IUX ORGAN OF TEE NORTH CAROLINA BAPTISTS DEVOTED TO BIBLE RELIGION, EDUCATION, LITERATURE AND GENERAL INTELLIGENCE '
Volume 58.
$-4
RALEIGH. Nl C. WEDNESDAY' JANUARYS Iftfla.',
Number 20.
The Biblical Kecorcjer.
PUBLISHED EVERY WEDNESDAY. ;
113 (up stairs) FayetterUle 8treet, Raleigh, N. 0.
' .Terms o Bubscbiptiow: .' ' i
Om copy, one) year. .", . .... . . ... '. t 8.00
Onoopr, six months.. .............. ,...,- 1.00
Club of ten (copy extra to sender) .......... 30.00
" Anonymous communication! will always' find
iheir way to the waste basket. No exceptions. ,
In sending letters of business, It is absolutely neo
Mary that you give your poetoffloe address In fulL
DO WW in-Mi-im.iii Jiiur limn
when your subscription expires, and also serves as
a receipt for your money. , .v ; i ,;x ,;
Obituaries, sixty words long, are inserted free of
barge. . When they exceed this length, one cent
for each word must pe paid in advance.
. When writing to hare your paper changed, please
state the poetoffloe at which you receive the paper,
as well as the one to which you wish It changed..;.
u.rtffln. rWvlw Puital Nnt TTi nimi mm -rttwft -
payable to the order of the Publisher. Do not send
tamps.
.Talks About Law-No. 0.
BT JUDGK B. W. WINSTON.
TBI UW OF BELF-DtriNCI. -
- la oar State, whenever a person admits
that he has killed another with a deadly
weapon, the law supplies malice : and, if
nothing else appear, he is guilty of mur
der. Facts in mitigation or justification
of his conduct must appear in evidence,
otherwise he pays ' the capital penalty.
As is well known, in all criminal cases,
the State must satisfy the : jury, beyond
all reasonable doubt, of the guilt of the
accused. J. But this rale has no applica
tion when one admits that he has slain
another. . For when he makes this admis
sion there is an end to all reasonable doubt,
and ttiA rWanriiint baa thfl hnrdnn mat tinnn
himself to show facta and circumstances
Every killing Is a homicide. But, of
When no particle of blame attaches to one
....... . . - .
in kuiing anotner, tne law says mac ne 19
justified in the act The familiar illustra
tion of this is when the sheriff does execu
tion upon one by hanging him.
t Then we have the general classification
called excusable homicide. This may arise
in several ways. If a person be doing
lawful act and accidentally kill another, this
is excusable homicide through misadven
ture. Or if one is set upon by another, and
being "pressed to the wall," slay his assail
ant to save his own life or his person from
treat bodily harm, this Is called excusable
homicide in self-defence. It is of this that
we propose, in part, to write in this article.
Before doing so, however, we will explain
that there is another and deeper grade of
homicide called felonious homicide. If the
felonious killing be with malice, and this
malice may be express or implied, we have
the crime at which human nature shudders,
called murder. -Bat if the felonious slaying
be without malice, we have manslaughter.
Let us consider, therefore, what are the
excusesthat the law adjudges sufficient to
redace the grade of the killing from murder
to excusable homicide or to manslaughter.
In the first place, let it be borne in mind
that words, however grievous, will not jus
tify a blow, or excuse, or indeed even miti
gate a killing.; That is to say, if one use
the most opprobrious epithet to your very
face and, in consequence of the same, you
strike him, you are guilty of a battery; or,
if you kill him, you are guilty of i murder.
True, in the former case the party who used
the words would be indictable for an anray,
but you would not be excusable.! Generally
speaking, the party who provokes the diffi
culty is the more guilty of the two, and is
so treated by the courts. .What will excuse
a blowl and what will excuse a killing t
Now quite a variety of facts and circum
stances will mitigate a killing from murder
to manslaughter, but what will absolutely
excuse the fact t .
' If one strikeand slay another to save his
own life or his person from great bodily
harm, which the assailant is about to and
would ififlict but for the disabling blow, the
slaying is excusable. So if one kill another
to prevent a felony threatened and begun,
and which if committed would be punish-
uia wun aeaiu, ne is wtuusauio.? w
; For example, if a man were breaking into
your dwelling in the night time and you
were to shoot and kill him to prevent the
crime, you would be excused. ' So if one
make a criminal assault on a female andjs
killed to prevent it, it would be excusable
homicide. But after the assault was con
summated if the assailant were killed, not
4. . 1.1. 1 l i it,, kmii nf nan.
v yie vtm met escape, uui iu uo um v i ,
sion, this would be murder. v ' r
Even if one kill the violator of the sanc
tity of home in flagranti delicto it is not ex
cusable homicide, but manslaughter The
famous Daniel Sickles trial for the slaying
of Philip Barton Key in Washington City
many years ago illustrated this point: and
in the trial, the opinions of our North Caro
lina Judges were often quoted. "VA K
If one, arrested by an officer for a felony,
Is making his escape and it become neces
sary to shoot ic order to hold the prisoner;
this is excusable homicide, perhaps. Cer
tain it is, If the offender is resisting arrest.
So it Is apprehended that if a private citizen
arrest one who has committed a capital fel
ony, and the offender endeavors to escape,
and it becomes necessary to shoot and kin
in order to hold the prisoner, this would be
excusable. Many years ago a man shot and
killed another who was walking in his front
yafd in the night time. '.The party was not
committing any offence. Our courts held
that to kill a man to prevent a bare civil
trespass was murder. -, :
Our statute ' provides that ' every person
present at any breach of the peace shall en
deavor to suppress the same, and if neces
sary may arrest the offenders.
A case occurred in the county of Wayne
in 1870 which is interesting. Barney Bry7
ant had a hog stolen. He suspected a fel
low named Cogdell. Armed himself and
wenttoCfcgdelrs houserrCogdell,-being ac
cused ; by Bryant of the theft, ran away.
Bryant ordered him four times to stop, and
then shot and hit him. - For this Bryant was
tried and convicted. "Had he killed when
he shot it would have been manslaughter at
the least, say the court. It will be ob
served that this stealing did not occur in the
presence of Bryant; nor did he say that he
came to arrest Cogdell; nor was It shown
that the shooting was necessary to prevent
his escape; nor did he have a warrant
In , this case the court clearly intimate
that one is not to be excused who slays
another not arrested, but fleeing from arrest
for; a minor felony, such as theft "and the
like. ".'.v-is,; .; 1 rr- '--'V
. , But it would seem that it the offence com
mitted be capital, and a person present
makes known bis intention to arrest, and
the felon flee he may be killed-if it be nec
essary to kill to prevent his escape. v
i Therefore, in these latter days of bur
glary, we may take courage, for if the burg-
lar is fleeing from our house in the dark and
we command him to halt and be under ar
rest, and he fail to do so, but continues his
flight, and we shoot and kill him, and the
shot be necessary to prevent his escape, this
would be excusable on our part.
.We have seen that words will not
excuse a blow or mitigate a killing. But a
blow will often reduce the grade of homicide
from murder to manslaughter. r
For example, if two men meet and fight
willingly, and in the heat of passion one
slay the other, this is but manslaughter.
The law has regard for the weakness of
mankind. "'
Sometimes one man will have a grudge
against another, malice the law calls it, and
he will provoke that other to strike, and
after, the first blow is stricken, the party as
saulted will draw his weapon and take hu
man life. If the jury find such facts as
these it would make a case of murder. We
do not have malice if the crime be man
slaughter, "Malice, prepense", and the
V furor brevis" do not go together. Mal
ice excludes passion ; passion presupposes
the absence of malice." This doctrine was
laid down in Madison Johnson's: case, in the
first volume of Iredell's Law. And while it
has not been changed to this day, still our
court, in a case in the 80 N O. R. against
one Barnwell, say that if there be malice,
and a reconciliation take place, and then a
killing, on a first provocation,-the law will
refer the motive to the latest, provocation,
and not to the old grudge.
Generally speaking, therefore, we may
say that a killingupon provocation is not
murder but manslaughter.
But in a crie against one Curry, in the
first of Joo.es, we find three exceptions to
this rule as follows :
1. When there is. provocation, no matter
how strong, if the killing is done in an un
usual manner, evincing thereby deliberate
wickedness of heart; it Is murder.
2. Where there is but slight provocation,
if the killing is done with an excess of vio
lence out of all proportion to the provoca
tion, it ia''murder.':--" -.-
8. Where the right to chastise is abused,
if the measure ' of - chastisement, . or the
weapons used, be likely to kill, it is murder.
B- A drunken fellow caught hold of. the
bridle rein of a man's horse and wouldn't
let the rider i proceed on bis journey. His
journey was delayed about ; ten minutes.
The men were somewhat related, and had
j ust been drinking together Finally the
man on the horse dismounted, knocked
the offender down with a jug, filled, with
molasses, and,, after felling him to the
ground, crushed in his skull with the stone
Jug, adding, 4D-a you, lie there.". This
was held only manslaughter; and was not
embraced in the second exception abovebe
cause the provocation was not very slight,
and there was no malice, and the weapon
was not prepared to kill. This case is re
ported in the fifth of Jones.'
We often hear of one "retreating to the
wall.' ?t mmvt mMit
- What does it mean 1 Certainly not that
he shall actually go back until he come to
an obstruction - which prevents further re
treat. It means simply that the party as
saulted must flee as far as he conveniently
can either by reason of some wall, ditch or
other impediment, or as far as the fierceness
of the assault will permit him; v ; ; f j
If one is defending his. habitation, and Is
without fault himself, he is hot compelled to
retreat' Vs"-t'i--f? ' w- V;'
" So if a person Unlawfully and feloniously
assault one, retreat is not necessary. Nor
does an officer, lawfully arresting one, have
to retreat to the wall. ' - "
But if the assault is without any felonious
Intent,' the" person assaulted may not stand
his ground and kill , his adversary, if there
be any way of escape open to him. -a,- So,
even if one enter into a fight willingly and
in the progress of the fight be be put to the
wall, and it become , necessary,, in order to
save his own life or his person from great
harm that he kill his adversary, this is ex
cusable homicide. - !
, It would not be proper to conclude this
paper without stating that if a. person is as
saulted in such a way as to induce in him a
reasonable belief that he is in actual danger
of losing his life, he will be justified in de
fending himself, even if the danger prove to
be apparent only and not real. , For exam
ple, if one draw and present a gun or pistol
at another, and that other reasonably fear
ing his life to be in danger, shoot and kill
first, this will Jbe1 excusable; although the
dead man's weapon should be found after;
wards to be not loaded. , ; t t , , :
TStTlSGtSTlONr
-to?
In North' Carolina, at the present time',
we have three verdicts in cases of homicide:
(1) guilty, (generally); (2) guilty of man
slaughter; (3) not guilty. '
Our. Judges now, often, are compelled to
charge the jury that the prisoner is guilty
of murder or of nothing. The law has no
grade between, the .two... .In. other words,
cases arise in which there is no element of
manslaughter. It is, hence,' guilty' or not
guilty.- ' " ?; ' ' 1 ' !
Juries are human, and are loth to take
human fife: hence the guilty sometimes es
cape entirely; whereas, -if there were an in
termediate grade of crime of -less gravity
than murder, it wonlj rarely occur that
there would be a' miscarriage Of justice, 't I
New York State; and Texas and Tennes
see, and many others, have changed the law
of homicide very materially and with satis
factory results. . ' ? " ; T i
There they have murder in the first de
gree and murder in the second degree. f
All murders which are perrjetrated by
means of poi&aing or lying in wait or
which are committed in the perpetration or
attempt to perpetrate any arson, rape, rob
bery, mayhem or burglary. and all other
kinds of wilful, deliberate and premeditated
killings, are murder of the first degree. .
Murder in the second degree includes all
other kinds of killing not embraced iff the
definition of murder in the first degree. So
that when the unlawful killing of a human
being is the result of malice, suddenly pro
duced at the time the'fatal blow is struck;
and the killing is without premeditation or
deliberation, it is murder in the second de
gree. -' "
t Our law givers now, about convening,"
'will find it interesting to see If the change
is desirable and necessary. ,t ,
The Hymn-Books I Like Best
I tan't sing a hymn. I have never written
one. I do not . claim to be a judge of the
S'ood points of one. Nor do I claim excel
ence in hymn reading an accomplishment
never attained by many preachers.
Yet, I love to read hymns that express
the varied experiences of the Lord's people
and their outgoings after God, holiness ana
heaven..':,, - -. .. : , "
I have a few old hymn books, one com
mendable feature of which is the absence of
the iig musio that mars so many of our mod
era books. " . . v ' ' T- -
The first book I'll speak of is the VOlney
Hymns, by Rev. John Newton, Rector of
St Mary, Woolnoth, London." The preface
bears date Feb. 15, 1779. ' My copy is an
American reprint of a somewhat later date.
Although only the name of Newton appears
on the title page, the book is the product of
the joint labors of John Newton and William
Cowper. The former says, in the preface,
that the work "was intended as a monument
to perpetuate the remembrance of an inti
mate and endeared friendship. With this
pleasing view, I entered upon my part,
which would have been smaller - than It
is, and ' the book would !: have , appeared
much sooner and in a very different form,
if the wise, though mysterious, providence
of Ood had not seen fit to cross my wishes.
We had . not proceeded far upon our pro
posed plan before my dear friend (Cowper)
was prevented by a long and afflicting indis
position from, affording me any farther as-
All the hymns in the book were composed
by Newton and Cowper, the former having
written nearly three hundred, while the lat
ter wrote about sixty of them in consequence
of his "indisposition." '
" Perhat)8 -some t account of - the r au
ut&Hs4
would enhance the reader's Interest in their
hymn-book. ' -
William Cowper was born at Berkham
stead,in Hertfordshire, England, in the year
1731. At a very early age, he evinced that
morbid tendency to diffidence,' melancholy
and despair which, in later years, led to
mental derangement and withdrawal from
the stern duties of public life. . Educated at
Westminster, he entered the legal profession,
from which he retired at the age of thirty
three. , VI rambled,t said he, ," from , the
thorny road of my austere patroness, juris
prudence, into' the primrose paths of litera
ture and poetry." Vr'-V
Lindley Murray says that Cowper was ap
pointed Clerk of the Journals of the Honse
of Lords; and, a parliamentary dispute mak
ing it necessary for him to appear at the bar
of the House, his terrors on this occasion
rose to so astonishing a height that they
overwhelmed his reason; and he was obliged
to relinquish a station so formidable to his
singular, sensibility. , Soon afterwards his
mind became clear and tranquil, and he set
tled in the town of Huntingdon in the year
During his lucid intervals he wrote with
a masterful hand, the works that have justly
placed his name among the literary celebri
ties' of Great- Britein.. Mri-
s I have seen'somewhere the statement that
at one time, while laboring under great de
pression and, the feeling that he had been
shut out from the mercy of God, he procured
a bottle of poison with suicidal intent, and
having reached his room, he discovered that
the bottle bad been broken and the poison
spilled. The. discovery of the accident be
interpreted as a token of the "Divine favor,
and in grateful acknowledgment of the
same; he sat down and wrote the hymn be
ginning: TM 1 ' . -
"God moves in a mysterious way,
His wonders to perform,1 &c.
Many of hia hymns are - found in-all the
popular hymn-books of the present day. I
am sorry that many of them are not printed
as he wrote them. For instance, in that
beautiful hymn wbo?e first stanza begins
" There is a fountain filled witJh blood," &c; v i ,
Cowper wrote '
The dying thief rejoiced to see .' ' '
That fountain in his day 'r r
1 And there hate , as vile as he, ,
;' Washed all my gins away" ' ;
expressing an accomplished fact, a blessed
personal experience already attained.
; The hymn,aa now printed in most of the
books, expresses a hope that may be ful
filled or an experience that may be attained.
Besides, I fail to find the sixth and seventh
stanzas in any book that I can lay my hand
upon. "f 1 'i I'-'s
- In addition to the many hymns he wrote,
he composed many pathetic and descriptive
poems, evincing the exquisite delicacy of his
feelings and the goodness of his heart ' His
"Task," which placed him in the front rank
of English poets, was published in 1785, and
his "Translation of the Iliad and Odyssey of
Homer in Blank Verse" appeared in 1791. t
The inquietude and darkness of the poet's
latter years were terminated by a gentle and
-tranquil dissolution in the year 1800, at the
l . :- ..: :l ... ........ ,.- .
I cannot forbear transcribing a few lines
from that excellent poem "Cowper's Grave,"
by Elizabeth Barrett Browning - ;
"Jt b a place where poete .crowned may ieel the
heart's decaying, ! " ;
- It is A place where- Mppy saints may eep amid
thttir praying ; '
Yet let the grief and humbleness as low as silence
languish I
Earth surely now may give her calm to whom
she gave her anguish,
" O poeto t from a maniac's tongue was poured the
. deathless singing I
i O christians I at your croes of hope a hopeless
, hand was clinging I - J ,
O men I this man in brotherhood yourf weary
paths beguiling, . -1
Groaned inly while he taught yon peace, and
died while ye were smiling I"
John Newton was born in England July
24. 1725. His pious mother early taught
him the Scriptures and commended him to
God in her prayers. Says he, in his autobi
ography, " though in process of time I sinned
away all the advantages of these early im
pressions, yet they were for a great while a
restraint upon me; they returned again and
again, and it was very long before I. could
wholly shake them off;" and when the Lord
at length opened my eyes, I found a great
benefit from the recollection of them. Far
ther, my dear mother, besides the pains she
took with me, often commended me with
many prayers and tears to God ; and I doubt
not but I reap the fruits of these prayers to
this hour." .
His mother died July 11th, 1732, or before
he had completed his seventh year. His
father, a sea going man, afterwards married
again, and young Newton went to sea, and
for many years was engaged in the African
slave trade.:4'':;;;'r;.-v
, He became sceptical, wicked and disgust
ingly profane, shocking even his wicked fel
low seamen by his horrid blasphemy. - He
tells us himself : . "I know not that I have
ever since met so daring a blasphemer : not
content with common oaths and impreca
tions, I daily invented new ones i so that I
was often seriously reproved by the captain
who" was himself a very passionate man and
not at all circumspect in his expressions.
When we met with many distasters, he
often would tell me that, to his great grief,
he had a Jonah on board ; that a curse at-
tended me-fvnerever 1 went ; anu mat au me
4iubleX h met with In the voyage were
owing'to his having taken me into the yes-
- ubl
BeL-?; I'
His many perils and hair-breadth escapes
from death, on land and sea, seem to have
made but little impression upon him. " The
Lord had now," he continues, "to appear
ance given me up to judicial hardness; I was
capable of anything. I had not the least
fear of God before my eyes, nor (so far as I
remember) the least; sensibility of con
science." ,, 1 i , ". ' ' f
Two instances of great suffering and hu
miliation I cannot forbear to mention :
While on the western coast of Africa, the
captain of the vessel having died, and New
ton not being on good terms with the mate,
and fearing that be would be transferred to
a man of-war, he determined to remain in
Africa. On an island near the western coast,
he was taken sick and committed to the care
of a negro woman, who soon manifested
great dislike towards him. But I will let
him tell the story himself: "I had some
times not a little difficulty to prcc-ra a
draught of cold water whtn turtkj v, iih
fever. My bed was a mat spread upon a
board or chest, and a log of wood my pil
low. "When my fever left me and my appe
tite returned, I would gladly have eaten,
but there was no one gave unto me. the
lived in plenty , herself, but hardly allowed
me sufficient to sustain life, except now and
then, when in the highest good humor, she
would seEd me victuals in her own plate
after she had dined ; and this (so greatly was
my pride humbled) I received with thanks
and eagerness, as the most eager beggar
does an alms. ? When I was very
slowly recovering, this woman would some
times pay me a visit, not to pity or relieve,
but to insult me. She would call me worth
less and indolent, arid compel me to walk,
which when I could hardly do,r sho ould
set her attendants to mimic my motion, to
clap their handa, hbgb, throw limes at me.
' Nor did I suffer less from the inclem
encyt)f the weather and the want of clothes-
ue rainy season was now advancing ; my
whole suit was a shirt, a pair of trowsers, a
cotton handkerchief instead of a cap, and a
cotton cloth about two yards long to supply
the want of upper garments; and, thus ac
coutred, I ' have been exposed for twenty,
thirty, perhsps near forty hours together, in
incessant rains accompanied with strong
gales of wind, without the least shelter,
when my master was on shore. I feel to this
day some faint returns of the violent pains
I then contracted. The excessive cold and
wet I endured in that voyage, and so soon
after I had recovered from a long sickness,,
quite broke my constitution and my spirits
The latter were soon restored ; but the ef
fects of the former still remain with me as a
needful memento of the service and wages
oBln,M;;:3'--'.vtT':vr' ;v r-;. - -
The second instance. Newton had, while
his ship was lying at Plymouth, deserted his
post, was caught and carried back to Ply
mouth. "I walked," says he, "throcghthe
streets guarded like a felon, ily heart was
full of indignation, fear and fchame. I was
confined two days in the guard-house, then
sent on board my ship, kept awhile in irons,
then publicly 'stripped and whipped; after
which I was degraded from my oface, and
all my former companions were forbidden,
to 6how me the least favor or even to tyea.lc
t6maT;v--i-;vT;-;l'v--;.'?''-V;j'
' Many other instances of suffering and nar
row escape might be related ; but these most
suffice.
John Newton's conversion was a inlrach ..
of ffrace? Let no poor prodigal, who may
chance to read this, despair of God's mercy
or his own salvation. 1 v" - ; - ,
It was Newton who said, "When I get to
heaven, I shall see three wonders there: the
first wonder will be to see many people there
whom I did not expect to see ; the second
wonder will be, to mi6s many people whom
I did expect to see; and the thiid and great
est wonder of all will be, to find myself
there.'? -V7;v;'i i
A short time before he "died, his sight
having failed him, he would offer comments.
On Scripture passages read at family wor
ship and lead in prayer. On one of these
occasions the lesson was that portion of
Scripture in which Paul says, "By the grace
of God, I am what I am." Newton's a act
ing comment followed; " I am not what D
nno-ht to be. i Ah! how imperfect and defi
cient 1 I am notwhat I Uriah to be. -I abhor
that which is evil, and I would cleave to
that which is good. lam cot what I hope
to be.' Soon, soon, I shall put oil mortality,
and. with mortality, all sin and imperfection l:
Yet, though I am not what I ought to be,
nor what I wish to be,or what I hope to be,.
I can truly say I am not what I once was, a
slave to sin and Satan and I can heartily
join with the Apostle and acknowledge, 'By
the grace of God, I am what I am 1' Let us
prayl" I believe It is not generally known that
Newton once visited the United States. It
was during his last voyage before his mar
rage, which latter event took place Feb. 1st, .
1750. ne sailed from Antiqua, one of the-'
West India islands, to Charleston, S. C. "In
this place," he continues,, "there are many
serious people ; but I knew not where to find
them out; indeed I was not aware of a differ
ence, but supposed that all who attended
publio worship were good christians."' I was .
as much in the dark about preaching, not
doubting but whatever came from the pul
pit must be very good. I had two or threa
opportunities of hearing a dissenting minis
ter named Smith, who, by what ! Lave
known since, I believe to have been an ex
cellent and powerful preacher of the gorj 1;
and there was something in bis manner tL t
struck mebut I did not rightly under: ??" I
him. The best words that men can i
are ineffectual till explained and apt I'd 1 7
the Spirit of God who alone can open t'
heart1' , ... :: '- N- " ' ' '
A few years after his marria -9 1 os' -doned
his seafaring life and entire J r 1
career of great usefulness as author t .:. i ; '
ister of the gospel.
Through his instrumentality, C:
Buchanan was, converted, ent i s J r
istry and went to the East Ind: -1. I
an's " Star in the East " led A J
son to enter the foreign ( ! '. I
instrumental in the coavtr .'.
Scott from the dirk rrrr: i r f i
the belief, practice and rror T
gelical truth, tcottf'
commentary oa t!. 3 1 . ,
that Newton; v. itLi I
mental in tlia cc n v :
cONTisr: ) '