think yon, fetlow-eititee
of North Carolina! Would yen .appose that ft,
British F ederal Toriea of the Old Dominion o,U
have tha fathomless presumption to'give up ibsw
perinlendence of iheiir party tactics' and maehimrr
in Virginia, and audaciously atrp forward lo sett
the conscience keepers, tbe political councilors asi
guiJing rtmrof the people of the gjod oU Nortk
Slate ! Extraordinary a it may eeem.'howewr, k
is neverUieles true that the British Tories la no
Old Dominion, regarding ihe people of tbts Stat
a mere vassal and serfs of Virginia, hm earn for
ward to take them under their cherge, m the ear,
ing Presidential election. They preaumptaowH;
tell us, m. substance, to return lo our allegieaea
uiu . irgmia; to aubmit tamely lo her political ft.
s . ye 7 ttrf 'W WIIUIWIIIY
MlfaWinJ hi PCrMTrriuff ODnnallLao A lml
- " r I '- w MiaMew
and mechanical portion of the community. - Tot
tell us, in aubstsnce, to follow in Ihe trail of Vin
ia, whether ah enioin it anon na to .n. -
rod, a quadrant, or a alill-worm whether sbslsak
us into a bog, a bnish-f.re, a hay-etock. a tar band
or a mill pond. These officious lories of tbt OU
Dominion-, pretty plainlv inform tha
Carolin, lhat tbey ire not sufficiently intejligeata
tniHK ior uiemieive; and that we have taken hoik
the law and tha gospela from Virginia so long, tU
it i presomptuou. in u to think now of breakiiig
away from her skirts. , - .
Fellow-citizens of .North Carolina I reeeW to I
I funk and acl for yoorselvee i and Mmsio ik. Ldi
determination to mark with exemplary Mtribatus,
m iiovemoer nexr, tbia flagrant, thia mooatrosikv
suit wiiicb baa been offered to yea.
Atrocious Inctiit.
A RinM lirAA.I-TM.t ...I . 1 : f ,. 1
- uu aiuuDg insou oaa aer. j
er hmtmMMUIiJftfw e.vo'tMit'ailea.1
man waa lately perpetrated in Florida, by lb Rejit
uovernoror mat province. It appear that Govh
or Rait) taok counsel from the example of the fay!
vjovernors, ana resolved to re-enact thssmcen
which had been gotten op in North Carolina at tW
opening or Ibe Kcvolatioa, by Governor JosUk
Martin and William Trvon. and in South f.-aroliia
by Governor Bull. Thia aggravated aflronl mei'9
mi. may o snmmed ap in a few wordet A vert
ollensrve and mendacrooa article bad appealed
gainst the Whig party, in a British Tory jaaratl
pubbabed us TaUabaaaee, A gentleman or I w. Ie
longing to ths Whig party, called upon tbe EtCtar
for ibe aame of the author of ibis article. . TbeEe
itor promised to stirrender the name, ahould llT
ctt next day. Tha call waa accordingly mad,
ihe Kditor wa absent. - A metn her r th WhU
ly aecilenlally meet ike Editor In the eVatUsf;
I aiianaoaee, ano ased ibgbr aaacolr upw
A little before, or after. ll! fwti.rn
WOom'iiftoeMnliioto hHmonlii'ktMf-'
ual, and Governor lieid assemblss in Tail
4 MILITARY FOHHP. ,,r I Ron .kUlU
- - " gHvw Has g aw serves
been plteed on the frontier, for lb defence f Fke
Wa ! i He, ia feet, places TallabaeeMendtrau
tial law, in a peiiod of profound peace 1 Govrrae
ReiJ, like Josiah Martin, and aome other dip
ries. eava bia ,k:. ,A ih, elbV .
' .vn- u mm .v. .MM .UUI IMltJ WW w
sens, wbila the ateanUoat was rapidly beaiio ki
awy to another part of the Territory. Tba Pi
went na been appealed to la tbe matter i w.
ao doubt, will regard it aa an admirable step ea lk
part of hi man Friday, Go. Raid. 1 ' "
Poor Consolation.
Tl.. Ci l l j . r l. Rritisk
: ,i w,.inuaiu vuubavore sooomiurt u
Tory brethres in thia Sute.jmder their late Wa
terloo defeat, by charging il to Whig frsuds,
, , , . . .! I Pnk!
ana, laiaeaiarma ana miarepresejuauonsi ; ,
poh! : Here the Standard Is again deceived"
sndsr-
tincee, raiae atarma and mimnresentanorni
weio practised by the fiierml Taritu ",A-
uianae to uie inieingenro ane vinue ot iu r
pie, all their shameful efforts lo gull sod mib-i
tbe true democracy of North Carolina, bars
terly failed I and they will be still more sign"?.
a a ' e 't vs. " . "h '"
reounea in November. ' .'--.-.
An Enqnlry. -Are
the Britieh Tory leadere aware that
tin Van Boron one atgnod hie nam ur,
tion oravine that a United States Bank sboula
f r y -.'i . -t
be rstabliihcd in AlhanyT