folk
-
Three Cents the Copy.
INDEPENDENCE IN ALL THINGS. Subscription PrtceTSLOO Per Year in Advance
VOL All.
JURORS IN THE THAW
IE FAIL TO
E
They Are Discharged, Standing 7
For Death, 5 For Acquittal
NEW TRIAL SET FOR NEXT FALL
Insanity Plea Favored by Those Who
Stand to End For Prisoner Jer
ome Will Oppose Ball Family
Disappointed.
New York City. After forty-seven
nours spent in fruitless discussion,
the jury in the trial of Harry K. Thaw
lor the killing of Stanford White was
discharged by Justice Fitzgerald in
the Criminal Branch of the Supreme
Court. Contrary to the custom in
discharging a jury, the court did not
thank the twelve men for the trying
work they had done. As they left the
eourt house the jurors said they felt
hurt by the cold manner in which they
had been dismissed.
The jurors on their last ballot, tak
en three-quarters of an hour before
their discharge, stood seven for mur
der in the first degree and five for ac
quittal on the ground of insanity.
Soon after the twelve men retired
they stood eight for murder in the
first degree and four for acquittal on
the ground of insanity, but after read
ing Thaw's letters and the will and
codicil the defendant had drawn up
on the night of his marriage, John S.
Dennee, Juror No. 10, said he had a
reasonable doubt as to Thaw's sanity
at the time of the shooting, and he
weni over to those who voted for ac
quittal. Dennee offered to compromise on a
verdict of manslaughter in the first
degree, but the four jurors who had
voted for acquittal from the first
would not accept the proposition. In
all nine ballots were taken.
Of the seven jurors who voted for
conviction six were willing to compro
mise on a verdict of manslaughter in
the second degree, but the rest would
not chanire their views. George Pfaff,
Juror No. 2, voted from first to last
tor conviction of murder in the first
degree, contending that if the de
fendant were sane at the time of the
Iciiifiig lie should be sent to the elec
trfe chair.
At no time from the moment the
jury retired until it was discharged
did Thaw have a chance for freedom.
The five jurors who voted for acquit
tal did so on the ground of insanity.
Had that verdict been brought In the
' ; ndant would have been committed
to the Matteawan Asylum for the
Criminal Insane, there to remain un
til he should be pronounced cured.
District Attorney Jerome told re
porters that he would place Thaw on
trial again, but not until the fourteen
homicide cases now pending had been
disposed of. This means that the sec
ond trial cannot possibly take place
until late fall or early winter. In the
meantime Thaw must remain in the
Tombs, because Mr. Jerome has said
that he would oppose any motion to
admit the defendant to bail, and it is
scarcely likely that any judge would
grant a motion in face of the District
Attorney's decided Opposition.
Mr. Jerome says there Is a possibil
ity that a change of venue may be
applied for. Jerome has his doubts
about that, however, and believes that
a jury can be found in New York
County that will declare Thaw guilty.
Gf course, in the event that Thaw
should develop insanity to a marked
degree in the meantime he would be
sent to Matteawan without being
compelled to undergo another trial.
Thaw is in good spirits. It was ex
pected that he would break down and
shout to be liberated. He did nothing
of the kind.
As soon as the courtroom had been
cleared the Thaw women went to the
n above the courtroom under the
escort of Lawyer O'Reilly, there to
console Harry. They found that they
needed more consolation than did the
r.an they had hoped to take to their
home with them.
Mrs. William Thaw and her two
daughters, Mrs. Carnegie and the
Countess of Yarmouth, left the court
building in one' automobile, Mrs. Eve
lyn Thaw in another. Mr. Harfridge
accompanied her. They declined to
say anything for publication. They
Were overcome by the blow and too
agitated to speak.
Estimates of the cost of the Thaw
case are as follows:
Expense to New York County
Jury fees. $1,536
Jury expenses 5,200
Fees to waiting talesmen. . . . 5,000
Tees to experts 22,200
fudge's salary 4,375
District Attorney's salary... .3,000
Assistant District Attorney's
salary . . . . i 1,875
Kxtra clerical work 2,000
County detectives 5,000
Kxtra detective service 3,000
Traveling and incidental. . . . 5,000
Court attaches 3,000
Stenographers' pay 4,500
'-xtra police S.uuu
witness fees and expenses. . 5,000
Grand total $78,686
Expense to the Thaw family
jWrts $45,000
Attorney fees (chief coun-
. se-. 100,000
Assistant counsel. . 40,000
l ost of original lawyers 20,000
jwrpenses of detectives, etc. 15,000
Prisoner's meais 1,500
traveling penses 1,000
jMes, etc 2500
facing up testimony (esti-
ttated) 10,000
$235,000
CAE
AGHE
CHRONOLC Y OF
THAW-WHITE CASE.
These are the chief events fc
the Thaw-White tragedy:
1906 June 25 Thaw shour..
and instantly kills Stan
ford White on the Mad
ison Square Roof Gar
den 1907 Jan. 23 Thaw arraigned
for trial before Justice
Fitzgerald in the Crim
inal Branch of the Su
preme Court; drawing
of jury commences.
Feb. 4 Morning Tak
ing of testimony begins;
prosecution puts in its
case during the fore
noon. Afternoon De
fense onens.
j Feb. 7 and 8 Evelyn
rseshit Thaw, wife or the
prisoner, testifies to the
story of her ruin by
Stanford White, which
she told her husband,
Harry Thaw.
Feb. 12 " Brainstor'
theory advanced
alienist for the defense.
Feb. 14 Death of juror's
wife stops trial.
Feb. 18, 19, 20, 21, 25,
2 6 Jerome cross-examines
Evelyn and attacks
her story of her down
fall. March 8 Thaw's defense
closed ; prosecution
opens in rebuttal.
March 1 8 Abraham H.
Hummel, puts in photo
graph of last page of
Evelyn's alleged retrac
tion of charges against
White.
March 20 Jerome halts
trial to demand a com
mission to test Thaw's
present sanity.
March 26 Commission
appointed by Justice
Fitzgerald to decide on
defendant's mental con
dition. April 4 Commission
after having examined
Thaw reports him sane;
trial ordered resumed.
April 8 Lawyer Delmas,
all evidence for both
sides being in, begins
final appeal to the jury.
April 10 District Attor
ney Jerome made his ar
gument; Justice Fitz
gerald charged the jury.
April 11 Jury deliber
ates. April 12 Jury disagrees
and is discharged.
BUSINESS SKY CLEARER.
Country's Groat Trade Centres Re
port Record Prosperity.
New York City. Special dispatches
to the Tribune from three of the
country's great centres of trade
Pittsburg, St. Louis and Chicago
show no appreciable falling off in
business. The opinions of financiers,
manufacturers and business men in
general are uniformly optimistic, and
do not reflect the pessimism expressed
by James J. Hill, Mr. Schiff and Mr.
Belmont in recent interviews.
Pittsburg eipects some slackening
up, and will welcome it, but scouts
any real business depression. Men
high in the seel trade say there can
be no depression there this year or
next.
St. Louis is enjoying the greatest
business prosperity in its history, and
prospects are for more business this
year than last. One of the great rail
road equipment companies reports or
ders on its books for nearly 100,000
cars.
Chicago reports business in every
line booming and on the increase.
FIFTEEN KILLED IN WRECK.
Injured Passengers Burned to Death
on the Canadian Pacific.
Fort William, Ont. Fifteen per
sons were killed and twenty injured
in the wreck of a Canadian Pacific
passenger train near Chapleau, 300
miles east of here. The train was
thrown from the track by a broken
rail and plunged down an embank
ment into a small lake. Some of the
injured passengers were pinned in
the wreckage and slowly burned to
death, while others met death in a
more merciful form in the waters of
the lake.
When the train struck the broken
rail five touri3t cars near the middle
of the train broke loose and rolled
down the embankment. One of the
cars was entirely submerged. The
other four stopped closer to the shore
and were only partly covered by
water. The latter caught fire and
the passengers imprisoned in a mass
of wreckage .were burned to death.
NO ROCKEFELLER BOULEVARD.
Cleveland Takes His Name From the
Driveway He Gave.
Cleveland, Ohio. John D. Rocke
feller's name is no longer borne by
the boulevard he gave to the city.
The administration has changed the
name of the upper driveway in Rocke
feller Park from Rockefeller Boule
vard to East Boulevard.
Residents in houses and apartments
along the driveway are indignant.
The change was authorized some time
ago, but those most affected knew
nothing of it until signs bearing the
new name were put up within the last
few days.
No explanation has been offered by
the city authorities.
COLUMBUb, N.
CARNEGIE DEDICATES HIS
$23,000,000 INSTITUTE
i1?
V-irns Pittsburg Institutions Over
to the People.
"ITS ALL LIKE A DREAM TO ME1
Denies That He is Entitled to Any
Credit For Amassing Millions
Distinguished Gathering at the
Ceremonies Scope of Institute.
Pittsburg, Pa. Surrounded by a
brilliant assemblage of world-famous
personages, Andrew Carnegie for
mally turned over to Pittsburg the
magnificent institute which bears his
name and for which he has given
f .3,900,000 in round figures, the
I argest sum ever given by any man
to any one institution.
With 2 5,000 people lining the quarter-mile
boulevard between the Hotel
Schenley, the headquarters of the vis
itors, and the Carnegie Institute, Mr.
Carnegie and his guests marched to
the dedication.
The line was led by Director Ar
thur Hammer8chlag, of the Carnegie
Tech Schools, followed by the mem
bers of the faculty. Then, came Mr.
Carnegie on the arm of W. N. Frew,
chairman of the board of trustees,
and behind them the guests, with
Lieutenant-General Alfred F. J. von
Lowenfeld, General Adjutant to the
German Emperc and Lieutenant
DiekhuUx, of the German army, in
the lead.
Following the German officers
came statesman and educator, artist
and famous manufacturer, church
man and politician. The Catholic
Bishop of Pittsburg walked with the
Episcopal Bishop. With Booker T.
Washington marched two educators
of another complexion.
The proceedings began at 9.45 a.
m., when Chairman Frew received
the guests in the Founders' room.
At 10.30 a. m. came the municipal
reception to visiting guests by Mayor
and Mrs. Guthrie, assisted by Mr.
and Mrs. Carnegie. At 11.30 came
the academic procession from the
Hotel Schenley to the institute, under
escort from the Faculty and students
of the Carnegie Technical Schools.
At 2 o'clock the dedication exercises
began in the music hall, and at 3
o'clock the rest of the buildings were
thrown open to the general public.
At night there was a concert of the
Pittsburg Orchestra.
The ceremonies, while elaborate,
were marked with extreme simplicity.
When Mr. Carnegie arose to make
his address the applause was long
renewed. He had been introduced
by Chairman W. M. Frew of the
Board of Trustees as a man who had
long been absent from Pittsburg, but
who still needed no introduction.
This expression seemed to furnish
Mr. Carnegie his inspiration. He
put his manuscript down, his eyes
flashed, he stepped far to the front
beyond the speaker's table, and rais
ing his arms, cried out:
"I have been in a dream ever since
I arrived here, and I am still in a
dream. As I look upon this build
ing, I can hardly realize what has
been done in my absence by the men
who have made it. I have tried to
make myself realize that I have any
thing to do with it, and have failed
to do so. My banker tells me that I
have so many bonds; I never even
saw them. Did I earn them? Well,
I started the machinery going and
they came to me. When the insti
tute project was first mentioned I
wrote my name to a little slip of
paper. That completed my task. 1
do not even know how many bonds
they took, because I don't know how
many I have. And still I am given
the credit. It doesn't belong to me.
"I cannot feel that I own a moun
tain. I don't think any man can
really feel he owns a stretch of land.
Let him "walk over mountains or
heather and say to himself, 'These
mountains are mine,' and he will not
be able, to make himself understand
the meaning of the words. So 'it is
impossible to make one's self under
stand that he owns a great fortune.
"I don't miss the money I gave.
So far as I know there are as many
bonds in the safe deposit vault as
there were before. I told my wife
last night, after I had viewed this
wonderful place, that I felt that Alad
din's Lamp had been working, and
she replied, 'Yes, and you did not
even have to rub the lamp.' That
sizes up my position exactly."
Mr. Carnegie delivered this re
markable speech in the most impas
sioned way with his eye glasses
thrust back over his head, and his
arms gesticulating. At times in it
he was vigorously applauded, but for
the most part the audience sat silent,
not unsympathetically, but rather as
if unable to take it in. Having said
this, he walked back to the speaker's
table, picked up his manuscript,
pulled down his glasses over his eyes
and delivered his prepared speech.
The institute is of marble, and
stands in Schenley Park, one of the
most beautiful in the city. The build
ing faces the south, and with its
wings and extensions covers an area
of four acres, while with the three
floors there is a space for the various
departments of sixteen acres, exclus
ive of two basements and the power
house. The total cost of the insti
tute, which occupied thirty months
in construction, was $6,000,000. The
bookstacks have a capacity of 1,500,
000 Volumes. The art galleries coveT
44,700 square feet and the museum
covers 104,000 square feet.
C... THURSDAY, APRIL 18, 1907.
W MTAimnn m...... .. i !
vvviwan irijfii CUME TO AMERICA!
By
MEAT AND DAIRY EXPORTS.
-4
Total Value $250,000,000 Last Year, a Growth
of Forty-five Per Cent, in Decade
Washington, D.? C. The total ex
portation of meats, dairy products
and food animals from the United
States last year aggregated over
0,00 0,0 00 in value, according to
a statement issned by the Bureau of
Statiglics of the Department of Com
merce and Labor; Thif represents
an increase of $70000,000, or forty
five per cent, during the decade 1896
to 1906. More tn sixty per cent,
of last year's exports went to the
United Kingdom. Even this large
percentage, however, is less than that
of a decadeago, when Great Britain
took over seventy tier cent, of Amer
ican exports.
Of the $250,000,000 worth of
meats, dairy products and food ani
mals passing out of the United
Stales last year, 40,000,000 was in
live "animals, $58;,000.000 in lard,
$36,000,000 in bacon, $25,000,000 in
fresh beef, $21,000,000 in hams,
$18,000,000 in oleomargarine, $14,
000,000 in pork other than bacon and
hams, $4,500,000 in butter and $2,
500,000 in cheese.
The farmers of America are en
Joying their full share of the general
prosperity of the country. The re
port of the Government recently made
public announces that the value of
farms increased thirty-three per cent,
in five years, from 1900 to 1906.
This increase extends to every State
in the Union in greater or less de
gree. Oklahoma shows the largest
increase, forty-three per cent., but
even New England; which does not
lay claim to much of a farming coun
try, shows a gain of eighteen per
cent.
This great increase in our farm
wealth is, of course, due to the re
markable advance in the value of
farm products, which is estimated to
be about forty per cent. Increased
earnings have come with better
knowledge of conditions and better
methods of farming, and as these
methods are constantly improving,
our continued prosperity seems as
sured. COST OF LIVING LESS.
Commodity Prices Fall, Partly Because the Hen
Is Busy.
v New York City. If- A decline of
nearly two per cen. in commodity
prices is attributed 1 by Dun's Index
Number in large measure to the
spring activities of the American hen
and the consequent decline in the
price of eggs of ten and a half cents
a dozen, which resulted in a heavy
increase in the per capita consump
tion, vlj
It is usual at thfstime ot year for
the prices of dairy and garden pro
ducts to recede, but4 last month the
decline was exceptional. Comment
ing on the causes of he decline, out
side df the influence of the break in
eggs, Dun's mentions the relief to
railway freight blockades, that made
it possible to move grain and many
other products more freely to mar
ket, and the feeling of conservatism
in some industries, which restricted
purchases of raw materials.
A BILLION PAID FOR AUTOS.
-
French Statistician Says That America Now
Leads the World.
Washington, D. C M. Faroux, a
French statistician, according to a
report received by the Bureau of
Manufactures, estimates that about
550,000 motor cars have been manu
factured in the nine years since the
experiment of self-propelled road ve
hicles first succeeded. These ma
chines sold for morel than a bullion
dollars.
Until a year ago France, the pio
neer, led the world in the production
of the motor vehicle. Now the United
States has takent the lead. Accord
ing to M Faroux, the United States
built 60,000 automobiles in 1906,
France 55,000, England 2S,000, Ger
many 22,000, Italy 19,000 and Bel
gium 12,000. In 19D1 the United
States built only 314 cars, and that
same year France built 23,711.
"Scar," in the New York Globe.
OUR GROWING FOREIGN TRADE.
Increase of $223,629,301 During the Past
Eight Months.
Washington, D. C. The foreign
trade of the United States increased
$223,629,301 during the eight
months ended February 28, not
withstanding a falling off of $23,
000,000 in the exports of foodstuffs.
The increase was made up of $132,
779,306 in the volume of imports
and $90,84S,995 in the value of ex
ports the most notable in any one
class being the exports of crude me
terials to be used in manufactures,
which reached a total of $447,073,
527, against $372,054,901 in the
same period of the previous year.
The imports of like materials also
1 showed a large increase $44,821.-
164. The totals for the several
classes and the comparative increases
are:
IMPORTS.
Foodstuffs $195,361 ,888 Inc $11,699,965
Crnde materials 307,897,965 Inc 44,821,164
Partly manufactured. 179,222,065 Inc 38,709,670
Finished man'factures 243.103,883 Inc 36,672,585
Miscellaneous 7,651,227 Inc 975,922
Totals $932,736,826 Inc $132,779,306
EXPORTS.
Foodstuffs $343,488,501 Dec $23,254,125
Crude materials 447,073,527 Inc 75,018,626
Partly manufactured. 168,398,442 Inc 25,587,043
Finished man'factures 309.978,384 Inc 14,100.575
Miscellaneous 20,303,524 Inc 396,876
Totals $1,298,240,378 Inc $90,848,995
In exports 1906 gave us compared'
with 1905 $21,000,000 more for less
cotton, $32,000,000 more for wheat,
$9,000,000 more for wheat flour, $1,
800,000 more for automobiles, $2,
400,000 more for railroad cars, near
ly $2,000,000 more for chemicals,
$4,000,000 more for copper, $2,600,
000 more for hops, $4,000,000 more
for scientific instruments and an-
; paratus, $1,200,000 more for
steel sheets, $1,700,000 more for
wire, $1,800,000 more for builders
hardware, $2,300,000 more for metal
working machinery, $1,400,000 more
for sewing machines, $2,000,000
more for locomotives, $5,000,000
more for uper leathers, $1,000,000
more for boots and shoes, $1,900,000
more for tallow, $7,600,000 more for
bacon, $2,000,000 more for pork, $3,
000,000 more for lard, $2, 300, 000 more
for oleo, $1,700,000 more for butter,
$1,700,000 more for cheese, $2,
100,000 more for naval stores, $2,
600,000 more for oil cake and meal,
$1,700,000 more for crude oil, $4,
I 500,000 more for refined oil, $1,600,
000 more for paper and manufac
tures thereof, $11,000,000 more for
seeds, $5,300,000 more for leaf to
bacco, $5,600,000 more for timber,
$9,000,000 more for lumber and pla
ning mill products, besides a host of
minor increases, with very few de
creases. EXPORTS OF MANUFACTURES.
Etfceed $700,000,000 a Year Have Doubled
in Value In Ten Years.
Washington, D. C. The United
States now ranks third among the
world's exporters of manufactures,
according to a monograph on "exports
of manufactures from the United
States and their distribution," issued
by the Bureau of Statistics of the De
partment of Commerce and Labor.
It is shown that not only do the
exports of manufactures now exceed
$700,000,000 per annum, and have
doubled in value in a single decade,
but the share which products of the
factory form of the total exports is
steadily increasing. A. comparison
shows that in 1880 manufactures
formed only fifteen per cent, of the
total exports of domestic products,
while in 1906 they formed forty per
cent.
In the decade ending with 1905
Ptnnrts nf mannfnptiipoa inproacod
j 198 per cent., while those from Ger
j many increased seventy-five per
' cent.; from the United Kingdom,
! forty per cent., and from France,
twenty-five per cent.
Customs Receipts Heavier.
New York City. Customs re- )
ceipts are running $70,605 a day
heavier than last year. So far
this fiscal year they have averaged
$749,579 a day, as against $678,973
during the fiscal year 1905-6. Treas
ury officials predict the highest an
nual record the country has ever
known on July 1.
NO. 51.
WHISKY'S STATUS DEFINED
President Declares That Liquors
Must Be Labeled Truly.
Blends and Compounds Are Substan.
tially Alike and Both Are For
- bidden by Pure Food Law.
Washington, D. C. The long-expected
opinion of Attorney-General
Bonaparte concerning the proper
labeling of whisky under the Pure
Pood law, approved June 30, 1906,
was made public at the White House.
Its purport is briefly told in the fol
lowing letter addressed by the Presi
dent to the Secretary of Agriculture:
. My Dear Mr. Secretary In accord
ance with your suggestion, I have
submitted the matter concerning the
proper labeling of whisky under the
Pure Food law to the Department of
Justice. I inclose the Attorney-General's
opinion. I agree with this
opinion, and direct that action be
taken in accordance with it.
Straight whisky will be labeled as
such.
A mixture of two or more straight
whiskies will be labeled Mended
whisky or whiskies.
A mixture of straight whisky and
ethyle alcohol, provided that there is
a sufficient amount of straight whisky
to make it genuinely a "mixture,"
will be labeled as compound, or com
pounded with pure grain distillate.
Imitation whisky will be labeled as
such.
THEODORE ROOSEVELT.
Referring to sherry, port and Ma
deira, whose flavors, the Attorney
General says, are distinct from each
other, he points out there is an evi
dent distinction to be drawn between
them and champagne, and adds:
"In the view of a chemist or
physicist, champagne would doubt
less be described as a 'compound,' for
it consists essentially of a wine, of
sugar, and of an aerating gas, three
substances obviously 'unlike.' The
law, however, in my opinion, does
not contemplate that an article
should be marked as a 'blend,' 'com
pound' or 'imitation' unless its desig
nation would be otherwise 'false or
misleading' to the consumer; and the
name 'champagne' would indicate to
any would-be purchaser who was or
dinarily intelligent and well informed
a wine artificially sweetened and
aerated, or, in other words, a com
posite substance."
"Compound" and "blend" are sub
statially synonymous, the Attorney
General says, when applied to mix
tures of liquids, in ordinary speech,
but the Pure Food law establishes a
distinction between them, based upon
the character of the ingredients.
The Attorney-General declares that
according to the true intent of the
Pure Food law, a mixture of whisky
with a neutral spirit must be deemed
a "compound" and not a "blend,"
although the spirit may bell distillate
from the same substance used to
furnish the whisky, and that such a
mixture stands on the same footing
as a mixture of whisky and brandy or
of whisky and rum.
FORAKER TAKES STUMP
Has Differed With President on Only
Three Points, He Says.
Canton, Ohio. Senator Joseph B.
Foraker opened his campaign against
the friends of Secretary Taft for con
trol of the State here when he deliv
ered a speech at the Board of Trade
dinner.
His topic was "Our Civic Life,"
but he discussed his career in Con
gress, explained his attitude toward
President Roosevelt's policies, de
clared that he would accept no criti
cism except from his constituents,
and held himself accountable to no
one else. He said he had only thrice
opposed legislation favored by Presi
dent Roosevelt, and that he would
abide by the judgment of the people
of Ohio as to whether he had done
right. His roferences to the Presi
dent were received without demon
stration. Mr. Foraker's reception upon his
arrival and during the afternoon was
perhaps not so warm as usual.
ANNOUNCED HIS SUICIDE.
Friend of Thaw Shoots Himself in
Pittsburg Theatre.
Pittsburg, Pa. Robert M. Crow,
twenty-two years old, attempted sui
cide by shooting himself in the abdo
men in a box at the Grand Opera
House during the performance in the
afternoon. He was taken to the
Homoeopathic Hospital, fatally
wounded.
Crow, who is a nephew of H. C.
McEldowney, president of the Union
Trust Company, i as been mentally
unbalanced for some time and has
spent all his time studying works on
insanity since the beginning of the
trial of his friend, Harry K. Thaw, in
New York., W. C. McEldowney, an
other uncle, declared that "Pittsburc
paranoia, an insane impulse to do
something sensational," caused Crow
to attempt his life under such spec
tacular circumstances.
Crow bought t box seat .t the the
atre and sent letters to his uncles
telling them of h'- intended suicide.
Miss Ethel Levy was singing "Un
requited Love" when he arose, in the
full sight of the audience, and fired
a shot into his body. Miss Levy ran
from the stage, wliile women in the
audience screamed and fainted. Both
uncles of the young man had received
his Tetters and were on the way to
the theatre.
a