CITIZEN.
THE WEATHEB:
iEAIN' .
CITIZEN WANT AD3
BRING KESULT8
ASIIEYILLE, N. C, FRID AY MORNING, JULY 14, 19; 1
VOL. XXVn., NO. 266
PRICE FIVE CENTS
FORTY KILLED Jfi
BUTTLE BETWEEN
SEE FOUND GUILTY
Hgve You Ever Noticed'-
OF
OF
TO
LORIMER TO LAST
F
ES
Statute FUes Penalty Frpm
Flatly Contradicts Edward H.
Federals and Maderistas En
gage In Bloody Fight Last
ing Day and Night
And John Sharp tyililanis h
Not Slow in Calling His
Ungenerous Remarks ;
One to Ten Years In the
State Penitentiary
Hlnes' Testimony as to Tele
phone Conversation
HEASHEllELE
GOVERNOR DENEEN
GLA1MS HE FOUGHT
SENATOR
HEYBURfl
ABDUCTION
SEEMS
UNABLE
MEXICAN
OGES
MILDRED
116
TRIED JO HOLD MEN,
' IN LINE FOR HOPKINS
Says Anyone Could StaKe Rep
utation Upon There Having
Beert 'Jackpot"
WASHINGTON. July 13. Gov.
Chas. Deneen, of Illinois, today fur
nished "eld day In the Lorlmer elec
tion investigation by the senate special
committee. He dclared that he did
not assist la the election of Senator
Lorlmer, a aome of the senator's
trlenda claimed, but fought against
It to the' last. He flatly contradicted
the version which Edward Hlnea, a
Chicago lumber man who la charged
with having asked for a Lorlmer
(lection fund contribution, gaw of the
famous telephone conversation be
tween the two on, the day Senator
Lorlmer waa efected. May l, 10.
Mr. Hlnes had testiOed he (Hlnea)
telephoned front Chicago to Deneen
that hp "had Just come In thla morn
ing from Washington, and waa on my
was to Springfield to .bring the mes
sage to you t Deneen) from Aldrlch
and' the president, urging upon you to
do all you poaalbly can to assist In
the election of a senator at the ear
Heat possible moment." and "that they
understood that Lorlmer could be
elected If you will assist;'' further Mr.
Hlnes testified that he understood De
neen to say he would asalst In Lari
mer's election and would ee Lorlmer
In ten minutes.
Gov. VDeneen testified today that
Hlnes asked him if he received a re
port from the president in reference
to Lorlmer. He said Taft had sent a
message to support Lorlmer.
"I asked him," continued Gov. De
neen, "If he had the message, and he
answered No.' He iald that the
president had sent It and that he had
Intended to' come to Springfield him
aelf but had missed the train iT ve
1 Mked him If President Tift sent
that message, for I thought It strange
- h. n.Mnt tn tell me that. He
U -
aid, 'Why he sent K. tnrougn oenawv
Atdrteh-o ewe h would sot aend
W t T dlrectty-rwho would Vsom
munlcate to you through George Rey
nolds, of the Continental bank. I
nynfww
VERDICT OF JUBY FIS
TO SATISFY ETHER SIDE.
Total Judgment Against the
American Tobacco Co.
j Amounts to $70,000
NEW TRIAL ASKED
RALEIGH, N. C.. July IS. The
Judgment against the American To
bacco company for $70,000. and the
costs In the case, was drawn this af
ternoon and signed by Judge H. O.
Connor, of the Federal court. In the
suit of Ware-Kramer Tobacco com
pany vs. American Tobacco company,
In which the Jury today returned a
verdict for 120.000 damages, flncrlng
that the American Tobacco company
Is a combination in restraint of trade
nd that the business of Ware-Kramer
company, Independent cigarette
manufacturers, was destroyed by un
lowful acts of the defendant In the
conduct of its business, the use of
coupons, free goods, special Inside
georet discounts and other means.
The verdJot for HMM multiplies
to f 10,000 under the provision of the
Sherman aatl-trus act that gives
treble damages. Also Judge Connor
under this act. taxes the counsel fees
for plaintiffs oounael, allowing $10.-
00 In this case. The American To
fcaoeo company gives notice of appeal.
Counsel for the plaintiff express
gnat dlssalaf action ar the amount of
.damages and at first intimated pur
pose to Join in a motion by the de
fendant for the verdict to be set aside
nd a new trtal ordered C. C. Daniels,
for tn plaintiffs, set out that the
Ware-Kramer company, received, la
In debt tTa.OOt and that all he $0,
00 verdict wfll go to the creditors
leaving nothing for' the real plaintiffs.
However, this afternoon In cham
bers, plaintiffs counsel signified their
acceptance of the verdict. , The suit
ms for $ 10,00 damages. I
It 4s a notable fact that In the oat
come of the" litigation neither Ware
or Ksamer, who were the active
business management of the III fated
.Weree-Kraroer company, receiver,
thing out of the litigation beyond
their witness fees, .creditors coming
in for all the damage asset. -
EDITOR. W DROWNED
, QfJINCT, Mass., July ll. Edgar
L. Robbtna, assistant city editor of
the Boston Traveler, waa drowned
last night while swimming her.
: : .-v.'"'.-. '. -
THREE MEN FIRE
INTO BULL RING
Both Sides Take up Firing Each
Side Thinking Other Was'
v Responsible .
PUEBLO, Max., July 13. Fighting
between federals and Maderistas,
which began last night and lasted
until daylight, was resumed this af
ternoon at Cerro San Juan, alose to
this city. Today's battle raged for
three hours and Is said to have claim
ed more than forty In killed and
wounded.
. A party of Maderistas who flod
from the bull ring last night engag
ed In a stiff fight with the federals,
cut' the Inter-Oceanic railroad at
Fabrica de Mattenso, took possession
of a train and proceeded to- San
Martin, ZS miles to the north, to
procure rifles and ammunition with
the avowed Intention fo return and
renew the attack. ' r(
Last night's fight, according; to
witnesses, was 'provoked by three
w. m n a "9 wrt.n waa an A tn Via
a son of former Governor , Muoclo
Marttnes, who passed the. bull ring
where the Maderistas were Quarter
ed and fired into the place 'and Into
the barracks of the Z&ragosa . bat
talion of . state troops oposlte. , .
The fire waa taken up by both aides,
each thinking the other had started
trouble. The fight was bloody and
among the forty dead were several
women and a federal lieutenant col
onel, Molse Breton. The 'affair la
laid by the revolutionists to 'the door
of the dentines, who It Is claimed,
had arranged the details tn advance
and calculated upon the effeot of the
preliminary shootjng. By others, the
clash was saldft have been provoked
by an attack of drunken revolution
ists on the penitentiary with the. In
tention of liberating the prsoners. ;
-' TTJKF WRITER DEAD . -': ;
NKW TORK. July . Boykln
Ford, way knew aa a. writer fcirf
topics and at on time owner of a
racing stable, died her tonight from
a complication of diseases. Mr. Ford
was born In Savannah, Oa., apd his
body will be taken there for burial.
JOHN ABBUGKLE MAY BE
TOO ILL TO CO BEFORE
E OF IHOUIHY
If So, Sub-Committee Will
be Sent to His Home to
Qet Deposition flJJt
EXPECT MUTCH OP HIM
WASHINGTON, July lt.-Whp
the house "sugar trust" Investigating
committee goes to New Tork next
week to continue Its Inquiry, It w(l
send a sub-committee to the home of
John Arbuckle, head of the firm of
Arbuckle Brothers, if Mr. Arbuckle
la unable to appear at the hearing
there. He is too 111 to come to Wash
ington in response to the commit
tee's request, and probably will not be
able to attend the New Tork hearing.
Mr. Arbuokl. whose Interests are
competitive with those of the Ameri
can Sugar Refining company. Is ex
pected by" the committee to reveal vi
tal information concerning the opera
tions of the trust and its control of
the country's sugar business. Wash
ington B. Thomas, of the American
Sugar Refining company, will be a
witness hi New Tork. Today Milton
D. Purdy, former assistant attorney
general, told the committee that he
did not know why fornfer Attorney
General Bonaparte did not prosecute
"sugar trust' officials for violation of
the Sherman anti-trust law in the
Pennsylvania sugar transaction, after
he (Purdy) had recommended that
the case be pressed in 10. Mr.
Purdy declared that his opinion that
the' Information presented to him In
that case. If proved, warranted prose
cution never had changed since the
oase was outlined to htm. A delega
tion of Louisiana cane sugar planters
and manufacturers will be heard by
the committee tomorrow.
LIGHTNING PLAYS A
. TRICK WITH BICYCLE
SOUTH WINDSOR. Conn.. July II.
During an electrical storm last
flight a flash of lightning struck. the
.handle bars of a bicycle standing
beside an elm tree In the yard Of
Charles Ryan. The handle bars were
torn off and driven' from the foot of
the tree up 10" feet, removing , the
bark as smoothly as If the work had
been done with a knife. The bars
were then turned back, slid down
five feet and hurled themselves eight
Inches deep In the wood, - none the
worse for their Jou.rcjr.y
HE WAS FOUNDER OF
ABSOLUTE LIFE CULT
Father of Clrl Instltulng Suit
for Divorce. Alleging Ali
enation by See
CHICAGO. July II. Evelyn Ar
tnur See, founder of the Absolute Life
cult, tonight waa found guilty of the
abduction of Mildred. Bridges, a 17-year-old
disciple of . the cult The
jury was out a little over an hour.
The statute flies the penalty at
from one to ten years In the peniten
tiary. Counsel for See made an im
mediate appeal for a retrial of the
ease. See's flat, the home of Abso
lute Life, named In the cult publica
tion as "the House of the Lord,", was
entered by the police in January. See
was arrested, and two young girls,
Mona Rees, aged II, and Mildred
Bridges, aged IT, who had been II v
tng In the apartment, latere taken Into
custody. Mrs. Felicia Rees and Mrs.
Lucille Bridges, mothers of the girl
and followers of See, also were closely
questioned. The police Investigation
resulted In a charge of abduction
against See. Stephen Bridges, a
.wealthy-jeweler.' father of Mildred,
k whose wife admitted she had con
tributed f 1.000, f 500 and many small
er monthly sums to See's suport, aid
ed the police in gaining evidence. He
alto began action for divorce and suit
for alienation of affections against
Sea. ' While In Jail See continued writ
ing and preaching his doctrine of a
perfect race, to be established
through -the new belief.
See refused to take the stand In his
defense, the chief witnesses being the
girls and their mothers, all apostles
of See. The girls repudiated an al
leged confession, aatd to have been
made to the police, that the See fiat
nad been used for immoral purposes.
and took refuge In the language of
Absolute Life, which to most of those
ht the court room proved unintelllgl
Me. ; '--- '
Mr. Bridges,' for the state, testified
that his daughter Jiad refused to re
arn' bttme- after being quarantined
with scarlet fever In See's. Bat. He
also testified that on returning sud
dealy from out of the city he had
found Mrs. Bridges at the home of
Absolute Life. '.,.
TWENTY THOUSli ELKS
VERY ATTRACTIVE SH0V7
Portland Carried Off All
Prizes for Greatest
Mileage Represented
MANY OTHER PRIZES
ATLANTIC CITY. N. J. Jury 11.
Twenty thousand Elks marched
through the principal streets of this
oHy today in annual review. Atlantic
avenue, the main thoroughfare of the
resort over which the big parade
countermarched, was densely packed
by an enthusiastic crowd that waa
kept Interested from the moment
Chief Marshal James R. Nicholson,
of Boston, came Into view with his
staff until the rear end of the line
maithed past.
The parade waa a big success. It
was divided Into ten divisions, and
every division had something, Interest,
tng. There were Elks la the conven
tional dress suts and Elks tn the most
fantastic uniforms. All of them got
an enthusiastic hand from the
thronga.
The following prises were awarded:
Lodge having the largest number
of men in line, aggregate mileage.
First prise, Portland. $180; second
prise, Nw Orleans, $100 third prise,
Bt Louis, B0.
Lodge making the best appearance
m uniform First prise, St, LouH,
$J50; second prise, Elisabeth, $110;
third prise, Cincinnati. $100.
Lodge coming great distance First
prise, Portland, $1S0; second prise.
New Orleans, $S0.
Lodge having the largest number
of ladles in line, sggregate mileage
First prise. Portland. $100; second
prise, Cincinnati. $100: third nri.
Syracuse. $60.
Lodge having the most attnotii
floats First Drlxe Oranea. t:eo-
ond prise.' Newport. $100; third
prize, rortiana, se.
Lodge having most beautiful baa
ner Philadelphia, $100,
. : 'L'"y.--;.y-
locusts w cosxEcncct ;
NEW HAVEN. Conn.. Julv II
The 17-year locusts which made thai
appearance through Connecticut this
year win disappear this week and
the larva wU remain in the ground
until till, f The locusts hare left
destruction In their wake and experts
figure the daman to trees and
etatlen la, this stats at more than
IIM.000. -
IL (0 BUT CNT UfT f DISH
g X-yJV TOWEL WITHOUT A OtRrUtK
5 HE. CAN TE A COLLEGE V lCV 1
j
IN UNSPARING TERMS VFOLLETTE
CRITICISES TAFTS ADMINISTRATION
. aaNeeMSBBsasssMBBnMsaeaaneMMMs) r "' '; v-
Wisconsin t Senator and Bristow, of Kansas Introduce Their Amendments With
. Speeches Against Reciprocity Measure At Same Time Senator LaFol--'
( : . lette Takes Occasion to Boost TafCs Predecessor
WAHHINOTON, July 11,-r-Two lm-
portan t Insurgent . speeches) 'against
the Canadian reeriproclty bill were
mad today when Senator LaFol lette
of Wisconsin, and Bristow, of Kansas.
Introduced their amendments to that
measure and spoke In favor of them
and against the specific features' of
. I I .,,, .... . F Jr . . .
Senator LafoUefte excoriated Presi
dent Taft's administration," not only
with reference to the . tariff teglala
tion pro psd, but also on hta conser
vation ipolloles-l Senator Bristow re
newed his fight against the present
sugar tariff, and urged the repeal
of tha "Iff Dutfjii. standard," teat on
Imported; augag. which, be declared
op rates entlcely; li fhe. Interest It
tha American Bugaf Refining, com
pany. Honing t rearK a-voU.o the
reciprocity ; bill aat v week, which
Chairman Penrose, of the aenate ' fi
nance corormuee, ; regaras as "nest
to a certainty," managers - on both
Ides of the senate, chamber are fig
uring seriously on the- subsequent
program. Most of them, havs counted
upon getting away after perfunctory
votes on the democratic free list and
woolen brils. but today It became evi
dent thsv other legislation will be
pressed for consideration.
The friends of tha Aritona and
New Mexico statehood and reappor
tionment bills, especially wiU de
mand votes, as win advocates of the
campaign publicity bill, .
Whatever their fate, these bHls
J. Y. JOYNER. OF RALEIGH
DN NEWJRUSTEES' BOARD
F. M. Harper, One of Direc
tors of The National Edu
cational Association
SAN FRANCISCO, Cal., July 13.
Carroll Gardner Pear, superintend
ent of schools of Milwaukee, was
ejected president of tha National Ed
ucational asoctatlon today to succeed
Mrs. Ella Flagg Young, of Chicago.
With Pearse. were elected all can
dldate on the Insurgent slate.
The Insurgents succeeded In tabling
until 1113 amendment to the by
laws submltied by a eommlttoe ap
pointed two years ago.
J. T. Joyner, of llalelgh, N. C. wnn
elected a member of the new board of
trustee.
The directors recommended to the
executive committee that St. Paul be
the next meeting place. .
It is customary f follow this rec
ommendation.
Among the directors of the Nation
al Educational association are:
North Carolina F. M. Harper, Ra
leigh.
SoOth Carolina D. B. Johnson,
Rock Hill.
Virgin Maurice M. Lynch, Win-
chaster.
CH0WER& )
WASHINGTON. July I-rorecat
for. North Carolina: Local thunder-
showers Friday and probably Satur
day;, light variable wind.
must necessarily be taken tnto' con
sideration In all adjournment calcu
lation. .. ,'. ,' ' :.
Senator LaFoIlette, In g speech
against reciprocity, today reviewed,
act by act, tha. administration of
President Taft (n unsparing term
and declared that the contest In
volved waa thg "fight between the
plain people and confederated jrlvl.
lege."
"Considered a a measure of re-
clprooltw," said he, ''the Canadian
agreement violate every tariff prin
ciple, of reciprocity heretofore ex
pressed In the platform of tha repub
lican party and recommended toy for.
mer republican president Considered
as a tariff bfli. It violates every tar
Iff piinctpH and. platform promtae
vim. wtjlch Wmf j, Taft jra ltl
pfealden. The reelproolty bill reduce
no duties the effect ef which can ever
reach the people, bat It reduce du
tie for the millers,: the packer,
Standard Oil, the Brewers, tha coal
combines, and in some measure for
the already grossly protected inter
est. It Is nothing that It pretends to
be and professes to be. nothing that it
Is. It is a lltW brother to the Payne
Aldrlch bill, tha greatest legislative
wrong Inflloted upon the Amerlcaa
pelple In' half a x!ntury."!
Continuing hi criticism of Mr.
Taft's administration Senator Lafol
lettev said: -' j
"Throughout the first page of his
first general message he found no i
T
CRASH, SEVERAL iNJIIRED
Five Oars ' Loaded With
Stone Crash Headon Into
Train No. 23
SPENCER; N. C, July 1J Engi
neer A. J. Helllg, of Norwood, was
severely Injured and six passengers
slightly hurt today at Granite Quar
ry on the Tadkln Branch of the
Southern railway a result of Ave
cars heavily losded with stone, crash
Ing headon Into passenger train No.
23, bound from Salisbury to Nor
wood. Vrhe passenger train was malt
ing good time when the stone cars
broke loose from a shifting engine
on a steep grade and dashed with
terrible force Into the train on the
passenger track. The locomotive
was demolished, the track torn up
and the fireman saved himself by
lumping. A baggage car was smash
ed and the beggagemaater left un
harmed. . The engineer wae badly
aided and bruised and wa carried
to a Halisnury noepual for treat
ment-
3,000 DOGS KILLED BY
BOSTON DOO CATCHER
BOSTON, July, 13. Three thousand
stray dogs have been killed during
the past 13 months by Boston's of
ficial dog catcher. The official dog
catchers are Huntington 8mlt,h Ju
lian Codman and Dr. Frank J. Sul
livan, all'Vealthy citizens. They are
officers of the Animal Rescue league
and volunteered their services. The
dogs have been picked up by the
league employe. i
Although the law prescribe ' a
liberal fee to the dog catcher for
every animal killed, the three desig
nated officials will not present a bill
to the city, as th law definitely pro
vides that thay must themselves doi
the catching and killing. Th of
ficial dog catcher ar understood not
to have had either the time or In
clination to go through th olty dally
catching dog.
space to Mr a word for the great
measure that bad mad the name of
his predecessor (Mr, Roosevelt), rev
ered and loved everywhere In the
united state.", ,.',. - -- ',
"In all the record of this admin
Istratlon no more glaring example 1
presented of the templet surrender
to specie Interest and th complete
reversal of Koossvelt'a progressive
policies than that shown In dealing
wtin me amendments to. th Inter
stale commerce act it would have
been difficult to frame a piece
ot legislation arresting Interstate
commerce mora harmful te th nubile
interest than the bin drafted by the
attorney general- and : recommended
to congsa by President Taft."
,. "IIMr t th Rooasvelt policies
a reldaiia aMllda. -Mn -Taft was
a pronounced progressiva : and the
leading nod most enthusiastic Jtoo.
velt champion from the first to th
last of the campaign. -
f "Three month after he waa In
augurated he seemed to have forgot
ten that there ever bad been any wall
known Roosevejlt pollfll. He ha -a 9
sooner taken til 'oath of offlo, than
ha sacrificed th progressive can
for th support of Aldrioh and Can
non and their reactionary pregram.
"Roclproplty I g popular , eatoh
word. The president seised upon It,
He. made an exetrutlve compact the
Baal, riot org reciprocity treaty, but
(Continued nti Psge rive)
ONTARIO FOREST FIRES
L
No Further Extensive Loses
of Life or Damage is Ex
pected to be Found
TORONTO, fltnt, July II. Report
tonight from Northern Ontario points
are to the effect that the forest Are
which for several day have swept
over a section of country etendlng 100
mile northward from North Bay
and covering a wide section east
and west have either been extinguish
,d or ar under control.
, No further extensive damage or loss
or lire la expected.
Th towns of Cocheran. South
Porcupln and Pottavllle have belfh
obliterated, Th fir swept clean th
township of Langmulr. Eldorado,
Shaw. Deloro, Ogden, McArthar and
Cripple Creek . district . The- known
dead total 123, the majority of whom
lost their lives at South . Porcupine
There are believed to have been many
otner raianties, and estimates based
upon unverified ' reports run a high
as 400. -
Among the 121 victims known to
havg perished In th neighborhood of
Porroiplne.ls Jules Metayer. 39 year
old, the French consul, Twenty-seven
foreigner lost thelf live In the West
Com shaft and thirty, other war
killed In. another of th Dome abaft.
There ar believed to have been many
other fatalities among the foreign la
borer. .... ''-'- ' '
A relief trln left North Bay this
afternoon for Porcupln with sup
plies. Plenty of funds have been
subscribed In this city for Immediate
help.
Refugees from the burned are say
that It cover l.OOO , square . .miles,
comprising a district that housed t.000
people. ; From. every quarter have
com fugitive who escspsd i th
flame, many of them badly burned
in their effort to sav valuable's in'
their flight. '
It I evident that It will be some
day and perhaps week before any
sccurats Idea of th total number of j
dead le available. - Many of th ter-
ror-auicken ned into th interior of
iCoTrtn4 on Fax Eight)
HEYBURN ATTACKED
CONFEDERATE CAUSE
Question of Paying Davis
Bodyguard and keeper or '
: Seal of Lost Cause up 1
WASHINGTON, July JL-Th reel,
nrocltv dhtA tit th ant iMt.u.-...
preceded by the endorsement of the
plea or Senator' Jo bit Sharp Williams,
ot Mississippi, ter the-retention on th
senate pay roll of "Jim" Jone. an
aged negro bodyguard, of Jefferson
bavia. in uportlng Senator WIU
llama, th senate overthrew lis own
commute on ' patronage, which : hail
reconynenqed the removal of Jone
from th pay roll. -, Blttsr words were
exchanged between Senator . William
and Senator Heyourn. of Idaho, ever
Mr. Meybtfrn'a characterisation of th
Confederacy aa n "Infameu cause,'
Mr, William retorting that he wa
unprepared to hear that oxprslon
from a "elvtliaei man.
'"But for th i parliamentary yule
that restrain me." declared Mr. Wil
liam, "I would have a few words to
say about tha kind of human being In'
whoa heart inch thought exist. .
' Senator William had asked to hav
"Jim" Jonea, the 1 1-year-old negro
who had been Jefferson Pevis' body
guard, and In who custody th seat
of th Confederacy waa intrusted, re
tained on th senate pay roll a a !-'
borer. , . .f'.vs-'f, ! 5 '
; Senator Hlyburn acquiesced In re
tention of the negro for hi service
formerly riven to the senate, "but nut
'because ot loyalty to th glory of an
Infamous cause." ' 1
Senator William replied with yrent
feeling that he wa 'nat preiarel to
hear a civlllxedan In th twnnii, j'i
eentury fall 'en Infamous canoe' ti.a
cause for which hi f William' tutn-r
laid down hi life."
?tue and Jackson may have bn
wrong," added Mr. Williams. That
.th government 1 now In xihteni-
a cause for congratulation t.
p hllurtn of the mn whrt ". ,1
Le and faekon, but I cannot r
th sentlTient I hav for a hu '
tng In whom uch sentiments " re
main hav been' expressed hole."
'Ther I no right of Amerlcsn clt
Isenshlp.'" he added, "that permits a
man to Insult th dead. '
"Wtl, wa It t a glorious cause 1"
asked Mr, Ilayburn,
"Thjir waa -muoh of glory In It.'
replied Mr. William. -
The snt sustained Senator Wil
liams by a vote of IT to It, leaving
Jone on th pay roll at ITI0 a year
a g laborer; '
' Mr. Heybum, following his bitter
altercation with Mr. Williams, voted
against th negro. ' ' .
Senator Heyburn' ' us ' of th
phrase-"Infamoua .cause" md to
enrage Senator . WBIlam. . WaVklng
Into th middle, aisle and shsklng hi
baad at th gentleman from Idaho ha
exclaimed passionately; , ' , -.
"Loyalty and courage and honor
ar thing that ar precou to honor
able men. The senator from Idaho
seems to have constituted himself a
censor to see that no kind word I
ever spoken of th men who wore th
gray. Whenoa com thin ' , censor
shlpT" When Senator lUybum re
joined that h wa simply exerclslnif
his right as an American eitlsen, Mr.'
WlMtam retorted! :; . ;;;'
"Ther I no Inherent lght In aa
(Contlrwd on Pag Eight)
THREE CORNEREO
PISTOL
DUEL ON UN
H KILLS
io:i
Two Policemen s Injure
Train Betunng From
Columbia to Charleston
IN BUOEINO CAB
CrlARLOTTIB, N. C, July ll.-k-la i
three-oornered pistol duel on board a i
negro excursion train, returning to
night about' l.l "o'clock from Colum
bia, S. C, to, Charlotte. John Reeve,
colored, of Rock Hill. 8. C. was killed.
Special Policeman 3. A. Bskrldge, of
Charlotte, wa dangerously wounded. -and
Special I'ollceman J. T. Wilson, .
also of this city, wa grased by a but
let from Reeve rvolvr, ' . , ;
Th trouble occurred In the smok
ing ear of tha train between Rock
Hill, and Fort Mill.- S- O., when tha
negro began firing hi pistol out of the ,
window. H was ordered by Wilson, .
who wa detailed to preserve order on
the train, to surrender hi pistol, but
Instead' 6pehd fire, on of the bul
let striking . Policeman Kskrldge.
wbo wa ataudlpg In Hi able. Wil
son says he than pulled his pistol and
shot Reeves dead. Eskridge. however.
also maintain that, bo fired th fatal .
hot'.- ... .":' . ) . ls " '.
Bskrldg la In a precarlou ondltloa
la a Jteaoltat hare. . t
: - .. "'.; : ;: . ..:'v:'