The News - FOUR O'CLOCK EDITION. ESTABLISHED 1888. Special Message On Brownsville "Shoztin The President Transmits to the Senate the Report of H. J. Browne Who Has Investigated The Affair. All oi Co. B. Wete Invol ved And all Cos. C. and D. Knew the Guilty Par ties Conyers ' Confes- j sion. By Associated Press. Washington, D. C, Dec. 14. The president today sent to the senate a rather lengthy special message deal-! ing with the Brownsville affair. The principal portion of the message con-: r f ..,.f e nr.. u-w,. Msts oi the report of Mr. Herbert - . , , . .1. Browne, specially employed oy . the War Department to investigate the matter. Accompanying this are the following remarks from the presi-1 dent: To the Senate: 1 inclose herewith a letter from ...... vine iaiu. the secretary ot war transmitting a, The ligt of participants given in report of the investigation made by ! this report Conyers furnished me Mr. Herbert J. Brown-, employed by : personally. I belive it is substantial the department iu conjunction witn !y correct, but with the influences Capt. W. G. Baldwin to investigate shown to be backing Conyers to ad as far as possible what happened at here to his false testimony given be Brownsville on the loth and 14th o fore the senate committee still be August, 1906. The report and docu- i ing exerted lie can , not be relied ments contain some information of , on to support his own confession sreat value and some statements , that are obviously w-orthless, but 1 Mibmit them in their entirety. This report enables us to fix with tolerable definiteness at least some ,-:" the criminals who took the lead in the murderous shooting of private j citizens at Brownsville. It establish- t o clearly the fact that the colored .-oldiers did the shooting; but upon this point further record was un necessary, as the fact that the coi u:xl soldiers did the shooting has already been established beyond all possibility of doubt. The investiga liirn has not gone far enough to en able us to determine all the facts, i;nj we will proceed with it; but it has gone far enough to determine with sufficient accuracy certain facts of enough importance to make it ad visable that I place the report before you. It appears that almost all the members of Company B must have been actively concerned in the shooting, either to the extent of be ing participants or to the extent of virtually encouraging those w-ho were participants. As to Compan ies C and D, there can be no ques tion that practically every man in them must have had knowledge, that the shooting was done by some of the soldiers of B Troop, and possi bly by one or two others in one of the other troops. This concealment was itself a grave offense, which was greatly aggravated by their testifying before the senate committee that they were ignorant of what they must have known. Nevertheless, it is to be said in partial extenuation that ihey were probably cowed by threats, made by the rare desperate of the men who had actually been engaged in the shooting, as to what woi:. happen to any man who failed t project the wrongdoers. Moreover, there ;tre circumstances tending to show that these misguided men were encouraged by outsiders to persist in their course of concealment and denial. I feel, therefore, that the guilt of the men who, after the event, thuis shielded the perpetrators of the wrons by refusing to tell the truth about, them, though serious, was in pan due to the unwise and improper attitude of others, and that some measure of allowance should be made for the misconduct. In other words, I believe we can afford to reinstate any of these men who now truthfully led what has happened, give all the aid they can io fix the responsibility upon those who are really guilty, and 5diow that they themselves had no guilty knowledge beforehand and vei(; in no way implicated in the affair, save by having knowledge of afterwards and failing and refusing to f'ivulge it. Under, the circum stances, and in view of' the length of time they have been out of the ser vice, and their loss of the benefit that would have accrued to them by continuous long-time service, we can afford to treat the men who meet the requirements given above as having been sufficiently punished by the consequences they brought upon themselves when they rendered ne cessary the exercise of the disciplin ary power. I recommend that a law be passed allowing the secretary of war, within a fixed period of time, say a year, to reinstate any of these soldiers whom he, after careful effl a mi nation, finds to have been inno cent and whom he finds to have done all in his power to help bring to jus tice the guilty. . - Meanwhile the investigation will be continued. The results have made it obvious that only by carrying on the investigation as the war depart-', ment has actually carried it on is Mercer. there the slightest chance of bring- Elizabeth City district. J. H. Hall, ing the offenders to justice or of presiding elder; Elizabeth City, J. D. separating not the innocent, for there I Bundy ; Edenton, J. W. Pater; Hert were doubtless hardly any innocent, I ford, T. A. Sykes. Has the Largest Circulation of Arvy Afternoon Paper Published in the Two Carolina's nrwirin nT a -my it Ovrnwn n s cr -- Eld 9 9 the less guilty from those whose was heinous. THEODORE ROOSEVELT. The White House, Dec. 14, 1908. Browne's, Report. Mr. Browne's report covers between fiftteen and twenty pages and deals in detail with the facts that have thus far been made clear by the in vestigation. Possibly the most in teresting part of it concerns the alleged confession of one Boyd Con yers, late of Company B, 25th In fantry. In introducing this document Mr. Browne says: Ex-Private Boyd Conyers, of Com pany B, 25th Infantry, now at Mon roe, Ga., told William Law-son, a detctive in the employ of Capt. Win. G. Baldwin, of Roanoke, Va., that he and three (or four) other men of the 25th Infantry were the leaders in the Brownsville raid. This information was obtained at different dates dur ing the month of June, 1908. Conyers tried to commit suicide af ter he found that he had made his statements to a detctive, declaring that the other negroes would kill him when it got out. He finally wrote to , , Senator Fo raker and received a re- py That reply he eon- strued to mean that "he should stic-k to his original story told before the senate committee at all hazards, and iiifc'it: lie muuus. l nave cveij ica- son to believe that his confession is genuine and gives for the first time true ; secret history of the Browns- until it is morougniy sustained uvw other sources. Evidences of similar encourage ment to stick to the lies told at Brownsville' and before the senate committee were found in many places and subsequent to the date of the jruiaiver letiei luey ueuctiiie auuugci and more obstructive than ever. The investigation has been con ducted with strict recognition of the advisability of preserving secrecy, and with discretion. No promises of im munity were made. The knowldege on the part of the ex-soldiers that the government could not punish them after their separation from the service, coupled with the belief that by preserving silence they would aid in the passage of the relief legisla tion now pending in congress, has (Continued on page 4) Special to The News. Durham, Dec. 14. The sixth day's session of the Methodist Conference opened with religious service by F. H. V 'ood. The proceedings of Saturday and 'ry were read, a number of com--eports were read, and adopted. T. X. Ivv was re-elected editor of The Advocate, and addressed the confer ance, which adjourned at 1:45. Principal Appointments. The principal appointments- are: Raleigh district, II. B. John, presiding elder; Raleigh. Edenton Street, F. M. Shanoerger; Central, L- B. .Jones; Smithfield, .1. M. Culbreth; Louisburg, F. A. Bishop; Oxford, L. S. Mossey. Durham district, J. B. Hurley, presid ing elder; Durham, Trinity, G. T. Adams; Memorial, M. Bradshaw; Carr Church. J. A. Daily; Chapel Hill, W. R. Royal; Roxboro, J. A. Hornaday; Bur lington, E. M. Snipes. . FayeUeville district, J. T. Gibbs, pre siding elder; Fayetteville, L. E. Thompson: Pittsb'oro, Y. A. Royal; Carthage, H. M. Eure; Sauford, K. W. Bailey: Rockingham district. W. II. Moore presiding elder; Rockingham, J. E. Underwood; Aberdeen, D, N. Covins; Hamlet, H. A. Humble; Laurinburg, N. H. D. Wilson; Maxton, A. P. Tyer; Lumberton, E M. Hoyle. Wilmington (district, W". L. Cunning gim, presiding eider; Wilmington Grace, T. A. Smoat; Fifth Street, K. D. Halmes: Bladen Street, W. E. Hurst; Trinity, W. L. Rexford. Newbern district... R. F. Bumpas, presiding elder; Newbern, Centenary, R. C. Beamon; Goldsboro, St. Pauls, E. H. Davis; St. Johns, J. H. Frizzelle; Kinston, F. D. Dwindell; Morehead City, L. P. Howard; Beaufort, J. H. McCracken. Washington district, A. McCullen presiding elder; Washington, M. T. Plyers; Greenville.. J. H. Shoe. Tarhoro and Mission, R, H. Willis and Q. A. Terrell; Rocky Mount, D. H. Tuttle; Wilson, G. W. Smith. Warrenton district: W. S. Rone, pre siding elder; Warrenton, W- W. Ross; Henderson. R. C. Craven; Scotland Neck, C. OO. Jones; Weldon. S. E. g Un APPOINTMENTS MADE ST 1 E. CQNFERNGE HA THE ONLY EVENING ASSOCIATED CHARLOTTE, N? C, Special to The News. Wilson, Dec. 14. The last'of the del egates of the Baptist state convention left for their homes today. . Yesterday the pulpits of the city were occupied by prominent Baptist ministers. Dr. E. Y. Mullins of Louisville, Ky., preach ed at the Baptist church. The dele gates were loud in their praise of Pas tor Jenkins and the Wilson people. President Carlyle, whose wise adminis tration led the commtion through troublesome waters iraveral times, was warmly commended on all sides. In the closing business session Sat urday there was considerable work accomplished. The school question wes settled by the appointment of a secondary school board which shall have charge of the secondary denom inational schools. A memorial service was held in honor of the late Dr. W. R. Gwaltney, of Hickory. The follow ing were named as the Aged Minis ter's Relief Board for next years: J. F. McDuffie. W. C. Barrett, H. A. Fou shee. J. W. Downey, E. W. Triplett, R. H. Riggsbee, A. L. Phipps, W. J. Brok den, and J. M. Arnett. The president appointed the follow ing committees to report next year: J,avmen's Work J. L. White, F. D. Hale. J. H. Highsmith, T. S. Frank lin, R.- B. Horn. Systematic Giving L. Johnson, G. T. Lumpkin, J. A. Campbell, B. W. Spillman, Walters Durham. Baptist Young People's Union As sembly J. T. Watts, C. E. Maddry, M. A. W'ood. M. A. Adams, W. C. Barrett. Pastor's Conference T. J. Taylor, J. W. Wildman, S. L. Morgan, J. R. Doan, W. H. Reddish. . To write reports at the next session: Foreign Missions A. J. Moncriefs. Heme Missions, H. W. Battle. Or phanage, J. W. Lynch. Sunday schools, J. W. Bailey. Obituaries, T. T. Speight. State Missions, C. L. Greaves. Committee on Correspondence Course W. C- Tyree, 15. W. Spillman, W. R. Cullom, H. C. Moore, and L. Johnson. Committee on Advisability of a Home for Aged Ministers W. C. Bar rett, W. C. Tyree, M. L. Kesler, J. J. HaH and M. L. Kesler. The usual resolution expressing graf titude to the Wilson church and Wil son people, the railroads and news papers was adopted and the convention adjourned. - Tuskegee, Ala., Dec. 14. The first "health exhibition" ever devoted wholly to the welfare of negroes was opened today at the Tuskegee Nor mal and Industrial Institute and will continue through the 'week. A leading feature f the exhibitin is the traveling exhibit of the Na tional Association for the Study and Prevention ot Tuberculosis. An extensive program of illustrated addresses, platform meetings and con ferences will be conducted along the lines of the recent International Con gress on Tuberculosis at Washing ton. In addition to the medical sessions the program gives particular atten tion to the general topics discussed at Washington as they relate to the negro race. . "S, r"V2P"" (Leave Me E-noun J y AlfTB jjggrV Y TU BERG U LOS IS OPEHS TO Blf LLID u A PRESS NEWSPAPERON CHARLOTTE. MONDAY EVENING DECEMBER 14, 1908 A COMMON OCCURRENCE ON THE STREET Big Blaze at Cotton Gin Special to The News. Lexington, N. C, Decr 14. Nine bales of cotton were damaged by fire yesterday afternoon at the gin of J. W. Earnheai t ' at this place. Some thing over sixty bales were piled on a vacant let near the street and it is supposed the fire originated from a cigar or cigarette stump. The cotton is not badly damaged and it is fortu nate for it had been left there by dif ferent farmers and was not insured. Perhaps the worst damaged bale be longed to o. poor farmer and it was his entire crop. All of yesterday afternoon several firemen remained at the fire for fear J of it catching again, and in fact it did catch n second time after the fire had apparently been extinguished for about an hour. ' The office cf the clerk, of, the court has been crowded to-day Avith pension ers from the different sections of the county. Amount received in this county is $7,G46,000, and the pension ers are divided into the following classes: Fist class, 4 receiving $120 per year: second class, 3 receiving $60; third class, 7 receiving $4S; fourth class, 15S receiving $25; and 108 wid ows who receive $25. Since last year there h?s been one death in the sec ond class, one in the third, six in tne fourth and six widows. - Thomas Perryrnan. ex-counterfeiter and escaped jail-bird from Davie coun ty, is in the Davidson county jail awaiting the arrival of an officer from Bavie where he is wanted for an as sault. It is said that he is also wanted for several other offenses. Perryrnan says he sei-ved a term in the peniten tiary at Albany, New York, for coun terfeiting. The Woman's Betterment Associa tion, an organization which has as its object the improvement of the grounds around the graded school, has been formed among the teachers of the Lex ington school. Miss Victoria Byerly has been elected president; . Miss Edna McCrary, secretary; and Miss Anna Johnson, treasurer. The association will give a supper at the opera house on the night of the 18th. Special to The News. Spartanburg, S. C, Dec. 14. The law abiding citizens ot" this county and section are worked up over a- perfect wave of crime that, has prevailed dur ing the last few days. The record since Friday night is three homicides, one nnirdorous assault and robbery and one stabbing that is likelv to prove fatal. George Mintz, white, has been ar rested on the charge of knocking Mrs. Sallie Green, who lives at Campobello, in the head with an axe and robbing iier of S75. The old lady is not ex pected to live. Saturday night Dump Dorroli, col ored, shot and killed Jess Leak, also colored,' at Switzer. Dorroh was ar rested. Saturday night Griff Parks and p. colored roan named Kilgore be came involved In a quarrel in Laurens county, just across the Spartanburg line. Parks shot and idlled Kilgore. Two white men employed in con struction work on the Carolina-Clinch-field and. Ohio Road, fell out about some work and one man drew his knife and stabbed the other. The injured man is expected to die. 1 Last Saturday two white men em ployed at Leonard and Beckman's Camp on C. C. and O. road engaged in a' quarrel and one killed ttte other. - Mrs. Thomas, an aged lady, v of this city, while walking through "Spring street late Saturday evening after a shopping tour was struck down and robbed by negro, who made his escape. PERFECT IKE SPARTANBURG EVERY DAY. INS ON TRIAL F0R1R0ER0F E. ANNIS By Associated P-ess Flushing, .. Dec. 14. Confident of his acouittal Thornton Jenkins Hains was brought to trial here this afternoon on the charge of being an acessory to the murder of William E Annis. Manacled to a deputy sheriff Hains was brought from Long Island city to the court room, shortly after 1 p. m. Judge Crane began the trial Councel for Hains made a firm motion to set upside the indictment. Flushing, L. I., Dec. 14. Judge Crane overruled the motion-. Flushing, N. Y., Dec. 14 The trial of Thornton Jenkins Hains, author and seafarer, charged with "being an accessory to the murder of William E. Annis, who was shot and killed at Bay side Yacht Club last summer by Cap tain Peter C. Hains, Jr., commenced this aftei-non. Long before the hour of trial there was quite a gathering of people in front of the town hall where the case is being tried. General Peter C. Hains, U. S. A. retired, father of the brothers now confined ill Long Island jail for the Annis murder, and his son, Major Hains came up from New York City to attend the trial. All the wheels of legal machinery will be mt in mo tion to bring the trial of Thornton Hains to a speedy conclusion. Admiral Sperry Warmly Received at Colombo By Associated Press. Colombo, Ceylon, Dec. 14. Admiral Sperry landed from the battleship Connecticut this morning to pay an official visit to the Governor of Ceylon. The guard of honcri had been assem bled and there was a big crowd on the waterfront, composed of natives and Europeans. The admiral was cheered as he stepped ashore. The admiral with members of his staff, drove to the governor's residence. Later in the day the governor returned the call and wafs received on board the Con necticut with the usual salutes. Meet to Frame New Tariff Bill By Associated Press. Washington, D. C, Dec. 14.-Chair-man Payne, of the house -ways and means committee, said Chas. M. Schwab, the steel magnate, will appear before the committee tomorrow. He conies voluntarily. The Repub lican members of the committee met today to take the first steps toward the framing of a new tariff bill. Democrats will have no voice in the deliberations on this bill, but probably will submit a minority report. Claud Kitchin Appointed on Naval Affairs Com. By Associated Press. Washington, D. C-, Dec. 14. Speaker Cannon appointed Claude Kitchin, of North Carolina, to the vacancy on the naval affairs committee. , Lynching Narrowly Averted. By Associated Press. Danville, Ky., Dec. 14. A mob gath ered at Jamestown, Russell county, last night with the intention of lynching James Hill,- a white man, charged with murdering 13-year-old Mamie "Womack. Onlv the vigilance of the sheriff saved Hill's life. Cubberly .Nominated. By Associated Press. Washington, Dec. 14. The president sent to the senate the nomination of Fred C. Cubberly for United States at torney for the northern district of Flor; ida. 1 J W 3a Alleged Leaders of Night Rider Gang on Trial ILLE AFFAIR TAKEN UP IN SENATE Washington, Dec. 14. Senator For- aker introduced an amendment to the bill providing for re-enlisement of the negro troops disc'iarged because of al leged participation in the Brownsville affair and addressed the senate con cerning the amendment. He proposed in his new measure to establish a tri bunal consisting of retired army offi cers before which evidence may be submitted as to the guilt of the defen dants and before whom the defen dants themselves might appear to an swer charges. The measure practical ly takes out. of the hands of the exe cutive and gives to the tribunal s ap pointed" by congress full authority to consider the Brownsville question, and by its findings provides for the re enlistment of the discharged negroes. 'Senator Foraker said that he did not expect it would be necessary to enter upon a new investigation of the Brownsville question, but that during the summer letters had been coming to him from these discharged soldiers declaring the detectives were constant ly engaging them in conversation. "These men," said Senator Fora ker, "are not secret service detec tives of course, for they would have no right under the law to engage in such service." Continuing the senator spoke of the activities of the detectives as outlined by his correspondent, saying that in many cases they went so far as to take up their dealing with the discharged soldiers for the purpose of securing confidence ana spying upon their move ments. Upon the conclusion of Sen ator Foraker's remarks, the president's message on the Brownsville affair was read. After the reading of the presidet's message had beenr concluded the clerk read all of the statements and other evidence submitted to the war depart nint for which the president's mes sage was merely a letter of transmittal. This is contrary to the usual custom. In view of the fact that the report contains what purports to be a partial confession of guilt by one of the dis charged negro soldiers much interest was shown in the reading. Proof Looks Conclusive. In the words of the president evi dence he placed before the senate "establishes clearly the fact that coi-t ored soldiers did the .shooting, and makes it possible "to fix with toler able definiteness at least some of the criminals who took the lead" in dhe affray that resulted in the summary discharge without honor of the bat talion of the 25th Infantry, colored, which was stationed at Fort Brown. The . message is a report of an in-1 vestigation made by a detective, Her bert J. Browne, employed by the war department in conjunction with Cap tain W. C. Baldwin, to investigate the fact as to the" Brownsville case. The evidence secured by . Browne, as the president sees it, makes it ap pear "that almost all the members of Company B must have been ac tively concerned in the shooting, either to the extent of being partici pants or to the extent of virtually en couraging those that were partici pants." - In the evidence transmitted in the confession of Boyd Conyers, formerly private of Company - B, 25th Infantry, now at Monroe, Ga. Conyers, it is stated, has confessed that he was the leader of the raid and it is added has given the' names of John Hollman, John Browne, and Carolina De Sus sure as leaders, all of Company B. It further is declared that William Anderson, James Bailey, Charles E. Cooper, William Lemons, Henry Jim erson, James "Rastus" Johnson and' Henry Jones were with them. HANCOCK'S PLEA WILLPROBABLY BE Special to The News. Winston-Salem, N. C, Dec. 14 L. G. Hancock, accused of the embezzle ment of over $2,000 while manager of the Lamb Fish Box Company here, ar rested at San Francisco," arrived here last night in charge of two local offi cers who went after him. Hancock pleads ignorance to taking the money. He says he knew nothing about leav ing here and never realized what he was doing until he reached ' Honolulu when he immediately decided to return to America. -Hancock's mother has been here several days. She has em ployed able counsel to defend her son. It is understood the plea will be in sanity. Hancock led a fast life while here. NT FOUR O'CLOCK EDITION. J PRICE 5 CENTS The Charge Against the Men is Brutal Murder of Captain Quentin Ran kin Public Feeling is Well Divided. Union City Crowded With Inhabitants of Reel Fool Lake Section And State Troops Further Blood shed in Feared. By Associated Press. Union City, Tenn., Dec. 14. Late to day eight men, alleged leaders of the Night Rider band of Reel Foot Lake, will be placed on trial for their lives, charged with the putting to death of Captain Quentin Rankin, a prominent attorney of Trenton, Tenn., the culmi- ; nating act of a series of outlawry so high handed as to call forth the mus tering of militia to aid the civil au thorities in hunting down and the pros ecution of the members of the clan. By the end of the week the hearing promises to be well under way. Whether the court proceedure shall be conducted in order or whether fur ther bloodshed shall occur during the heat of the legal battle is considered uncertain From Reel Foot Lake and other" strongholds of the clan men are pour ing into Union City in numbers, with their sympathies going out to those of their friends on trial or held in jail, while the state has well organized its forces determined to put down any possible outbreak in its incipiency. As to public feeling, it is well di vided. ' Names of Men of Trial. The men placed on trial today, who when formerly arraignedv last week, declared themselveb not guilty, are Gar ret. Johnson, Sam Applewhite, Roy Ransom, Bud Morris, Fred Pinken, Ar thur Cloar, Lid Burton and Bob Huff man. 1 . . Venezuela Protests By Associated Press. . - Caracas, Venezuela, Friday, via Port of Spain, Trinidad, Dec. 14. Foreign Minister Paul today sent a note to members of the diplomatic corps, pro testing against "Repeated violations of territorial rights, of Venezuela" by the Dutch warships that have been cruis ing in Venezuelan waters. No blockade has been declared. It is set forth that the continual inter ference with coastwise shipping is hav ing a detrimental effect upon the com merce of neutral powers. In conclu sion the foreign minister says: 'Venezuela protests . with ' energy against these aggressions upon terri torial sovereignty of the republic and holds Holland responsible for all con sequences." Judge Garber Dead. Bv Associated Press. Berkeley, Cal., Dec. 14.Judge John Garber, well known in California and Nevada, as jurist and mining lawyer, died here from typhoid fever today. Judge Barber came to California in the early days from Virginia. - To Name Personnel of Cabinet. By Associated Press. New York, Dec. 14. President-elect Taft, who is spending several . days here prior to going to Augusta, Ga., for five weeks rest preceding his trip to the Panama Canal Zone, has an ncunced he does expect to be in posi tion to further outline the personnel of his cabinet during his stay ther. He is devoting some of his time pre paring speeches. Taken to Atlanta. By Associated Press. ( San Francisco, Dec. 14. Captain of Detectives Roberts of Atlanta, Ga., left here in charge of Elma Long, who is wanted in a Southern city for pawn ing a diamond ring which he did not own. Jail Delivery at Laurens, S. CI By Associated Press. Laurens, 8. C,. Bee, 14. A jail de livery occurred here today. Four ot the prisoners were recaptured within, two hours, and one is still at large this afternoon. The Accident Record of U. S. By Associated Press, v Washington, D. C Dec. 14. Be tween thirty and thirty-five thousand deaths and two million injured is the accident record in the United States during the past year among -working-men, according to a bulletin on acci dents issued to-day by the Bureau of Labor .