J 11 I.JU JWIU'IIJ
IJ0.43
Jid- i.Yjrik' Carolina GazfUtr
:'. - " naieHEi, wikkit, at
THOU AS J. I.E.TIAV.
TKItMS. - .
iiMCirTi i", three ilnllnre pr annnm rne
ill kritlr rtiiVre4 1 pay the whole '. M most liberal amendment
aiMint of the eri tubwriitlinn )n aiiranae.
k Mimwrt rr iecrt w (T fi Itee.iT f i nei.
joicrten tiirew iimri mr one Hollar, anil ei
.S,reenla for each ennlititianre.'
I ifriii to lite Kditnr nail be post paid . ;
STATE COXVEXTIOX
Jn the Thirljr-Serona
Article
. v Tuttday, June SO. ..
Gen. D0CK.ERY rose to make a
tisrsestion to the gentleman from Cra-
en, who rail just addressed the House
i eloquently, ni! Iliat toe propriety
amending this article be submitted
the .People in a distinct and sena
te proposition. ' . To incorporate it in
e Constitution, would endanger its
tifiention by the people. After the
tisfactory exposition of th princi-
les of the Catholic Fait by the een-
eman from" Craven;' he3ar-wHlinz
rWuWfvHmen
re, oy, inie,rinng wnn it.
Gen. D. said, it had become, very
shionable here, ami fashion was con
uioOr for Cffitlf men t tiv at
ae of their- Religious tenets. The
ntleman from Buncombe, (Governor
ivain) said lie belonged to the Pres
tterianChurch, if he h'l never been
rned out lie Gen.- D.) belonged
the Baptist CUu (Ii, and was certain,
had, not : been turned - out."' But
nugh a member of hat Church, he
at not disposed to exclude Catholics
6m ofnee, however, all who were op-
bud to the alteration of that Article
Jt ! Ii ncture, migh t bt '.il enminccd
s ui gui or jraoufu lunat tcs. i v as
o recpect to be paid to the feelings or
rejudices of the people, on this ques-l-WTiatever
other- potiticat "siiis
e flight have to answer for, no one
nuld accuse him of pnying too much
ourt to the. people on the contrary,
i trieniu thought he paid too little
t when their viHhes were" known;
ey ought to be respected. ; -
Much had been said by the gentle-
m r-'r-W'---.-; -r r.., W,.,,.. r..C ....
an irom graven, in relation to me
vert u res made to the East from the
ftttt. In his. section of country.
ie-tenth of the people were not
)are that this Article was to be
ldfhedi Antl why Vtrf Because the
nuuteui extensively in me " est, in-
irmation in that quarter not being ne-
fssaryraswas imagined but the East
as flooded with pamphlets. It was
lifTicient for the 'West to know that a
onvention wis to be called to redress
f fir grievances on the score of tine-
luaj Representation. - As to the vote
h Convention being thinner one year.
ah another, to which the gentleman
ad alluded, it was owing ( the cir-
mstanre of the;, tieople having dis-
vered that this- article was" to- be
"At one of- the ' election
ounds in his county, he had been ask-'
by several gentlemen, it the jLon-;
itut'on, when formed, would be sub
itteI to the, people. On his assu-
lnce, tnat it wouiu, tney tnen saiu
ley would vote for calling a Conven-
fiii, reserving tue rigni io vote against
be Constitution if this Article were
terfered-withssn
Gen. D. repeated that he wished to
new that he uid not deserve to be
rinded as a bigut for, if an opportu
ne were anortieu ntm ior voTin to
nend: theAificl- at' the : polls,-he
fention, but from a conviction, that
' people would reject the Constitu
Mr. 'GASTON said, that having exr
fessed his view so fully,' it was with
jxtreme reluctance he rose, to "say an-
u'er, worn, -rie nan intenueti. wiien
similar susrrestion to that now jnade
y the kind irentieman from Richmond,
fa thrown out by the gentleman from
ffene General Speight) to have said
word in reply. The gentlemen seem
predicate their suggestions on the
round that ne . tiar gome particular,
ersonal interest -in this matter, He
ed to assure them that this was not
e case that' if Catholics were ex
pdetl from office, no man in the State
fould feci less pain at the circum-
pnee than he would.- He believed if
I ouwnright attack were made upon
ffbgiou freedom by the, retention of
' twojiit atir vpx tbe j real
WMaise, of the fxplt1 and after a
i't!e.8ervestenc; of feeling had woik
lthat there would be, fro'in! the
jeofail) s to the seaboard, but one sn
j'nt of dissatisfaction. V : .
j jV't.h eganl to the suggestion about
iUched amendments,' he was for two
rns opposed to it In the first
l.',fc w,e "o authority to do it
H ,n theaeebnd, if we had, we ought
We are to submit an entire' Con.
'totioa to the people not deiched
PJentsit jnust. gtthem. as an
fiVr HARRINGTON did not rise to
Btt a speech on tha'cooiinittee, but
J 'aim ply In' say, that 12 years ago, hav
I ing had the honor to propose that this
stain
sHoffltttoe-" blotted "frnm'fttve iihin T'hnatiana tvnrakln An.L .k.t
1 cutrhpnn. u-aa time lKn ,!;
posed to incur an j responsibility which
might rest upon him. His voice, it was
true, had not been heard in this dis
- - --. ..v -.", " . I. , tun-
cussion, bat his silence must not be
Menoibe Hl lo rertmiB i rrer longer tconstrned into a wishjo ikulfe Jioiadu-j
JJr. SMI III regret,t.ed that he should
be again called 'to address the commit
tee on this question, but circumstan
ces rendered it necessary he should appear-either
in person or by Attorney;
It would seem that the Convention had
esiaoiisiiin'r some new K,eiirimtr or iq
Wfthtsrffie friaT lf (RT'cownty'-if Or
ange and her Delegates on this floor. '
He had yet to learn what either or them
had none to merit such particular (lis
tinctiiin. He felt it to be liis duty to
submit a lew observations, in reply to
the gentleman from Craven, who had
singled out the people of Orange as a
tar-jet to hoot. at; though. : as- the
Chairmsn of this committee well knew,
he did not possess the physical ability
d go into an elaborate investigation of
matters whicjb. jiemce .tXkyxy.iAi
rntirmaT ConveTitTpru
t -wlikJi ftV gentiemati" fronr Craven
had alluded. 1 his Article was dis
cussed in that Convention, antl was re
tamed in the Constitution presented to
hpep!e.Hi8 ownimpresisiiSR .'ttlhe'
time," was, that it oui;ht to be altered,
but more mature reflection had chang
ed his opinion. His name had also
beert read out by' the tentleman.T as
composing one of a committee appoint
ed to distribute an Address, in which
the expurgation of this Article was re
commended. It was true, that tlywHH
pointment had been conferred upon
him, but it was equally true, that he
had not distributed the documents for-
warded to hiiiu They were sect to his
)ffirew11iltsborhrhrirrhereT
sumed, the greater portion of them yet
n.l M.. tn..uj ii all t a ii a
that he had circulated them, and that
the people of Orange were once in fa
vor of ..ran amendmcnt-of -tnin.-Article
and were now opposed to it? He want
ed to know who had the right to say
they shOUldnof change" their opinions
as often as they pleased. ' I hey had
the rirht ahd were not to he arraipupd
on mis noor lor me exercise pi it.
They also had the right to instruct their
Delegates for every community is
privileged to express us opinions, any
ine rigui to no so in smaller mailers,
involve me right s
ubliiatiohs referred to, were not dis- j portant questions. Is Orange county,
with her 500 voters, too insignificant
to be heard on this floor? : Whatever
others thought, he felt himself bound
to obey the known wishes of his con
stituents; and he should do so.
- Allusion has also been made, said
Dr. S. to the small number of votes by
wh'ch I was elected a Delegate of this
body." The vote was not a large one,
it is true Sir, but it was large enough
to elect me. But why was the vote so
small? There were ten Candidates,
every one of whom was probably more
worthy than himself, but the people did
not tlunk so, and the vote was divided
among so many, that the largest vote
was a small one. This Sir, is the rea
son. If however, he had been sent
here by twenty Totes, he i.houliJ ron
sider himself as representing the whole
county of Orange. . He was born and
raised-there anil ought to be presumed
to know the feelings and wishes of the
people. : " , - . ' ..
; Df. S. saiJ, that ftir.the, remarks
which heTliad previously submitted on
this jjuestion .hOiatf .peenTcalTettra"
Uieuti but lie imasr'tned; that- he was a-
Btvll lle would .ii4it-C!M"ffT0"frohf- the influence bf
Priestcraft as any gentleman on that
floor. -"The object of all governments
pie Wd when the wislies of the eo
pl are known, a good government will
conform to them In the British Gov
ernment, within a few years, how often
has theSoyereign liimself bctn com
pelled to 'yield to-theorce of public
opinion as a matter of policy. The
same results have occurred in France
and elsewhere, the' most powerful Sov
ereigns have bowed with deference to
its irresistible influence. It is more
operative in this country, and the prin
ciple applies" with equal force to large
or -smau communitiea of men.
Sir. said Dr. S. there is no rjasom
why this Article should be amended
there is no emergency which demands
it What persecutions have been aU
tempted, that gentlemen are so' ex
cited? rli had K1 nothing in dispar
agement of JloTnati' Catholics he had
as much respect for some Catholics that
heTtnew, as anr member in this Con
vention. "But Ve was not willing, by
expunging this Article, to let in Turks,
Hindoos and Jews. They might call
him a bigot as much as 'they pleased,
but he would not ronscnt to this. In
what way could "we bind thern to a
proper discharge of their duties, if we
should admit them? Must4 we swear
the Turk nri tile' Koforh must ivc sen".
airte tlie Holy Scriptures' that weinay
wear the Jew on the OUTestamcnt?
If a Tura comes to .our country, let
him be a Mussulman and nj y hva
RALEIGH; N.. THUIISDAY, 00T03l 10; IC35
1 . ..JTWid ' ' .' in' ; ii 'i
Religion; but if he thrusts himself .in
to our Civil Compact, he ou?ht to wor.
I imp h MAntlnm-m f.... ".... n :i. .
I k t.1 VI.. Cllll(IUU IIU iiiAfru lllltl
think, he could not concur in his lati
tudinarian doctrines of Religious free
dom. As an American citizen, and a
native-born son of Korth Carolina, he
jia wHiBgkatertetlRbuTd 1
dulge in their own peculiar species of
worship but he was not willing that
they should .fill, the high places 4 the
land. The rights of men are necessa
rily restricted. The Minister of the
Gospel is precluded from a seat in the
Legislature, because policy requires
it, and there are various other, res-
property a man Cannot VOte Tor a teen -
ator, unless he own a freehold.
fi. l..' . i
These are civil rights, as contra - du -
tinguished from natural rights and no
man should be branded as a bio-ot be-
i ! .1 , t .
cause he considers that Government
best, which restrains fewest of the
natural rights of men. The right of
conscience was a natural right it did
not. grow out of the regulations of So-
cletr. r ; ; :
five gcntlemaa: from .Ciavert had
Chare4 iheesf
meutftwUlMSto t wwiin Conventw
Ther -Wt-wStfttf-f mtMrig'Wtheer
right, and if the Esst have aided them reported by the" Committee of the
to obtain it, they did so doubtless fromfWliolehe noped the Members of the
correct principles. He never imagin- Convention would forbear to olfer any
e4 htmsfrlharthey ivcre tn've'TfurtheT ameDduientr-ahtl act at once on
consideration for the vote of the East. that. rt. K.; ' :
tie stood pcnectiy acquitted to nun
self of the charge of having made any
baigai-touching" the
thought that the discussion i would endVhole.trHe had voted- id-favor-of
as it has, and that was one reason why
btndeavored to prevent ft, in the first
usance, by moving to lay the Resolu- not consider the amendment proposed
lion on the table. It was not true in by the gentleman from Wilke as re
point of fact, that this was an Eastern moving the stain from our Constitu
and Western question for so lar as he tion. and would not therefore: vote
liaiL teen enabW
were more unequivocally opposed to others might do.Jlg wjnuliLnot throw
an jlteraltonof this-Artiele than thoat"a luo io'ihe tohnlt. ', Striking out
West themselves, who, it is said, held the word Prottitanl, and inserting
out the amendment of wis Article as Christian woul j not cure the. evil j for
a bait He did not wish to offer any hj b?lieved that there were some pco
violence -to-the anderifanding which pie so ignorant, or so "blinded by prt
had hitherto existed between the two judice, as to believe that Cutholict wcret
sections; and tegrett '"that he had to" riot Christian Met as we - are, said
trespass again on thfe ine of the com- Governor B. to amend our Constitu-
mitteej but having been instructed by tion, we ought to dej it effectually, and
aTrrunequivocarexpri'Ssm iltfounded pre-
opinion, he felt bound to state the fact judices of the people. Why, said he,
Dr. S. said he was willing. to yield are the Jews to be excluded from or
to the voice of the people and if this fice?. They were th a favorite people
was deemed so important a matter, of the AlmiWhtv. Our Saviour and Via
not
rate proposition?! If they would du it,
at (the next August election, his word
for it, the question against expunging
the Article would be decided , by an
overwhelming majority. Has it come
to this, that the sovereign will of the
people shall not rule? And that there
shall be no expression of it, because it
may-come, into collision with this
body? , It was the most Anti-Republi- ernment? He was opposed to all re
can doctrine he ever heard broached; ligious. tests for office, and should
and was certainly one which could not
receive the sanction of this Convention.
; ; tf'edntiday, Jufi I,, u
; The Convention took up the Report
of the Committee of the whole on the
32d Section when Mr, EDWARDS
moved to amend the Report by insert-
ing the following, viz: '
"l nai-ail men narui' a natural ann nnaliena-
oie rtgm to woruiip Aiiuigiiiy t,a, aecorain-t to the deedi done io Ihe body." .-,
the diclalea of their own eonscivncei, all rcli-l' ti.......i:.. . it.'. . i.
rout leu. at nnaimcaiioni for office, we ineaji .t 1 ,,e qa"lon on this amendment was
pmibie wnn iiienrincipicani rree oerninent,'!.TaKcn , wniioui (ieDaie, 0 T 1 eai-aivu
!'Mf; GAITHER,Tr6ml!iurkctsaid,he' Nays and negatived 80 votes to 46V
preferred the Rcprot of the committee The Report of the committee of ,ie
of the whole to the proposed amend,- Whole being under. consideration: - ;:
mentIewould, hmiK
of. the most libfral amendment to this
article of :ihe Conalitutionj for he cansfed froin thei:otnmittee of OiS whole
sidered it a blot on that instrument
but as he was convinced it was the de-
sire of a " considerable portion of his
that if any great alteration was made
in it thev would not accent of the
amended Constitution, rather thanrun
the risk of the loss of that, he should
accept of the proposed amendment, of
the gentleman Jfrora .Wilkes (Geni
tFetlborn) as reported by the commit
tee of the whole. J Mr. O. was. sorry
that so strong a prejudice 'should pre
vail in his section of the country a
gainst the Roman Catholic Religion
but that he had no doubt when the
people came toj-ead the able exposition
01 tlie uociniica ui mat jlvciijiuii wiiitu
had been given to this Convention by
the gentleman from Craven Judge
Gaaortthese prejudices would entire
ly1 vaniah, and the amended Constitu
tion would be well received. : l
Mr. JOINEU rose, he said, tarcake
speech, but it should be a short one.
lie expressed himself perfectly satis
fied with the ; article of. the Constitu
tion under. consideration and there
fore opposed to any amendment of it
He had no doubt, the fiamers of the
Constitution had good. reasonsTor pla
cing this article in it, and he wished
to retain it " He believed, it was in-
fended to. prevent ihe Roman Catho
lies from being adioiUed to, office in
the Government.and.he approved of it
He wished to keepjtas jtceping thun-jestabllsh, the vHoly Inquisition" in
fer to be used when wanted. . V (North Carolina that we are now pre
Tbe question on Mr. EDWARDS'S, paring the wheel, and the rack, the
proposed amendment was taken by thumb screws, and the hot irons, for
In
h
Yeas and Hi
iave
been al-
ready publislied7v?Sl
negatived
87
vote to so. f-
ilMllliaMliMillW'i '""
Gen. JACOCK.S
then offered an
amendment, in the following words;
mSo pcraon ho shall ilenr the beinf of Gml
hall b eapuble of hol.linj hj uflioe or ultoe of
miLr wwirteftwwk;,f pwrtWion-jain a class of
kerebf eenreO iliill not H oni racl l miqu
ell of lieentioutne, or jwitif m-aetieea mean
ittont with theiWMW or Mfcty of the Snie." ,
.Xl-e Lqtt,MtJni..on , ,thk. Amendment
was taken without debate, by Yeas and
Nays already published and was ne
gatived by 8-2 votes to
Mr. HOL.MK3 then pronowit tl.e rottowlnt
ubitiintet "That bo perton who tlwll Heny (h
bein oi a God. shall be- eaunhle of holilimr nv
hip without Uiaerimlnalimt, ahull rirer lw frre
!' " Pf " i Wa si.ie, .roi.ie.i the rlgh
! "erehr lwlared ami eatablUhea hll nol be
!.ooUli,4 w ,M , jMif)r vnmli i
mubie with Hie freeima mfeiy of ih
;Sl"e. rWl lulher, that no itreferenee
ahail eer be ti by law to aor relieiou aeel:
or mode of or.hip.' 1 ,
The question on this Auiendineht
was taken without debate, by Yeas and
-Nftys ('already published aiid was ne
'gativcd T8 votes to 46.
Governor SWAIN obssrved, that as
it nnneared evident, from what had
tleman from Vilkes, which had been
Governor llijVtJil said, it was
not his intention to vote for the amend
every liberal proposition for amendiug
this objectionable section! but he did
performance - of- his - duty, whatever
men am 'sst the Jew as talented, as
virtuouV as well qualified to fill any
office in our Government as any other
citizens in our community? A Jew
may ba appointed to any office under
the General Government. Jle may bs
raised to the Presidency of the United
States. And why shall we refuse to
admit him to any office under our Gov-
therefore vote against th'is amendment
Judge DANIEL wished to offer the
Amendment which he had brought for-
warJ in'- Committee of the Whole, in
order to obtain the Yeas and Nays up
on it It was in the following words:
That h i expedient to remote
,iiTi'ATa'm'ntprJm aM?'4
33(1 Article, from all who lit not deny the be-
inir of a Gml ami an ccnnni.liilit in llim f.i
for the amendmcnt'hich'waf rennrti"
namely to strike out of the 32d section
of the Constitution the word Protestant,
land instead thereof insert the word
lieve in the truth of the Christian Re
ligion to hoW civil office in the State,'
In giving this vote, he was not in
fluenced by the motives, which the gen
tleman fromHalifax fGov. Branch
hail so charitably attributed to the
friends of the Amendment, that is, to
throw the tub to the whale, as he is
pleased to call the people nor yet for
the accommodation of a certain indi
vidual, as he supposes but for rea
sons which he would undertake to
(Matejor himselt-l
Mr. F. said he had listened with ve
ry strict attention to all that had been
said on this subject and,' of all d
bates he had ever witnessed, this had
taken the widest range. As regards
Ttxt, it had swept over eighteen cen
turies, and as regards sfacf., it had
travelled round the globe its fangehas
been circumscribed only by the limits
set to human imagination.; If a stran
ger, uninformed as to the true state of
the question, had dropped in here, and
listened attentively to alt that has been
said, he must havs come to the conclu
sion, that we were debating whether
we.s!iould, or not, establish a cruel
fcsr oath to bind men's consciences
, nay, most likely, he wpc
jto'the conclusion, that wi
he wpuld have come
we are about to
the punishment of recusant Papists
that fie merciless Jluto de ft. itself,
was 'fo be, kindled up in the midst of
this Protestant community. "Nowyair,
is tins sur is u true, that we are about
to establish i. test oath? Is it true,
that .we are about tu commence the
people for conscience sake? -. No, sir,
it is- not'g.i.r If srentlemen will des
cend from th. clouds, iti which . they
have'b-'en 'wanderingin," fibm"that
march of mind" we have heard so
itiucli about, they will please to march
back to tli6 regious of common sense,
they W.iI1 see that their imaginations
the rue
uiLsin ina v-onstuunon wuicn our
Rc vol u tianary t forefathers es tabl ished
for North Carolina in the year 1776,
there is a clause designated as the S2d
section, which .provides, that no per-
son who denies the being of . God, or.
the truth of the Protestant Religion, or
the divuie authority luf the old or new
Tes.Uments, . or, wno shall hdd reli-
gi iis principles incompatible with the
freedom and safety of .the State, shall
be capable of h ildinz civil office with-'
m this.,.tjai;,,Ever auicethe
:ofthgo5titul
that a part -of, Uiia Arjisle. lJLUbera
aaimpto'k-enm
ers have, thought that, thn whole of it If .the ' 321 Article-was expunged
ought to be expunged Jn consequence from tlie Constitution and the instru
bf these ppiiiions, the Legislature in mnt then? placed in the hand of an
the.ctndtwhichthia it,
meets, gave a discretionary power to wl&t would he suppose our Religion
the Convention 'to amend the 32d Ar- to be? H would first read the 19th
Vicle orme Constitution f ' anl the on-
ly question now before us is Shall we.iwhic1ihcL wnuld-aea- that vnW men,'
anrnJit. or shall we leave it as it is?. Christian, Turk, and Jew, stand pre.
Some wish to amend it, others wish to cicely on the same footing, and con
strike it out altogether, and others a- sequently, Sit far as this goes, in North
gain wUli to leave it as it is. For my Carolina, the Christian has no advan
parti il Mr, F. I am ; opposed - to tage. over the Turk. V Ha would then
striking out the whole Article, but I dime to the Slat Article, where h
wish to amend it. - To amend is one would sea that Preachers of the Goi-.
thing to strike out altogether is jtud juidiulett'" frow"" hoIitHty-ai-ata-
oUierVhava-rSlitt
we have no nower to deslroyn tOmncirof State, but that : Preachers
strikeout altiTgRTier would be to de-
stroy. ; ;;; 7-- -.v:. ; -
Among the arguments advanced by
those who are for itfiklng oiitraftogetJn'-0 v-nnstianity; -- m WouItT next
er7oiie Is7tirt the 824 Article comes com , toL th"- S4,, Article. If ho
in direct conflict with the 19th section ould have- sagacity enough to dia
of. weBill.of Rights, which prohibition in .
uTk.c .11 .. n.i..i .h.i nn. this article, he would at the same time -.
alienable right to worship Almighty
Gudaccording to tha -UicUWs of their
own conscience." Mr, F. said, for
his part, he could not see this conflict
this incompatibility; The 19th
sectiou of the Bill of Riuhts . secured
toall meirhrTight
God according to the dictates of their
own "conscience the 32d Article does'
not deny this right, nor take it away nw uoobta wi I vanish, for in this ha
it does not prenribe any mode of will see a full recognition 7 of Chris. 1
wonhip, or any set of religious prin- tiamty. - Then, I ask again, shall wo
Ciples it only declares, that pers-ins ?Pun8e lh only Article that recog.
who deny the" being of God, te. shall .n,"4t mr U,"ionl auA leVfr ml '
not ba ca'pable of. holding civil office gi.we Articles which ; appear rather ;
within this State. Now, to show that to discountenance it? If we had now.
the 32d Artkle conflicts with the 19th ft to tnke out the whole, he did not
section of tha Bill of Rights, gentle-.know that anj greatevils would follow'
men must first prove, that it is neces- fronLd,Hn? ,0 'ad no rear" for' '
sary for men to hold civil office be- t,,e Cliristian Religion. It had spread .
Tore they can worship God according to what it now is, against all opposi.
to the dictates of their own con--;ton - U ftrew p in despite of oppres- .
scien:e. , W'ilt anynertse up here ,0,) and flourished under perse. , -and
say, that you must first be in pos-, cu,12,,,,l W "ave B"ll,,ng ' -er for ,
session of a civil offiein North Caro- ,ts ,fina' triumph but we have no
Una, ' before yon cao. exercise the lmc'1 Pow'er. "d as the subject stands r
freedom of conscience? Nof'no one balamed in the Constitution as it now .
wilt say sik The Turk, the IIin-ia.0.e
doo, the wild Savage of our own for.J,,ue' r?, ?. other. i : ; - -
ests, can come among us and worship;
Ma a,ccortitng to-tfte dictates of their
consciences, and there is; nothing in
our Constitution or laws to harm them,
or make them afraidi lihey cannot --6K--I
y wo
tateii
wofidiiCloiHwewothele of' '
ei of the1rowircunscTeiice7bUt they" Po' .shall. bx.ca'wblof-hihijrig - -j"
acquire all the civil, and I politi- any oCice, prplacw of trust or profit in '
may
al rights of native-born citiaemi they
are protected . In their - persons and
wa.t:f, -uu -1 HK!- peipte--cnoofle to
vote for them, they may occupy seats
in the Legislature, and become law
makers themselves. Tlie . S2d Arti
cle deprives them of none of these
rights, .either, civil of religious, but it
forbids them from holdinir civil office.
to long a$ the; may deny the being. of
uoa, or me ouier-truuis reierreu to
in that' Article. Surely, there is
nothing so very cruel and prescrip
tive in this, as gentlemen would seem
to make out ; Mr. F. said, it appcarr
ed very strange to him, while-gentle
men were.so bitterly denouncing the
S2d Article, tliat the 31st should have
entirely escaped their noticed '.'If the
32d Article . excludes. Atheists-and
Deists from civil office, does not the
31st go much. farther for it excludes
Preachers of tha Gospel; from Seats in
tho Legislature? 4 Will gentlemen
contend that . the doors ; -to civil office"
shall be- throw n open to Atheiats and
Deists, and that the Teacher or the
Christian Religion, shall be shut out
from our Legislative halls? If it ' is
a violation of principle to exclude the
A.tocisi anu uetsi irom uuicr, 1a n not
equally so to exclude the Preacher of
the Gospel from tire Legislature, and
r .,r;;i ',1: -
irom seats in me wouncii 01 oiaier
But the sympathies of gentlemen seem
to be with the one class, and not-with
the other. A Preacher of Mahomc
danism may come among as, build his
mosque, collect his congregation, and
preach; to them, and, if he has the '
civil qualifications,,; may be- elected -.. .
to, and take his seat in the Legisla
ture, while the Teachers 'of ur own "
Religion of that Religion on which
all our institutions stand, are denied
the like privilege' and yet gentlemen- -"
who talk so mudi about liberality and
the march of mind have not uttered a
single whisper against the 31st Ar-
tide! ' ' ' '
MrTTrsaidriie wouldl now state
what to, his mind was a very Irong
argument against itriklng out the S2d
section.. It , we take up Uie Consti
tution and esam'vna it, we will find
.tliabteAia-fwaAw
.which hayft refereueani tlwChristian'"' -
Religion that is, the 19th section of
the Bill of Rights, and the Slst. S2d.
an 34th sections of the, Constitution. -
Thrt$o( these would seem rather to
discountenance, or throw aside the
Christian Religion, while the other
one alone, namely, the seem to
recognize it Now sir, shall we, a '
Christiat) people, living in a Christian
country .-expunge from our fundamen
tal law, the. only Article which recog-
nixes Christianity, and.lea.ve remain
Article of theBtll of Riahu, from
JKLlIieialatwrv
"f the Koran are not so forbidden thus
lar no wouidseethat the Constitution
. mora uyoraoie to Mahomedanikm
,i'co,vr haV a jealousy exists rgainst
"RiSiouXlhur(;hea..tWrak. - alto- - -,
Sr ? w,u nothing against ,
l,,e religion of the 1 urk. but an evident
"Passion against the Christian Re-
."g'onand so far as he an judge fromj
whether.we aiehmtians, -But now
wfore himthe S2.t Article, and alt
be unwilling to expunge on
But, said Mr. F. let us take tip .tha ; :
jsta section itseti, examine its parts,
'nd see if it be so very objectionable ' '
las soine w ould inake i out to bo. The '. --
first tlausc is In" these words "That
the eiviM -part m eh fwithin this Go y
ernmint" ? Nnw Sir, is tins so very
m-a-Chi rttT eimmffnrtyr to exctuitaf' "'
from civil office the man who denies
the being of Gtd?-the. wrktoh who -can
took up at the glorious sun ga.i
on tlie starry heaven. Mhe spacioua
firmament on high.V wlio can look a .
broad oh the face of na tu re, or tu 111 .
hi eyes irr on his own bosoni. and yet
deny the being of God,' If jt is bigot,
ry to witiihold civil trast, or moral con-
ffdence from such a wretch,' then Sir, "
for one, I am willing "to, be written
down as-a bigot. Some gentlemen,
hawerer, tell us that there are no such
persons as V?ie', that is, no person -who
deny the being of Qod. - If they -intend
tliis assertion as an argument
why t fie clause in question ought ,to ba
stricken out,' then I meet it as followa- ,
There are either suth persons as Athe-,
isti. or . there are not Mf.thpr K
such p'crsons, tlieif they poghi net! to
be trusted .with .office, -;of. vith,anf , 1
thing'clse and, "if, there be Jiosueh
persnils, then this elause in the tni- -,
tution is at most b'it lurnlus.isp, and. ,
as it takes up but little room, it.iuayaa ,'
well remain as an evidence or the hon
est pi ecaution of our forefathers. But,
Sir, I (liner with gt-niieraen, when -
they say there are n such persona as
Atheists. I cannot ny. reinaiked Mr.
F. that I know any surh, but we hava .
hearil of Ibei'ii. ;W"e read Iliat during
the French Revelation, tihtion tri
nmohed in alt Fraocer-We read that
the Natioual Asa: robly,exutl!ei Chris.