yiy
it i 1 1
VOL. l.MO.H.
ju'rrsisoi n. c; frida v, February -jr. vm
il.DJ A YfL?
VALET CONFESSES.
AMcsishin; Turn In the Now famous
Rice M order Trial
TILLS PABTICILARS CF Ml'KDEK.
Lawyer Patrick Dosed the A ted fill
lionclrs.and Finally Cblorotormed
;--". llira Vcath! "
New York, Spuria!. A very dram-
to point In the trial of Lawyer Albert
T. Ittrlrk lor the murder of the Texas
millionaire, William Marsh Rbe, was
sracbed Thursday afternoon. Chas. F,
Jonwth?ralrt. had twa relating the
ircumsUncea leading up to tbe some
what sudden death of Mr. Illce, in
"--A'ltmlr.--TlM!ji.. pulunglng at .once
Into the details. b held the attention
. ff bis sndieave to ttr end of his re-
iUl. Freed of luiaur points his story
"In August Patrick gew impatient
Mr. Itiee. though ua invalid, was liv
ing too long to suit thi lawyer's pur
! . Pa:rJ k sai l he uM come te
the boue and MSI him himself if Ueves
aary. - He sugared ' chloroform and
tone Mid he would get some. .The lira
of chloroform as a nn-ann was-suggea-jd
by a magazine arti 1. It w de
termined on after J .mi talked with a
physician wfc a person
heart, was affected, a was Mgf Rices.
-rn!4'ha nuwl easily killed with 1' and
ivu little irate of the drug would he
left. Join got a two-ounce vial of It
' by writfug to his brother !n Texay.
3.r-fm then branch-! off into tbe a!
lettated plan adopted to weaken the al
. legid plan adopted to weaken th al
tilsi mwury and iron pill. The puis
brought on dehlljtatirr diarrhoea
Then, unwittingly, a friend brought
Mr. Riee a present 'of banana. Of the
tf:i nd man ate nine. The fruit made
him exceedingtwy 111, and y the
weakening done of mercury were kept
ap. Hy Saturday, atw ut the l(?hth
day of ttio last IllneM.. Mr. Hire bv
flaw !elirotui. This ftfimony brought
the eects-:np to S'inday. the day of
fleatfh. and th wltn-tg ea!l that dur
ing thcae day of Uinr i he kept I'st
rlrk Informed of the dt!af'.8 ptrr&inaiUly
and by tIe5t?sone.
WilUftm Marsh IllreX lul(k death.
dwared the wltnc. wain decided on
t a conference b -tweMi I'atrick and
Jon held Saturday night. Jon- had
told Hie lawyer of the arrival" of a
draft fr l.5W. I'africk tJd him It
wit time to apply the chloroform, now
Out the draft had r nn and that l"ap
t&un Biker wan coming, or they would
sr?e all. Joii'w agreed.
Jon here told his irtory of the a--
tt killliif. He made a nme of a tow
1 la the, amatr end of which wait a
chloroforin-noaked ponipe. t'reepinjf
Into the room where Mr vili lay
.!eei4n(. he quickly covnre the aleep
er' face with the larne end or the 'cone
Jons rushed out of the m:im. In half
an hour he came back. He removed
the cone.- Mr. Klce was deal. Jnmi
wore he telephoned to Patrick the
word.: "Mr. Hire Is very 111." the'
vjrr-d slfrnal tHnwreii the two of
dtath. Jones' story of the end was in
cluded by the statement that Patrick'
came to the house nd removed, all of
Mr. rtit'o's papers..
'Some time In AiiKwt," Jones
In the course of bis narrative, " Pairi.-::
sk(d me if I did nut think Mr. nice.
, wo living too I'm for our w-rdfafn. H.
tboiiKbt It w.-Kilil be a good thirn; if we'
oi:ld put hhn out of the way. He s d
if J'dt?ll him wme nlulit when Mr.
like t;nn sJcopiu? (fnindly, he'd io:'n
;p find do It. If I would not."
"What wan Baid of chloroform?"
sLer Attorney 0lorne.
Patrick, said that would be an eisy
M".y to put Mr, Klce away. An artii !
In a msfiazSne Kave him. th- Idea.
K.:''tTK'tlli(iS Vi! Fall! nbout cottinz
h'.o.ofonii. ond Patrb k' nalrNBt was
- very narti to get: tlvit One ha l to navS
nil Porta of ceitWk'ajea before the drtiK-
r.t would sell it. 1 told Patrick be
xouui leave that to me. I sent mr
br'Hhcr $3 and he st rit. tue cUlorf.irm
In a four-ounce liottle. Patrl.k sail
be bad often wondered about what
E'M'U!?. he-.cfT.vt of sMorMMm jxr &
person n.lTllcte.1 with heart trouble. I
put the -question to !r. Curry, and be
w-ld-no little chloroform would be
ncj-drd to kill a pernon wh ba.l heart
.disease; that It 'was doubtful If ny
traces of the pnlmn would remain nf
ter death. I told Patrick what l)r
Curry bnrl sald.'
Secretary Long to Retire.
Washington, Rpeeial.Now that the
Schley matter has been settled ofti
einlly, it is understood that Secretary
l-ong feels that he la at liberty to car
ry out the project cherished by him
In the laRt yeap of President MrKIn
ley's administration and retire to pri
vate life. However, this Is not expected
to ensue at once, for (here l.s no certain
knowledge of what may follow In Con
gress, notwithstanding a strong belief
by (he administration .that-the c
Is settled beyond revival.-Therefore, it
is understood the change In the, cabi
net circle will not take place before tbe
adjournment of the present session of
'Congress and perhops not until next
fall. "
Carriage Factory Wrecked!
Vuidosta, 3a., Spec.!al.--Dui'lng'ft ter
rttic wind storm here Thursday morn
ing, the carriage factory of the Robert-Cranford-Thu'her,
Company, was wreck
ed. The building fell 15 mlnutffl before
the employes were duo ta begin tnelr
day's work. The low to (he company
Is 10,01)0. No funher damago than
bwlo trees nd fonces (leetroyed has
been reported. .
DEATH CF GEN. TOON.
Stat 5uperiUndat of Public In
- tructlon Passes Away.
( -Raleigh, Special. The people ner
were shocked at the news of the death
of Gen. Thomas F. Toon. State Super
intendent of Public Instruction, which
occurred Wednesday1 tutmlnf after 10
o'clock at his hoace here. ila was
thought to tie entirely- well, and
thouitb be had not ben lu bis offlc
Bltce be Kft Norember 20th to to to
northeastern Nurth Carolina. b bad
for everal days bef n consulted about
business and was In fine spirits Tues
day and Wednesday. He felt well at
breakfast, but afterwards complained
of acut indigestion. A pbyticlau u
bent for and v-'ry responded, in a
few minutes Gen. Toon aid be felt all
right. He (.aid be would ! down a
linJu while.
The moment be. di l.so
hifc face became purpie and death cam
like a flash..
The news came like a thunderclap to
the Ftate olScUIa, who hastened to his
home.. The Council cf Sta' met and
adopted the following resolutions:
"Ketiolved, That in the dtaiii cfjGen.
TJKmas' VentrteSi Too a. la.'&LV r-'
tendent of I'ubbc Intruetion.,i(reVilui
associates in the Executive Department
of the State government, bave lost a
wifie and faithful counsellor and friend
and the Sta'.s one of her tnoel careful
loyal in peaoe. b!s herijit.r'sptriv" at
rest and North Carolina mourns tbe
loss of a Bul-le eoa.
"Kesolred. That we tender the rela
titcs of the deceased our deepest eyxn
pathy. iu their great affliction.
"Resoived, Ttkit a copy of these .rea
lutiocs be sent to tbe family tuid aow
be seiead uprjn the minutes ot '-las
tVuneil of State."
Th flags. State and national, on ths
cspttol were placed at half-taff, and
the building was closed. At 2 oVlotk
Just before the Supreme Court fended
its business ftr tbe day. Attorney Gen
eral Gilmer made otfloial announce
ment of the (jwth and the ciur: ad
journed as a mark of 'respect.
Gen. Ton waa born in Columbus
county, June Vi, l4it. He graduated at
Wake Forest College in IMii with, very
high honors. He enl'.eUd as a private
in Company K. Twentieth Heglment,
North Carolina Troops, and was a col
onel before he was 23 ysars old. He
was' la 1S63 appointed under a special
a. :t of Congress a temporal y brigjdfer
general, and commanded Johnsons
Hrlgadc for many months, while John
son was recovering from wounds. He1
wo then re-comm!ss!oned as colonel
and resumed the command of his old
regjment. He was wounded five time
He gave your correspondent two bul-
icui exiractea rrom him. After the
wsr be was q the service of the At
lantic Co(ut Line IS years, then took
charge of Fair Uluff Academy. In 1867
he married Miss Carrie Smith, who is
burled at Fair Uluff. Five children
survive him. these being Mrs. Olivia
KoVland. of Hrodie, Warren, countv;.
Mrs. Mary Fuller, and Miss hobble
Toon, of Lumlerton; ,-T. F. . Toon, -Of
Atlanta, Oa., and 11: U. Toon, of Lynch
burg, S. C. Itoth of the latter are in the
railroad service. He leave two broth
ers. Archie Toon and Abraham Toon,
of Wbiteyllle. and a half-brother. Don
ald McCrarken, of Whiteville. He rep
resented Columbus county in the lower
House of the' Legislature and KoIhm m
and Columbus in the Senate. In l.v.tl be
married Mrs. It. C. Ward, who survives
him. He made l.umbcrton his home ;in1
devoted himself to teaching and fdrm
ing.'Wtth hlc nomination for the office
of State Superintendent and bin career
therein all are familiar: He wis n
likable 'man. In all roKe-w an,i ,i. i
voted to his work and tt the bet in-!
terests of North CaroKnn If t ..a, ... I
known .where Ti will l, huKln it -i. f
' l'"' " '. IV
.1. l . .
ucaire mai ne riihii lie nurieii here.
Three m on ths ago General Toon left
here to go with Governor Aycock in r.n
educational trlpto the northeastern
countries. He told his assistsnf. Capt.
r'ucKeii, inat ne ureaucq the trip anil
wished lie could get out of going. Ho
was restless and seemed to fear trouble
He paid afterwards he dvik cold al
Wilmington, while sitting in a draft
after speaking.
At n meeting held In the executive
'office the following resolution wai
unanimously adopted: "llesolved. That
the Governor and bis Council respect
fully request that the remains of Gen
eral Tooii be laid In state In the rotun
da of the capltol pending the arrange
ments for funarel. obsequies." A fur
ther resolution was adopted requestine
the Governor to communicate the ac
tion of the Council through Capt. John
Duckett to relatives. The body will ii,(
lie in statu, as Mrs. Toon desires that
It nil a In nt (he house until the gen
eral's children nnive.
Liberals Condemn Surrender.
London, By Cable. At. thev annual
meeting of the general committee ol
the National Uberal Federation held
at Leicester, after considerable debate,
n resolution was passed condemning
the policy of .insisting on the uncondi
tional surrender of the Boers In South
Africa! nkVntlng (he future eoui'uit
nunt and security of South Africa
Could only be secured by regular pence,
on broad, generous' lines;'- - welcoming
the impetus lrd Rosebery has given
to, this policy asd calling on all Libera!
members of the llous-of Commons to
support the Liberal leader. Sir Henry
Canipbell-Bsnnevnian, .in his advocacy
of th policy, -
UPHOLDS VERDICT
President Sustains findings of Tbe
.Naval Court of Icqui-y.
EE CRITICISES BQTil ALMI2ALS.
Caasures Schley For HI -Retrotrada
Movement" and Sampson For Be
lag Absent.
WashlnEton. 'SDecial. The men
arandum of the" President upoa the
appeal of Admiral Schley from the ver
dict U tte court of inquiry to'exaailae
into bis conduct during the Spai.ish
Ainerican war, was fcivcu 10 tuc pitaa
Wednesday, it ,
"I have 'received th a;jH al of Ad
miral ikhley and the a:.fcwtr UW-relo
from the Navy lepai tnnuu i have ex
amined both w ith tae uUiibiit t art, a
vsll as the preceJitg appeal to the
Secretary Of the Navy, i have nad
through -all the u-stiuiony takt'n beiore
the court and the staietueuui. of the
couakti for Admirals ampauu and
bchiey, have eiaiui&ed all ute 'official
Santiago naval caaiiga .copies
of the logbooks and signal books, and
the testimony before tbe Court of
Claims, and have also personally bad,
before me-the four surviving captain;
of the two admirals, which were ac
tively engagea at eauuago.
"It appears that tbe court of in
quiry was unanimous in its findings of
(act and unanimous in its expressions
of opinion on mot of its findings of
fact 'No appeal is male to me from
the verdict o ftbe court on tbete points
where it was uuanlmous. I rave, bow
aver, gone carefully over the evidence
on these points also. I am satisfied
that on the whole the court did sub
stantial Justice. It should have specifi
cally condemned the failure to enforce
an efficient night blockade at Santiago
while Admiral Schley was in com
mand. On the other hand. I, feel thai
there is a reasonable doubt whether
be did. not move bis squadron with
sufficient expedition from port to port.
fr i. . i .... i . f n .. 1 . 4. ,1
JU -uu.ji.aUim...,u.u,
miral bchley action on tbo point
where, it seems to me be most gravely
rred;; his 'retrograde movement
when be abandoned 1 the blockade, and
hla iliKotiPiiienc cf orders and mite I
Statement oi tacts in relation meieio.
It should be remembered, however,
that the majority of these actioms
which the court censures occurred
live weeks or more before ths fight
Itself; and it certainly seems that if
Admiral Schley's actions : were cen
surable he shoulj not have been left
as secodd in command under Admiral
Sampson. His offenses were in effect
condoned when be was not called to
account for them. Admiral Sampson,
after tbe fight In an official letter to
the Department, alluded for the first
time to' Admiral Schley's reprcsensibla
conduct six weeks previously. If Ad-
mtral Schley was guilty of rcprehensi-
ble conduct of a kind which called for
such notice, froni .Admiral Sampson,
then Admiral Sampson ought, not to
have left him as senior officer of the
blockading squadron on the Zt of
July, when he, . .(.Sampson i , steamei
away on bis proper errand of com
munication w-ith General Shafter.
"We can. therefore, for' our, present
purposes dismiss consideration of so
much of the appeal as related to any
thing except the battle. As regards
this, the point raited .in the appeal is
between Admiral Pair.pson and A1
mlrnl Schley, as to which was In com
mand, ami as to which was entitled
to the credit, if either of then) was
really entitled to any unusual-and pre
eminent rreuu oy ny special ranw
lion oi genius, sum. una e-ourage. i i.e-j
court e-ould have considered both of
,n,'so 1"eKtlons. but ius a matter of
fact It unanimously excluded evidence
offered
upon them, and through Its
president announced lis refusal to
hear Admiral Sampson's side at all;
and. in vlew'of such exclusion the ma-.
Jorlty of the court acted with entire
propriety in not expressing anv opin-
(on on theae polnta. The matter has.
-. howeveLJecn ralsedby the president
of the court. Mrutl ver. It Is the point
upon which Admiral Schlev in his ap
peal lavs rnost stress, "and which he
especially nsks me to consider. I
haw therefore earefnllv investigated
this matter also, and have informed
myself upon it from (be best sources
ef Information at my command,'
"Tbe appeal ot Aonnrar etcniey to
me Is not, as to this, the chief-point
be raises, really an appital from the
detclsion of the court of inquiry. Fives
stxtdis of the appeal is devoted to this
question of command and credit; that
is, to matter which the court of In
qulry dU not consider. It is in effect
an appeal from the action of President
McKlnley three vicars ago, when- ho
.sent In the recommendations for pro
motion wiin mo Santiago squadron;
basing these recommendations upon
his estimate of the credit to which
the officers werv respectively entitled.
What 1 have to docl.lo, therefore, is
.whether or not President McKiuloy
did In just too i the matter. This neces
sarily involve s u comparison of -the uc
tions of the different commanders en
gaged. The exhaustive official reports
of the action leave, little to bo brougi.t
out anew; but ns the question of Ad
miral Sampson's right to be considered
In chief command, which" was deter
mined lt bin favor by President Mc-j
Klnb-y, and later by the : Court of
CminiM. has never hitherto leen o:ll
clally raised, I deemed It best to sev
curo statements "of the conimnndors of
the, five ships (other than ttje Brook
lyn and New ".York, th? flagships e.f
the two admirals) which were actively
cnimgcd In tho fight."
The President thoa quotca from a
' '.' '' "4 - ...', -. gj '...,,
magazine' article written by the late
Admlrtil Philip and tbe statement by
... 1 1 . ..... . A : i
Taylor and Commander Wainwright
and review s the damajte to the BpanttiU
ship by tlw (runs of the American flct
and continues:
"From the statements of the cap
tains above, from the official reports,
and from the testimony .before th
court of Inquiry, the fight tan be
plotted wttb absolute certainty la its
Important outline, though thefe is
conflict as to minor pOinta. When the
four Spanish cruisers came out of the
b arbor the New Tork bad left tuer posi
tion in in ciockading line 40 or 45
mlnutaa before. She bad hoisted tbe
signal Tls regard tbe movements - of
the commander Ic-cbief." but had not
hoisted the signal to the second In
fcommand to take chojfge. which.
as
appeal' by the signal book, was some
times but not always-used when the
command was transferred. As soon as
the engagement began the New York,
turned and steamed back hoisting a;
signal to close tn, which , however,
none of the squadron saw. She was
in plain sight, and not vary much
farther from the easternmost blockad
ing ships than the latter were from the
Brooklyn, which was the westernmost
of the line. As soon as the Spanish
shine appeared the five big Aruricn
llockaders started toward them la ac
tordauce with the standing-' orders of
l-dmlral Sampson. After this lirst
iioe each 'acted purely ou bis cwj.
nitiatire. 'For some minutes the
Spanish and" American vessels stead
ly appioacbed one another, aiid the
Iribtiiig was at the hottest. Then the
il ready damaged Spanish i.hip.4 turned
io tbe westward, while at tbe anie
-inin'tho uesifrn most American ves
ttd, the HriKiklyn, which was nearest
Uie Sjiantfch line, turned tu the east
sard, makiitg a loop or three-quarter
.'irele, at the end of which she agaiu
leaded westward, farther off from
ind farther behind the Spanish ves
W'ls than before-the loop had begun,
JUl fatlll a-lca.i 01 ikU ol tilt, j.lilrxicuM
'Cftseis, aanougu laitbcr ouUiue. itio
lexas, the next ship to the ilrooklyu,
Jltlier Wiia ur touccivtd berseii io Lo
)ui iu'kucu jeopardy by tus lirouklyu a
:um toward tier t.ai she backed nc-r
:ugnes, coming ua..o.st or quite to a
luudotil); ho i but both tbe uresoa,
ind the Iowa, wn.ch were origiuiiUy1
io the, eastward cf her, passed her.
in J it was isouie lici-- aitc-c hiu agum
la; ted bctiue she" regained iier loim-
' n posiuou relatively to tbe Spau.bu
. u.b .t.u Th(J Slani8h vS8t.ls aad
Lfra! htt,aoi out ,n t.ululJlu lor lht
j ,c.bl tto CoIon , of ,n-
aUlerg .Md graauailv torgiIls ahead of
them without suiiering much damage.
rhtt foP.l!. h.mt uhi.-h had tot
j 4owc, tnem out of tbw harbor wera
. A(,sLr,,VtH, t,v tha nre of ,h, nour.
ti-OHt of tin. Anierirn iitrr vessels and
af the .(Jlouctjiier, which headed
straight. in for them, paylngno more
heed to their quick-fire guns than to
the heavy artillery of the forts, to
which she waa alaq exposed. .
"In the running flght which followed
until the Teresa, . Oquendo and .Vis
'.aya were destroyed, the Indiana
gradually dropped behind, although
ihe continued to Are until the lat d
the three vessels went ashore. The
Brooklyn was ahead of any of tbe
j otlu,r Amerlcan vessels on a course
outside theirs; she was nearly broad
ide on to the Spaniards. The Oregon,
'.owa sjid Texas were all close together
and actively engaged throughout this
running flcht. The Brooklyn 'and Ore
gon, .followed at some distance by the
Texas, then continued in the chase of
the Colon, which wnt nearly thirty
miles farther before (ihe also went
; ahore. During, this chase of the Colon
ltwir u-no ir: itii 1 1 v-, nn fiirtitintr. ..
j -These' are' tbo facta as sot forth
,. ,n Kta,eWnf of the can-
tains, and ebs-'where in their ntTicial
reports and. testimony. They leave ns
room for doubt i,n any important
point. ,'
The question of command Is It)
-,hIs rfts noralnaj. anii technical. Ad-
,,, , Sainton's shin, tbe New York
was seen at the outset of the lU'ht
from all the other ships ox(cpt tiio
Brooklyn. Four of these five shin cap
tans have testified tliafhey .regarded
him as present and In command. He
signaled 'Close In' to the tlee't' as soon
ns' , the first Spanish shlj) appeared
but bis signal was. notSeen bv any
American vessel. He was actually un
der fire from the forts, anil himself
fired a couple of -bhots, af (ho 4-Iose oi
the action with tho torpedo boats, in
addition to signaling tho Indiana Just
at the close' of the action. Hut during
the action not a single order from hit.n
was received by any of the ships that
were actively engaged. -
"Admiral Schley at the outset ol
the actjon hoisted tho two signals rI
'Clear ship' and 'Close in,' which was
simply carrying out the standing or
tiers of Admiral Sampson as to what
Should be done 'If the enemy's shipl
attempted to break. .out of tho harbor
Fntil after the close eif the; first Pen
tion of .the; fight at the mouth of tht
harbor, and until after he had tuad
his loop and the Spanish ships went
fleeing to tho westward, not nnotbei
American thlp noticed a signal from
him. When tho western pursuit , had b
gun the Oregon, find the Oregon only,
noticed and repeated one of bis slgnali
of command. ''be captain of tho Ore
gon then regarded him ns in com
mand. ...but did not in any shape or wav
execute any movement or any action
of any kind whatsoever In nccordanc
with any orcle'r from him. ' -
"in short, the question as to wbbb
of, tho two awn) Admiral Sampson oi
Admiral Scbl'ey, w us lit. tho time lu
command, la f merely ' nominal- char
acter. Technically Sampson com.
muuded the fleet, and Schley, aa usual,
tho western division. Tbo actual fact i
the important fact, is that after tlA
battle was Joined not a helm wai
glutted, -not a gun was fired; not -a
pound of steam, was put on in the i n
glne reoia abroad any ship aetivelj
engaged, in obedience to tho order ol
cither SampKen or Schley, ,savo os
tbelr own two vessels, rt was a cap
tain's fight
"Therefore the credit to which eacfc
of the two is entitled rests ou matter
apart from the claim of uorminai
command over the squadron; for -t
far as the actual fight was concerned
neither one nor tbe other In fact ex
erclsed any command. Sampson - was
hardly more than technically in th
fight. His reap claim for credit upo
his work as commander-in-chief; upoi
the excellency of the blockade; upoi
the preparedness of the squadron;
upon the-arrangement of the shipt
head-on In a 'seml-cirlce around vlh
harbor; and the standing orders it
accordance with which they instantlj
moved to the attack of the Spaniard!
when the latter appeared. For all thes
things the credit -is his.
"Admiral Schley Is rightly entitled
as is Captain Cook to the crelit ol
what the Brooklyn did In the fight. Oi
Ih whole she did well; but 1 agn
with the unanimous finding of tin
three admirals who composed tin
court of Inquiry as to the loop.' It
seriously marred the Brooklyn's other
wise excellent record, being in facl
the one gravv mistake mado by any
American ship that day. Had th
Ilrooklyu turned to the westward, thai
la, la the' same direction that th
Spanish ships wre goaig, insuii oi
In tbe contrary direction, she weuk
undoubtedly have been in more 'dan
gerous proximity' to them. But v'
would have been more dangerous Tor
them as well as for her! This kind ol
danger must not be too uicelj
weighed by those wtioe trade it ll
to dare greatly for the honor of tht
flag. Moreover the' danger was cor
tainly twt as great, as that whir h. it
thn rlf-(cini miiment menaced Wain
rright's fraglls craft as he drove for
w ard against vthe, foe. It was not :
my Judgment as. great as the dangei
to which the Texas was exposed bj
the turn as actually made. It ccflair.lt
caused bo'.h the Brtxiklyn ind th
Texas -niaterialry to lose position com
pared to the fleeing Spanish vessels
But after the loop had once been takec
Admiral Schley hidled tbe Hrooklvi
manfully and well. Sho and the Or
pon were henceforth and headmost
tho Anvcrfcan vessels though the
Iowa certainly, and seemingly the
Texas also did as much iu hamnierini
to a standstill tb Viscaya. Oqueudo
and Teresa while the Indiana did al.
her eastward position - and chipped'
,, Mnr r.i..r, i .i... i, . i
the Colon the Brooklyn and Oregor
hare the credit between them.
"I'nder such circumstances It seems
trr.me that the recommendations, of
Priidnt MeKtwler.- we emlnentLv
oper, and that so far as Admiral
Sampson and Schley were concerned it
S'obld have been unjust for him to
have made other recommendations.
Personally I feel that in view of Cap
tain Clark's long voyage In the Oregon
nd the condition in which he brought
her to the scene of service, as well as
Ihe way in which he actually managed
ier before and during the fight, it
would have been well to have given
i!m the same advancement that waa
tiven . Walnwrlght. But waiving this,
t is evident that Walnwrlght was en
iitled to receive more than any of Ihe
flier commanders; and that ,. it was
uet .to Admiral Sampson that htf
ihould receive a greater advanc e in
lumbers than Admiral Schley there
was nothing dope In the battle that
warranted any unusual reward for ei
ther. In short, as regards Admirals
Sampson and Schley, 1 find that Presi
l"nt McKlnley did substantial justice,
nd that there would be no warrant
for reversing his action.
"Both .Admiral Sampson' and Ad
iiiral Schley are now on the retired
list. In concluding their report tbo
iK-iiibers of the court of inquiry. Ad
miral Dewey 'Benham ;.:'. 1 Knmsay,
tinlte in stating that they recommend
Miat no' further action be bad' in' the
matter. With this recommendation I
most heartily con. -nr. Them is no. ex
tus'e wliarever from- either side for any
further agitation of this unhappy con
troversy. To beep It alive would mer'.dy
do. damage to tho navy and to tha
ountry." . ' '
, kriuftvr Ally Come.
i), -,i--ri;r: it-,- cable.-It. - Is said in
tu-er eire-Us jhat if. Messrs. Wlltnarans
'Mid -W.cM.cLi.,. after Investigating the
"tiuipi n in- the. I'ni.ted States, advise
S'.r. KruRi r tii it a todV e.f tin? I'nited
St.?ti. would be beneficial to the Boer
cause. lh.-' Ile-cr "President w-IU over
ccni'i. bis aversion' to a long trip and
fiVid"i"!rtke-t?u Journey. Mr.- Kruger.ls
in excellent physical condition, and
his physicians advise him that he
cf-uld's ifely go f.-j America at the prop-r..-Tse-.i.
Messrt. Wolmarans and
Wessels will spend a raouth In tha
Fulled tStares.
i . . - ' . "'..'
Government For Philippines.
Washington, Special. Senator B
e'on gave notice of his intention" to
offe? an amendment to the PhlHppino
tariff bill, declaring It to be the inten
tion of the United .States when order
shalY'be restored in tlio Philippines, to
allow tbe format-ion of a government
for and by the Philippine people and
to ftiuirruifee to them the same liberty
rind imio.pc ridctice that this country has
plalgcd to the Cuban- people.,-'
Dentists in Atlniita.
Atlanta,, Special.The Southern
branch of the National Dental Associa
tion met here la annual convention.
The attendance. Is large. During the
day a number of papers of interest to
tho profession were read and the pres
ident's address was listened to. Officers
will be elected Friday.
"''' , . -
HAD A FREE FIGHT U
Tillman cnJ McLau in Come to Blows
- la the Senate Chamber, ,
BOTH SUSPENDED FOR CONTEMPT.
Sensational Development In the Old
Controversy Between the Senior
nd Junior Senator From S. C
Washington. Spoei:. Washing
ton's birthday was ai'&naliaed Sa the
I'mted Stat"S Senate by a "11 fight. .
The two Senators fro.n Souiu Caro
lina wrt-e the active participants in the
affray. Mr. Tiliniaur iu t-iio course of a
rpeech upon ths Philippine tariff, made
serious reflections up u: the honor of
bU colleague,' M". .Mcl.aurii. In. brief
he charged that Mr. M. i.iurln's vote in
supiirt of t"he ratification of the treaty
of Paiis ba,i 'been cast through the air
of iiutrojcr influences.
His 'stat men: was developed in a
colli.Mjuy bet wet u him and Mr. Spooner
of Wisconsin. Mr. Tillman at first
declined to mention r.aiuea, but ythea
the Wisconsin Senator reminded hitn
that he owed it to himself, to the Sen
ate' and. to the country "to name tho
man." Mr. Tillman indicated that he
leinrr-J tu
Carolina. Little imagining that hla
words were l.lxely to be prohetie, Mr.
Spoontr remarked, sentenilously; "'t..
will leave the Senator to fighf that out
with his eotleague.'
Mr. MeUuirin was not In the cham
ber at the time, being engaged in com
mittee work; 'but lie waa sent for and '
I appeared Just as Mr. Tillman concluded
his speech.
Pale as ashes, Mr. Mctaurin rose to
address the S- tiate. speaking to a ques- ;
tion of persomil 'privilege. He reviewed
Mi- Till...an- . ..,, t..,. l.lAflv anit than V
, , . . , , u.
dencunced the statement made by b
colleague as "a wilful and deliberate
lie.'
Se'arcely badthe words fallen from
his lips wnem Mr. Tillman, sitting a
few seats from. him. w ith Mr.-Teller of
Colorado between them, sprang at him.
Mr. MeLaurin,-who had half turned
towards Mr. Tillman, met him half
way. and in an instant the two Sena
tors, having swept Mr. Teller aside,
were engaged in a rough and tumble
fist fight. Mr. Melnrln received a
heavy blow ou the forehead, whlk. Mr.
Tillman got a bad punch on the nose.,
which brought blood.
Assistant Sergeaut-at-Arm.s . Layton
Strang over desks to reach and separ
ate the combatants and himself re
calved several blows. He got between
them finally and by main strength
wrenched them apart.
Senators Warren of .Vyoming anil
Scott of West Virginia, two of the most
powerful men in the Senate, leaped to
hi.s assistance arid, pinioning the arms
3f th belligerent Senators, forced them,
into their s-ats.
Intense excitement prevailed In tht
Senate and in the galleries, which wefe.J
irr-ngca with people who had been at
tr; d by the spirited debate. Every
body was on his feet. Not. a word, how
ever, was spoken. Senators stood aoont
the chumbi r, for the mordent quite
helpless apd pale to the lips. Finally
order wa restored partially, and in
-the midst of intese excitement the
Senate went into secret legislative ses
sion. For two hours the Senate discussed
the event b-hlnd closed doors. 'When
the doors w,cre reopened it was mqdt
known that both of tho South 'Caro
lina Senators by unanimous vote had
been declared to be in contempt of the
Senate. They were permitted, by a
vote of the Senate, to make apologies
to the Senate. The statements wer
listened to by both the Senators and
tho pec-pie m the galleries with breath
le.'s interest. - -
Senator. Tillman left the capltol
when eidjou'ninient was taken for re
cess and did not return for the night
session. Senator4McLaurln was in the
chamber about 8 o'clock, but left early.
Neither Senator, when seen at his
homo, would make a statement.
The Pope's Anniversary.
Rome, By Cable. The Pope Thurs
day entered on the twenty-fifth year
of his pontificate. Although the main
celebration of ths jubilea is postponed
until March 3rd, when tha combined
festival. of the Jubilee and coronation
will ha observed. The day was marked
by the singing of a te deum in St
Peter's, and other observances,, :Tha
font iff was (he-recipient of congratu
iatlons from all sides.
Arrival of Prince Henry.
..New York, .Spociai.--Prince Henrj
of Prussia, . tepresentatlve of : bl
brother, the Emperor, of Germany, at
.the launching" of ' the hitter's Amerl
eanbiiilt Aiu-ht, reached New York
Sunday, un l was cordially welcomed
as a guest of "the' nation. The land
cat teries that - guard the antcr harbp.
fired salutes of 21 gnus; tho rifles l
u f in cuii me Mumirai ussem'.HcJ
In his honor re-echoed the' sentiment;
there were verbal greetings from t!w
representatives 'of President Roose
veil, the army, the navy and the city
ef.Xow York, and a "great crowd
J4ed tbo way in the, city to see th
German sailors and the Prince of Go
many.