;v . " "'" . . ' f v . ' - I:
.irH - '.. 1 r r
- I f , : r ' ft
i ' - . I ;
I ' I
. i 1 ' i
! i , 1 ! r
!
tt
N
St,
i
iS
:k i
i.' f f : f . ; ..
Ii
t .
declaring hit i''n''" l VsV"
Mrilco Hi ft part of the United States,
S to" Squiring all the inhabitants
to return to thefr horn, on pain .of being
considered trultors, nm subject their per
sont to punishment, and their property to
confiwJition none to his intention of pro
vWink icivil government for New Mexico
with ft territorial legislature none to his
absolving in the name of the United States
the Inhabitants of that jcountry from their
hlleglarico to the Itepublic of Mexico
and finally, none to hi claiming all per-
' sons residing within thai territory .,,-
'zens of lhe United States, and denouncing
I: the doom of traitors against all or them
j who should be found in arms against us.
; To nothing that was done, by either Com
modore Sloat or Commodore Stockton, in
regard t6 these matters is any exception
taken j yet, Commodore 5Sloat proclaimed
, to-the Inhabitants of California as ear-i
'Jy as July, 1810 that thenceforward, Cal-
V I Torn i a would be a portion of the United
States, and would enjoy a permanent gov
; 'rhment And. in his general orders,, is-
sued July 7th, he says to the troops who
were about to be landed on the coast,
that It jvvas their duty not only to take
',1 California, but to preserve it afterwards
1 as a part of the United States at all haz-
lards. And Commodore' Stockton by his
proclamation makes known to all men.
that; he has by right of conquest taken
possession of the territory known as Up
per and tower California, and declares it
to be the territory of the United States :
! deuce without seeing that the persons ad
ministering- the government ot Mexico
were exceedingly anxious to settle " the
question of boundary and that in order to
enable them to do this, nothing might be
dong further to arouse or irritate the jeal
ousjfeelings of the Mexican nation, and
thaittherefbre we should send them a com
missioner, with power to settle the pend
ing dispute. , Well, we were not satisfied
with; that. They had hromised to receive
a commissioner ; the President tendered
thenH a minister resident. To that minis
ter they objected, because he could not
be received without arousing excited feel
ingsfand endangering the government of
the Country. But that! is not all. Long
before Mr. Slidell's mission was set on
fbotjon the 15th June,! 1845. the acting
Secretary of War writes to General Tay
lor in these terms i
" The point of your ultimate destination
is tpe western frontier of Texas, where
youjivill select and occupy, on or near the
Rio Grande del Norte, such a site as will
consist with the health of the troops, and
will I be best adapted to repel invasion,
and fo protect what, in the event of an
nexation, will be our western border."
ISfpw, sir, here is an order as early as tion :
the 1 5th of June, 1845, in which General
Taylor is directed to select a position on
or near the Rio del Norte, claimed as the
western frontier of Texas, which should
have these conditions it should consist
witHUhe health of the troops and be the
puuu ucst auapteu 10 repel invasion, ana
to protect, in the eventjof invasion, what
wasto be our western! border. Now, it
will fee sufficiently obviouS from these doc
uments, I think, that it was the intention
of tpe President that General Taylor
should move to the left ! bank of the Rio
self desired to settle the differences upon ; -
amicable terms would he have pressed j CONGRESSIONAL? DEBATE
amission of peace by ar aggression upoti
the power with which be desired to res
tore friendly relations V Rut, be it remem
bered, I have shown to the Senate alrea
dy, that the (President considered, (we
have it under his own hand in the orders
transmitted to His officers that the ex
pulsion of the Mexicans from the left bank
of the Rio Grrande the removal of. their,
settlements was an act jof aggression, a
hostile act, an act to be avoided in or
der to insure the peaceful settlement of
our difficulties, and which nothing .would
justify but the occurrence of actual war.
Thus, it seems to me, that not only did
the President bring on the war by an un
lawful and unconstitutional act,; but that
he has prosecuted it for the purpose of
conquest. - I I
To be concluded next iceeki
PENSIONS TO ;WIDOWS.
I ro were calleg upon' (ai wo shortly fhotiTdlH) Marylnnd expect to lidn,., ' .
,i lo tote ftJhqiufaud UMire aen andoma.fiiy counlr'triib )t4 JrJ fJH.r-
j miltons ol'dolbrs-to'rarry hti ihU far.of Con. be in any danger in .Metir(S
H'qnest of, Mexico. Fpr hss (Nlr.r P?r, l,e ' COTst arc in any danl'-r? -
,'JAscisTai;i848r1
The House having again resolved itself into
lhoU"ht that, both a mattfrof conscience and
in. a pecunjary point of tie it was much bet
ter to rntq a few thousand dollars fr the sup
port of lhevidows and families of those braTe
men who had already fallen in battle, lhan to
vote Gfiy thousand men and'nfiy millions of mo-
Committee of therAVhole on the Private Calen
dar. and resumed the consideration of the Bill
for, the relief of Mary Brown, widow. of Jacob ne" to conquer: the sister Republic of Mexico
Brown
SENATOR MANGUM'5 RESOLUTION.
The Washington correspondent of the Balti
more American gives the following; sketch of
the debate which took place ih the l. S. Sen.
Mr. BOWLIN said he had heretofore offered
an-mendment, to obviate the constant struggle
which had been sustained in this House against
the principle under which the Government had
sought to pension the widows of the soldiers of
the Revolution. There was a principle involv.
ed in that rule; and the abandonment of
the rule was the abandonment of the prin
ciple. The principle was, that no pension
had an army bf f.rlr
not whin thetn and ai
iiicic uanuiui qi our
Mr. Mcl.ANE aid tU f
Carolina had kindlj v!ur.t
qtiesiion, or he should mi i
iuterrosate him. Il4 (Mr.
knnw if m rYT.l -i .:. '. '
" iiwi IHWa
or r.r
ui:.i
and to make thousands more widows and or-
I ' t .111 ' i
pnans, wiio woulo eventually ie supported out hope when it: first weet to V
of the National Treasury. Mr! B..was about Mr. BOYDEN. Nn, nr.
to state his vieivs as to the course he intended any such idea. Whar, sir :
to pursue in relation to;the families of those 4 American army t N), ir,
who had fallen rin this Mexican war ; w hen ed of such a thing. I ah ,
Mr. ATKINSON, interposed, said that, ! utmost confidence upon cur u
whenever the tjme should come, he would be trr how great the oddi. I
found ready and willing to support the defend- . the more Mexican tlric
ers of our rights and liberties. He would take , were to lake to thtirj !.r
the libertv! of rnllinrr fitinn W'hirra in sunnort armr u-.n
a i . .. i i w 1 I - - " 1 -'-"'rwk''ivuiftlil
should De allowed to any widow who did not i thcir consistency by refwing men and means no man would be mor, f.
live in the lime of the Revolution. The year ,0 carrJ -on-a Warwhich they had denominated, rote all that ' might U
wass uit-reiore uxt u as mo mniiauoii ; so hy solemn vote, unnecesary and unconstitu
that no marriage since that day could entitle the j lionai . w.hich damnable act would ever follow
widow to a pension. It was considered that no ! them wUh odhm u n;r himscf he voted for
lady would be likely to marry under twelve ! ,he waff ald lorioJ irt iu AU ,C a?ked oj
years of age ; and therefore every woman mar- j gentlemen was for them to stand up and refuse
ried previous to this period must have lived lo vo(Q mon and ,npans to carry on lhe
ntPnn Thnrsilav inmn Mr Mancrtim Rpsnlii , . ' , ! V . . . . . I war anu ln) WOUKl Le damned Itt UiC CSlima-
ate on inursday upon ftlr. Mangum s Kesolu- hhig bi pasS) therefore, it should carry on its ' ,ion nf ,he people.
lace the reason For extending the law to the pre. -Mr. UOVDEN remarked that as it suited
sent case in the terms of his amendment ! lne gentleman to put questions, he would pro.
namely, that she was. born before the close of. pounj OI)C fo lhe gentleman. Reminding the
me iwjvoiuiion, anu uiu mu wuum mai irying gentleman of lhe present state of the Treasury, ate people. Just at the
perioci tnua bringing w.tn.n me equuy 01 the he de,hed (0 know pf,he gcn,cman from Vir- posed our Subtreacurv! v
principle the existing law But if you pass the ginia whcther he would come up to the point specie payments, lo, ari I 1
bill without such an amendment, you establish directly to borrow money, and likewise to levy mines come lo our relu f.
a preceueni allowing a pension 10 me wiaow 01 a direcl tax upon ,ho t of ,he ,T , . M Chairmnn.
L - . -l .'ii , ' r . - '
under tho name of the territory of Calfor
!iiia.irXncf Again, on the 17th August, he
: declares - that the territory of California
iow peloogs to the United fcrates, and Urarde. General Taylor so understood it,
wilt bo governed, as Isooii as' circumstan
' cejj permit, by oflicers. and laws similar
to pose by which other territories of the
lynlted States are regulated and govern
! cd i Here.i then wc see ofTtccrs acting un
do the authority of the. President, with
ou : rebuke from him, clAiming apd estab-
1 jflis ling civil goverements in Mexico and
. j California, as4he permanent territories of
Utht Phited States ; claiming their inhabi-
' ; j tajtts jas Jour citizens, promising them a
ii permanent form of a government, and
Mr. MangumV Resolution i is substantially
that the President be requested to state whe
ther the General Order 376 issued by Gener
al Scott was from instructions from the War
Department, and also any opinion of Gen. Scott
on file, as the military means necessary to car
ry them into effect. ,
Mr. Mangum pressed his ! Resolution, and
the duty of the President to communicate what
ever information was necessary for 'the true
guidance of the body. One Senator,) from Nr
C. said that he desired to know what was the
.1 r t.
mem irom an uanr m :
ly safe. Rut, sir, as to i
pose no man thinks of Hi
poso that the Executive (
would now think of h ,
Have not the orders aire
not our men just a!outrf
of Mexico? (Money in !
suppose that our men ?
much gold from tho?e 51
hearts can desiro ; Sir-
Riprntivp. mirnose on this subiect. and that he
should officially inform the Senate whkt object4 without further action in committee, and pro
was now designed by the war. f cee?ec? to ?Pa ?n the '"en,s tho c!' 'rhf
There was a tender-footedness upon this sub
a revolutionary soldier who was not married till
ihe year 1813 ; and if the claim be allowed
without qualification in once instance, itcanjjot
be refused in any.
Mr. STUART, of Michigan, was in favor of
reporting the whole subject back to the House,
That r '
ject, a sort ot skiitishness, ihich was surpri
sing He had never seen such a sensitiveness
before in his long service in this body and in
'denouncing them as traitors if they should
take dp arms against the United States-
yhaUs this but conquest? What is it
but seirure and permanent annexation by
force 'of arms ? This, then sir, I presume
ii the President designed to do at the very
rttma jWnen no called upon the country lor
il Recognition of this' war, and placing at
; ibis disposal means of men and money to
i prosecute It, No intimation is given to
1 ti9 lh any of his correspondence if he did
' tltlthen entertain the design-r-at what
. j time, the 'change took place in the Presi
.V i ,r,dintial ji)ind. In June, July and August,
" ;'iVpm thel;Navy and the War Departments
ta all ofljeers charged with carrying into
. i ..' .eiecutio'n the wishes of the President in
f Line Prosecution of the war we have the
! '1 ' i .. - . .
Same general tone ot instructions, secure
these territories, and sen we have all
theso officers seizing the territories and
treatinir them as a nermanent nart of the
, - , - - i
Jflited States, And to these proceedings
'TlHe President-takes no exception! He
J dies not Intimate, by the slightest breath
otj disapprobation, that the zeal of these
I commanders has exceeded the purposes of
, tlje Executive !
. I rntist suppose then, sir, that this was
i j lne objoqt for which the President prqse
' ' cutcd the vrar from the begining. and that
! Indemnity was not lhe purpose for which
he carried on the war. Why, sir, is it
,HQt a single mode of securing indemnity
li sucn nau been his purpose. At the
commencement of the war, what did he
yant indemnity for T Mexico, it is true,
Sowed to our citizens mqny. If the ob
ject had been1 to seize the Mexican terri
ory and simply to hold it by military oc
tupation in order to compel Mexico to re
Cognizo and discharge her debts to us,
jwhy is hpthing of this kind mentioned in
these instructions ? Why did these ofl
jCers trcuit the territories of which they
obtalnod possession as a conquest, which
was to bepomo a portion of the United
States ? i'. Why is it that no intimation
. fives given to them or to us that the ob
T'ject had, been misunderstood that the
possession which they held of these ter-
Ti tor ies was as a sort of mortgage, or in
the nature of a security to be held until
the.payrncnt pf the dcbt3 'due to us by
Mexico
But this View of the subject, 1 think;, be
- CQines still Wtranger when we consider the
mode a which the President carried on
; ms i negotiations. Mr. Slidell was sent
:to Mexico, if I recollect rightly, in the
j.month pf November, J believe that his
) credentials hoar date on tho 10th of that
'month. iWell, when he went to Mexico
lhe ivas not received. Why was he not ?
GratitJe. such a site as ! will consist with
the Health of the troops, and will be .. best
adapted to repel invasion," &c. Brazos
Santiago is the nearest entrance to the
moiit$ of the Rio Grande j and Point Isa
bel,! Iwlthin that entrance and 21 miles
frorii J Matamoros, would have fulfilled
more completely tnan an other ,pption
theconditions imposed by the Secretary.
But we had no artillery, no engineer force
or appliances, and but a moderate amount
of ipjfHntry ; and the occupation of Point
Isabe, under these circumstances, - and
witljat least the possibility of resistance
froni the Mexicans, might have compri
sed the safety of the command. I. there
fore,! determined to take up the nexr ac
cessible position in the rear, which is the
mouth of the Nueces river."
Cjeh. Taylor says expressly that he un
derstood that he would more completely
carf out the order by j taking a position
at Point Isabel. Why did he not? He
immediately assigns the reason.
Ai early as the 15th". of December, an
order was issued to Gen. Taylor, which
he understood to be an order to take up
his position on the left bank of the Rio
Graride. An order which he thought would
have been best complied with by estab
lishing his position at Fort Isabel. And
he iriformed the department on the 4th of
October, that this would have been done,
but that he had not the requisite force to
enable him to do it without the fear of a
check on the part of Mexico. Well, sir,
did He understand the order rightly? Let
us see. On the lGth the Secretary writes
tojhjjjrn.
";You will approach "as near the western
boundary of Texas (the Rio Grande) as
circumstances will permit." &c.j
And the final order of the 13th of Jan
uary, 184G, which all admit, was an im
for in a despatch of his dated 4th Octo
ber,j-1845, he says !
" Itjwul be recollected that the instruc
tion pf June 15, issued Jay Mr. Bancroft
" select and occupy, on or near the Hio ' communicate light to the Senate. 1 hey were
atraiu ot inioiming me senate ot what j was de
signed of what was donednd Senators were
called upon to carry out the ivishes of j the Ad.
ministration without even knowing what they
were, j
Mr. Crittenden thought: the Senator from
Michigan might well be sensitive at being call
ed tender-footed" upon this subject. The
Senator had signalized himself by opposition to
till callsoCinformation here. I Whenever light
was wanted he was for keeping dark j and we
were to be made to walk blind. folded over red
hot coals in order to keep the President's se
crets prosecuting the war. j j
There was no State secrets worth keeping.
Such things belonged to little Governments and
little persons. Little Governments jadopted
them and nobody else. They belonged to lit
tie things, little people and little Govern
ments. When we employed spies, in Heaven's
name keep secret your operations, but not in
other great things. The Senator from Mfchi
gan did not want Mexico to know what we
wanted what we designed. Why, I we did
not know ourselves. We were kept in the dark
wholly in the dark. S
The other day the Senator did not want to
destroy the Nationality of Mexico. Soon after
we could swallow the whole of Mexico and it
would not hurt us. Now he was for tho entire
subjugation, or conquest of Mexico. We might
swallow Mexico, though he thought t would
make us a most misshapen mass.
Mexico was now entirely at our mercy, and
we could " swallow" as the Senator sraid, leg,
arm, or head, or even the whole if necessary.
Any new species of cannibalism we were strong
enough to attempt. Mexico was conquered al
ready, and there was no need of all these State
secrets all these impenetralia and arcana.
It was unbecoming our people to adopt this dark
ness, j j
Mr. Crittenden argued that within six weeks
we should have peace, and question put to us
would be in a legislative form what would
we do with Mexico? Mr; C. held, lin most
eloquent words and with great force of manner,
he
amendment of the gentleman from Missouri,
(Mr. Bowlin) was based, not on the fact of her
marriage, but on the fact that she was born and
lived during the period of the Revolution.
Mr. BOWLIN here interposed and explain.,
ed his amendment.
Mr. STUART resumed. He understood the
gentleman's reasoning in favor of his amend
ment, and only wished to show its fallacy. If
Congress pensioned widows at all, it was done
on account of the services of their husbands.
It was of no consequence when the widow was
head of the Treasurv J
last week. in. looking' r;.or
money. box, has discovert
in one corner which .i J
looked.
Mr. ATKINSON. If
Cure in lfhn and IT ll ,.
afforded signal service in the war of the Revo
lution, we will aid you in sustaining yourself.
That was the consideration, and not because of
her birth during the revolution, or before it, was
she entitled to a pension ; but because her hus
band was a soldier. In this was the equity of
the case. It was of ne-consequence (he said)
whether she had lived through ihe Revolution!
ary struggle, or whether, from necessity or
choice, she had not married until after the year
1794. He was opposed to the passage of the
bill, not because he was opposed to the princi
ple, for he was in favor of that, in all its length
and breadth. Under the present law. there
to repay this borrowed money. Or did he in
land to vote for Treasury notes, to pay the hard
earnings of our soldiers in what the Democrat
ic party have been in lhe habit of denominating
rajj-rhonev I He should like to hear the nen
tleman upon' these quesions.
Mr. ATKINSON replied: I will tell the
gentleman that,; whatever may be necessary for much money there he c
mo uticiiu' ui uiu rims anu nonor oi inecoun- jn-onie tnould be taxed t
try, I am willing to lay a lax, either directly or But Mr. A.(ohjccted to il
indirectly, on ail the property in the tinted and would movo thattb'.
Slates. He would tell any gentleman that he tho bill to the House, iu,
would do any thing for the preservation of tho be rejected.
honor of his country. These (said Mr. A.) are M. BOYDEN. I ani ?
my views. 11. that astonishes me is, that men apprehended by the ::;
will declare the war unjust, and yet vote means He certainly is the onlv
to support it. j who could misunderstar, i
Mr. BOYDEN resumed. Oh yes; here is j Mr. ATKINSON. C
Democratic ecohomv for you ! When the Na- j the gentleman from NVn
linnnl Trpnciirv, t'ic nlmnil eitiniclml ivlinn ' rinni . int .A.v.,l!nn I '
k rpi .r . a t t.imuk . aii.im. itw, ..wi.ii , iwua , uuu, ICIIAIUUII' I,.
"u"u iUU, 'iioh o we ' the specie was flowing out at both ends, and ! leader ainonjr tfco U
wovernmeni was mis.: oecause your nusnana no,hinr to sunolv its olare b.,t Trrasurv note to be .noakinrr Uv ,
o "ii j i . - i ---- " j - -
the gentleman vould vote any number of men ' the gentleman could jest
and any amount ol money to overrun and con- i as the pension nf Mary
quer all Mexico. Yes, ".when her army had j Mr. BOYDEN. Jim .
been destroyed nay, totally annihilated, by j it would bo taken for gt:;
some fifteen thousand American f-oldiers, (and ! other side of the House
a braver and more gallant body of men never j but as I understand the i'
entered a batllfe. field.) and when our forces I live ! i
since the annihilation of the Mexican army had
been trebled, and when Mexico by panting at
our feet, bleeding at every pore, he would still
vote any amount of men and money the Exec
utive might require, and, for the purpose of con
cealing the true object of those men and this
kA
were but about five thousand pens.oners ; and (Iofee of ,lolmr antl lihertv of the cotJinlry.
it would not increase the list much ,t we were ! Ma Go(J deIjver us ffom ch a dcfence of ho
to pension he widow of every Revolutionary j hon-or and Jibertv of .he country ! Oh es : he
and the gentleman has const itutional scruples; he
can find no authority in the constitution for vo
ting a pension t6 this poor widow. Oh no ; no
authority for voting this pension. Talk about
the constitution ! Who does not know that
that sacred instrument has long since ceased
to have any binding influence upon the present
Executive ?
Virginia (said Mr. B.) in what article, what
section, or what clause of that once sacred in.
strument he finds authority to dignify the Presi
dent of the United States with lhe title of con-
soldier. If we were even to double the number
it would not cause any very startling expendi
ture of money. The danger was not in paying
these soldiers too much, or doing too much for
their widows. He could not, in the present
case, admit the claim of this lady on the score
of her relationship to Major Jacob Brown ; for,
by the time of the end of tho present war, many
cases of this character would come up ; and he
doubted not, if they could be all looked up at this
time, they would amount to many as two thous
and cases. If this case was peculiar on this
score, he must confess he could not see it. He
could easily perceive why it should add to lhe
reputation of this lady, and entitle her lo lhe
consideration of the country. This whole case,
he contended, was only one among a thousand
perative one to Gen. Taylor, to advance - lnat the Senate had a right to know what was
to toe left bank ot the Kio Grandp. ahont ! "one ana wtiai was designed. ;
the meaning and propriety of which there ' Mr Cass rejoiced that war was a game, and
is no dispute. It is concluded in exactlv that secrets were necessary. He would vote for
ine same terms -as the two orders prece
ding it. He is directed to advance, and
occtp3ra position on, or near the left bank
of the Rio Grande. There is no intima
tion:?it any time after! this despatch or
General Taylor, informing him that he is
mistaken in the construction which he
putsUupon the order. On the contrary, af
ter (hat despatch must have been rcceiv-ed-n
early three months after it was
wrien it is again indicated to be the
all necessary public information whichUhe Ex
ecutive might deem it discreet to give.!
Mr. Crittenden objected to the communica
tions in a partial form, and to one Senator.
Every Senator here was an equal anS it was
hardly respectful to let just such an amount of
light, or twilight, as he regarded as mpst pro
per to give. The Senator; became here the
grave distributor of knowledge to others. He
(Mr. Crittenden) wanted the information in an
official form. Give us io-ht lihti-liht
i ne people nau a ngni to Know what th
Mr. ATKINSON. W
you said the war was un:
Mr. BOYDEN. Ihav
war was just or 'unjuff.1 1
occasion to $ay--as I haj
ent to vote on a certain i
lieve the war! to have I
unconstitutionally cornnic
tire, without any warrant i
Here tho couTersati ;i
: 4
WHIG MEETING1 IT
At a meeting of the
rus, held in Concord,' en '
on motion of; Maj. Jc Vf ;
I would ask the genileman from j bert W. Kirkpatrick
Chair, and Robert I'urh
to act as Secretary. Tl
lutions were then subml:
queror, and to authorize him, under and by vir- i Krimminger and after J
tue of that high title, to levy any amount of tax- j marks of Majj R. llarri
es he pleases upon eight millions of people, and ci Ji, i .
1 . 'i l u- i unanimously adopted :
to appropriate them to such purposes as his im- 'i 1
rooeno . 1 i... a.- . i PiTiui maiesiy rimy set: mi i .tin, uuuui uir , ...i.u, -vn"u'
1 "i . . V UT. constitution, and the defence of the liberty and ! vention to be held in Kale!;
suuuiu ub uasseu. uui ii nao ueen urged 10 . r . . . - , nnA ,,.
non; ,m r i honor of the country, alter sanctioning such ry next, and that this
villi ITIUi; Jl I C IJI VII UMlcl I tUMIHIS 1 t 1 11 , . : I i
..u t a j 1 . i ,u- 1 high handed and tyrannical measures !
would cost too much. Mr. S. deprecated this r;IM .. x. . , , ,
. . , . I heCH AIRMAN here remarked that the
ui I'liiiitrui in juuii" irms. ii nc orrce un
derstood that they would not take
XX) I f fT G O ml ha iitMil.l iKn
ni.r. : Mr. BOY DEN proceeded to say lhat when
t m c -i i i .u- he rose he had intended to submit bid one or
xii t,wui;iu9iuii, im. o. tuiu no iiiuuu uk'sl; ic
ril'Tti r
egates to represent thq !
the same.
1
.t u,, . ..... i de,)flte ha(1 vvandered awav from Mary Brown. Resolved, That c cpntn: ;
e care ot their , of t. (Jo ??, . (liminish.d COIJfiJence n th
House that vol- ; . .w-,. . ,u . iU-o ..rinrlnlei of the WhiL' s
regard the present lamontab
marks to justify himself in voting against the re
solution, whether amended or not. He should
do, as he had before said, with the hope of get
ting up a general law upon this subject ; and
if it were not for this expectation, he would vote
every individual claim of this class that might
be presented. He moved that the committee
rise and report the whole subject to the House,
with a recommendation that it be referred to
the Committee on Revolutionary Pensions, with
instructions to report a general bill.
Mr. ATKINSON said it might be that he
in an vuci
tvvn ntisarv.ilinns tn lln rOmmittPO. but that ho rountrV, as ll IS
hnd nnronapmn1v born lod oft" bv the ncntJc cessary and lortign war, v.
r A.:rn,l ih.it ho evils, as mainly attributed to t
uiiLii ituiii i i ' una. i - u'-ii v,u '
should not onlv' vote .for this pension for Mary
! .. . . ' . 1 .
me
7
design of the department, that he should ecutive meant j-j i 1 was not so keenly ulive to the principles of jus-
oceupy the same position which he was ! Mangum argued this question still fur- 1 tice' and sympathy as other men. He did not
directed to do previously. lie is direc- lner' and xvisned to know, b.nd most to know, believe that this House had the right to dispose
ted 'to do it bv a teoetition of the ordir U. i what the Executive meant: upon this subject : j of money belonging to the people by conferring
sued in June, 1845, almost in the same i wtial 7f me1. to tU mJh Mexic0 afler il was
terms. Well, now what is the inference j C0"V'rtf' lh's war was coming to! an end
from this? Jf in June, 1845, Gen. Taylor ,w 5i .k rhP werern? i ! cPm
had been provided with a train of ar il !?' Cha,r,!?n of the Comm.ttee of Mil-
i il... K , . V, 1 ,ul i itary Affairs would tell us this, he would care
lery.f he had a suitable aparatus of en-; less for the resolution, i The Senator (Mr.
gmers. he would tinder the order of June Cass) went for the conquest ot Mexico, and this
I"L 'lVB uuitncea, ana laKcn possession ; was what was meant. " .! i
Mr. Allen gave notice that he should intro.
duce his ancient resolution,- of allowing light
to come in upon all subjects, save one (and
that probably negotiations.) He would have
Brown, but that he should vote pension
widow of any American tidier that had fallen
in this War. ' CinM .nuy stand up here
and say that tlx (iovernmcnt should do less fr
this poor and aged woman than the brave and
frallant Major Brown had done for his step
mother ? But the gentleman from irginia re
marked that it -was wrong and unsafe to trust
our sympathies in such a case, and, rnoieover,
that the case should not be dt-cided upon the
cess of these principles in t
election in 19441
Resolved, Thit al this pi tit I
other during thejwhole ItUiory
it behooves ihe patriotic of ali ;
together in resisting the dative r
Executive Power, and! in brjn
Federal Government from, it? i
War and Conquest, tol its ih'p"
fostering the arts of pj'aco ai I
prosperity and htppiness of our
iiesoirea tanner, J nai il i s n
4
i 1
i '
i Aae rresident tolls you that Mexico, in of Hort Tnbpl Pvnoii;nn k f
I ! JPle her plighted word, insultingly re- frofri that position, and placing it under
used to receive our minister. Well, now thelfcontrol of the United States. If he
)tff plairi to mer-it is evident, that when : had donn sn wnnlrl K f i
, unwrtlnf in Inn orMrt n,, .-. . 1 I. r l i it .l , n .
i ' r rr-rr - i v i luiiui' intT wriif-ii 1 1 m u 1 1 n r i nn rtrri wo a 'w . 1 1 , . - : ...
; xAt-si.A Kf., ' r m "T r,T ? . mia government i , a" fxecunvo nominations considered in public
PlV bctueer . our consul at Mexico Was it not what was designed by the cov- ' aud no Executive secrets. M ;
; I 0 if the means After a few words more' the Resolution was
:rr; : ' : r:",l5Atcul,.ve ioeen in. u,.s po o T u s evident , adopted.
$tr resident from the United States. The
l r .1 .i . . .
rzyfrsivn Meq l tnuiK, on me loth' of Qc-
toper, 1815 " The Mexican government
; vtl receive a commissioner to settle the
preicnt dispute ; and two months jhere
, nuer.on hc 15tb of Uecembcr,
it was so designed, because when thpv
hat given him tho means and the same
order-he assumes the position with the ! ANVO m,en; sa!: tb.e f-aarensburg
entire approbation and suDDort of the ! T ' "efaiu' Irom Kutherford county,!
it on any object which, in their opinion, may be
deserving of the national sympathy and compas
sion. The powers of Congress were strictly
defined. They must act on the principle of Jaw,
and not upon the principle of sympathy or their
own id3as'of justice ; because that which would
excite the sympathy of one man might excite the
ridicule ot another. and the contrary. He would
go as far as any to support the widows of Rev
olutionary soldiers, but must protest against
Congress putting its hand in the public purse
out of sympathy merely. Mr. A. considered
lhat the various reasons given by gentlemen for
their support of this bill, in" themselves furnish
ed argument against the principle involved in
this special legislation.
Afler further debate upon the merits of the
case by Messrs. D. P. KING, DICKINSON,
JOHNSON,of Arkansas, and ROCKWELL,
principles of justice. , , "esoirca janner. jqaiuisr.
Mr. ATKINSON hei again interposed and h ,he people throughout the U
remarked: Bectxusc we could never come to
any conclusion upon (hat principle.
Mr. BOYDEN. There may be men who
cannot safely trust their sympathies, but, for his j
part, he had always relied ypon his, and thought
they could be trilled, especially when they led
lo charitable and benevolent deeds. The gen- ;
tleman said he was willing to tax his constitu- j
entsto defend the liberties of the country. But ;
primary assemblages, Uboli d !
their opinion on he prejsen coud!;"
affairs, in order, jthat ihpir ii!cnc
construed into ah approbation t.f t
tho present administration bf tic I
vernment.
The following' persons were tl
as Delegates under thelfirst reso!
George W. ScoU, Mscs;Peit?, (.
T n . i .
government. Wp . now f t uarneu n ery preuy mulatto CirJ.
onthsjhere-i sinqlar mode of proceeding, if tho obiect yP?rS old to that Place to sel1 er-
(TQ en J n Inrm o a r . 1, . . .
SrrrJu ' r ? r Fe. Preserve peace and amity be. ! r ' "T 7rtXouf I other side of the House, and partirulaly those
constituents for earning on this war for" the
conquest of a sister Republic ?
Mr. ATKINSON replied. He would vote
any tax which might be necessary to prosecute
the war vigorously, in order. to secure an honora
ble peace. He would ask: the gentleman from
North Carolina jf h. would do that ? Let him
say yes or no to it. !
Mr. BOYDEN said he ;had no difficulty in
that wna not an answer lo ihp noesl ion he asked , cr, . 1'. Pharr. John r. Khiler, K
him. Why does the gentleman answer in this , ,fn. John Shimpck, Rpfus'Barrii
evasive wav?. He would ! repeat the question. Scott, Jas. L. lladger, Dr. iS. L. (
Would the centleman vole! a direct tax unoirhis C. Means, J. F- Gilmer, JJW. 1)! .-
rier, ur. . o. liingham, .ictor U. 1
V. S. Harriii, S, C. Harrl.; IU
trick. R. C. Cook, Kjrbyi Pope, J
While, Dr. W.IW. Itankfn, ;ani 1
Harms. . ;
On motion ofL.,B.
ceedinzs of this Imeetii)
Carolina Wa'cbman,
Raleigh Reniier.
ROB. KIIIKPATRICJ
Rob. Burton; Sec
:?Z&?i.!t "'e PCr60a "je I bedn take for Some cause. ro JZ
of Massachuselts
Mr. BOYDEN, in support of the bill remark
ed lhat he was at first a little surprised at lhe
observations of some of the gentlemen upon the ; answering this or any other question that he 1
or any other gentleman detired to propound to
mrr
sorpe cause, real or 8uir??n was "cstedf but the other escaped.
. ti . . 1 O f Hnp nrrocfaii iravn hta noma fnn
, j . . .icu iui oIIle cause, real or sun-
M A. aV " 8",""mcnt - lle pod, that before . I,e J'resi lent sends his
The one arrested gave his name as Jos.
of the gentleman from Virginia, who hadlaken t htm. He was glad of the opportunity to de-
occasion to read us a lecture upon the dinger Clare that, as at ipreient aqtisca, ne would not
nrimmincr,
i ! i t i I
BeiekCkcek, Wilkes co.. J
of trusting our sympathies, or even the princi- j vote a single man nor a dollar of money for the , Messrs. Editors': Is
r i '
i2ia nnprtinn r l . 1 . -r .
i 7 i- "wuirj-iie uiejfican
j cwwtcrreplie8 in substance, not a word
In. uie credentials of t))is person
bot4t ling any differences. He is sent
DtrAat Mtiilnnt minUi.. i "
Z tit ' 7i pienipoientiary.
A if Iriefldiplomatic relations between
w, wo coy nirwis had ne ver for a
I .HteUit j055ibir to read the corrrsp
order i icciiAt tU
and scope of which was to place a rpilita
ry force within the territory claimed aqd
occupied by Mexico. Xnw. ; it k.
Wilt ' .nnUV l.f. , ' --- -- .-v,.w. w, mi
ivju iimL iinii stipn n m nn & I : .1 , . . ; . . v
mJH- ; mu,u"cu "eP ' w lIB PcPe. reported inlthe Legislature
o . . . i. t i 01 irusnn our pvuiuai
w n- ?rn. Sa,d 15? - eL WaS Damed l pies of jiisiice, unless we had rules prescribed purpose of carrying on this war for tho con. ! wijen voti' notidc tin irn
VV llliam Wilson. dkersiin Carjttt ! : J .. t i i .... j : j,:..:' r f-; ' Ito vrnnll rnia i ...nnt ik. ! ' . . i 1 .1
. lo U9 (J wniC we "inoiicu in UUIUUII3- w-jai 'i i'jvah.". - - -wo ""m w- i ,u Sfnnriflrfl mnn nairM h-
fc
irnoi e
tenng it. The gentleman had taken occasion ! men now in :iexico; ne would pennon tneir t. j0 ti wi til draw
.C7, r .- . -r.1 I-.,. . i to cro into a lonfr discussion of our pension law. Widows if ihey fell ; ho would go still further . x .Z -A- rA 5n r r
Kstuvunu jitieciors. : 1 ne 0111 toi 7 ,..7 ... . 'r 1 ;n;r :r tv. ui J . toineueces.o.. iu r
-ive the eWtiT ? V i T and seemed to be greatly alarmed at the idea of -he was willing if jbougK necessary, to vote
S !I1? n PJrC8l?Inn?1 TC,rS doling a small ..ension to the p(or widow, whose , the most liberal ovi.ion U the familie. of all i
moment
on-
only prop and stay in her declining years had . who foil or died In the service.
war, in fight inj; the
if f 1 . calculated to rouse the! m-1 of South Caroling, having been defeated ! PT . tJ m
dignation of Mexico, and. to nrfl I ; " ' Ue'eaieU I fllen through the Mexican j
Posidbilitv nf SMflr 'rZurA ?V compel - an- extra ses- battles of the country. From lhe great solicb
between the two conn VVJV " T ' W cast its Electo- uide of the gentleman fbr the safety of the Trea
tionlwas desirable ?h1; A W.g? T' Tj lhr "PPointed by sury, he hoped lhat the gentleman from Virgin
on was uesiMule, if the President him-1 the Law of Congress. i ,,t ..i;..;t.
Avr from Mexico for ihih
tural, and unjust war," in wl.
Mr.-McLANE. desired the gentleman from ! 5&Q' ia .V l,r
North Carolina to inform him whether bo would j cmc V -TkVi TllTn T I
vote means to reinforce ami make safe the ar-f abotut J. or "fr , j i f ';
my now in ..Metjeo qr ihcnavy ofT the coast ? ; made his .Ppwrfful sjcc. ;
Mr. BOYD EX,' Does the gentleman from ' Question, he made him ti
I