4 THE SUB-TREASURY BILL. Dr. Beall's Reply to " United Action." Lenoir, N. C., Aug., '90. Mb. Editor: Your correspondent, " United Action," in The Progressive Farmer of August 12th, starts out as if he was raally a seeker after truth. He says, "he would like to ask his brothers of Caldwell, county some questions for information." But be fore he writes hilf a doz9n sentences he reveals the fact that his real object is not to get "information," but to ridicule, criticize and find fault with the action of the Caldwell County Al liance in rejectfng the " Sab-Treasury bill," and for putting forth a plan which they believed to be more prac ticable, more conservative, and broad enough for all classes, who suffer equally with the farmer, and from the same cause, to stand upon and fight a common cause. If you will give me space, Mr. Editor, and I fael sure your cou-tesy will not deny me," I will answer, as briefly as possible, all the brother's questions avid give him all the " infor mation " he asks for. The truth never loses anything by a fair and free discussion. Many of our most intelligent and conservative brethren cannot sub scribe to the " Sub Treasury " scheme, and as I hive not seen in any Alli ance paper a fair presentation of ob jections to it as we see them, I am glad of this opportunity to let our brethren in North Carolina know them through your widely-circulated journal. I will write first of the l: Sub Treasury bill " and then of the " Cald well plan." When the National Alli ance first formulated its demands and the Sub Treasury scheme ana sent them dowrn to the Sub Alliances for approval or rejection, in our innocence, as freemen; we thought we had a right to discuss them and judge of their fitness to promote our prosper ity. But, judging from the tone and logic oi our brother's letter, we mhsed the true idea, which was this: To ratify the infallible edict of a great central power without questioning. As a free born American citizen 1 proves: against the idea that of any body's doctrine I shall approve what I believe to be wrong. The National Alliance demanded that the United States government should purchase and control the railroads and telegraphs of the country. How many Alliances in North Carolina approved that de mand ? I doubt if a single one did, and if they did it wa3 without thinking of the enormous cost, the corrupting tendencies, and without seeing the tremendous centralizing power sought to be placed in the hands of the gen eral government. Now, sir, if that demand can be re pudiated by a single Alliance and it still be considered loyal to our order, in the nime of common justice and common sense I ask why should we be com polled t o adopt the Sub Treas ury bill as a test of loyalty, when to many of us it seems as obj: ctionable, impracticable and centralizing as the other ? Oh! but, says your corres pondent, "united action is our only hope." Unity of action in a good cause is right and desirable, but if any action is shown to be injurious in its tendencies and results or even doubtful, then to demand that all in or out of the orier shall still stand by it, is the height of folly. Such a course cm result only in disaster to our order. Better a thousand times ac knowledge our error, repudiate it and begin a new course. This principle is as sound in economics and politics as in morals. Now, what are some of the reasons that caused our County Alliance, and many Sub-Alliances, to reject the Sab Treasury bill ? First, because it vio lates that principle of our order hich demands equal rights for all and special privileges to none. Our State Alliance has again and again demanded class legislation, but this bill is the very essence of class legislation, demanding for the farmers special privileges which are denied to all other classes. And worse, still; it gives special privileges to the prosper ous farmers which are denied to the farmers and laborers who never have a surplus; and besides all this it de nies any privilege to that large class of our order the mechanics. Not a farmer west of States ville, and not a great number east of it, no; a single mechanic throughout the State would get a single dollar of that " fia; money." Our order again and again has de nounced trusts and combinations to raise the price of the necessaries of life. This bill puts it in the power of the rich farmers and those who buy the warehouse certificates to force the most gigantic trust on the necessaries of life ever known. What does the rich farmer, or any one who has a surplus of wheat or corn, want to put it in the warehouse for if it is not to hold them till he can squeeze from the needy consumer such prices as he wants ? What, then, becomes of our brother farmers, in and out of the Alliance, who have to purchase these necessaries on account of a fail rvf their crops ? What becomes of that large class of our brethren th ma chanic, who are always compelled to purchase the necessa.riA9 nf lifo ? But they say the bill will enable our f urmers to borrow money on easy THE PROGRESSIVE FARMER SEPTEMBER 9, 1890. terms. What, then, becomes of that other -principle of our order which discourages our members from going in dot and borrowing? I, lets the people have money at a nominal cost," says your correspon ds. I answer, the needy farmer cannot get the money without pawn iug hi3 crop and then only for 80 cts. when the market would give him a dollar in cash. And it is a fact that people who are needy enough to pawn a thing hardly ever redeem it. We of the South have always denoun red the principle of giving special favors by legislation to the manufacturers. We have alwaj sjdenied that the gov ernment has the right to take money out of the pockets of one class, either directly or indirectly, and put it in the pockets of another class. " But," says the advocate of this bill, " the government has given special favors to the manufacturers, and now we demand special favors for the farm ers." This is the logic il outcome of the protection theory, but it is not consistent with Alliance principles. We would consider it a great evil for a mad dog to bite one of our legs. Would it cure us of hydro phobia to let him bite the other leg ? It seems to us that it would be '-otter to neutralize the poison with caustic and kill the dog. But if the advocates of this plan can ignore the principles and Consti tution of our Alliance, it would hard ly seem worth while to mention trie " Constitution of the United States," which expressly declares that nothing shall be a legal tender but gold and silver, and which nowhere gives tie government the right to lend money to individuals. It matters not to him if it is a radical departure from the financial principles of the ablest finan ciers among our forefathers Gallatin, Hamilton and Morns. He is willing to throw aside' the fixed laws of politi cal economy, the well tried systems of the greatest and most prosperous commercial nations of the earth England, Germany and France, and risk all upon the untried theory of a visionary novelist, which will prove as deceptive as " the baseless fabric of a dream." And the untried theory must be made the test of our loyalty 1 Men born and raised on the farm, know ing from experience all the toils, wants and burdens of the soil tiller, must be pushed aside if they do not accept this test. Our true and tried statesmen who have stood in the " imminent deadly breach " for the rights of the people, who have never faltered or lost heart in the darkest hours of our country's trials, must be tried by it. Not by their honor, their integrity, their experience, their great talents, nor their great public services, but by this paltry test must they stand or fall. France, one hundred years ago, intoxicated with madness and led by madmen, destroyed her best men by the guillotine. Loyalty to a faction and not loyalty to country was the test. Lavoisior, one of the greatest scien- tists who ever lived, one of the great est benefactors France ever had, espe cially to her farmers, was cruelly be headed by one of the dominant fac tions. One of his countrymen ex claimed, "It has taken but a few minutes to destroy this great life, it will take a hundred years to make an other like it." The world felt the shock and stood aghast in horror, and r ranee to-day hangs her head in shame and sorrow over the cruel, senseless act. Shall we repeat the folly and mad- ness of the French revolution, and politically destroy the pillars of the temple and destroy ourselves in the ruins ? In my next I will discuss the " Cald well Plan " and answer some of your correspondent's questions. R. L. Beall. LETTER FROM THE CENTRAL COUNTY. Hickory Mountain. Mr. Editor: Thinking that vour readers would, perhaps, like to hear from the central county of the State, 1 avail myself of your columns to cive a few points. It has truthfully been said that "in unity there is strength," and the farmers though slow to ap preciate the aphorism, have at last grasped the idea. There is, in my opinion, a brighter day ahead for the farming: interest. We have not. as yet, secured free coinage, but -we nave made a great advance in that di rection. We have wrung from a hostile Congress a. bill which is ger mane to it, and we have forced the leader of the Republican party to de clare in favor of reciprocity, which is out anotner name for free trade. Let the good work go on, gathering strength as it moves, until every class of citizens in this great country shall have an equal chance in the race for competency. The crops in our section are re markably fine. Corn and cotton are better than for years. Respectfully, Samuel Thomas. Bro. J. C. Parker, Secretary of Maple Grove Alliance, No. 356, writes that ome of their members do not take as much interest as they should, but that he hopes they will join hand in hand and march forward with the rest of them. DIAGNOSIS BY CONSTITUTION AL DOCTORS. National Economiet. A certain class of individuals, in eluding Senators and members of Congress, are just at present giving the people considerale advice and n struction in regard to ihe Consticu tion. The ability to construe ,he exact meaning of the Constitution seems to follow an election to Congress. A few months sojourn at the capital of the nation as a member of either branch of Congress is presumed by some to qualify aperson, no matter what may nave been his previous con dition or ability, to properly interpret the most intricate provisions of the national Constitution. In order that the plain people, who for the safety of the couatry consti tute the membership of the Farmers' Alliance, may decide for themselves, and bring to bear upon this question the good common seme which as a class they possess, the full powers of Congress as stated in the Constitution is printed herewith in full. The original Constitution as signed Sep tetnber 17, 1787, consisted of seven articles and their subdivisions. Since that time there has been fifteen amend ments added. The first ten amendments were proposed to the several States Sep tember 25, 1789. The eleventh amendment was submitted September 5, 1794. The twelfth amendment, December 11, 1803. The thirteenth amendment, February 1, 1865. The fourteenth amendment, June 16, 1866. The fifteenth and last amend ments relate to personal rights or qualifications for holding office. Sec tion 8 of article 1 of the original Con stitution designates the following powers of Congress: Sec. 8. Tne Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxe, duties, imports and excises, to pay the debts and provide for the common defense and general welfare of the United Stages but all duties, imposts and excises shall be uniform through out the United States; to borrow money on the credit of the United States; to regulate commerce with foieign nations, and among: the sev- ' ' eral States, and with the Indian tribes; to establish a uniform rule of natural! zatioo, and uniform laws on the sub ject of bankruptcies throughout the United States; to coin money, regulate the value thereof, and of foreign coin, and fix " the standard of weights and measures; to provide for the punish ment of counteifeiting the securities and current coin of the United States; to establish postoffices and post roads; to promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for lim ited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries; to constitute tribunals inferior to the Supreme Court; to define and punish piracies and felonies committed on the high seas and offenses against the law of nations; to declare war, grant letters marque and reprisal, and make rules concerning captures on land and water; to raise and support armies but no appropriation of money to that use shall be for a longer term than two years; to provide and maintain a navy; to make rules for the govern ment and regulation of the land and naval forces; to provide for calling forth the militia to execute the laws of the Union, suppress insurrections and repel invasions; to provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining trie militia, and tor governing such part of them as may be employed in tne service oi the United States, re serving to the States respectively the appointment of the officers, and the authority of tr lining the militia ac cording to the descipline prescribed Dy congress; to exercise exclusive legislation in all.cases whatsoever over such district (not exceeding ten miles square) as may by cession of particular States, an i the acceptance of Con gress, become the seat of the govern ment of the United States, and to ex ercise like authority over all places purchased by the consent of the legis lature of the State in which the same shall be, for the erection of forts, magazines, . arsenals, dock yards and other needful buildings, and to make all laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying'into execution for foregoing powers and all other powers vested by this Constitution in the gov ernment of the United States, or in any department or officer thereof. Sections 9 and 10 of article 1 limits the power of Congress and the States: Sec. 9. The migration or importa tion of such persons as any of the States now existing shall think proper to admit, .shall not be prohibited by the Congress prior to the year one thousand eight hundred and eight, but a tax or duty may be be imposed on such importation,-not exceeding ten dollars for each person. ? The privilege of the writ of habeas corpus. shall not be suspended, unless when, in cases of rebellion or invasion the public safety may require it. No bill of attainder or expost facto law shall be passed. No capitation or other di rect tax shall be laid, unless in pro portion to the census or enumeration hereinbefore directed to be taken. No tax or duty shall be laii on articles exported from any State. No preference shall be given by any regulation of commerce or revenue to the ports of one State over those of another; nor shall vessels bound to or from one State be obliged to enter, clear and pay duties in another.- No money shall be drawn from the Treas ury but in consequence of appropria tions made by law; and a regular statement and account of the receipts and expenditures of all public money shall be published from time to time. No title of nobility shall be granted by the United States; and no person holding any office of profit or trust under them shall, without the consent of the Congress, accept of any present, emolument, office, or title of any kind whatever, from any king, prince, or foreign State. Sec. 10. No State shall enter into any treaty, alliance, or confederation ; grant letters of marque and reprisal; uoin money; emit bills of credit; make any thing but gold and silver coin a tender in payment of debts; pass any bill of attainder, expost facto law, or law impairing the obligation of contracts, or grant any title of no bility. No State shall, without the consent of Congress, lay any imposts orduties on imports or exports, except what may be absolutely necessary for executing its inspection laws; and the net produce of all duties and imposts, Uid by any State on imports or ex- Ywt.a shn.1 h tor tne use oi tne iw, 0l Treasury of the United States; and all such laws shall be subject to the re viiion and control of the Congress. No State shall, without the consent of Congress, lay any d'lty of tonnage, keep troops or ships of war, in time of peace; enter into any agreement or compact with another State, or with a foreign power, or engage in war, unless actually invaded, or in such imminent danger as will not admit of delay. Let the above provisions be read carefully, for within their powers and limitations every law upon the statute books relating to the material interests of the people are based. By and through these provisions Congress has made laws for the establishment of a United States bank, for the disposal of the public . domain, to divide the surplus in the national Treasury among the States, to make grants of land to railroads, to give subsidies to steam ships, to improve rivers and harbors, grant pensions to soldiers and annuities to Iniuns, to issue legal tender paper money at any ticne, to establish nation al banks, refund the national debt, demonetize silver and. change the unit of money; to tax State bank issues out of existence, erect monuments and statutes by the hundreds, purchase lands and build warehouses, store and care for whisky, control interstate commerce, purchase Alaska, buy patent rights, guarantee the payment of Pacific railroad bonds, pay interest on these bonds to the extent of $62, 000,000; loan to the banks, witnout interest, over $60,000,000 at a ti ne; purchase its own bond?, and pay as premium up to the present time $43, 000,000; loan money to the world's fair and cotton exposition; expend $300,000 yearly experimenting in dsn culture, grant pensions to civilians, appropriate money to fire and flood sufferers, rent out water privileges, sand expeditions to the North Pole, sustain a bureau of education, expend an enormous amount on a geological survey, put in operation a weather bureau, establish coast life saving stations with a corp3 of practically en listed men, build lighthouses along the coast, authorize the construction of bridges, and to arm a large corps of men to police the sections of,coun try where distilling is done, under a system of internal revenue laws, which have not a line in the Constitution for a foundation. There are thousands upon thousands of laws similar in character to those mentioned above. Yet they are based upon nothing but the implied powers of Congress. The Constitution ought to be plain in its provisions. It was framed by plain men and ratified by those of still more humble attainments. Taking this view of th matter, why is it so very improbable that & calm, considerate thinker, though he may bea farmer, is not capable of forming quite definite conclusions as to what may be right or wr ng under the Constitution. This instrument was intended to benefit all w rthy classes, and its objects are perverted when such results are not attained. Agri culture is now suffering from legisla tive privileges granted to the enemies of labor in production. It demands redress and is met with the reply that such demands are unconstitutional. As proof that these demands are within the provisions of the Constitu tion, the language of the Constitution itself is given in this article, and a partial list of laws that have been en. acted are enumerated. If Congress has the power to do what the records show it has done, it can go further and legislate for the relief of the farmer. Lt it be done. - Bro. D. Y. White, Secretary of Alliance, No. 371, Chatham county, writes that his Alliance had a grand rally on the 21st of August. Bro. D. Reid Parker, of Trinity College, was the orator of the day and spoke for one hour and a' half. It was the best Alliance speech that ever has been de livered in western Chatham. It did not'' seem like hard times to look at the many good things that were put on the table. He writes that they have 50 members and hare paid $30 to the Business Agency fund. WEEKLY WEATHER CROP BULLETIN For the Week Ending Saturday, Aug. 30th, 1890. . Central Office, Raleigh, N. C. The reports of correspondents of the We.Wy Weather Crop Bulletin, issued by the North Carolina Experiment Station and State Weather Service, co-operating with the United States Signal Service, show that the week ending Saturday, August 30th, has been generally favorable for the ma turing of crops. The temperature has been about the average during the day time, but the nights have been too cool. The temperature ranged during the week from 94 to 52 degrees. The weather was rather dry until the 28th, on which day copious rains fell. Some very heay showers occurred Thursday night at a number ofplaces. The average rain fall for the week was 1.65 inches, which is 0.25 inches above the normal. September is gen erally a dryer month than August. The cotton crop is still above the aver age. It is opening rapidly and pick ing is in progress. New cotton is al ready in market. The tobacco crop also will be a fine one. Cutting and curing is going on, and the curings are generally reported good. The rains during August have, however, made in the lowlands a rank growth and there will be some rough, coarse tobacco which is too big for good treatment. The crop of corn, rice and potatoes is good. Eastern District. The temperature has been about the average during the day, but the nights have been cool with heavy dews. Lowest tempera ture reached 54 degrees. Cotton shows rust in some places, but not widespread. It is opening and pick ing has commenced. Rice harvest in progress in the southeastern counties, crops excellent and some weeks earlier than usual. Good crops of potatoes. The average-rainfall for the week in this district was 1.75 inches, which is somewhat the average. A very heavy rain storm i3 reported on the night ot 28th at Rocky Point, Pender county. Central District. The average rain fall ''for this week was 1.00 inches. Heavy rains occurred during night of 28th. At Raleigh, Wake county, 2.25 inches fell. The highest tempera ture was 94 degrees, the lowest 52. The nights have been cool and un favorable to most crops. Cotton is still above the average, is opening fast. Picking is progressing rapidly and new cotton is in market. The tobacco crop will be a fine one. Cur ings are reported good. Fodder is being saved. Corn and potato crops good. Western District. The weather has been warm and cloudy, with cool mornings, and dry until the 28th. Heavy rains fell on the night of the 28th at a number of places, the aver age for the district being 2.15 inches. The wet weather is unfavorable for cotton; however, Saturday opened dry and warmer. Cotton has com menced to open. Tobacco is being cut and cured rapidly. Corn is good on uplands and lowlands. The week was favorable for making hay and fodder. H. B. Battle, Ph D., Director. C. P. von Herrmann, Signal Corps, Assistant. THE LAW AND LOGIC OF IT. The controversy between the New York Central Railroad directorate and the Knights of Labor brings the question of railroad control control once more in a concrete form and visible shape before the whole people. Without entering into the merits of the controversy itself, there are some things to be considered from the standpoint of the general community which demand a rigid examination. A proper reply to the issues we shall raise will, in the end,fhave much to do with forming and moulding even the opinions of jurists and courts. Judges are but men, and court dicta is formed by human influences, no matter how reverential may be the estimation in which they are held. First, then, we may ask what is the function of a railroad and the corpor ate direction thereof ? The answer is simple and direct. A railroad is a public highway, operated by machin ery, whjse motive-power is steam. Its directorate are public carriers and nothing else. A tramway, whose equipment is operated by steam, is none the less a public highway. A macadamized road, the vehicles of which are moved by animals, has long since been recognized as public property by all civilized people. Can a scientific highway be any more than that? Of course not. Tnere is not a legislative discussion ia this or any other country, from: the beginning of the railroad system, in which any other position than that jf public highways and common carriers has ever been assigned to railways or their ownership. As to the corporations by which the roads are directed and managed, Lord Chief Justice Coleridge expressed the legal position in one-sentence when he said: "A railway is a public trust, charged with remuneration for private capital invested." The proof of this, if any were needed, is found in the fact that a railroad cannot exist without the rmh lie consent, as embodied in a f ranch?? granted by representative publV aISe thority. iu It follows, then, that in order t earn profit and be protected there;n that the railroad company is bound t ' execute the public trust placed unde its management. To do that it ml have its road-bed and appurtenance in perfect condition, while its eqn ment and working force, human and mechanical, must always be kep ;n working order and harmony. Fullfilling these conditions, obeyino. the laws and faithfully serving the public, a railroad corporation is unde legal relations, entitled to all the pro. tection a State can give it. But the courts thereof connot discriminate be tween degrees or qualities of equip, ment. They must, certainly, and will if honest jurists, regard the corpora! tion and its obligations as a whole If a railroad obstinately refused to do its work because the locomotives were out of order, a court would rightfully declare its franchise forfeited. Why, then, should there be dis. crimination against its labor equip, ment in any event or when the direc torate, for its own selfish and tyrani cal purposes, as is the case with the New York Central management, de clines to be in harmony with the laborers it employs ? The State will deal with the laborers or directors as citizens; it can only deal with the corporation as a public trust, carrying a yaluable franchise, which demand's service, which service must be exe cuted at the cost of the franchise itself. This is the simple logic as well as the law of the matter. The State should see to its enforcement. The United. States, under its powers to regulate interstate commerce, should see to it that the railroads do the work for which they we&e created. If citizens breed discord, let them be lawfully dealt with. AN ARGUMENT AGAINST THE y SUB-TREASURY SCHEME. Away, far, far in the future, if the Sub-Treasury Bill is ever resurrected from its legislative death, deposited there several months ago by Congres sional discretion, we imagine how such a measure will be debited in the' halls jf Congress. We can hear the eloquent Senator from Boodleibm thundering invective against such a rash measure. Arising to his feet, arrayed in his " stud horse' clothes," his exuberance of guts puffing and quivering with emotion as he grinshc; his teeth and wails: 'O! Mr. President," he would thunder, " is this nation going to get down so low as to build barns ? That is what the bill proposes to do. Are we going to give these rural jays mil lions of money, to be wrung from our suffering manufacturers, only to be squandered on pig styes and corn houses ? Are we going to lend out the public money at one per cent, to hayseed socialists and rustic com munists, when oar trusts and monopo lies can make one hundred per cent.? Do you want to tear the commercial bowel i out of this nation by doing this for the rich and predominating farmer ? Are the trust managers and railroad magnates to be robbed of their slender wages to sew on the farmer the golden buttons of aristoc racy ? "No I a thousand times infinite no 1 Down with the oppressors of our great businesses, and let the greatest nation this mud pill ' has ever seen continue on its unparalleled career of pros perity. " Mr. President, I do most heartily protest against this reckless expendi ture of the sacred public funds. I ad most sincerely in for an economical administration, and, hear me gentle men, I am not in favor of the United States going into the general produce business, as this bill proposes. The farmers of this great country are now in the soup in hot soup. Let them stay there, ' for if we trust representa tives try to get them out we are bound to burn our hands; see ?" With this last significant peroration the Senate boodler sat down amidst' the deafening roars of the various rep resentatives of the great business in terests of the country, supposed to be representative Senators of the people and law makers for the nfiAion. And in another moment the established order of business deposited the Sub Treasury Bdl in the National mausol eum, along with some other ancient Congressional lumber, and there to sleep the sleep that knows no waking Farmers, this will surely be the fate of that bill which promises to relieve the present depression and benefit all the nation if you do not rouse your selves t from your present political lethargy and show your strength and might and stand up for your political rights and freedom. Bro. A C. Hayes, Lecturer of Brassfield Alliance Durham county, writes that thev now have 47 male and 15 female members. They have been organized over two years ana think they have been greatly beneutea in financial matters. Their members have given fewer mortgages this yea than ever before, and have learned economize. i