-V ' THE .WEATHER North and South Carellna-l-Cleudy ,4 wimwhat colder Tuesday; riln Tuesday night and Wednssdsy; colds . Wednesday. FIRST CONCERTED PARLEY TREATIES Favorable Report on All Covenants by Senate Committee. NOT AN ORGANIZED 'POLITICAL ATTACK Glass Denies Wilson Has Suggested Course to Democratic Friends. WASHINGTON. Feb. 27. The ilrst concerted attack on the arms conference treaties, cnaracterigea oy tactics which , administration leaders openly charged suggested a filibuster, was launched 1b the senate today", Just as the foreign relations cornmittee completed its consideration of the covenants and ordered all of, therafayorably re ported. ": 'v After several hours of wrangl ing, a unanimous agreement v. as reported to vote, not later than 2 p. m- Thursday on 'ratification of the treaty with Japan relating to Tap and other mandated Islands in the Pacific. Immediately after ward debate is to begin on the other treaties resulting from the conference negotiations. Using the Tap treaty as the im mediate vehicle of their discussion, but interspersing remarks on many ether subjects and frequent quo rum calls, opponents of the con ference program carried on such a determined all day assault that the senate managers prolonged the ses sion into the evening in the hope of wearing down their assailants. One incident 1 to the - series of nointed exchanges running through the debate was a complete dis- j claimer irom xne aomgerauc biuc, that "political opposition" had been : organized against the treaties or had been counselled by former President ' Wlujpn. Senator Glass, democrat "Virginia, Who was a member of the cabinet In the last administration denied as a "purest Invention." a published atory that Mr. Wilson had suggested a course of action to his friends in the senate. ,' '";" --"-'x JOHNSON AND REED ' ATTACK TAP TREATY The attack on iba Tap treaty, during whioh many stray shots were taken at others of the arms conference agreements,, was led by Senators . Johnson, republican, California and - Reed, democrat,. Missouri, the former characterised the . Tap pact ' as "a dismal pro logue," to the conference series of venants, and the latter openly rihanrlnir renubllcah leaders With ATTA DN ARMS aa effort 0.;;fpri.;MM0l.!itrr- rietd-1''averr1 manil - - J through the . senate before -the f country discovered what they coin Jtnln. .; ,. The Tap treaty was defended by; Senator tinaerwooa oi jiaui", democratic leader and a member of the American arms delegation, although he declared he was not entirely in' agreement with the premises on" which the pact was drawn. He argued that the United States never had : an "undivided one-fifth of sovereignty over Par clflo islands and hence was not giving it up under the reaty.' HARDING CONSIDERS BILL WITH FORDNEY Conference on Tariff Is Held at Will House. , ( WASHINGTON; Fen. 2t The tariff hill was discussed today at White u,, rr htnrri4" President f Harding and Representative Mondell. n( Wyoming, the repumican nu leader, and Chairman Fordnef, of the ways and means committee. It was Indicated afterwards 'that the execu tive desired a speeding up of worn on the measure, which is now in pro cess of rewritlng-by republican mem ber of the senste finance .committee. Specific rates In the bill occupied (lie attention today of the senate committeemen, sometif whom said is rtpciFion Iff , the controversy with house leaders over American valua tion probably, would be deferred un til work on the rate had been com pleted. The ad valorem' duties, it was stated, still are being written on the hasts of the foreign valuation of the imported articles but It was dis closed that at the same time exports attached to the committee are trans late these1 rates into figures based "ii the American wholesale "?!lin.8 nrlee of the imports so that " the iwtsis finally is agrees) upon the suo tltutlfin of figures can be accompllsh- VM without delay. ' tint he would Insist on a Mil with American valuation and added that it was his opinio' that 'if the senate measure did not provide for such valuation It would be referred to, the ways and means committee for re drafting Instead of being sent to con ference as would 4)6 4he.ttsual pro 'edurc. -i. .'."' ,., :. - '.v J. j.'.'"" HUDY CANKOT REMEMBER SHOOTING WIFE, BE SA1S . . 1M - ..r . "4 . ;.- MIAMI, Fla., Feb. 2 7. Edgar 1 ' Krady; Chicago automobile man ho shot and probably fatally w minded his wife and, cut his own ;!'ioat Sunday afternoon in a local lintel, was placed under arrest In a hospital this evening, wnen py- nana atnm,nr.,t fhnf ne wouia .... . - p recover. Mrs.: Frady can not live u was stated. Mrs. Frady this morning, resi ding that ishe could not live, asked for a lawyer, who drew up a win for her. K :'; ? ' ' Friends of Mrs! Frady Issued a denial of Frady's assertions that she had accepted t attention ot other men. . . ''' -. - Frady. questioned by a deputy sheriff this afternoon said he could not remember the shooting. '. SEVERAL BADLY WOUNDEO DURING BELFAST tHOOTINtt - BELFAST, Feb. 27. (By ' The As sociated Press J There was heavy firing by civilians In the Short Btrand district at 8 o'clock this evening. The firing folIwed-a terrific bomb explosion at ( o'clock this afternoon at the corner of Vulean and Ssaford treets and Newtownardi' road wbsn Tom Mullan, a 14 years eld newsboy, was. seriously wounded In the, legs and head. v ' v There also, was shooting M which 'there were-eastm itlee Queens Hrldre and Albert Tirldca. two of the -frincipi Lagaav- nncipai ; erftsslngs af the Hivef THE EST ABLISH ED 1868. Retrenchment In School Funds Now Threatening Educational Progress CHICAGO, Feb. 27. Retrench ment in expenditures for public schortts Is seriously threatening the educational progress of the United States, John J. Tigert, federaj com missioner of education, told dele pates to the convention of the National Education association here today. "It is obvious," he said, "that the present efficiency of the schools cannot be maintained If teachers' salaries are reduced and it Is probable that they will have to be increased still further even in the face of decreases In the cost of living-." " The average teacher's salary at present, he added, is not over $900 a year. - A difference of opinion devolop ed over the need forta centralized .direction of the nation's educa tional activities in charge of a member of the presidential cabi net. The need for such a national organization was Judged by Geo. D. Strayer, of Columbia university, who declared: LETTER INTENDED FDR REPUBLICAN Large Manufacturing In terests Want "American Valuation Plan." WUH1N0T03 SCBSAO TBI iHHITUXS CITIZE.f ( II. I. P. tllYiHT) WASHINGTON, Feb. 27. In their - hour of "sore distress" the republican leaders are being de luged' with letters giving advise,- or making protests. Now and then letters from these people are by mistake addressed to democratic senators. Big republi can manufacturers artd special in terests do not seem -to keep up with the political affiliation of the members of the senate. For in stance, Senator Simmons, demo crat tariff leader of the senate, re ceived today, a letter from one of these Interests in California, that was evidently addressed to him by mistake. This letter reads: '.'We .nanufacturers on this coast are reading with great surprise of the attitude of the republican members of the senate'"" finance coifimlttee in the matter of the American valuation plan as applied to the Fordney bill. "The conditions existing in this facturing city in the United States. Yesterday canvasses showed 1,000 heads of families in this city out of employment and we are asked to provide work for them. CONGRESS DOING ' NOTHING FOR FACTORIES "How can we do so when the people we send to congress to rep resent Mis and enact laws wnicn will keep our population employed are either doing nothing or delib erately working out a scheme that has for its object xne conunueu xlnnlnr flnwn nf OUT factories. . "if vou will examine costs of material, costs of. labor, and Stan dard nf llvinar In this country and foreign countries you will And that a protective tarm in connection with the American valuation pian Is an absolute necessity. "The remedy for this condition lies In the adoption of th Amer ican valuation plan immediately. "If you are one of the dissenters we trust you will review the mat ter nd vote in favor of the plan." That is what you chII "letting th est out. of the bag," Senator Simmons said today, "Hepitbll cans in congresa who have been going around In circles for months in th matter of the enactment of a new tariff measure to take the place of the Simmons-i.rraerwooa act, which they hnd ai' denounced, are between the devK and the sea. Nobody knows now whether 'a tar iff hiii win h enacted at this ses sion or not The people of the country have made such an up rising against' ths so called Ameri can valuation pian in the Fordney bill, that the republicans have lost their nerve, since the found the nlan was entirely unworkable. .nntnr Simmons ind his ex perts here for months have been engaged in a practical demnnstra kv mrav nf fact nn 1 argument that this plan Is rot only highly unjust and designed to grfmt hun dred? of millions,!?! special favors tu the big interests, but ilso that It is not practical to operate. ABBiiriri C'ft ATTORNEYS IN T MOTION FOR EVIDENCE 'ev irriAvntsoo.- Feb'. 17Coun sel for Boscoe C. (Fatty) Arbuckle, . Thanfrffl.iiffhter In connec tion with the death of Miss Virginia Rappe, petitioned Superior Judge Harold Ixuderbach today for the right to take the depositions of five rhienirn witnesses for Arbuckle third trial, scheduled to being March 33 The district attorney was given three days in whichto answer the - The proposed witnesses are doctor ,in hnvA been familiar -with certain supposed physical defects of i certain uiy" i---- -- M1 Rapp which have a direct bear- lug on tne case, ONE KJIXKO. TWO HVItT BYBOMB IN BELFAST BELFAST, Feb. 27. Tonight bomb was thrown from the top of a tramcar in York street and Rich, ard Duffy was killed and two other persons were woundod Two bombs were th.'.wn In BaHyn-iir-ret street. One of them burst bu did no damage. The other did not "TwoVrson were' wounded by shots fired Into a strcei car In 6ea ford' street. U , -y-j, At.LEGEQ rfsV TcTaXPLA.N wthoritM in connection wltf jthe death of his mother, Mrs, Ada Drury Convex near Haslehunrt torfay de. Wlrort tWwba. ithhl. rnjther until he was ar- Daic'.... . ..n.laH In turn mtni III UUII"U. "unr "JTrfhCSt offli-ers to- SENDS SIMMONS SUPREM AS "DEDICATED "Good administration, ths struc ture of our national government, the practical importance of educa tion in our national life all call for the recognition of education in our federal government through the establishement of a national department of education with a secretarx in the President's cabi net." Alexander Inglls, of Harvard university, opposed federal sup port and direction of public schools as "fundamentally unsound poli cies of government." Long dis tance, governmental Interference in schools administration, he de nounced as "vicious." "Let us not be deceived," ha as serted, "all acta providing soldier federal subsidies in aid of educa tion carry with them the dynamite of federal participation in the con trol of education and the deter mination of educational policies. yien that bomb exploded it will be of little service to have their advocates protest that they did not know their measures were loaded," E COURT UPWSI.C.S. ON FARES IN STATES Without Dissent Holds That "Commerce Is Unit With no State Lines." WASHINGTON, Feb. 27. De claring that "commerce is a unit and docs not regard state lines." the Supreme court today, through I Chief Justice Tart, and without dissent handed down a decision upholding the authority of the in terstate commerce commission, un der the transportation act of It 20 to fix state railroad passenger fares when necessary to remove "un due, unreasonable and unjust dis crimination against Interstate com merce. Two cases were presented to the rourt. One was brought by the four commissions of Wisconsin and others against the Chicago, Bur lington and Quincy railroad seek ing an InJurtoUon to prevent, the railroads of th'e state from putting into effect on state passenger traf fic the . rate of 3.8 cents per milo allowed W the government on in terstate travel. The other' was brought . by the State" of New York ugainst the federal government, the interstate commence commis sion and certain. .railroads ot that tnto on -the ground the three enf f,f:w5r?ttMiir commission produced v reasonable returns to the railroads upon- their state traffic. ; In both states freight rates had been advanced to ths interstate level without objection from the states., : ; "Congress in Its control of lt interstate commerce system it seeking in the transportation act to make the system adequate to the needs of the country by. s. curing for it a reasonable compen satory return for all the work It tSocs," ins chief justice stated In the opinion. "The states are seek. Ing to use the same system for in trastate traffic. That entails lerga duties and expenditures on the in terstate commerce system -which may burden it unless compensation is received for the Intrastate busi ness reasonably proportionate to that for the interstate business Congress as the dominant control ler of ' interstate commerce may, therefore, restrain undue limita tion of the earning power of this interstate commerce system lri do-' Ing state work. It can impose any ifasonahle condition on a state t:se of interstate carrlers'for intra state commerce It deems neoes aar.V or desirable. This Is because of the supremacy of the national power lri this field." AUTOMOTIVE MEN MEET IN CHARLOTTE CHARLOTTE. Feb. 87. Thirl cnariotte Automotive Trade associ ation at the Weekly ' luncheon to day heard E. L. Whitmore, presi dent of the Greensboro association: R. W. Morton, publicity director of the Greensboro automobile show and' J. C. Muir, factory representa tive of the Franklin Auto company. Mr. Whltmore spoke of the fine feeling displayed at the meeting. Mr. Morton spoke on the Oaf City show and Mr. Muir so ke of the growth of business within the list three months. Improvement being noted in many "sections of the country. FIVE BROKERAGE HOtTSFSI - IN FINANCIAL TROVUI.ES NEW. YORK. Feb. 27. Fmar cial troubles overtook -five more brokerage houses in-Wall street to day. J . . , - Involuntary bankruptcy petitions were filed against four. , whllo a fifth, C. W. Starbuck and company,' made a voluntary assignment for the benefit of creditors.- Today's failures brought ths te jt.I since last November ul to 85. The firm of Afosher and Wallace was the fint to go down today, an nouncement of Its suspension from the Consolidated Stock exchange being followed quickly y the filing of a bankruptcy petition in federal court. Liabilities were estimated at $175,000. while assets were not fated. -w '' The- same fate, overtook Thomas H. Cowley and company and Bhew ry and Falkland, liabilities and as sets of the former being listed, re spectively, as 100,000 and 140.000. while in the ease of Bhwwry and Falkland HabiUUea alone were es timated at 160.000. Neither liabilities nor aeUWertH estimated In the petition against Gamble and Tate., This firm, like C. W. Starbuck and company. Is an "outside" house, with no exchagge connection. ; . - '. BIUnSH TROOPS BBGI.V " EVACUATION OK DCBUN DUBLIN. Feb. T.Th svacua tlon of British troops wsa resumed trdav. Two hundred of the first Wt drssooea fronaXurraf 0jm-J harked for England. HEVELLEACmZEN TO THE UP-BUILDING ItSHEVILLE, N. C, TUESDAY MORNING J FEBRUARY'S, 1922. UN SUFFRAGE AIN1ENT1LD VALID AS PASSED Supreme Court , Sustains Constitutionality of Fed eral Amendment. STATE PROVISIONS NOT ENTERTAINED Objection ; to Tennessee's Ratification Is Held to Be "Immaterial." ... WASHINGTON, Feb. 87. The constitutionality of the women's suffrage or nineteenth amendment, was sustained today by the su preme court In an unanimous de cision rendered by Justice Bran dies. The challenge came from the state of Maryland where Oscar Leser and others sought to prevent the registration of two women as qualified- voters in Baltimore. Leser and his associates contended that the constitution of Maryland lim ited suffrage to men: that the leg islature of Maryland had refused to ratify the woman's suffrage amendment and that the amend ment had not become a part of the federal constitution. The Maryland state courts sustained the amend ment. . c-'1: The contention that an amend ment to the federal constitution r lating to additions to the electo rate cannot be made without the consent of the state, the court dis posed of by reference to the fif teenth or equal suffrage amend ment, declaring that "one cannot be valid and the other Invalid." It pointed out that the validity of the fifteenth amendment hid been rec ognized for half a century. CONSTITUTIONS OF STATES OP NO EFFECT The suggestion that several of the 30' states which .ratified the 19th amendment had provisions in their state constitutions which pro hlblted the legislatures from ratl flylng should not be entertalued the court stated, tiecause the state leg islatures derived their power In .iich matters from . the federal constitution, which "transcends any limitations sought to Imposed by the people of a state." ; Ths-' remaining objection ; thst ths ratifying resolutions of Ten nessee and West Virginia wars In operative,' because adopted fin vio lation of legislative procedure , in those states many havs been ren dered "immaterial," the court de clared, by the subsequent ratifica tion of the amendment by Con necticut and Vermont. Tha in tention was disposed of however. m---tfrtWrer grmtnd, the court. stated, adding tnat tne secretary ot state having Issued a proclama tion of , the , ratification of the amendment by the legislatures of thirty-six states the amendment to all Intents and purposes hsd be come a part of the constitution. As Tennessee and West Virginia had power to ratify and had offi cially notified the secretsry o. state lhat they had dons ao,-tIrlr action was binding upon the secretary, and upon being certified by that official had become collusive upon the courts. PROCEEDINGS BEGIN BY C. S. FAIRCHILO f The wemen suffrage or nineteenth amendment to the constitution was challenged In the supreme court, in proceedings instituted by Charles B. Falrchlld of New-York, for himself and In behalf of tha American Con stitutional league, to enjoin the sec retary of state from issuing and the attorney- general from enforcing a proclamation declaring the artlfica tlon of the amendment, and by Oscar Leser and ether cttiiens of Mary land., constituting an organization known as the "Maryland League for State Defense." The former proceed. Ings were based on the ground that the amendment bad not been validly adopted, and the latter that the amendment was unconstitutional. The federal courts in the district of Columbia and the state courts In Maryland, where the cases, rpec tively, were originally brought, ruled against the objections to the amend ment. In the oral arguments In the supreme eourt In the Fairohild case, the government contended that the secretary of state having Issued the ratification proclamation there was nothing to restrain, and that the ease therefore became moot, not present ing a controversy for judical decision. In th I.ip rase, the government acknowledged t that the proceedings had haen . Instituted by voters who had sufficient Interest . to warrant thMe nramnca In court, but that tne issue raised was political, one for MrfJnn. hv conaress or for settle ment In some other avenue than by adjudication in the rourts. While the state of Maryland had refused to ratify the amendment, it was poiniea nut the state alsor refused to question its constitutionality.;. - -The power ef oongress to propose the amendment to the state legisla tures for ratification was assailed by Its opponents on the ground that the people reserved - to themselves in their state constitutions the rtght to regulate suffrage, and tnat in i "ti ers! government legally could not have anything whatever, to do with changing the "sovereign" power" em bodied In suffrage auallfioatlons. The people were not setting up an amending agency fo rthelr own de struction.", the opponents contended, asserting that, , In limiting federal Jurisdiction the "sovereign people" did not intend, that their agents con ducting the federal government, should have the , power to destroy them. ' Following this line of argu ment It was .argued that the people alone by amendments to their state constitutions or by a constitutional convention- called for the purpose could extend or. abridge their sever -elrntv. - - "'.- ., v . The fifteenth t or raee suffrsge amendment, adopted after the war between the states, was not a pre cedent, it was asserted, by the op ponents because it was an expression of the ."results of revolution," ao auleoed In by all- the people, for the "reconstruction" , of the - nation, by extending to the negro 'race freedom and equality," or which the war was fought." Any other method 4 "for - r able aecree or tne otvu war wouiu have been equally effective," it was argued. Should It be held, notwithstanding these' Abjections, the congress had oonstltuional power to submit tiie amendment for ratification by state legislatures, the prescribed ' three fourths of the legislatures, required for constitutional ratification, did not give their approval, the opponents of women's suffrage insisted naming Missouri. Tennessee end West vir ilnla, counted among the 3s states . tetnsa W OF WESTERN NORTH liEttilBULI DEFER ACTION QfJ Makes Suggestion After Conference With the President. LEGION IS OPPOSED TO FURTHER DELAY Refunding of Foreign Debt Is Discussed at White House. WASHINGTON, Feb. ST. -Post, ponement of house action oh the soldiers' bonus bill for a while longer was suggested today by Representative Mondell, of Wyo ming, the republican leader, after he nnd Chairman Fordnfcy, of the ways and means committee, had conferred with President Hardinj at the White House. Emphasizing that the suggestion whs his own, Mr. Mondell said it wns well known that the house Intended to pass a bonus measure at this session and that a little delay might serve "to clear the rkies." He explained that within u short time there probably would bo more definite information aa to expected saving in expenditures for the next fiscal year; returns from the foreign debt and whether business conditions could be ex pected to improve to the extent of insuring additional .federal 'reve nues. - Mr. Mondell and Mr. Fordney were understood to have appraised the 'resident formally of the ac tfon of the special house sub-committee in rejecting the executive's proposal that the bonus be ft nam ed by ly sales tax and approve Ing instead 'a bill without any defl ntte means of raising the revenuo. They would not indicate what views the executive had expressed, ( rut Kepresentauve Ixingworth, of Ohio, a member of the committee dealing with the bonus question, said tonight after a visit to the While House that Mr. Harding was still of the opinion that the legTs Ution should either be financed by a sales tax or postponed. Before seeing the President, Mr. Fordney conferred with Hanford MacNider, natio n a 1 commander, and John Thomas Taylor, legisla tive agent of the American Legion. Mr, MacNider and Mr. . Taylor called at the White House to see the President' but were Informed Mr. Harding's engagement list for the forenoon was filled.' They said thty would return later In the day. rar. juacniaar said the leg on as opposed to any further delay ana indicated that It was his de sire to present his-views ta tha executive. He' reiterated that th- legion would not be drawn lnt any discussion ot ways and means for raising the necessary bonus, Indicating that It was interested trly In the speedy passage of the legislation. On leaving the White House both Mr, Mondell and Mr. Fordney said the house would pass a bonus bill t.t this session. Mr. Mondell stated that he could not say whether a measure without means of raising the revenue could be put througn the senate. Asked as to ways of financing the adjusted compensation, the re publican house leader referred aoain to expected aavlngs In the next fiscal year, but he would not give an estimate as to what this amount would be. He Indicated that the question of the refunded foreign debt as a means of financ ing the bonus had been brought up at the White House conference, bJt declined to say what views the President hsd expressed. FIRE IN AUGUSTA'S BUSINESS DISTRICT General Alarm Sounded ""ttltcn Trunk Factory i, untied. ? AtrGtaTA. Ga Feb' tt. Firs starting here at 12 o'clock tonight oyer Montell a studio in tht aeartof the business district threatens the bloox. . Oeneral alarm has sounded aifd the fire Is bursting from ail sldel snd through the ton of the (our-etory Montgomery building where the fire started. The plaes where tonight's fir started was only two buildings dis tant from the spot where the last conflagration was checked; The Au gusta Trunk factory, a leather goods store on the .first floor of the bujld ilng, has been completely gutted and the flames are bursting from ths roo and windows. It seems at this time, however, that the flra will be controlled before it Ignites nearby buildings, fire walls serving as barriers. The pjlnd is very light, blowing gently to the east, but the flame are not mounting high nor are wperks flying aa fast as they did in the fife of November last. All of the engines of the city's) fire department ere In service with the exception of the necessary reserve. TEXTILE STRIKE IN BHODE ISLAND AT CLIMAX TODAY n ... . i . it PROVIDENCE, R. I Feb. 27. i-A climax to the textile strike which has closed many cotton mills In Ilhode Island for five weekc 'will be reached tomor row afternoon when strikers and mill owners must reply to the final appeal ot the state board of mediation' and conciliation. The board's appeal called - for an immediate resumption of work on the part of the strik ers and the acceptance ot Judge 3. Hahn and. sole arbiler of the wage dispute. Today was quiet In both the I'awtuxef and Blackstone Valleys. Rumors that mills iiMhe Pawtuxet Val ley would 'is re-opened this morning to employes willing to return on the basis of a 20 per cent reduction In pay called forth pickets 1 to all mill sp proaches. Lines were formed during the early hours of that night but dwindled away this morning ss the watchers saw no smoke in the big mill chimneys. Pawtuxet Valley strike lead ers met with the executive com mittee- of the Amalgamated Textile Workers today to frame the union's answer, to the- state board..'? " - SOLDIERS BONUS CAROLINA" Indict Twelve On Conspiracy To Of Several Million Claim Federal Reserve Bank Made Threats To Force State . Banks To Par-Clearance Plan MONROE. N. C, Feb. J7. Doc umentary evidence Intended to show that the Richmond federal reserve bank had threatened to pursue a course that would have seriously damaged and caused much financial loss to North Caro lina banks operation under state charter, was introduced by the let ter today hsre in the trial of the so-called "par. clearance" case. Through letters and other doc uments that ths state banks sought to prove that, the fideral reserve bank threatened to snd checks on them by messenger to demnnd cash payment over the counter, unless they agreed to remit at pat, and ta dishonor such checks It pay ment at par were declined. The alleged threats, according to the evidence, followed the passage of an act by tha North Carolina leg islature authorising the state banks to charge exchange on all checks circulated through other banks. Thinks Is a Poor Treaty Compelling Counsel Be Sent to Canada. wiurasTos oms tss uaTiu.a omu) , lit at . 0. IRYtST) . WASHINGTON, Feb. 27. Gov. rnor Morrison is In a real spirited row -with the state department over Matthew Bullock, negro, who Is wsnted in North Csrollna on a charge of inciting to riot. Act ing Secretary of State Fletcher to day sent a telegram to the gov ernor In reply to a recent telegram from that official declining to an- P0'"? counsel In the case of Bui. lock! Secretary Fletcher pointed out In his message that under the ex tradition treaty between the Unt ted States and Great, Britain, which likewise applies . to Canada, per sons may be extradited '"only upon such evidence of criminality as. according to the laws ot the place where the fugitive or person ro charged shall be found, would justify his apprehension and com mitment for trial If the crime or offense had there been committed." The secretary also stated Inst there was plenty ot precedent foi st ate authorities In the United States to employ counsel in Can ada, adding that In some Instances contested cases prosecuted by the Canadian authorities In the United States had gone as far as the Uni ted States suprem court." " The telegram from Governor Morrison was considered sarcastic in tone, the governor declaring that "If treaty relations with Can ada are not such ss to guarantee the return to this country of dee tne reiurn o mis country or aes- perate criminals like Matthew Bui. lock without ths states of this union being subjected to the hu miliation of having to appear Be fore tome judge In a petty judicial proceeding In Canada It ,1s cer tainly a distressing situation." The text of Secretary Fletcher's reply follows: , "You' may desire to take Into consideration that by treaty with Great Brltian, which Is applicable to Canada, It Is provided that ex' tradition shall be granted 'only up on such evidence of criminality as, according to the laws of the place where the fugitive or person so charged shall be found, would Jus tify his apprehension and commit ment for trial If the crime or of fense had there be committed. "This, of course, raises a judicial question and in contested cases late authorities not Infrequently employ counsel in Canada.' as do likewise Canadian authorities lu the United States, where occasion ally extradition cases go so far as the United States supreme coiirt. "Counsel Hamilton reports Feb ruary 24 prisoner remanded until March 3, 10 a. m. Judge stated there would be no further remand and, reiterated absolute necessity (or oral testimony." SHOE MAN HEARD BY COMMERCE BODY Intcr-Ktste Commission Craddock. Hears 3. WASHINGTON. Feb. T. The In terstate Commerce commission in al lowing maintenance of existing rail road rates., was declared to be "hold ing an umbrella over the railroads at the expense of other industry" by J. W. Craddock, of Lynchburg. Vs., president of the Craddock-Terry Shoe company, who appeared today for or ganlaatfone of sioe manufacturers, wholesalers end retailers. The sched ules must corns down, he added, be cause thn country was "through the ilk shirt era." Mr. Oradriook said hla industry would not specify what rates should be cut or to what degree, but con mdrl that coat freights ahrntld be taken up -generally first, and agri cultural products second. ' What was almost the only appeal for lower xiaaesnger rates, waa made today by K. B. Lelghton. represent ing the International Theatrical as aioialion. Thn fire-wr ai-hedules of SV cents per mile for traveler should be rstored, he declared, because the atrical failures had Increased tre mendously In numbers, while road hows had decreased, demonstrating that the charges were too high for the trafflo to bear. . ELECTROCUTED AS riSHINO une touchis livs wine MACONf, Oa Feb. !7. Sarah Arnold, negro woman, who was fish ing In the Ocmulgae river here late today, oast her Mne over two oo volt power wires, and was killed Instant ly. A short circuit was formed by ths line snd the two big plants were pA eut of business for two hours. MORRISON SENDS PRQBEQF ROMA SARCASTIC NOTE DISASTER ON BULLOCK CASE ... PRICE FIVE CENTS . Evidence also was Introduced to support thn claim of the state banks that a large percentage of their revenue Is derived from the exchange charges and that many of them would be driven out of business If they should be denied this Income, and to support the contention of the state banks that the alleged "threats" by the Rich mond bank were deigned merely to force ths state banks to adopt the par clearance system. Witnesses examinud today In cluded: H. A. Page. Jr., AberJeen; Leake S. Covington, Rockingham; J. Q. Sewsll and J. J, Jenkins, KIK'r City; J. C. Wescott, Bayboro. and others. Witnesses for the reserve bank will testify later. At a night session of Superior court, over which Judge James U Webb Is presiding, the plaintiff state banks concluded the presen tation of evidence. The reserve bank .will begin the Introduction of evidence tomorrow morning. GOES INTO NEXT WEEK Twenty Witnesses Ap pear Before Board, r Others Expected. NORFOLK, Vs.. Feb, if. Ths Investigation at Lang ley Field and at the army supply base to deter mine the cause of the Roma dis aster last Tuesday will . probably txtend into next week, according to announcement made tnolght, by Colonel Fisher, c h I e f of the llghter-than-alr service at Langley Held. t, . . Twenty or . more witnesses al ready have appeared before the board of Inquiry to give testimony lu regard to the catastrophe. It is anticipated that. Important testi mony bearing on the case will b given by Charles Dworack 'and Master Sergeant Harry , A. Chap man ss aeon as they are able to appear before the board. Mr. Dworack and Sergeant Chapman, two of the most seriously injured Hurvlvors, sre undsr treatment tor shock snd burns at the public health service hospital here. WhIK ths board ot inquiry has been In session, at post. headqUsr ters at lAngley field, frequent trips of inspection by officers of the station with other air service experts have been made to ths wreckage of the Roma at the army base, colonel Cardonl, Italian air expert, has returned to Wsshlng ton after making a thorough ex I. ruination of the ' wreck of the Roma, Me visited the scene of the dissster st the request of Msjor General Mason M. Pstrlck, chief rf the army air service. In order that he might be able to; throw tome light on the cause of the ;. , - . . . ji.iu.i colSn ,! 'llnLl r' th. Z.?:"' J':'1! Investigation now under way at Langley field, ths ruins of the Roma wllf not be moved from the npot where the . huge ' airship Blunged to her doom last Tuesday, causing the death of II men. PRESBYTERIANS IN STORMY, MEETING Edwin CnnistDenbHl Admission to - the Churtth. BObTO.V. Fen. Vt. At a stormy meeting of the Boston Presbytery, the ruling body of the Presbyterian det nomination for Greater Boston, ths First Presbyterian church of Brook line was removed from the nomina tion and Its sunoly usntor. Kdwtit Curtis, was denied admission to the Presbyterisn church aa a minister. The many charges against the -pastor Included allegations that he had on several occasions said grace frivolously and In one Instance Hap-, tlsed a dog immediately after offici ating st a funeral. The case hsd been the subject of seversl hearings before the Presbytery and the fact that several hundred members of ths Rrookllne church upheld tha pas tor led to the church Itself being re moved from the denomination at to day's session Officials of the church said tonight that further steps would be taken, possibly In tha civil courts. - To support - the charges . that Mr. Curtis ssld grace in a frivolous man ner, affidavits were presented from people who lived at the same board ing hottss as the pastor. On onn oc casion, it ss alleged, Mr. Curtis said; "O, Lord, w thank the for the salad." On another he said: "lard, we thank tbee- for French fried potatoes." A deposition by two women churrh members declared that after return ing with them from a funeral. Mr. Curtis became Interested In a dog at their home.-1 He took a gtass nf water, the deposition eiateil. and sprinkled some of the wmer on the dogs bead. TO CONSIDER ALABAMA OFFER ON MUSCLE SHOALS WASHINGTON, B'eb.- J7-- Py The Associated Press.) The Ford Oder for purchase and lease of the govern ment's war projected properties st Muscle Shoals, Ala., was temporarily side-tracked tndsy by the house mili tary commutes after almost threa weeks' continuous Investigation and the fvay was -f'tare'd to begin con sideratlon tomorrow of the rival pro posal for. the same properties sub mitted by the. Alabama Power com pany, . At the same time, Chairman Kahn said the committee hoped to dlspos by the end of the week of all hear ings on offers before It, including those from Mr. Ford, the Alabama Power company and Frederick E. Engstrum aim begin work next week on preparing a report for ths. house, reciting the. committee's opinions en tha various proposals It wilt havs studied.. 12 PAGES, TODAY Dollars i" DEFENDANTS All SHIR.GONTRftCTS Says Indictments Due ta Personal reelings 01 Attorney General,, INVOLVE DEALS ON . WAR-TIME CONTRACT. Allege Money, Obtained by Fraud From Emergen-, cy Fleet Corporation. WASH I N OTON. Fsb. IT.-r, Charles W. Morse, New York shlp-l builder, his three sons Ervln, Ben jamin and Harry Moras, and sight, others alleged to have been asso-, elated with him In connection with war-time shipping contracts were today Indicted by ths federal grand : jurv on charges of "oonsplracy to ... defraud", the United States and tne Emergency Fleet corporation. Those Indicted in addition to Morse and his son were;- , Colin It- Livingston, tormer president Vlrg Inta Shipbuilding corporation, and president ojC tha Boy Scouts of America. Ufcorge M. Burdetts, attorney fcrt thejvtorse interests, especially thej United States Transportation, inc.; Nehemiah II. Campbell, of New York., asslstsnt treasursr. United St a t s s Transportation company. Inc. Rupert -M, Much, Augusts, Maine, assistant treasurer. Vir ginia Shipbuilding corporation. - W. W. Scott, Washington, D. C, attorney for Virginia Shipbuildings corporation, Phfllp Relnhardt, auditor ; tor United States Fleet corporation at Alexandria, Va. Leonard 1. Christie,, treasure" Virginia Shipbuilding corporation, Robert O, Whits, assistant treas urer Oroton'Iron works and presi dent United States Transport com pany, inc. : ...v ... Two indictments were returned, both, covering Identical transac tions and accusing ths same per sons. Ons charges' a conspiracy in dsftaud the United States and th.i other .- conspiracy to"ommlt-sii offense against ths . United State by defrauding (ha Untied State shipping hoard. ( ' 1 TO RKQUIRK BO?fI ; OF TKW THOUSAND United States Attorney Peyton Gordon. It was stated, will require the defendants to, appear In thn District of Columbia Supreme couit for arraignment, when they can- ' be released ' under 60 bond In each case. , ' . In a statement issued .aftsr trt Indictments . were returned Mr: Morse charged thst "the indict ment, which Is terribly unjust, as wilt be proven later, I believe was secured because of personal feeling against me on the part of Attoi-r.ey-Ueneral Daugherty and cer lain present officials of the Unite ! States shipping board. Mr Morse's attorney, Wilton 0. Lambert, said t h a t Indictments against Mr. Morse snd his "associates would never; have been returned had they Seen permitted to appear before the grand jury" and that the de. iehdanta all would be promptly' .tcqultted as soon as the '"real and actual evidence" Is presented. , The 'contracts between- t h Emergency Fleet corporation snd the Uroton Iron workg and the Virginia Shipbuilding corporation r,n which the charges resulting in the Indictments were based, in volved an amount said to approxi mate 149,000,000. No estimate was made, however. In the Indictments of the full amount which the de fendants ars charged with having misappropriated and F 1 e t c her Uobyns, of Chicago, special assls-. tarti. to the attorney-general wh;i irokecuted the investigations fY the government, declined after the Indictments were returned, to n. jtlmsts the amount ot money out oi wmrn is alleged the United State, was defrauded, . but it was v understood the sums which ths government, alleged were misap. propi lated . amounted to several million dollars. . - The Indictments charged ths : fendants specifically with MlseW pretending to the shipping board and the fleet corporation that the -shipbuilding corporations they rep resented would be able to erscf snd equip from their own funds shipbuilding plants of sufficient . s'.ne to enable them to carry out " contracts given them by the fleet' corporation,-and to proceed wlth; out dlay to th construction of," test's. The Intention of the de '"n dan is. it was alleged was to ; obtain large sums of money from ; the fleet corporation by. falsely .. representing that ssid amount would be used for construction nf vessels and to divert large sums from the ship construction and divert and use the same for th, f rection of plants snd housing fa fllltes and thus convert the ftmrt v o the use of the shipbuilder cor. por.-rtlons and themselves and to delay ship construction. FAIXF.LY PRETF.NDF.T) .WOVEY TCK THEM The Indictments further . charrs that (he defendants falsely pretend-' ad that large sums of money were due from the fleet corporation as progress payments an.f obtained thev money when they "'weil knew It was not due." Hlmllar charges wars mad . that when the defanits represented that their corporations hsd Invested ' large smnunts in shipbuilding plants; and for that reason alleged the pUnts wto adequate security -for loans and ' advances, they "defrauded, all fh? time knowing in truth and in faet tha corporations would act have Invest In their said plants the large suras . attributed to them." , Larg quantities ef material ware, obtained from the fleet oorporatlno' by the defendants for the ooastrao-4 tlon of vessels and later, the indict-, ment charged, the defendant . sold great masses ef the material and con verted the proceeds of the sales "t the corporations snd themselves." i Ths name ot William F. McA1v. Charges Of Defraud U. S. CONNECTED IN y, but iney - IT i