CITIZEN THE WEATHER: FAIR. A Citizen For Rent Ad Will Rent That Vacant Room. yOL.XXV.NO.79. ASHEVILLE, N. C, THURSDAY MORNING, JANUARY 7, 1909. PRICK FIVE CENTS. MINISTER'S ROOSEVELT SHAKES BIG STICK IN FACE OF THE SENATE AND Doesn't it Make You Mad HE SAYS GRAFT MUST ONE DAY HIDE ITS HEAD DISMEMBERED BODY FOUND TELLS IT 'WHERE TO GET OFF' Bays It lias No Business to Give Orders to Head of , Department. GRISGOM WILL MEET THE U.S. Partially Consumed By Fire j Owen Wistcr, Author of In Two Heating Stoves - Of Church. "The Virginian" Believes flood Time Coming. , THE AS 4 IS RESPONSIBLE FOB EVERYTHING Heads of Department Are Not Subject to Beck and Call of Senate. (By Associated Press.) WASHINGTON, Jan. 8. President Roosevelt today Informed the enate In no uncertain terms that he had given hli approval to the aborptlon of the Tennessee Coal and Iron com pany by the United States corporation and that he had Instructed Attorney Qeneral Bonaparte not to respond to the senate Inquiry as to the reason for his failure to prosecute the steel company.'" . The president concludes his message with the statement that he does not conceive it to "be within the authority of the senate to give directions of this character to head of an executive de partment." The message to the senate Is in res ponse to a resolution Introduced by Senator Culberson calling on the attor ney general to state whether he had brought an action against the steel company because of its acquisition of the Tennessee concern, and if not, the reason for non-action. While the resolution was not direct ed to President Roosevelt bis atten tion was called to it by Attorney Gen eral Bonaparte. The president says: "As to the transaction in question I was personally cognizant and res ponsible for its every detail. For the Information of the senate I transmit a copy of a letter sent by me to the At torney General, November 4, as fol lows: His Letter. "The White House, "Washington, November 4, 1908. "My Dear Attorney General: Judge B. H. Gary and Mr. H. C. Frlck, on behalf of the steel .corporation, have 4-iust'fale4. ujpoit jpfu,TrjmkjKW. there Is a certain business firm, (name of which I ..have not been told but which Is of real Important In New York business circles) which will un doubtedly fall this week if help is not given. Among Its assets are a major ity of the securities of the Tennessee Coal company. Application has been urgently made to the steel corporation to purchase this stock as the only means of avoiding a failure. "Judge Gary and Mr. Frlck Inform ed me that as a mere business trans action they; do not care to purchase the stock; that under ordinary cir cumstances they would not consider purchasing the stock, because but lit tle benefit will come to the stesl cor poration from the purchase; that they are aware that the purchase will be used as a handle for attack upon them upon the ground that they are striv ing to secure a monopoly of the busi ness and prevent competition, not that this would represent what could hon estly be said, but what might reckless ly and untruthfully be said. "They Inform me that as a matter of fact the policy of the company has been to decline to acquire more than sixty per cent of the steel pro perties and that this policy had been persevered in for several years past With the object of preventing these accusations and as a matter of fact their proportion of steel properties has slightly decreased, so that It Is be low sixty per cent, and the acquisition Of the property in question will not false it above sixty per cent Prevent Panic. " 'But they feel that it Is Immense ly to their Interest as to the Interest of every responsible business man to try to prevent a panic and general smash-up at this time and that they are wAllng to go into this transact ion, which they would not otherwise go into,' because it seems the opinion of those best fitted to express judg ment In New York that it will be an important factor In preventing a break that might be ruinous; and that this has been . urged upon them by the combination of the most responsible bankers In New York who are now en gaged In endeavoring to save the sit uation, but they asserted they did not wish to do this if I stated that It oncht pot to be done. I answered that while of course I could not advise them to take the action proposed I felt It no public duty of mine to Interpose anVj objection. "Sincerely yours, ' (Signed.) "THEODORE ROOSEVELT" (Continued on page two.) GATES ASKS FOR FREE TRADE IN IRON, COALED LUMBER (By Associated Press.) .WASHINGTON, Jan. . John W, Gates has Joined the ranks of those who are asking for free trade in iron, coai and lumber. A letter to Speaker Cannon dated at Port Arthur, Texas, . reads as follows: -I notice a great deal of evidence to being taken on tariff matters in SVaahinjton, it seem to me ' there BATTLESHIP Expected to Arrive in Mes sina Sunday Relief Ship Will Start Today. PANIC IS SPREAD BY "HOOLIGANS" Run Through Naples Crying Earthquake and Thieves Go to Work. (By Associated Press.) ROME, Jan. 6. Ambassador Grls com will leave here tomorrow for Messina, to meet the American squad ron, which is expected to arrive there Sunday, under Rear-Admiral Sperry on the flagship Connecticut. The steamer Bayern, the American relief ship, flying the Red Cross emblem, will sail for Messina tomorrow. This steamer, with its great cargo of sup plies will be able to take care of thousands of sufferers. There are three surgeons abroad and fifty nurses, of whom three are American and three English. Fifty eight thousand dollars has been spent for the medical out fit, provisions and clothes for distribu tion at Messina. There Is an Immense supply of the necessaries of life aboard for men, women and children, partlc ular attention having been paid to food, for little ones. In the past 48 hours, $160,000 has been spent In Rome, and $50,000 in Genoa, for clothing alone. There are aitoo medical supplies sufficient for the establishment of three camp hos pitals ashore. Those in charge of the expedition "have $30,000 In small bills for careful distribution, l,, W,ord -received. front , Naples says inai - jiioonsanr a tiring ine mgnt ran through various quarters of the city crying "Earthquake", "Earth quake.". Their cries aroused thous ands of people who rushed out of their houses, thus giving thieves an oppor tunity to work. The frightened pop ulation gathered in the squares and crowded the churches. Some of them took crucifixes and images of saints and carried them through the streets in procession said wailing and weep ing. People More Calm. Signer Bertilllli. minister of public works, who Is now In Regglo. has telegraphod to Premier Gioll, that the people there are beginning to be more calm and for that reason there is no pressing need of steamers for the transportation of refugees. The min ister adds that efforts should now be directed toward the sending nf a great quantity of wood and other building material for the construction of huts along the Sicilian and Calabrlan coasts. The following list of places In Reg glo province is published as having suffered the greatest damage frorri the earthquake: Bagiara. f'annitello, Cat ania. Galileo, Laganati, Melicuoca., Melito, Montedello. Motta. Palml. Pel iaro, Pedargonl, San Procoplo, ftanto Stefano, Scllla, SemlnaZa, SInopoli, and Giovanni. The generosity of the American people :.i coming to the aid of the earthquake sufferers Is the predomi nating feature which Is now attract ing attention here. The feeling of gratefulness extends from the king down to the most lowly subject. In accepting In behalf of the Italian na tion, the supplies sent by the Ameri can government, the king said to Am bassador Grlscom: "Your people will be delighted to hear of this mark of International humanitarianlsm and will follow with the keenest interest the work of mercy being performed by the Bayern." The king further Informed tha American ambassador that he had re ceived with the greatest appreciation the communication notifying the gov ernment of the appropriation of $800. 000 for the earthquake victims. Slgnor Tittonl, the foreign minister said: "Never before on any occasion has owurred such a demonstration of sympathy as that of America. It in cludes all classes and conditions from the president to the humblest citizen. Nothing could more tightly bind to gether the two countries, or render their friendship closer." Count Taverna. the president of the (Continued on pigs three.) are three articles that ought to be put on the' free list Iron ""ore, coal, and lumber. ' I have a large portion of my fortune in the stetl business, but I say this to you conscientiously and candidly. A cat of 10 per cent In the schedule would not hurt the man ufacturer of Iron and steel a parti- When you Ask the Lady in ana ne Aosoiuteiy Keiuses vocm i n juaue xou Mad Xnoughf BITTER ATTACK ON GOVERNOR OF TENNESSEE Senior Counsel for Alleged Night Riders Is Repri manded by Judge. "MEN BRIBED TO "rwr? tttt?t nn?x wan Nothing In Evidence to Sus tain Charge, Says Judge Jones. (By Associated Press.) UNION CITY, Teun., Jan. . After a bitter attack on the governor of the state and an attempt to bring the killing of Former United States Senator Edward W. Carmaek into the case, Rice Pierce, senior counsel for the eight alleged night riders, on the trial for the murder of Captain Quen- tln Ranken, today was reprimanded by Judge Jones. Mr. Pierce was preparing to close his argument for the defense and was discussing the testimony of Kehring er, Hogg and Morris, night riders who turned state's evidence. Ho launch ed Into a violent denunciation of Gov ernor Patterson. "The governor of the state," he said, "after sending on army Into Oh ion county to trample on the rights of the people, to snatch honest men from their homes and bully them and abuse them, offered a reward of $10,000 for the arrest or Ranken's murderer.-)," said Pierce. "I do not approve of crimes. I de nounce murder, whether tt is a cow ardly assassination on the streets of our capital, or any equally cowardly murder on the banks of Rcelfoot lake, but I submit that all men are equal before the law, and that the man or men who assassinated Car mack are entitled to no better treat ment than those who killed nanken. "After filling Obion county with soldiers, what does Patterson, the governor of this state, do? He sends for Fehrlnger, Hogg and Morris and bribes them to perjure themselves to send innocent men to the gallows." Is Reprimanded. Several times the attorney repeated this charge and then Judge Jones said: "The court dots not believe that the judiciary should permit to pass unnoticed this assault on the chief ex ecutive of the state. There Is noth ing In the evidence to sustain coun sel's charge. The witneses swore re peatedly that what Governor Patter son told them was that if they told the truth he would give them an un conditional pardoa and see that they got safely out of the country. In no way Is It In evidence that he offered them pardon to Involve any one In the murder." ' "But," retorted Pierce, "these wit nesses, or one of them at least, swore that If Patterson had not offered him the pardon he would not have made the confession. Just what cite he of fered them I do not know, but I be lieve I have a right to say he bribed the witnesses to perjure themselves." "Mrs. Pierce," again said the court, "these remarks are highly Improper, and the court will not permit you to make them. Gentlemen of the jury, there I nothing in the evidence upon which the charge against the govern or can be based." . Mr. Pierce had spoken nearly two hours when he was stopped by Judge Jones. Court adjourned a few minutes later until tomorrow, when two hours of time still to tha defense's credit will be used. ' Tha case will go to the Jury, oa Thursday, : . 1 Front of you With the Big Hat STATE SENATE AND HOUSE ARE .NOW ORGANIZED . r- ' s - All Officers Nominated at Caucus Elected by Good Majority. $50,000 MAY liE kV0TI D AFFLICTED. - :: Resolution ProViding :A im propriation Introduced In the House. (Special te The Citizen.) RALK1GH, N. C, Jan. . The North Carolina general assembly or ganized today wjth A. W. Graham, of Grantvlile. speaker of tho house and Lieutenant Governor Francis D. Winston, president In tho senate un til the new lieutenant governor, W. C. Newland, Hikes office us presiding of ficer Janunry 12. Whitehead Klutz, of Salisbury, was made president pro tern for the session. All otler officers In both branches were elected In accordance with tho selections made In the democratic caucus lam niKht The vote ror speak er In the house was Graham, (demo cratic), ninety; Harshaw. (republi can,) twenty -seven, Hayes, of Chat ham, and Dowd, of Mecklenburg, both defeatetl ciihdidates in the democra tlc caucus, nominated and seconded the nomination of Graham for the speakership ;ind Hayes later Introduc ed the speaker to the members when he assumed i lie chair. In the sen.ite. Klutz was nominated by In(r, of Iredell, for president pro tern and J. .1. Brltt, (republican), was nominated by HLarburk, of Korsylh. The vote tua. Klutz, thirty-one, HriU nine. Tho senat- passed a resolution pre paratory C o the InauKuratloti of kov ernor and xiato officers Tuesday, Jan uary 12, at '.ne o'clock. A Joint, resolution was offered In the house by )'' rry, of Vance, cxlendltiK profnnd svnipathy to the klni; an I queen of It.ily and their subjects and appropriates GO, 000 for relief of the sufferers foi rn tho earthqunke. This was refcrp I to the committee en fin aneo and m, -t await the appointment of this committee. The hou.- and senate passed reso lutions riot K Ing Governor ;ienu of their rcaitiie ss to receive Ms mes sage and n recess Was taken to 1 n n o'clock tomorrow, when the governor will appear before a Joint scision in person and road his message, as he did two yc is ago. POSTAL SAVINGS BANK NOW UP. (By Associated Press.) WASHINGTON, Jan. 1. The i.,ll to establish pot'sl savings banks was taken up bv 'ha senate today and read Xor amendment, Senator Carter In charge of ib- measure announcing that he would not attempt to get a vote on the hill until next week. (FAIR WASHINGTON, Jan. Forecast: North Carolina Fair with a cold wava Thursday and Friday; fresh northwest wiads, I to Kindly Removo it. FATE OF ERB'S SLAYER HANGS IN BALANCE Case Against Mrs. Beisel and Mrs. Erb Is Given to Jury. PATHETIC APPEAL FOR ACQUITTAL. With Withering " Sarcasm McDade Refers to tho "Innocent Wife." (By Associated Press.) MKDIA, PA.. Jan. . The falo of Mrs. Catherine M. Helsel and Mrs. M. Florence Erb, charged with the mur der of Cuptain J. Clayton Erb, at his country home "Red Gables" on Octo ber n, hangs In the balance. The esse whs given to the Jury at :90 this altertioon and after deliberating for four hours they were locked up for the night. Not an Intimation was given as to a poll of the Jury. When court opened H. Krank Ithodes, began the closing address for the defendants. lie ridiculed the lonitn'inwealth's case, and said not one scintilla of evidence had been ad duced to show that Mrs. Erb was In any way connected with the murder of her husband that Mrs. Beisel the other defendant had shot Erb that her own life and that of her sister might be spared He unmercifully scored the "Philadelphia gang" as he Irmed them, for the part the Phila delphia detectives and coroner's phy sician Wadsworlh look In securing evi dence and testifying against the ac cused, lie rbwd with a pathetic ploa for the aoriiilttal of the defendants. Mr. Ithodes was followed by District Attorney Me Dade, the latter bitterly resented the "slur cast upon the Phil ad lphbms"who, he declared, had ben asked to aid the Delaware county au thorities, who ill the time were busy on the Chester strike trouble. Close Attention. The Jury " the dls4rle. attorney i loser attenti'm than they had evinced at any time during the trial which had In en In progress for eight days, and w hen he spri ad upon the floor of the i rf room lh- blue print of the kit.- ond (lour of Ced Gables," where Kit) wan murdered, every Juror left his sent in the box and seemed Intent up on Kaitilnt,' all Information possible. As Mr. Meliade described In the min utest detail the "cruel murder" many of the Jurymen questioned him as to I he version of the crime. He pleaded for a first degree verdict, saying the murder was a "diabolical plot, ron leivr d hv shrewd cunning women." With withering sarcasm he referred to the "Innocent wife, who had black ened the character of a man who gave her bis honored name." He closed his addres by reading the endearing letters from Captain Krb to his wife, which were offered In evidence yester day. Judge Johnson consumed an hour In his charge to the Jury, reviewing the evidence adduced by both tho prose cution and the defense. BRITISH STEAMER LANDS ON ROCKS. (By Associated Press.) NORFOI-iK, VA., Jan. Losing hor hearings in the dense fog early yes terday morning the British steamer Anglo-African, with a cargo from TO coplla,' Mexico, bound for Baltimore, brought tip on Smith's Island, off Cape Charles. There Is Utile wrod and only a moderate sea ronslng. She Is re 8hs Is re-j ported in good condition. ROBBERY MOTIVE OF, FEARFUL MURDER. Pews and Communion Ta ble Daubed With Blood Toll of Struggle. (By Associated Prsst.) DETROIT, Mich., Jan. 6. The dis membered body of Rsv, J. H, Car. mlchael , Methodist minister, was found today partially consumed by lire n tha two heating stoves of one of his three ohurohes near Columbus, in the southwestern part of BU Clair county. Investigation was begun to clear away temporary uncertainty as to the Identity of the victim and to discover the perpetrator of the crime. The Identity of the clergyman was soon affected by Orvllle Lindsay, who was sent to the church for that pur pose hJK Mr Carmlchaot, who had been In rreat distress since her bus band failed to return home as expect ed last evening, and who surmised that tho minister had been murder ed, as she had heard report that some one had been murdered In the Columbus church. A clue to tha murderer and the mo tlve was more difficult to obtain. There was a rumor that a man had left a train at Hlckey and had W en seen at Columbus church. The fact that several coins were found In the clothing of the dead man and In the ashes , of the stoves precluded ; the theory of robbery and at the. tlm of bt death it was not known that the murdered minister had an enemy In tn world, t Rev. Carmlehael had bean in Mich igan about ten years, and for two years had been pastor of the three thurches at Columbus, Adair and China. With his wife and three ohli- dren ha resided at Adair. leaving noma yesterday morning he told Mrs, Carmlchaot that he was going to Co lumbus ta arrange for a series of re. Vlval meetings there., Ha wavert his hand affectionately to a group of chil drert as he drove out of the village of Adair and from that moment all tracs of him Is lost. . Discovers Crime. Myron Brown, who lives near the scene of the tragedy, was the first to dlarover tha crime today. While he was waiting at the cross-roads to keep an appointment the cold wind drove him to saek shelter In the church. Ho was surprised to And the church doors unlocked and upon opening them was terrified to see the church floor, tha pews and even tho communloi' table ..daubed with blood and fragments of bloody clothing scattered all around. Evidently the clergyman, who was OB years old, and of athletic build, had made a torrlllc struggle for his life. Without Investigating further Urown fled to hlrf home, where he had a key to the church. He returned and locked the doors and hurried to tho village of llickey.frotn which plaen he not I tied the sheriff's office at I'ort Huron. The authorities on their arrival at the church found parts of the dis membered body In the Iwo stoves, and discovered In one stove the head of what was apparently a new hatchet, the bundle ,f which had been burn ed off. A dirk wan also found In the church end It Is believed (hat the dlr4 nerved for the murder while the hatchet was used to cut the body to pieces. The minlater's horse was found today tied to a tree In the vil lage of I'di'i River, the dead man's overcoat lielng discovered In the bug gy. Pine River Is a small village near Thornton, on tho main line of the (Irand Trunk railroad, mid fully twenty mil -s from the vene of the murder. TAFT INTERESTED IN CHILD LABOR. (By Associated Pr.) ACOl'HTA. Jan. . The presi dent-elect Is it member of the Nat ional child labor commission, and he today listed to a report from M J. McKlway, secretary of the commis sion for tin- Southern stales. Mr. Mc- Klway hut had quarters at Atlanta, it Is his corn luslon that the child labor laws of the Houtherti states art pretty well adapted to condition, but there Is lackness In their enforcement. No action on the nuhjert Is understood to be contemplated at this time. National Chairman Frank H. Hitch cock returned from his trip to lilr- mlneham and Atlanta this morning and this afternoon had an extended Interview with Mr. Taft. WELL-TO-DO FARMER HELD FOR TRIAL ON CHARGE OF PEONAGE (By Associated Press.) VALOOHTA. CJa., Jan. t. United States Commissioner Powell here to doy held f. Ramsey, a well-to-do Brooks county farmer for trial before Judge Emory Bpeer on the charge of peonage. The alleged poen, uus Scott, a ne gro, and apparently half wltted testi fied that on of Ramsey's neighbors IS BITTER FOE OF CORRUPTION. Failure to Register and Vote is Main Cause of : drafting in America. '-! (Special Correspondent of CU!n.) rilU.ADKl.rHIA. Jan. ."It la only a question or time until graft will be eradicated from publlo affair t was never more hopeful than bow,? Optimistic Owen AVtstorl Ha .be longs to that class of Americana that fully realise tha existence of evil In fluences hers and there la pubUe life, but that have undaunted faith In the conviction that ultimately the great average voter will set all.thlngs right. Wlsler' courage Is particularly striking in view of the fact that In Philadelphia's last oouncllmanto alec Hon he was not only personally over whelmlngly defeuted In his attempt to free the people of his own ward from tha yoke of gang rule politics, but In every Instance save on thu cltlsens showed their preference for a continuation of tha present republi can "graft" administration. - , In Wlstera ward In particular the Issues had boon clearly drawn. It was honesty and decency vs. gang rule. . Wlstnr was up for councilman. "According to the return, t vot ers In your ward voted for clean pol itics and S,GJ voted for the other kind, liow are you abla - to sustain such optimism In tha faco of these figures?" t asked Mr. Winter during our Interview at hl horn In !iqs Street. .15 , j : , "I base my prophecy on my discov ery of gsrm of discontent," ha re plied. "The hatter classes ars grow ing discontented. -When they become fully aroused, and t Ucllv they will arrive, at that point suddenly, graft will ha lesft a fatal blow, " -There Is a great crlmf In existence In this rminlry upon which no direct concentrated firs has ever besn mads. It Is a crime . principally of the wealthy, the aristocratic. Borne day -the effect of this crime will be nation ally realised. When it Is, goodbye to graft, The basis of tha crime 1 am referring to Is failure to register and failure to vote. That If why Phila delphia's election went overwhelm Ingly against clean government The best people of Philadelphia did not ' go lo the polls. If by not going lo ' the poll they allowed mart to gain office that rob the city, are they not morally guilty of the erim of tha grafters? !r.; "The man 'who has taken no Inter-', est in politics Is becoming dlscon tended with conditions. In seeking a reason for condltons, ha is finding that It Is he who is to bhtma. "For years the rich young men of Philadelphia have been a dormant mass. I myself was dormant until tha gas steal awoke me. When I wrote the story of the 'Keystone Crime' for a magazine a year and a half ago my whole soul was stirred. I realised for the first time there were soma dutleM I owed to those about ms be side wrltlig books I might maks enough money to live comfortably writing, but If I didn't because of . iion-liitcrext do my duty as voter, was I not allowing those about me to suffer? That was the question SS It uresented itself to me for the first time. "Philadelphia Is right now being rohbnd rlKlrt and left by the contrac tors the sewer, contractors, the ! pavement contractors and others. By raining the HHwssment on real estate the city eole.td 12,000,000 more last year than the year previous, or ever before Yet the people get BO benefit of this 12,000,000. It goes to' the cont nn tors. Why tho assessment on this building has been Increased from $i,.'i'io to tl 1,500 In three years, yet the i lly water is so dirty I would be deprived of a bath If 1 didn't go to private expense to get clean water. A to the pavement and draining of city street, look out of my window. j here m ;t pool ni water neep enougn lo drown lit. I can stand It, but' should I not do all I can for others It... I... l.l...u..lnnl Th.,. Is no way of getting around it. My plain duty is to vote?" WlMter said other things.; Although brought up an aristocrat, he spoke as a tnHii with a new convietlon. His ; tone of voice wao not that of ths dreamer, hut the steady and forceful : one or a man wno nas aeu.rmuiea w make good in a new capacity. s'-yj who was at outs with Ramsey had In duced him to swear out tha warrant. The negro had sworn that he had been held In a stato ot "peonage' for six years and had received but it for his services In all that time. Ramsey Introduced witnesses to show ha had frequently .paid the negro mora than that. He was held In $5,009 bond la tha Federal court . ; .